11th December 1862
Claim For Wages
Robert Newall, miner, appeared to claim £1 6s 1d, being balance of wages due to him from the Hematite Iron Ore Company. Mr. Webster appeared for the complainant, and Mr. Halton for the defendant.
Mr. Webster having briefly stated the case, called the complainant, who stated that he was a collier and had worked in No. 2 pit of the Hematite Iron Ore Company. About three weeks ago Mr. Bayles, the manager of that pit, engaged him to clear a
drift in the pit to the extent of 18 yards. He was to receive 3s 6d a yard, for doing the work. He was to be paid 8s 9d a score for the coals he took out, and 3d for the clay. The drift was to be driven 6 feet high and 6 feet wide. The drift had a stone
roof and a metal sole. He had driven 18 yards into that drift. After he had wrought a week, Mr. Bayles came to him and told him that he was to clear the drift in another direction from that in which he was clearing it; but he did not do so; he cleared it
straight on. When he got a certain distance in the drift he came in contact with a pillar of coal, and the overman of the pit told him that he was to drive right through the coal. Mr. Bayles afterwards came and told him that he was not to drive through
the coal in that manner, but that he was to drive through the metal. He then told Mr. Bayles that if he was not to be allowed he would not be able to make much wages. At the end of the fortnight he measured his work, and he found that he had completed
the distance of 18 yards, which he agreed to do when he was engaged by Mr. Bayles. The 18 yards at 3s 6d, amounted to £3 3s; six score of coals and two bogies, amounted to £2 12s 10d; and 29 bogies of clay at 3d per bogie amounted to 7s 3d,
which made a total of £6 3s 10d. He had received and given credit for £4 9s 10d; 4s 10d had been stopped off him for a load of coals. That made £4 16s 8d; and the balance he now claimed was £1 6s 1d, which the company had refused
to pay him.
Cross-examined: His "marrow" and Mr. Taylor, the overman of the pit, was present when he made the contract with Mr. Bayles to drive the drift in the pit for 3s 6d a yard. The agreement was made for a fortnight. He was told to take metal,
bank coal, and fire clay out of the drift. There was nothing said about taking half stone and half coal out of the drift. It was not his bargain to take half stone and half coal out of the drift for 3s 6d per yard. The first 9 yards he took out consisted
of metal and fire clay. There were no stones amongst it; but there was some coal in it. The next nine yards they took away were all coal together. They had to make the drift six feet wide and six feet high. When they took the material away, the drift
might perhaps be an inch or two wider than six feet. He denied that his bargain with Mr. Bayles was to take half stone and half coal out of the pit.
By Mr. Webster: The first nine yards we took away, we only got seven bogies of coal out of it, which amounts to 2s., I could not tell how much dirt we got out. The second nine yards were all coal.
John Hannah examined, said he was "marrow" along with the last witness when they drove the drift in the pit. He knew the arrangement which had been made with the complainant and Mr. Bayles. He considered they were justified in having the
same pay for the coal they took out of the drift, as they got for the metal. They agreed that they were to have so much per yard for driving the drift, no matter whether the material they took out was coal or metal.
This being the case for the complainant, Mr. Halton addressed the court on behalf of the defendants. He remarked that Mr. Bayles, colliery viewer, appeared as the representatives of the Hematite Iron Company; and he would call that gentleman to speak as
to the bargain which he had with the complainant. When the contract was made it was agreed that the complainant was to take half stone and half coal out of the drift. When they proceeded nine yards in the drift, instead of taking out half stone and half
coal, they took all the coal from the coal side of the drift, and also made it much wider. Of course, it was great advantage for the complainant to do that, because he was not only getting 3s 6d per yard for excavating the coal, but he had also so much
per score of bogies as well for the coal he took out. He considered that Mr. Bayles had dealt remarkably liberal with the complainant; but instead of him working according to the agreement which he had made, he had made the drift much wider than he ought
to have made it, and consequently the pit had been very much injured thereby. He (Mr. Halton) contended that his clients ought not to have been proceeded against, but the defendants might have proceeded against the complainant for the injury he had done
to the pit by not doing his work according to the instructions which had been given him by Mr. Bayles.
Mr. Bayles, upon being called by Mr. Halton, deposed that he was colliery viewer in No. 2 pit of the Hematite Iron Ore Company. About three weeks on Monday he let a contract to the complainant. The contract was to make an air course in an old working of
the pit alongside a previous old air course. The bargain was that the complainant should take out half coal and half debris. The work was to be done at the rate of 3s 6d per yard, for the specified width, six feet. The complainant in the present case
completed the first nine yards of the work to his satisfaction; but after that he was informed by Mr. Taylor, the overman in the pit, that he had begun to take nothing but coal out of the second nine yards. Upon that information he went to the pit, and
found that Mr. Taylor's statement was correct. He then told complainant that as he had disobeyed his orders, he could not pay him for taking so much coal out. Complainant had left the stone on the right side of the drift and had taken nothing but coal
from the left side. They had made a space of 15 feet which had consequently made the drift almost useless as an air course. He had ordered the complainant to make the drift six feet wide, and to take half stone and half coal out of it, but he had not
done so.
By Mr. Webster: The face of the drift before the complainant commenced to work on it presented coal and stone. There were three feet of coal and three feet of stone. I have not got an account of the coal that was taken out of the first nine yards. The
books of the colliery will show the quantity that was taken out.
Thomas Taylor, overman of the pit, corroborated the facts stated by Mr. Bayles. Mr. Webster applied for an adjournment of the case until Thursday next, in order that the books might be produced to show what quantity of coal had been taken out of
the first nine yards.
The Chairman: It is not usual to adjourn a case after it has been heard.
Mr. Halton: It would make no difference if the books of the colliery were produced. The complainant has disobeyed the order of Mr. Bayles.
Mr. Bayles in reply to the bench, said that when he first discovered that the complainant was taking all coal and no stone out of the drift he told him that he would only give him 1s per yard for excavating it; and he had paid him at that rate for the
second nine yards.
The Chairman: We dismiss the case.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bayles, — | | Colliery Viewer | |
| Halton, — | | Solicitor | |
| Hannah, John | | Collier | |
| Newhall, Robert | | Collier | |
| Taylor, Thomas | | Overman | |
| Webster, — | | Solicitor | |