|
5th December 1862 Letters to the EditorWalker Colliery ExplosionSir, In your impression of Tuesday last your correspondent, "Y," ventures to impugn the verdict of the jury who sat upon this sad calamity on the ground that the evidence did not justify their opinion of its being "accidental." As one of the parties who heard the evidence, it was perfectly clear that there must have been a naked light of some kind with which the gas came in contact, but it was by no means clear where the naked light was which originated the explosion, and the problem was narrowed to two positions :— 1. Workmen were engaged with safety-lamps, as their only light, in the close vicinity of the goaf, where, on the removal of the coal, the overlying strata fall and block up the passages, and within this goaf, which it is impossible to ventilate, gas, if anywhere in the colliery, must accumulate. But without some accident to the lamp, either beyond the control of the workmen — as in the case of an unexpected fall of roof stone damaging his lamp — or in the contingency, forcibly pointed out by Davy, that a current of explosive gas propelled against the gauze of his safety-lamp, beyond a certain, not very high, velocity, was attended with danger — or within his control, where, by a careless swing of his pick, he might perforate the gauze of his lamp, and thus expose the flame, — in any one of these contingencies happening, the explosion, it is not unreasonable to assume, might originate. 2. Two workmen were blasting stone under a current of fresh air of 10,000 cubic feet per minute, passing them with a velocity of six feet per second, where their naked lights were exposed only so long as to light up the match of each shot, and where in this narrow channel of pure air no gas could by any possibility accumulate. Unless, therefore, in defiance of all rules, and contrary to all prudence in men of this class — for they were deputies, selected men, to keep watch and ward over the pit — they uncovered their lamps at some distance from their labour, and in a position to communicate with the goaf, of the existence and precise position of which they were fully cognizant, the probability is shut out of the explosion having occurred through their agency. These were the two positions given to evolve the cause, and the results of the "very minute" examination of the colliery developed the following state of things, as affording probabilities, for they can be carried no higher, that the explosion originated in the first position from one of the causes enumerated. Nothing is more clear than the run of an explosion when the area over which it has passed is afterwards examined. The timber is scorched on the side from which the fire is driven, and all the stoppings and doors are pushed before the blast and cast over and smashed in the current of its path. And over the entire working district to which the explosion was confined these unerring indications carried up the seat of the explosion to the goaf near to and adjoining which workmen with safety-lamps were employed. And by the same infallible test not one prop exhibited the least trace of fire in the return drift in which the deputies were blasting, and their covered lamps, found beside them, showed they had attended to their duty. In this condition of things, to what other decision could the jury have come ? They might have found that a workman, by culpable negligence in the use of his lamp, had damaged it, and so expose the flame ; but there was not the slightest evidence to sustain this view. Or, they might have found that, from causes beyond his control, his lamp was damaged, and no other verdict than an "accident" would meet this conjecture. Or they might, in the face of facts, on the consequential evidence of the blast, assume that the deputies using powder had, with a sort of malice prepense, gone out of their way, and jeopardised their own lives by exposing the naked flame of their lamps where they well knew gas, if at all, must exist — a view distinctly negative by the fact that their lamps were found closed and perfect. I say, with so many conflicting circumstances before them, the jury had no other alternative left them than to acquit the colliery, with so much special evidence adduced in favour of its management, and declare that in some way, without specifying the precise mode, the explosion had been one of "pure accident." I am, Sir, yours, &c., W.A.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||