Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

12th February 1862

Comment

The calamitous accident in the Hartley Colliery has communicated an extraordinary interest to all the statistics of mining ; and most opportunely, therefore, has a Parliamentary Paper appeared to tell us what has been attempted during the last ten years in the way of precaution against these disasters, and what success has attended the efforts of the Legislature. A series of tables now before us exhibits the whole number of "fatal accidents which have occurred in the Coal Mines of the United Kingdom since the system of Colliery Inspection came into operation," and to this intelligence other particulars are added, by which the relation between the amount of work done and the number of lives lost in any given period or district may be generally ascertained. It seems obvious enough that the Mine from which the greatest weight of coal is raised with the least sacrifice of life must be the best conducted Mine, and, if the risks of mining are found to diminish in proportion to the presumable efficiency of the Inspection maintained, we should be entitled to assume that we are in the right way to check these appalling calamities, if not to prevent them altogether.

Unfortunately, no arithmetical demonstration on these points can yet be attained. We have not the smallest doubt about the facts, nor are we in the least degree perplexed by the apparent inconclusiveness of the returns before us. That uncertainty or vacillation of evidence arises from the very nature of the case. We meet with it in all such inquiries. To take a similar example, there is nothing more difficult than to determine whether railway travelling has been upon the whole better or worse regulated at any given period than at any former period. We can only reckon the number of miles travelled, the number of passengers conveyed, the number of accidents, and the number of lives lost. We can then establish the proportions borne by one set of figures to another, but the evidence so obtained is anything but infallible. A single accident, in itself, perhaps, not reflecting any great discredit on railway management, may be attended with dreadful fatality, and swell the year's returns beyond measure. It was just the same in the bills of mortality returned from our squadron on the West Coast of Africa. For two or three years the casualties would be few, and we fancied we had learnt how to conquer the fever, when a sudden epidemic would destroy a ship's crew and bring the average of deaths up as high as ever. In the case before us, if we suppose, as we probably may, that Inspection has been producing its effects in the better regulation of Mines, and that deaths from colliery accidents were on the decline, we should find all our calculations at once upset by the overwhelming disaster at Hartley. That one ghastly item would render the year 1862 worse-looking, perhaps, than any year preceding, and yet in reality the Mines of the kingdom generally might be under far better management than before. But, besides this fundamental element of disturbance, there are other considerations materially affecting the bare figures of the returns. Mines in the course of years become deeper and deeper, and the work gets proportionately more dangerous, so that the risks to be encountered are greater, and the management may be really more successful even where the accidents show but little diminution. Again, improved Inspection is sure to yield improved information ; no casualties escape notice, and a return exhibiting an increase of deaths above those of former years may mean, not that more deaths have happened, but that more have been recorded.

After these remarks we can state without discouragement, and the reader will learn without surprise, that no regular, constant, or unbroken improvement is to be discovered in the returns now issued. In one of the most important of them the Inspector is satisfied with the recent progress of things, and appeals, with natural gratification, to the fact that the figures for the last year in the table are more favourable than those of any year preceding it. We have no doubt, indeed, that the return does testify to progress achieved, but what if the Hartley accident had happened in this district ? All the deductions would have been destroyed in a moment, and it would have been open to any one to argue that we were worse off than before. All the returns are liable to species of disturbance ; indeed, we observe in one of them that a certain terrible "explosion" is entered specifically, and under its own particular title, as if its consequences ought not to be included in the reckoning of current casualties. In the Yorkshire district the annual deaths range from about 50 to 60 for nine years together, with a single exception, but that exception, which occurs in the middle of the list, shows 245 ! In the South-Western district things showed a gradual improvement from the year 1857 — after the number of Inspectors had been increased — up to 1859, the deaths being successively 85, 54, 46 ; but in 1860 they rose to 198 — more than all the three previous years had produced together. Yet the district in general had probably gone on improving.

These things, it will be said, would find their level in an average. Possibly ; but it must be a long average, whereas the Inspection system is but a very few years old. In the year 1850 we started with four Inspectors for the whole country, but before twelve months had well passed it was found that the Staff must be increased, and in 1852 the four were made six. In 1855 the six were made twelve, and, if there is anything like positive evidence in the returns before us, it is to the effect that as the work was divided the results became more steadily felt. But where we have only five years to compare, while the comparison is open to the disturbances we have described, it needs no words to show that the figures must be inconclusive. In fact, they go up and down, sometimes for better, sometimes for worse ; at one time persuading us that things are on the mend, at another destroying the assurance by the record of some shocking catastrophe. Still, if we could take a long period, we might make allowance for these checks, and look for a gradual improvement in the figures of a course of years ; but this evidence is not before us, and we cannot supply its place.

We conceive, however, that comprehensive reforms may possibly be set against sweeping catastrophes. If, for instance, Inspectors should be empowered for the future to see that each Mine had at least its two shafts, or two communications with the upper air, we should escape all that loss of life which is traceable, not to the immediate effects of an accident, but to means of exit from the Mine after the accident has occurred. This might save us many a hecatomb. Inspection, in fact, can only be effective in proportion to the power of insuring precautions with which the Inspectors are invested. Hartley Colliery had not escaped notice nor remained unvisited, but the Inspector had no authority to insist on the construction of a second shaft. There can be no difficulty in ascertaining what are the chief causes of accidents, and how far these causes are removable. We see already what would infallibly be gained by sinking a second shaft to every Mine, just as we have long learnt what may be done by complete ventilation. It is clear that, if we adopt all the precautions in our power, and provide by proper inspection for the due observance of the system established, we must succeed in diminishing the dangers of mining. In fact, it cannot be doubted that we have done so already. We cannot prove that these risks have been actually smaller in each successive year since Inspectors were appointed, but that proof, as we have shown, was not to be expected. We cannot absolutely prove that the risk is less now than it was fifty years ago, but that is because for the latter period we have no corresponding returns. At present we are enabled by the statistics before us to say that for every 70,000 tons of coal drawn for our use from the bowels of the earth one miner loses his life. We believe the proportion would have been far worse in days gone by, though we cannot prove as much by the same kind of evidence. Common sense, however, is at hand, if figures are not, to tell us we are on the right track ; and we hope that very few years may now elapse before the statistics of mining inform us more distinctly of our progress.


Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hartley Colliery  Hartley Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
16 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Annual Register for 1862)
18 Jan 1862  Terrible Colliery Accident (The Times)
20 Jan 1862  The Dreadful Colliery Accident In Northumberland (The Times)
21 Jan 1862  The Catastrophe at Hartley Colliery (The Times)
22 Jan 1862  The Calamity In Northumberland (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery (The Times)
24 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  The Awful Calamity In New Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Sufferers By The Accident At Hartley Pit (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Dreadful Colliery Accident, Loss of Two Hundred and twenty lives (Illustrated London News)
25 Jan 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., Terrible Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
29 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Sufferers By the Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Pit Tragedy (Illustrated London News)
01 Feb 1862  Meetings At Consett and Blackhill (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Calamity, Mr. Elliott On Insurance (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Mining Accidents, Government Inspection And Public Sympathy (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Heroes Of Hartley (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, Accidents In Coal Mines (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Disaster (The Times)
07 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
08 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Complete Report Of The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Photographs Of The Hartley Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
12 Feb 1862  Comment (The Times)
15 Feb 1862  Topics of the Week (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Home News (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., The Inquiry into the Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Feb 1862  The Hartley Fund, Meeting Of The Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Bury and Norwich Post)
20 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Western Daily Press)
22 Feb 1862  Sayings and Doings in Parliament, The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Accident, Honour To Whom Honour Is Due (Morpeth Herald)
22 Feb 1862  Miscellaneous News (The Leeds Times)
22 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
22 Feb 1862  The New Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Widows and Orphans (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Mar 1862  Sunderland Contributions To The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 Mar 1862  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
29 Mar 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund At The Mansion House (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
05 Apr 1862  The Hartley Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
26 Apr 1862  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 May 1862  Poem On The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
14 May 1862  The Sinkers' Testimonial (Newcastle Daily Journal)
14 May 1862  The Survivors At New Hartley (Newcastle Daily Journal)
17 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonials, Presentation Ceremony (Newcastle Daily Journal)
20 May 1862  Sinkers' Testimonial Fund (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  News (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  The Reward Of Merit (Newcastle Daily Journal)
22 May 1862  Presentation To The Hartley Sinkers (Shields Daily Gazette)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Heroes (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Calamity (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  Presentation Of Testimonials To The Hartley Sinkers (Morpeth Herald)
27 May 1862  The Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
30 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonial Fund, Notice To Workmen, Tradesmen, And Others (Newcastle Courant)
07 Jun 1862  The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
02 Aug 1862  Model Of The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1862  "Reading The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  North Of England Mining Institute (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  "The Reading Of The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Oct 1862  The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Jan 1863  The Hartley Sinkers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
14 Feb 1863  The Hartley Surplus (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Feb 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  Hartley Relief Fund Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  News (Newcastle Daily Chronicle)
08 May 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Courant)
27 Jun 1863  News (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Nov 1863  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Apr 1880  Hartley Colliery Accident Fund (The Times)
25 May 1886  Death Of One Of The Hartley Heroes (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette)
27 Jun 1910  Aged Miners' Cottages, Hartley Disaster Memorial (Sunderland Daily Echo)
08 Jun 1927  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for New Hartley
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print