Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

14th February 1863, Page: 5, Column: 2

The Hartley Surplus

A few weeks ago, when a sad explosion occurred in the Edmond's Main Colliery, near Barnsley, and destroyed no fewer than sixty lives, an appeal was made to the benevolent, on behalf of the survivors. Usually, in cases of great calamity, the fountain of public charity flows freely, but in this instance, instead of a golden stream it gave forth only feeble and intermittent droppings, which were wholly inadequate to supply even the current wants of the sufferers. Fresh appeals were issued, the influence of the press was invoked and obtained, but very little money came in. It appeared as if public benevolence towards sufferers by colliery disasters had culminated in the Hartley affair, and could not be aroused by any similar catastrophe of smaller dimensions.

Nor did the reality belie the appearance. Not that the wealthy and the charitable, whose purses had usually been opened wide on such occasions were totally deaf to the cry for help from Edmond's Main. Their ears were open, their hearts were warm, and they were desirous that aid should be afforded ; but they did not feel justified in giving. And why ? Because it was known that the Hartley Fund was enormously disproportionate to the requirements of the case, that a very large sum of money had been collected, and only a fraction of it expended, and that there was a large balance locked up somewhere from which no person was deriving any benefit. This was the reply given to the Appeal from Yorkshire: We subscribed thousands of pounds last year in excess of the amount required : the money is lying unappropriated in Northumberland ; you belong to the same class of sufferers as those for whose benefit it was collected ; you must try and obtain a share of it.

These sentiments seemed to be general, and last week a writer under the nom de plume of "Vox Populi" commenced to ventilate the matter in the Times. "What has become of the Hartley surplus ?" he asked, and then he went on to say :— "If the surplus is invested in readily convertible securities, it might have been expected that at least part of it would have been devoted to assuage the sorrows of the poor women and children so suddenly and cruelly deprived of husbands and fathers by the Edmond's Main explosion. I may, perhaps, be charged with ignorance of the law, and be told that such an appropriation would be a breach of trust. However this may be, the voice of the public would have proclaimed an indemnity. "

To a letter in the Times, which evidently expressed the opinions of a large section of the public as this, it was right and proper that the secretary to the Hartley Relief Fund Committee should furnish a reply. Accordingly in a subsequent number of the leading journal appeared the response of Mr. Atkinson, who, acting no doubt under the instruction of the committee, gives ample information respecting the appropriation of the money. About £5,500, it appears, has been administered to those for whose benefit the fund was, in the first instance, subscribed, another £5,500 is at credit with the bankers, and £70,000 is invested in safe and available securities. The amount of surplus that will accrue when all the claims on the fund are satisfied is being ascertained by an eminent actuary in London, and when the committee receive his report they intend to give the question of the disposal of the surplus immediate consideration. The Mayor of Newcastle writes to the Times to a similar effect, but urging that no further delay should take place in deciding what shall be done with the money ; and thus the whole facts of the case are placed before the public.

In a second letter, "Vox Populi" has expressed his surprise at the very trifling amount that has been bestowed upon those to whom, in strict justice, the money belongs. We confess to a share in the same feeling. From the commencement we have found it impossible to get rid of an impression — an impression that has more than once found utterance in the local papers — that the committee have dealt out the fruits of public benevolence with a somewhat niggard and parsimonious hand. The intention of the donors was clearly shown in the munificence of the subscription. The majority of the subscribers, we are sure, by no means intended, as the committee seem to think, that the bereaved should be simply placed in the position, as regards their weekly incomings, that they would have occupied if the calamity had not occurred. The subscribers considered not merely the loss of pecuniary resources, but that greater and irreparable loss of husband, of father, of brother — of all that this world holds dear ; and the money was intended to be given not as a dole, but as a solatium — not as more relief, but as a compensation.

It is now, perhaps, too late to say much upon this head. The complaints about the administration of the fund, which found expression at an earlier stage of the proceedings, have gradually died away, and but for the unfortunate explosion in Yorkshire we should probably have heard nothing more about the Hartley fund or its recipients for some time to come. The correspondence which has taken place in the Times has, however, reawakened public attention, and the question, what shall be done with the surplus which will remain when the wants of the Hartley sufferers have been satisfied, must have an answer. What the amount of that surplus may be we have no means of judging, that it will be considerable is certain, for some of the widows have emigrated, others of the recipients have commuted their claims, and, consequently the demands upon the fund are rapidly diminishing. It has been proposed to appropriate it, or a large portion of it, to the establishment or aid of a national relief society to which the pitmen and the coal-owners should be required to make a small periodical contribution. This is, no doubt, a very excellent suggestion, and we see no great difficulty in the way of its adoption. We have more than once thought that the Charity Commissioners might be induced to take charge of the money, applying it in certain regulated proportions to assist the local benevolence which is sure to be excited by colliery disasters. If the sanction of Parliament could be obtained to either of these suggestions we think they would be found to work well and to give general satisfaction.

There are those amongst us, who will probably take objections to these, or any similar proposition, on the ground that their adoption would involve the withdrawal of the surplus from this district. The objection is a selfish one. A very large proportion of the money was subscribed by persons who have no connection whatever with this coalfield, and who would have contributed with equal munificence if the accident had occurred in the Welsh, the Scotch, or any other coal-yielding district of Great Britain. No consideration of locality influenced the subscribers, no such consideration should be allowed to prevail in the disposal of the sum — whatever it may be — which will legitimately accrue after the widows and orphans at Hartley have been provided for.

For ourselves we have no decided leanings in this matter towards any particular project. "Whatever is done with the surplus ought to be done with the approval of the subscribers. In the hands of those parties we leave it, merely expressing the hope that it will be so settled as to secure the greatest possible amount of good to the greatest possible number, and that above all things care will be taken to avoid such an appropriation as will encourage recklessness on the part of the pitmen, or carelessness on the part of the coal-owners.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hartley Colliery  Hartley Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
16 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Annual Register for 1862)
18 Jan 1862  Terrible Colliery Accident (The Times)
20 Jan 1862  The Dreadful Colliery Accident In Northumberland (The Times)
21 Jan 1862  The Catastrophe at Hartley Colliery (The Times)
22 Jan 1862  The Calamity In Northumberland (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery (The Times)
24 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  The Awful Calamity In New Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Sufferers By The Accident At Hartley Pit (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Dreadful Colliery Accident, Loss of Two Hundred and twenty lives (Illustrated London News)
25 Jan 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., Terrible Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
29 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Sufferers By the Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Pit Tragedy (Illustrated London News)
01 Feb 1862  Meetings At Consett and Blackhill (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Calamity, Mr. Elliott On Insurance (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Mining Accidents, Government Inspection And Public Sympathy (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Heroes Of Hartley (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, Accidents In Coal Mines (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Disaster (The Times)
07 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
08 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Complete Report Of The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Photographs Of The Hartley Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
12 Feb 1862  Comment (The Times)
15 Feb 1862  Topics of the Week (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Home News (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., The Inquiry into the Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Feb 1862  The Hartley Fund, Meeting Of The Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Bury and Norwich Post)
20 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Western Daily Press)
22 Feb 1862  Sayings and Doings in Parliament, The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Accident, Honour To Whom Honour Is Due (Morpeth Herald)
22 Feb 1862  Miscellaneous News (The Leeds Times)
22 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
22 Feb 1862  The New Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Widows and Orphans (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Mar 1862  Sunderland Contributions To The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 Mar 1862  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
29 Mar 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund At The Mansion House (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
05 Apr 1862  The Hartley Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
26 Apr 1862  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 May 1862  Poem On The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
14 May 1862  The Sinkers' Testimonial (Newcastle Daily Journal)
14 May 1862  The Survivors At New Hartley (Newcastle Daily Journal)
17 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonials, Presentation Ceremony (Newcastle Daily Journal)
20 May 1862  Sinkers' Testimonial Fund (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  News (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  The Reward Of Merit (Newcastle Daily Journal)
22 May 1862  Presentation To The Hartley Sinkers (Shields Daily Gazette)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Heroes (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Calamity (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  Presentation Of Testimonials To The Hartley Sinkers (Morpeth Herald)
27 May 1862  The Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
30 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonial Fund, Notice To Workmen, Tradesmen, And Others (Newcastle Courant)
07 Jun 1862  The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
02 Aug 1862  Model Of The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1862  "Reading The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  North Of England Mining Institute (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  "The Reading Of The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Oct 1862  The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Jan 1863  The Hartley Sinkers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
14 Feb 1863  The Hartley Surplus (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Feb 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  Hartley Relief Fund Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  News (Newcastle Daily Chronicle)
08 May 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Courant)
27 Jun 1863  News (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Nov 1863  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Apr 1880  Hartley Colliery Accident Fund (The Times)
25 May 1886  Death Of One Of The Hartley Heroes (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette)
27 Jun 1910  Aged Miners' Cottages, Hartley Disaster Memorial (Sunderland Daily Echo)
08 Jun 1927  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for New Hartley
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print