28th June 1862, Page: 5, Column: 1
The Miners' Permanent Fund
"What's in a name?" Sometimes a good deal.
The rose doubtless would smell as sweet, its
perfume would be as exquisite, if it were called a
thorn, but an appellation is not always a matter
of perfect indifference. A catching title to a book
sometimes passes it through successive editions ;
a captivating signboard often draws customers to
a shop ; a lucky hit in the way of a name for a
firm or a joint-stock association has frequently
made a speculator's fortune. The mere title of the
Scottish Widows Fund — so characteristic of
benevolence — contributed largely to the success of that
colossal organisation for life insurance purposes.
The name of Old Parr made the fortune of the
proprietor of a patent medicine. We need not
multiply instances. Every reader's experience or
observation will convince him that a good name,
in more senses than one, is excellent capital.
We think the proprietors of a London society
whose avowed object was to provide for the
widows aud families of miners killed whilst pursuing
their ordinary avocations were exceedingly
happy in their choice of a designation. Its title,
"The National Association for the Relief of
British Miners," carried with it a certain amount
of respect and confidence. Its scope was wide, its
aim beneficent. It seemed to spring up just at
the right moment, when the great heart of England
had been sorely stricken by the terrible
calamity at New Hartley, and when every humane
mind felt that something ought to be done to mitigate
the sorrows of those left destitute by like
catastrophes. We confess that we were never able
to give any support to this new organization. It
seemed to us to lack the elements of security and
continuance. It grew too rapidly to give promise
of permanence. Its principles were sound, its
object charitable, its professions laudable, the
sphere of its operations, if not commensurate with
the evil to be mitigated, at least sufficiently
extensive to be practical, and yet we were never able to
place any confidence in the undertaking. It seemed
to us to have a lofty name, and nothing more. True
there were honourable and influential men in the
Council — Sir Fitzroy Kelly, whose career at the
Bar and in the Legislature entitles him to honour,
and Mr. Gurney, who ranks high not only as a
millionaire but as a philanthropist. We knew,
however, that men of this standing were not likely
to take an active interest in the association — at
least not in the details and management of its
affairs. Led into it from motives of humanity and
benevolence, they rather gave the countenance of
their names and the aid of their purses than that
rigid and jealous oversight which we consider
necessary in every association or society entrusted
with money. A speech by Sir Fitzroy Kelly
at Willis' Rooms showed us that he, at all events,
was in entire ignorance as to the condition of our
miners. He evidently looked upon them as black
slaves who needed help and protection, and his
description of a colliery district might have passed
for that of a Hindoo village. Mr. Gurney probably
has not much more knowledge on the subject.
Both had only the idea of subscribing a few
sovereigns, and inducing their friends to do the
same, to further a charitable object.
In all this they grossly and grievously erred.
Our miners are among the most intelligent of the
industrial classes ; they require co-operation, not
charity; they know what will suit their
"order;" they love their wives and families,
and are anxious to provide against the
casualties of life; they are willing to establish a
fund of their own, and only want a little help to
help themselves — help, not from the public
indiscriminately, but from colliery-owners who profit
by the sweat of their brow, and from others who
directly or indirectly derive benefit from the coal
trade. Accordingly from the first we advocated
the formation of a permanent fund jointly by the
colliery-owners and their workmen, on an equitable
basis, under the provisions of an Act of Parliament
which might readily have been obtained,
and with a joint management, any difficulties connected
with which might easily have been overcome.
We were glad to see a body of miners fall
in with these views. They naturally appealed to
the Committee of the Coal Trade, and it was with
much regret we found that Committee decline to
take the initiative in the movement.
The consequence was, a division of opinion and
feeling among the coal-miners; some linked themselves
to the (so-called) National Association, others
commenced a local fund, to be conducted by themselves.
Events which have just occurred may
bring these parties together. The National is in
a state of collapse. Mr. Towers has ceased any
further connection with it, having (he says) been
received on his return from the North with
"insolent coldness" by his associates ; and Mr.
Gurney states it is at present impossible for the
Association to go on. A statement that financial
matters are to undergo examination raises a suspicion
that a screw is loose in that quarter — not,
we apprehend, that there has been any felonious
abstraction of the funds, but rather, we conclude,
that the expenses of management have been somewhat
heavier than the Council anticipated. Mr.
Towers' revelations are instructive. He tells us
that all the Council were chosen by himself, and
taunts these gentlemen with ingratitude. He
furthermore assures us that he can, at bidding,
summon to his assistance, a Council consisting of
the very highest nobility of the land ! The coal
miners must be greatly indebted to Mr. Towers for
the interest which he takes in their behalf, but
"the gentleman doth protest too much." He is
too kind and too zealous. The miners ought not
to expect so much service without recompense, and
if they have a paid manager they should at least
have an independent Council or Committee to
direct his proceedings and audit his accounts.
With the story of the Deposit Bank still ringing
in our ears, we can place no confidence in the
very highest nobility in the land, if they are a
manager's nominees, and their names simply decorate
his circulars.
We hope the miners will now take their affairs
into their own hands, The best thing they can do
is to organize a local association for the counties
of Northumberland and Durham, and register its
rules under the Friendly Societies' Act. We see
they have obtained the assistance of several gentlemen
having good standing and position, of high
character and business habits — among others of
Mr. Bramwell, of Durham, and Mr. Henry Taylor
and Mr. Councillor Benson, of this town. They
have also promises of encouragement and support
from the Bishop of Durham and a few coal-owners,
whose number, there can be no doubt,
will shortly increase. If the work be rightly gone
about, and the miners rally round those who are
able and willing to aid and advise them, a permanent
fund may shortly be established, equal to all
the ordinary contingencies of a pitman's calling.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Benson, —, Councillor | | | |
| Bramwell, John | | Recorder of Durham | |
| Durham, Bishop of | | | |
| Gurney, — | | | |
| Kelly, Fitzroy, Sir | | | |
| Taylor, Henry | | | |
| Towers, — | | Fund Agent | |