




























































|
| Newspaper Articles |
|
Newspaper Articles |
 |
|
 |
21st May 1862, Page: 2, Column: 4
The Reward Of Merit
In every great movement there are some who dissent
from the opinions and question the acts of the
general body ; and in every case where there are
funds to be distributed, whether for private or public
services, and whether given by the whole body of the
nation or by philanthropic and charitable individuals,
there will be claimants who consider their merits, or
deserts, equal to those of others whose claims are
more generally acknowledged, and who will consequently
feel dissatisfied, either at being overlooked or
rewarded in a minor degree. Every person has acquaintances
who conceive that their inventions, it may
be, or their services, have not been rewarded by the
public or their employers ; and the columns of the
public daily contains complaints from naval and
military men, who have had men whom they consider
their inferiors placed over their heads, and from
inventors of artillery or machinery, and others, whose
genius has not been acknowledged, and who suffer the
mortification of seeing people whom they believe to
have achieved less than themselves advanced over
them, and receiving the rewards of successful genius.
It is not to be wondered at, therefore, considering this
general proneness on the part of everybody to consider
their own geese swans, that among the many
men who laboured so incessantly and nobly at the
New Hartley Pit, in the search for the bodies of the
miners, there should be some who consider that their
exertions have not been fully acknowledged, and that,
in proportion to others engaged in the same work,
they would not be adequately rewarded by the
remuneration which the committee of the Sinkers'
Testimonial Fund proposed to award to them.
This feeling of dissatisfaction, which unfortunately
exists, found expression in the letter which
Mr. Robert Milburne, of New Hartley, wrote on behalf
of himself and others, and which we very readily
printed in the Journal a few days ago. It was only
fair to the men that they should be allowed to lay
their case before the public ; and, so far as we are
concerned, had the greatest possible pleasure in
assisting them to gain the public ear. Not that we
believed they had any just ground of complaint.
We were acquainted with the composition of the Testimonial
Committee, and knew that the gentlemen who
form it are thoroughly practical, and, therefore, the best
qualified to judge of the value of each man's work. We
knew also that they were perfectly impartial, and had
no possible motive for not dealing with the case of
each man on its own merits ; and when we knew that
they had taken the greatest care to ascertain the precise
amount of assistance which each man lent to the
work, we felt convinced that there was no reason for
charging them with an unjust appropriation of the
funds which they had kindly, and at great sacrifice of
time and money, undertaken to apportion. We knew,
therefore, that in any attack, coming from whatever
quarter it might, the Committee were well able to
justify themselves ; and, for the very reason that the
Committee were well able to take care of themselves,
we the more readily gave publicity to the complaint of
the men, who, being in a minority, and being on the
Weaker side, were the more in need of aid from
the public press. The letter of Mr. Hurst,
the honorary secretary to the Committee, which
we published yesterday, gave a tardy but complete
reply to the premature complaint that
had been raised, though we cannot agree with
Mr. Hurst that the letter of Mr. Milburne
had the least effect in prejudicing the public against
the committee. For the reasons stated above, the
public had full faith in the committee ; but Mr.
Hurst's letter came in time to clear the ground for
the interesting proceedings of the evening, and to
give additional confidence to the public that the
claims of all the men had been recognised in the proportion
justly due to them. Barring the few who
still feel disappointed, but of whom, we believe, Milburne
is not one, the public will view with unfeigned
satisfaction and approval the appropriation which
the committee has made of its funds, and the proceedings
of last evening, when the pecuniary
rewards and tokens of the medals, which will soon be
presented, were handed to the courageous band who
had so well and truly earned them. No one supposes
that what the men received was the value of
the courage which they exhibited ; that noble quality
is beyond all reward ; but the Committee, so far as
they were enabled by the funds placed at their disposal,
did their best to reward meritorious actions,
which were done for the sake of humanity only.
Not one of all the men who risked their lives in the
attempt to save their fellow-miners dreamt at the
time that they would receive the smallest reward, in
any shape, for what they were doing. No one conceived
he was doing more than an everyday
act of duty ; and when, in the midst of their
prolonged and hazardous exertions, the public
voice in praise of their courage and enduring
fortitude began to reach them, they expressed surprise
that so much public approbation should be given to
what they conceived was an ordinary matter of duty
to each other, and one which was of every-day occurrence.
But their bravery was, nevertheless, of the
truest order. We have no desire, any more than has
Mr. Whitley, to disparage the glory won at the
cannon's month, or at the bayonet's point ; but here,
in the coldness, darkness, and quietness of the pit,
there were no British cheers, no neighings of the warhorse,
no bugle blasts, no close ranks of men
shoulder to shoulder, encouraging the miners
to rescue the living, or search for the dead.
Each was a hero without the incentives which
prompt the warrior, and without the exciting
circumstances which accompany the soldier
on the field. If ever the truth of the saying, that
peace has its victories as well as war, was manifest, it
was last night in the New Town Hall ; and while receiving
the acknowledgments with which their applauding
countrymen presented them, the sinkers and
pitmen were justified in feeling even a nobler pride
than that which the heroes of the Alma and Balaclava
experienced when receiving from their sovereign their
well-earned decorations.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hurst, Thomas G. | | Hon. Sec. | |
| Milburne, Robert | | Miner | |
| Whitley, — | | | |
 |
 |
|
Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
Pub. Date | Article (Newspaper) |
| 16 Jan 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (Annual Register for 1862) |
| 18 Jan 1862 | Terrible Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 20 Jan 1862 | The Dreadful Colliery Accident In Northumberland (The Times) |
| 21 Jan 1862 | The Catastrophe at Hartley Colliery (The Times) |
| 22 Jan 1862 | The Calamity In Northumberland (The Times) |
| 23 Jan 1862 | The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times) |
| 23 Jan 1862 | Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery (The Times) |
| 24 Jan 1862 | The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times) |
| 25 Jan 1862 | The Awful Calamity In New Hartley Colliery (The Times) |
| 25 Jan 1862 | Letters to the Editor, The Sufferers By The Accident At Hartley Pit (The Times) |
| 25 Jan 1862 | Dreadful Colliery Accident, Loss of Two Hundred and twenty lives (Illustrated London News) |
| 25 Jan 1862 | Accidents, Inquests, etc., Terrible Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 27 Jan 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 28 Jan 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 28 Jan 1862 | Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 29 Jan 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 30 Jan 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 30 Jan 1862 | The Sufferers By the Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 31 Jan 1862 | Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 31 Jan 1862 | Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Pit Tragedy (Illustrated London News) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | Meetings At Consett and Blackhill (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Calamity, Mr. Elliott On Insurance (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | Mining Accidents, Government Inspection And Public Sympathy (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 01 Feb 1862 | The Heroes Of Hartley (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 03 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 03 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Disaster (The Times) |
| 05 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 05 Feb 1862 | Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Disaster (The Times) |
| 06 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 06 Feb 1862 | Letters to the Editor, Accidents In Coal Mines (The Times) |
| 06 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Disaster (The Times) |
| 07 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times) |
| 08 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 08 Feb 1862 | Complete Report Of The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 08 Feb 1862 | Photographs Of The Hartley Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 12 Feb 1862 | Comment (The Times) |
| 15 Feb 1862 | Topics of the Week (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 15 Feb 1862 | Home News (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 15 Feb 1862 | Accidents, Inquests, etc., The Inquiry into the Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 15 Feb 1862 | Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 15 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Fund, Meeting Of The Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 18 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Accident (Bury and Norwich Post) |
| 20 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Western Daily Press) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | Sayings and Doings in Parliament, The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | The Hartley Accident, Honour To Whom Honour Is Due (Morpeth Herald) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | Miscellaneous News (The Leeds Times) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 22 Feb 1862 | The New Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 01 Mar 1862 | Home News, The Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 08 Mar 1862 | Home News, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 08 Mar 1862 | Home News, The Hartley Widows and Orphans (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 08 Mar 1862 | The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 15 Mar 1862 | Sunderland Contributions To The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 24 Mar 1862 | Letters to the Editor (The Times) |
| 29 Mar 1862 | The Hartley Relief Fund At The Mansion House (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 05 Apr 1862 | The Hartley Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 26 Apr 1862 | The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 03 May 1862 | Poem On The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 14 May 1862 | The Sinkers' Testimonial (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 14 May 1862 | The Survivors At New Hartley (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 17 May 1862 | Hartley Sinkers' Testimonials, Presentation Ceremony (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 20 May 1862 | Sinkers' Testimonial Fund (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 21 May 1862 | News (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 21 May 1862 | The Reward Of Merit (Newcastle Daily Journal) |
| 22 May 1862 | Presentation To The Hartley Sinkers (Shields Daily Gazette) |
| 24 May 1862 | The Hartley Heroes (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 24 May 1862 | The Hartley Calamity (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 24 May 1862 | Presentation Of Testimonials To The Hartley Sinkers (Morpeth Herald) |
| 27 May 1862 | The Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times) |
| 30 May 1862 | Hartley Sinkers' Testimonial Fund, Notice To Workmen, Tradesmen, And Others (Newcastle Courant) |
| 07 Jun 1862 | The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 02 Aug 1862 | Model Of The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 30 Aug 1862 | "Reading The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 11 Oct 1862 | North Of England Mining Institute (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 11 Oct 1862 | "The Reading Of The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 18 Oct 1862 | The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 03 Jan 1863 | The Hartley Sinkers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 03 Feb 1863 | Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Times) |
| 07 Feb 1863 | Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Times) |
| 07 Feb 1863 | Letters to the Editor (The Times) |
| 14 Feb 1863 | The Hartley Surplus (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 21 Feb 1863 | The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 28 Feb 1863 | Hartley Relief Fund Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 28 Feb 1863 | News (Newcastle Daily Chronicle) |
| 08 May 1863 | The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Courant) |
| 27 Jun 1863 | News (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury) |
| 21 Nov 1863 | The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper) |
| 27 Apr 1880 | Hartley Colliery Accident Fund (The Times) |
| 25 May 1886 | Death Of One Of The Hartley Heroes (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette) |
| 27 Jun 1910 | Aged Miners' Cottages, Hartley Disaster Memorial (Sunderland Daily Echo) |
| 08 Jun 1927 | News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining) |
 | Main page for New Hartley |
 | Accident/Disaster Page |
 | Memorial images gallery |
|
|