Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th December 1862

Letters to the Editor

Colliery Explosions

Sir, — During the ten years ending December 31, 1860, it is officially recorded 9,090 lives were lost in our collieries, and 605,154,940 tons of coal raised ; so that on the average one person was killed for every 66,573 tons, and there was an annual slaughter of 909 persons. Of accidents which are not fatal no general summary has yet been presented ; but it is well known that there is a frightful amount of maiming, from slight hurts to actual crippling for life. All "of woman born" are exposed to risk of one kind or other from the cradle to the grave, but the perils of the collier are manifold and, in some respects, peculiar. He encounters perils above and perils below ; perils in descending and perils in ascending ; perils by fire and perils by water ; and perils of the most varied and remarkable character. Thus we are informed that one man was "strangled by his comforter winding round the axle of the waggon on which he was riding ;" a second was "strangled by the cage chain twisting round his neck on landing at the bottom of the pit ;" a third was smoking, when a lump of coal fell and drove the stem of his pipe into the roof of his mouth, whereof he died ; and a fourth was killed by the fall of a piece of ice from the side of the shaft while he was standing at the bottom. This list might be greatly extended, and any one desiring copious information on the subject may peruse the Reports of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Coal Mines, which abound in details of the most exciting, most instructive, and frequently most shocking description. Crushing to death by sudden falls of the roof is of common occurrence, and by jamming on tramways only occasional ; tumbling down shafts from the breaking of ropes or chains, or otherwise, and overwinding are not rare, though less frequent than formerly ; suffocation from carbonic acid gas evolved from old workings is not very unusual ; sudden and overwhelming irruption of water has occasioned great destruction of life ; but of all the causes of death in collieries explosions from firedamp have been the most prolific. King Firedamp is the veritable King of Dahomey of the coal pit ; but, happily, there is no point on which skilful and experienced colliery engineers seem to be more agreed than that of their power to render this monarch impotent. Of all the dangers incidental to the life of a collier it has been amply demonstrated that the explosion of firedamp is among the most preventable. It is sickening to wade through the ponderous folio volumes of the Reports previously referred to, and to observe that, with very few exceptions, ignition of the gas has been caused entirely by the neglect of the most obvious precautions, or from gross ignorance or mismanagement of those in charge of the underground works. Efficient ventilation, the exclusive use of the safety lamp, and the enforcement of the strictest discipline, are pretty sure and effectual preventatives of explosions. Mr. Wynne, one of the colliery inspectors, thus writes in his Report to the Home-office of the accidents which occurred in 1859, in North Staffordshire, Cheshire, and Shropshire :—

"This fearful source of premature death (explosions) has not been the cause of so many accidents or deaths as in previous years, which I attribute to that very salutary first general rule which makes the owner or agent responsible for the due ventilation of the working places of the mine, and nearly every death by explosion may be traced to the want of attention to this rule."

One of the most striking instances on record of the protection afforded by the safety lamp is contained in Mr. Inspector Hedley's Report for 1860. At the Shipley Hard Coal Colliery, Derbyshire, in November, a large outburst of gas took place in a well ventilated part of the pit, when the Davy lamps became full of flame and the Geordie or Stephenson lamps were extinguished. One man in escaping had to pass along "a face of work" 60 or 70 yards long with his Davy lamp full of flame. Had he tripped and the gas exploded 70 lives would have been lost, and "another would have been added to the list of unaccountable explosions. A defective lamp, or the exposure of a light, would have been suggested as the cause of the catastrophe." Strict discipline is not less essential to guard against explosion ; but this is the most difficult condition to ensure. Familiarity with danger is apt to produce indifference to it. There are reckless and incorrigible fools who, in spite of every precaution, will find their way into coal pits, and not hesitate to jeopardize the lives of their comrades as well as their own. Foolhardiness has destroyed thousands in our pits. Now, it is obvious that in the working of all coal seams which are known to yield firedamp the blasting of coal with gunpowder should be conducted with extreme care ; and in fiery seams from which gas escapes copiously at all times, and occasionally with sufficient rapidity to produce "blowers," thus necessitating the constant use of the safety lamp, it is at least doubtful whether the practice should ever be allowed. Mr. Nicholas Wood, one of the most skilful and experienced colliery workers of the day was asked the following question before the Select Committee of the House of Commons on accidents in Coal Mines (July 14, 1853, No. 3,817) :—

"Would you allow him (the collier) to use gunpowder at his own discretion ?"

The answer was, —

"No, certainly not ; I think where lamps are used no gunpowder should be used, except by direct authority of the overman, or some accredited person, and then it should only be used in cases where the mine is generally considered to be perfectly safe without the use of safety lamps, and where lamps are used only as a security against sudden outbreaks of Gas. I think in a mine that is doubtfully safe safety lamps should be used and gunpowder should be prohibited ; lamps should be used where the mines are liable to become unsafe by any sudden outbreak of gas."

The Belgian Government imposes the following stringent regulations as to the employment of gunpowder in coal mines :—

"The use of gunpowder for blasting coal in firedamp seams is forbidden, with those exceptions which are permitted by Administration. The employment of this aid is only allowed for works in the rock, under the reserve expressed in the following conditions :— ‘No substance is to be employed in lighting the match which is capable of burning with flame ; not to fire the shot until. by inspection of the flame of the lamp, it has been carefully ascertained that there is no inflammable gas in that part of the works ; to appoint for the performance of this duty, and that of lighting the charge, master workmen, or experienced miners, previously exercised in this duty.' "

I will now present a series of instances in which explosions have been caused by blasting.

Cwmbach, Aberdare, October 8, 1852. — "Gas exploded by firing blast." Two men killed.

Smithfold Colliery, Durham, March 3, 1855. — Two men were working near an accumulation of firedamp, and knowing this, contrary to orders, fired a shot and lighted the gas.

Holland Colliery, Upholland, Wigan, August 9, 1855. — Explosion of firedamp and gunpowder. Two men killed.

Foley Colliery, Longton, Staffordshire. — "Explosion caused by a too free use of powder in blasting when gas was known to be floating near the roof of the mine." Two men killed.

Townhouse Colliery, Lancashire, 1856. — "A new workman . . . . attempted to fire his shot with a ‘German' or paper squib filled with powder, which on being lighted, flew, as it appeared, into the goaf and lighted some firedamp, which had apparently issued shortly before from a fall of roof." Ten persons were burnt and five fatally.

Bells Mill Colliery, Shelton, belonging to Earl Granville, 1857. — Gas was known to have accumulated, and must have increased during the day to such an extent "that the concussion caused by the firing several shots brought it out into the working places, and on firing another shot the explosion took place." Safety lamps were used. "This case confirms the opinion I (Mr. Inspector Wynne) have long entertained that where the use of safety lamps is necessary, blasting by powder should not be allowed."

Deep and fiery mine belonging to the Standish and Shevington Cannel Company, Lancashire, Dec. 25, 1858. — Shale, loosened by two shots, was left at the end of a level, where it fell and obstructed ventilation ; and, on attempting to fire a third shot, an accumulation of gas had taken place near the shot-hole, which ignited and exploded an unstopped canister containing 9lb. of powder. The man who held it was killed.

Bryndu Colliery, South Wales, Dec. 1858. — "The man working in the level had bored a hole in the coal, and was ready to fire it. He went for the fireman, whose duty it was first to examine the place, and then, if safe, to fire the shot himself. On this occasion he did not do so. A little gas had accumulated near the face of the level, which he exploded at his naked light. This is a locked lamp colliery, and, in my opinion (writes Mr. Inspector Evans), blasting the coal ought not to be allowed." Twelve persons were killed.

Walthew-house Colliery, Wigan, Feb. 17, 1859. — "An explosion of firedamp after firing a shot ;" one man killed.

Clarke's Silkstone Colliery, near Barnsley, 1860. — "In firing a shot some inflammable gas ignited in the works, and two men were thereby slightly burnt."

Seaham Colliery, Sunderland, belonging to the Marchioness of Londonderry, Sept. 24, 1860. — Safety lamps were used. Two men were employed in blasting stone, and had orders only to open a lamp for the purpose of firing shots, after ascertaining by careful examination that it was safe to do so. Shortly before the explosion, the district had been examined by the master shifter and pronounced free from gas. The men perished from after-damp in a place of supposed safety at a distance, and both their lamps were found to be in order and uninjured. The gas was ignited by the explosion of the shot. Experiments were afterwards made upon the air circulating through this part of the mine, which led to the conclusion that most probably a "blower," or sudden irruption of gas, had caused the accident.

Cwmdare Colliery, South Wales, 1860. — "On the night of the explosion, the colliers in this place, contrary to rules, fired a shot in the top coal, and instantly an explosion of gas took place ; some gas lodged in the "gob" walls, and was probably fired by the fuse." Locked safety lamps were used, but almost every one had a key.

That the Bardsley Main Coal is a fiery seam, is sufficiently proved by the following explosions of gas which have occurred in working this seam in the immediate vicinity of Barnsley :— March, 1847, 73 persons were killed at the Oaks or Ardsley Main Colliery ; February, 1847, six persons, and January, 1849, 75 persons were killed in the Darley Main Colliery ; December, 1851, 50 persons were killed in the Warren-vale Colliery ; January, 1853, 10 persons were killed in Elsecar Colliery ; February 19, 1857, the terrific catastrophe occurred at the Lundhill Colliery, when 198 persons were killed ; and now we have the explosion at Edmund's Main Colliery. I presume that this accident took place, as usual, in the Main Coal. Barnsley, it will be admitted, has become ingloriously famous in the annals of death from firedamp.

Now, Sir, I think you will agree with me that, if blasting be allowed in the getting of coal, it should either be prohibited in the Barnsley Collieries, or conducted with extraordinary precaution. The facts and opinions of the highest practical authorities which I have advanced, seem to indicate prohibition in this district. Under no possible circumstances is it conceivable that perfect immunity from explosions can be secured so long as the practice is continued. We have seen that, even when no gas could be detected in the air circulating through a pit, the firing of a shot has been coincident with the irruption and ignition of a "blower." But I observe in The Times of to-day that, according to the deposition of one witness at the inquest now pending, on Saturday, at Edmund's Main Colliery, "there was enough (gas) to fire at the lamps all the day, from 6 in the morning till 2 p.m." in the same part of the pit where the explosion occurred on the following Monday. It is further stated that "gas came from slits over the whole face of the coal, not from any large orifice," and that "the gas fired at the fuse before the shot went off."

At present our information concerning the explosion at Edmund's Main Colliery is incomplete and unsatisfactory, and we must suspend judgement until the conclusion of the coroner's inquisition on that deplorable event. But assuming that the statements already published are correct, and that blasting with gunpowder was permitted in the Barnsley Main Coal, — a seam, be it remembered, which was well known to be fiery, and which the most competent authorities in the country assert cannot be worked with security to life unless safety lamps are exclusively used, — then, there need be no hesitation in declaring that the managers of the colliery have been guilty of culpable recklessness of human life. Upon the coroner and the jury will devolve a responsibility of no ordinary kind, and it is earnestly to be desired that in this solemn inquiry they will acquit themselves like men, and deliver a verdict in strict accordance with the evidence. England demands that they shall do their duty honestly and boldly, having only the fear of God before their eyes.

The casualties arising from blasting coal are extremely numerous, though it must be admitted comparatively few explosions of gas have been traced to the use of gunpowder. The reports of Her Majesty's Inspectors of Coal Mines abound in the records of deaths from the careless application of this formidable agent. Colliers are proverbially reckless and in the handling of gunpowder and mode of conducting their blasting operations have frequently not displayed even the prudence of children. In many cases it is undoubted that blasting is injurious to the interests both of colliery lessors and lessees. Much coal is reduced to slack, which is either valueless or comparatively of small worth. It is only a few weeks ago that I was conversing on this subject with a gentleman in South Wales, who has had very great experience as a colliery viewer, and who expressed his unqualified condemnation of the indiscriminate practice of blasting coal, but added that in some localities — as he knew to his regret — the colliers would not work if debarred the use of gunpowder. Their labour may be thereby facilitate, yet it is questionable whether they would not willingly consent to abandon the practice on receiving slightly additional wages, and whether colliery proprietors and workers would not be more than compensated by the increased value of their coal consequent on the diminution in the proportion of slack. I have had many years' experience in the working of collieries in one part of England, and have arrived at the conviction that in my district powder, except in the driving of rock-roading, is an abomination in coalpits, and in many cases ought to be prohibited. Blasting may be essential in some cases to enable the coal to be got with profit, but there can be no doubt that it is frequently resorted to when neither necessary nor desirable.

I am, Sir, your obedient servant,

N.

Dec. 17.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Granville, Earl      
Londonderry, Marchioness of      
Wood, Nicholas      Whos Who Page
Wynne, Thomas    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print