|
6th February 1862 The Hartley Colliery Accident(From Our Own Reporter.) Seaton Delaval, Tuesday. When the jury met this morning, Emmerson, one of the sinkers employed, was called and gave much the same account as Mr. Coulson of the operations in the shaft, which he described as being very unsafe all the time they were at work. The masses of stone which fell were so large that they had to be split up before they could be removed. No air came up through the ruins at first, but when they had made sufficient progress for the air to rise up it smelt "stythy" — i.e., laden with gas. Mr. John Taylor, coalowner and check viewer to the colliery on behalf of Lord Hastings, the lessor, was the next witness. He was at the pit shortly after the accident, and assisted in the first operations for clearing the shaft until it was given over into the hands of Mr. Coulson. He felt no alarm until the Tuesday, when Mr. Coulson came to him and asked whether there was carburetted hydrogen in the mine. Upon the he went down and made an examination of the air returning from the pit. He could discover no indications of gas with the lamp or candle, but his head was affected, and shortly after that the sinkers were obliged to come up, being affected by the gas which rose in the shaft. He was convinced that every possible exertion had been used by Mr. Coulson and his men to get through the obstruction. Mr. Taylor said that he had paid great attention to the subject of gases generated in mines, and he believed that in this case when the beam fell, carrying the brattice with it, the openings by which the air was taken into the middle seam and furnace drift were both blocked up, the consequence of which would be naturally that the smoke from the furnace would travel backwards and forwards in the middle or yard seam where the men were. The oxygen in that seam would thus be deteriorated, imperfect combustion would be going on, and carbonic oxide would be generated, which, mixing with the carbonic acid gas naturally produced in the mine, would kill the men. Hartley Colliery, he believed, had been skilfully managed, and every precaution had been taken for the safety of the men. It was not a dangerous colliery, nor was there any inflammable gas in it. Mr. John Short, the enginewright, was recalled, and gave the following dimensions of the engine and beam. The engine was of 300-horse power. The diameter of the cylinder was 86½in., with a 10-ft. stroke inside, 9ft. 3in. outside, and seven strokes per minute. The beam was cast by Messrs. Losh, Wilson, and Bell, of the Walker Ironworks. Its weight was 42 tons. The weight which it had to lift, including the "spears" and the column of water, was 43 tons 18 cwt., and it was calculated to carry at least three times that weight, if not more. The length of the beam was 34ft. 6in., and the vertical section in the centre where it broke was 8ft. 2in. It was formed of two separate sides, joined together by bolts and studs. The diameter of the piston rod was 9½in., and its weight 4,816lb. The weight of the piston was the same, and the weight of the cross-head, which was of malleable iron, and was fractured by the accident, 1,904lb. The cap of the cross-head, which was also fractured, was 3¾ inches thick on the top side, and 3½ on the underside. The main dry spears or pumping rods were 14 inches square, and the bottom spears 10 inches square. They were Memel pine. The pumps in the staple worked from the cylinder, and were not disturbed by the accident. The load of the engine was balanced by a counter beam and by a metal catch-pin. The bottom and middle pumps were 24 inches diameter in the barrel, and the staple pumps 20 inches. The steam was condensed on both sides of the cylinder. Mr. Short reiterated his opinion that the spears broke before the beam. The face of the fracture was quite bright and there were no indications of a previous crack. Mr. T. Hoskins, C.E., chief engineer to Messrs. Hawks, Crawshay, and Sons, was next called. He said that he had minutely examined the whole of the beam and was of opinion that the metal was of very fair quality and would be calculated to carry a weight considerably greater — at least four times as great — than that which it was carrying at the time of the accident. A sudden check, operating with other causes, would be very likely to cause it to break. He did not believe that the slipping down of the beam from the hydraulics when it was raised three inches out of the brasses would have fractured it, and certainly if there had been a crack then it would have gone on to complete fracture long before the accident, which he understood was several weeks after. The face of the fracture was quite bright, but if there had been a crack before it would have been rusted by the atmosphere. The sides of the beam were what were called opens and castings, which would not be so strong as box castings. The cavities in the beam revealed by the fracture had occurred from the contraction of the fluid metal during the process of cooling. Such cavities would always occur in cooling where there was a large section to cast, unless the metal abstracted by the contraction were supplied by a process of feeding. That might prevent such cavities occurring to a certain extent, but not altogether. The centre gudgeons or axles of the beam had been wedged and keyed into a hexagon hole in the beam. This must have required very great force — so much so that their heads showed strong marks of the "swages" used to drive them. The effect of this would be to throw an enormous strain on the cohesion of the metal surrounding the gudgeon-hole, and probably it would be one of the causes assisting to break the beam. In addition to that the angular shape of the gudgeon-hole was unfavourable to its strength ; a circular hole would have been the best. Two of the angles of the gudgeon-hole, those at the top and bottom, coincided with the line of fracture. The modern practice in fitting these gudgeons on axles was to bore a circular hole in the beam, turn the gudgeon to fit, and then simply secure it by on key. That mode threw the least possible tension on the metal. On being asked his opinion of the cause of the fracture, Mr. Hoskings said there must have been two or three causes in operation. In the first place, he thought the gudgeon had been unduly keyed — driven home with unnecessary force. There had also been a want of due distribution of metal ; there was too much metal in the centre boss, and the vertically curved ribs along it, instead of adding to its strength, would impoverish the metal in the line of the fracture. If the gudgeon worked hot — which he had been told was the case — a slight expansion would thus be produced, and, with the tight keying, this would be another operating cause of the fracture, especially at the tiem when it took place, there being a severe frost. Mr. Hoskings did not think that the pumps had got wedged, but the bottom spear had given way, judging from the fracture he had seen, from the weight which was on it. The wood did not appear to be of the best quality. The engine would thus be relieved from the outside weight, and the beam would strike violently on the spring beam inside, producing a severe shock, which, taken in combination with the causes he had before referred to, sufficiently accounted for the accident. A very slight and comparatively inexpensive engineering arrangement would be quite enough to prevent beams from falling under similar circumstances. Either a strong scaffolding might be built underneath, or it might be secured by trusses and iron bridles ; but, in one way or another, it would be the easiest thing in the world to secure a beam working in such a dangerous position so that it could not fall down the shaft, if it should unhappily break in a similar manner. Mr. Thomas Clark, ironfounder, of Newcastle, said the quality of the metal was very good. That was shown by the fracture, for any cast iron which possessed strength showed an irregularity in the fracture ; and in looking at the beam he had observed a great many fragments still hanging to it, not broken entirely away. This showed great tenacity. The appearance, too, of the section of the fracture was very favourable as to its casting, and its colour also indicated good iron. The explanation given by Mr. J. H. Murray, of Chester-le-Street, ironfounder, of the cause of the fracture, differed slightly from Mr. Hoskings's account. The beam had certainly not been broken by its usual work, but by concussion. When the engine lost her load in the pit the piston would strike violently on the bottom of the cylinder, and then the beam would be broken. The fracture of the cross-beam, he thought, proved this. The proportions of the beam were very good, though it would have been improved by the addition of more metal in the centre. Mr. Blackwell remarked that he could not agree with the witness that the piston had struck the cylinder. The spring beam had received a very severe blow, as he should be able to show. The next witness called was Mr. H. Warence, of the Walker Iron Works (where the beam was cast), who produced an entry from the books of the firm showing the composition of the casting was one-third Blenarvon No. 3, cold blast, and two-thirds No 1 O.M.O. Scotch. At the conclusion of this witness's evidence the inquiry was further adjourned until Wednesday, at 1 o'clock. The following is a copy of a petition which it is proposed the miners of Northumberland and Durham should sign and send to the Legislature :— "To the Honourable the Commons of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland in Parliament assembled, the humble Petition of the Coal Miners of Great Britain respectfully showeth, — "That from the frequent number of terrible disasters occurring among miners, produced by one shaft, which is necessarily bratticed, to one mine, as in the last appalling catastrophe at Hartley Pit, your petitioners are convinced there is no safety for themselves, or security for their families from destitution, whenever your petitioners are exposed to the dangerous conditions of single-shafted mines. That your petitioners have arrived at the inevitable conclusion, from sad experience among their class, that every mine, previous to working coal, should have two distinct shafts sunk, one at the dip and another at the rise, with a view to the ulterior plans of the mine ; and also that, in proportion to the extent of the royalty to be worked, a proportionate number of shafts ought to be put down, not only for better ventilation and the security of the miners, but also, in the judgement of your petitioners, for the cheaper and more advantageous working of the mines. Your petitioners therefore humbly pray that your honourable House will cause inquiry to be made into the present system of ventilation and working of mines, with a view to the better protection of miners from the appalling disasters that are perpetually overtaking them. And your petitioners will ever pray," &c.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||