|
1st January 1863 Cutting and Wounding at William PitJames Mootry was charged with stabbing and wounding John Garrigan, at William Pit, on Saturday last. Mr. Paitson appeared for the prisoner. Prosecutor stated that he was a collier at William Pit. On Saturday last, about two o'clock in the afternoon, he was coming up the pit in a basket in company with six others. When he had got to the mouth of the pit he saw prisoner shoving an empty basket to the pit top. He got out of the basket he was in, and prisoner asked him if he was as good a man as he was on Wednesday night. They had had a quarrel on Wednesday night. He (prosecutor) said he was, and he put his hand forward to push prisoner out of the way. Prisoner then stepped back and kicked him on the lower part of his body. Prosecutor stooped down, and when he recovered from the kick he ran at prisoner, and pulled him by the hair. While he had hold of the prisoner he heard people around him shouting that prisoner was striking him with a knife. The men interfered, and prisoner was taken away. He had several cuts upon him which had been done by the prisoner. The clothes worn by the prosecutor were then produced, and he stated that there were seven cuts upon his jacket, three on his flannel shirt, and two upon his waistcoat. These cuts were all done in the scuffle with the prisoner. He saw the knife in prisoner's hands after the quarrel was over. In cross-examination prosecutor stated that had struck prisoner on the previous Wednesday night. Prisoner struck him first. The cuts on his back were very slight. There was one upon the shoulder, and the other two were farther back. Michael Fitzgerald deposed that he came up in the bucket with the prosecutor. The first thing he saw was prosecutor pushing prisoner aside. Prisoner then struck prosecutor, and shortly after that he saw prisoner with a knife in his hand, but he did not see him do anything with it. Henry McGorran, after corroborating the previous witness's evidence, said he saw prisoner stab prosecutor. He saw prisoner using a knife several times. He told prisoner to drop the knife, but he paid no attention to him. Andrew Graham gave similar evidence. Inspector Wood said that on Saturday afternoon prosecutor came to the police station, and gave information that he had been stabbed. About three o'clock he (the inspector) went to the pit, and charged prisoner with kicking and cutting the prosecutor. Prisoner replied that prosecutor had struck him first, and that he had then kicked him. He was cutting some tobacco with his knife, and he was so put about that he did not know what he did with the knife. He brought him to the police office, and found a knife, a tobacco box, and a short pipe in his pocket. Dr. Wilson deposed to having seen prosecutor on Saturday evening about ten o'clock. He examined his back, and on the upper part of the left shoulder blade he observed a small wound, about a quarter of an inch in length, which appeared to have been done within a few hours. He also observed a few inches from the other, and more to the centre of the back, another wound of a smaller character. The wounds had been very slight indeed. The bore the evidence of having been done by some sharp instrument. The wounds were not at all dangerous. He examined the cuts in the waistcoat, and they corresponded with the cuts in the flannel shirt, and also with the wounds. Mr. Paitson addressed the bench for the prisoner, and read a letter from Mr. Golightly, foreman at William Pit, stating that prisoner had been two years at the pit, and was a very quiet man. The magistrates retired, and, after a short absence, returned to court, when the Chairman said that they decided to send the case to the Sessions.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||