23rd August 1862, Page: 5, Column: 4
The Manorial Righrs Of The Ecclesiastical Commissioners
An inquiry of very great importance
to many holders of property in the North of England,
has been held during the last few days at the King's
Head Imn, Darlington. It appears that at the Spring
Assizes a person named Blackett, residing in Hamsterley,
and the owner of some allotments there, brought an
action against Bradley and others, for damages caused
to his property by the working of coal beneath it by the
defendants, who are lessees under the Ecclesiastical Commissioners.
The case was referred to arbitration, Jas. Grant,
Esq., being appointed arbitrator. The chief question
raised is the liability of the Ecclesiastical Commissioners
to pay compensation for damages they may cause to surface
lands by their mining operations. Mr. Kemplay appeared
for the plaintiff; and Mr. Davison for the
defendants. Mr. Kemplay, in opening the case, said
he appeared for Jos. Blackett, the plaintiff, who
desired to recover damages occurring to certain lands in
the townships of Lynesack and Softly. The property
injured consisted of about fifty and a half acres of
grass land, and it was allotted under the enclosure
act. Defendants admitted the plaintiff's possession of
the land, and also that they and their servants were
working the minerals beneath. The land had been
greatly injured through the falling in of the surface,
owing to the mining operations beneath, and that also,
he believed, would be admitted by the defendants. The
amount of damage done would, however, have to be
proved by witnesses in that court. With regard to the
defence which the defendants set up, he might say
a few words. They alleged that the Bishop of Durham
was lord of the manor of Wolsingham. in which
this township was situated, and that, as such,
he possessed rights over it prior to the passing of the
enclosure act of 1758, which that act did not in any
way interfere with, he being still left with the same
privileges as to working minerals, &c., as he had
previously possessed. Another plea was that of jura
regalia, but he confessed he could not see how it could
be applied to the matter. It was alleged by the
defendants, however, that the Bishop of Durham had
Palatine rights over the county, and it was upon that
ground that the plea was introduced. He should not
argue against those pleas there, but he merely stated
them. Defendants put in other pleas of defence, but
they were chiefly formed. The evidence occupied four
days hearing, but the award will not be given for some
time.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Blackett, Joseph | | | |
| Bradley, — | | Mine Owner | |
| Davison, — | | Solicitor | |
| Durham, Bishop of | | | |
| Grant, James | | Arbitrator | |
| Kemplay, — | | Solicitor | |