|
20th December 1862, Page: 8, Column: 4 Mr. Dunn On The Walker Colliery ExplosionThe following letter appears in a London weekly contemporary :— Sir, — Since the delivery of the verdict upon the late melancholy occasion, I see that some anonymous communications have been made even to the Times paper; and, as no published plans of the colliery have hitherto been laid before the public, I am not a little surprised that they can be imagined capable of forming an opinion for or against the evidence given, and the verdict of the jury ; I am, therefore, tempted to give what I am satisfied is the real state of the facts, together with a sketch of the locus in quo. The ventilation of the colliery, when in full work, was stated as between 50,000 and 60,000 cubic feet per minute, subdivided into six ventilating columns, one of which was devoted to the airing of the principal working places contiguous, and the goaf, which is agreed upon all hands to have been the principal seat of the fire, and to guard against which safety-lamps were employed. A process was at the time going on in the up-cast shaft, where two furnaces were ordinarily employed to keep up the ventilation, but which furnaces so heated the shaft that it was necessary to diminish their effect at the week's end to accommodate the shaft workers. This operation, according to the very honest evidence of the furnace keeper, diminished the amount of ventilation one-half, so that the quantum of air passing amongst the workers contiguous to the goaf may be set down as from 4,500 to 5,000 cubic feet per minute. Coincident with this state of things was the blasting of stone at a 5-fm dip trouble up the opposite side of the above working, and contiguous to the said goaf which blew down, was in another branch of the ventilation, but it was allowed to be going on under precarious circumstances, and the results prove that the fire had spread over the whole of that district; hence the various opinions as to where the origin of the fire took place ; whether at the exposed lights, where the blasting was going on, or at one of the lamps used by the coal workmen, of which there is no collateral proof, as all the persons were killed. In prosecuting an inquiry of this nature, it is most natural and most necessary that the men of the colliery should confer with the inspector as to the previous state of the pit, and whether anything out of the ordinary course had been carried on; but, on the contrary, not a single man either conferred or offered himself for examination, whilst the colliery owners had summoned to their aid a host of viewers, according to custom upon these occasions. Therefore, I was driven to the necessity of eliciting the bearing facts of the case, which I made out as follows:— 1. — That the ventilation was diminished one-half by the process before referred to, as attested by Holt, the furnace keeper. 2. — That, notwithstanding that, the blasting at the trouble was going on as usual. 3. — That also eight or ten hewers and putters were working coal immediately adjacent to the foul goafs, although with safety lamps, and this without any necessity. Herein, then, lay the gravamen of the question as to the prudence of having these workings going on with the acknowledged elimination of the ventilation, and this brings me to refer to a recommendation contained in a little pamphlet I lately published under the title of "How to Prevent Accidents in Collieries." In the 23rd page of that pamphlet I find the following passage :— "That every pit's crew shall select a committee of three or five intelligent or reasonable men, who shall entreat of the manager to make them acquainted with the general arrangements of the colliery, such as the air-courses, the splits, the furnaces, and such other of the general principles of management as may enable them not only to make suggestions for their own safety, but to be competent to act more efficiently upon the emergency of an explosion, in reinstating the colliery and in relieving the sufferers," &c. With these remarks I leave the public to judge how far the very colliers have been remiss in their duty to leave the inspector to cope with the advocates of the colliery without putting him in possession of the material features of the case. I may remark that the late melancholy catastrophe at Worsborough, in Yorkshire, would corroborate these remarks; for there it would appear that certain operations were attempted by the manager without the privity of the men, who might have availed themselves of such knowledge, and have saved their lives. I will close this article with the remark, that the advantages intended by the Mine Inspection Act cannot be realised without the active exertion of the colliers in some such manner as the above. P.S. — Strange to relate, only two or three of the workmen attended the inquest. Government Mine Inspector.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||