|
3rd February 1862 The Hartley Colliery Accident(From Our Own Reporter.) Newcastle-On-Tyne, Saturday. Among other expedients for securing the greatest amount of vigilance on the part of owners and viewers, and for compelling them to take every possible precaution to protect the lives of the men from the manifold perils they encounter in their daily labours, it has been proposed to invest Coroners' juries with the power of returning what are called intermediate verdicts. At present, they can only find a verdict of "Accidental Death" or "Manslaughter," and, without wishing to go so far as to incriminate any particular person, they may be of opinion that there has been neglect somewhere ; but when they append an expression of such opinion to the verdict, Coroners will often tell them that it amounts to a finding of manslaughter, and object to receive a verdict in an ambiguous form. There are few of these accidents in which a prosecution for manslaughter could be sustained, and it has been suggested that Coroners' juries should have the power, in cases where there has been a neglect of obvious precautions, to inflict a pecuniary fine on the owners or managers, in proportion to the extent of the negligence. This fine might either take the shape of an obligation to pay the average wages of the men to their relatives for a certain period, or it might be levied in a lump sum. In this district, which contains some of the most extensive and best-managed collieries in the kingdom, conducted by the most experienced viewers, — there appears no ground for asserting that owners, as a rule, do not take every care to prevent accidents, but it is, unfortunately, far different in other parts of the country, where the principles of scientific mining are not so well understood. But the strict observance of these principles so often requires large preparatory outlay, and interferes so much with the "get" of coal, that in every district there will be men who neglect the necessary precautions, turn a deaf ear to the inspector's suggestions, and work their mine on the very verge of danger for the sake of an additional return. To place before such men the prospect of a pecuniary penalty of this sort, it is urged, would be the most effectual preventative of accidents. They would at once take steps to work their mines on the most approved principles — they would adopt the most stringent rules, and they would take care to select for their officers the steadiest and most experienced men, who would watch with the greatest vigilance over the execution of those rules. It is said that all attempts to obtain compensation in cases of colliery accidents — and there have been several made — under Lord Campbell's Act, have altogether failed, because the judges have held that a servant on his hiring undertakes as between him and his master to run all the ordinary risks of the service, including the risk of negligence on the part of a fellow-servant, presuming always that the master has taken reasonable care to preserve him from such risk by associating him with persons of ordinary skill and care. I should have thought, however, that where the cause of the accident could be clearly traced to the parsimony or neglect of the master, an action might be sustained, but there appears to be an impression here that the Act is inapplicable to colliery accidents generally. Certainly, to say the least of it, it does not furnish a very accessible means of redress to widows and orphans who are indebted to public charity for their daily bread. Whether Lord Campbell's Act requires amendment in this respect, or whether, considering how helplessly the miner has to trust his safety to his superiors, and how little he can do of himself to avert the dangers which surround him, coalowners ought to be placed under a more stringent responsibility than the rest of the community it is not for me to say, but it is easy to see that some such provision would act very powerfully in securing the best management. I believe the proposal has the support of most of the inspectors, who believe that it would add great weight to their suggestions, and they would probably prefer it to any addition to their own powers. In France and Belgium the principle has been established for some time past, and in addition to fines the Government has also the power of imprisoning the persons responsible for the accident. Were such a power lodged in the hands of a Coroner's jury, or any other tribunal, we should probably hear no more, even without further legislation, of the single shaft system, for every coalowner would feel that, after the warning of the Hartley pit, any accident which might happen for want of a second shaft would cost him a pretty heavy sum. It is not, however, so much in great calamities like this as in the smaller accidents which are perpetually happening, and to which public attention is scarcely ever directed, that the weight of such a penalty would be most felt. In these great accidents, when the flooding of the mine or the destruction of the workings by the tempestuous fire stops the operations for some time, the loss to the lessee is so great, often involving his ruin, that a fine would bring him no additional smart. But the necessity of taking every precaution and observing the strictest vigilance would be much more strongly impressed upon him if he were perpetually being dropped on for £50 or £100 to maintain the widow and family of some poor fellow who had perished through his negligence or mismanagement. Besides the cases of deaths there are many accidents which result inn bodily injury more or less serious, and of these — though they may arise from gross mismanagement — the public of course hear nothing. It is worth while considering whether it would not be desirable to follow the precedent of the Factory Act, and empower the inspectors to prosecute for penalties in cases of non-fatal accidents. It is certainly a great defect in the present system that there is no inquiry into the causes of these occurrences, though in many cases it would reveal the most serious defects in the system of working the mine or in the discipline kept. The coalowners of course cannot be expected to concur very readily in the principle of compensation. They will point out that they are already liable to specific penalties if they break certain general and special rules which Parliament and the inspectors have imposed on them, and they will object to the kind of exceptional legislation which would subject them in addition to other undefined penalties for acts against which the law has not warned them, and of the relevancy of which to the cause of death a jury, generally totally devoid of mining knowledge, is to be the sole judge. From such a wide net they will say there is no escape from them. The force of these arguments, however, must be very much weakened by the strong objections they have always urged against allowing the inspectors to interfere with any opinion on their mode of working each particular pit. The inspectors, they contend — drawing certainly a very fine distinction — have only to look to the safety of the men, and can have nothing to say to the principles on which the coal is won. They are placed in this dilemma, — either they must concede to the inspector greater latitude of interference with the workings ; or they must be compelled, like the railway companies, to compensate those who suffer from their mismanagement. All the persons with whom I have conversed on this grave subject agree that a most important step towards preventing the occurrence of accidents would be to give to those who hold responsible positions in coal mines additional means of education in the scientific parts of their duties. I do not speak of the head viewers, who in this district are for the most part highly educated and experienced men ; but of the resident officials, superintendents or overmen, and the like, on whose daily and hourly conduct of a mine depends to a great extent the safety of the men employed in it. They are ordinarily men who have risen from the ranks, and though in the country of George Stephenson, Fairbairn, and others it is impossible to speak of the class with disrespect, yet even here — and the remark applies with much more force elsewhere — great as may be their practical acquirements, as a rule few of them have had an opportunity of obtaining that amount of scientific knowledge which would enable them to appreciate the full value of the rules and precautions which they have to carry out. Long acquaintance with danger is apt to make merely practical men foolhardy. Contingencies, moreover, are always arising in the working of a mine which require to be met immediately, before there can be an opportunity of consulting the scientific officer in charge, and there can be no doubt that to make the non-commissioned officers, as we may call them, thoroughly acquainted with the why and wherefore of everything they would have to do would greatly increase their value and diminish the risk of accidents, particularly those which arise from deficient or impeded ventilation. There is, I believe, a mining college established in this town, which has already done good service ; and it would be a great public advantage if other such colleges were established at convenient places in every district where mining operations are carried on. Not a vessel leaves our ports but its captain and chief officers have passed through some sort of examination and have received a certificate of competency. The miner's calling is infinitely more hazardous than the sailor's, and surely he has a right to require that those into whose hands he intrusts his life should have given equal proof of their ability to cope with the perils which hourly threaten him. I am aware that in the safeguards I have pointed out I have gone beyond the requirements of the present accident ; but public attention has been so forcibly directed to the subject that there never can be a better opportunity for pressing the adoption of every precaution for the protection of those brave men to whose patient and arduous toil this country owes so much. An accident like that at the Hartley pit can never occur again if Parliament will only insert in the present Act an additional general rule that no pit shall be worked until two shafts have been sunk, or at least until there are two independent ways in and out provided. That this will be done in the ensuing Session no one here seems to doubt. In a former letter I quoted the authority of George Stephenson against the single-shaft system, and I take the opportunity here to give his exact words :— "I think," he says, — "The ventilation of coal mines would be much more certain if two pits were sunk instead of one. The air for ventilating the mine (in a bratticed shaft) descends on one side, and, after passing through the workings, ascends up the other. The partition is frequently wearing out of order, and the air oozes through from the downcast to the upcast, there being a difference in the weight of the atmosphere in one shaft and the other, arising from the one being heated by the furnace while the other is not, and whatever air passes from the downcast to the upcast will diminish the quantity passing through the workings. Now, I consider that a much better, and in the end much cheaper ventilation would be carried on by having two pits instead of one. . . . . . . All the wooden partitions are saved, which will make up the difference of the cost." Mr. T. E. Forster, next to Mr. N. Wood the largest viewer in the coal trade, when questioned on the point before the committee of the House of Commons in 1852 says "I would not depend on a brattice in a shaft ; I would have two distinct shafts, — a downcast and an upcast shaft." These two authorities ought to have settled the matter long ago. I think it may be taken for granted from what I have heard that no such trust will again be placed in castings, however massive. Every beam which may henceforth be placed in a similar position will be of malleable iron. With regard to the general question of the prevention of accidents in coal mines, while the work of legislation is on hand it may be worth while to consider what amendments can be made in the general rules. I should think there could be no objection to the Home Secretary appointing a commission, composed of practical and scientific men, which should draw up an extra code, more detailed, and embracing every contingency which might be supposed to be common to all mines. This might probably prevent the necessity of any extension of the summary powers of the inspectors, which, in the face of the objections both of inspectors and coalowners, would be a delicate task to undertake. No amendment, however, in this respect would be of any avail without such augmentation of their strength, either in the shape of additional inspectors or the appointment of sub-inspectors, as would enable them to keep themselves thoroughly acquainted with the state of every pit in their district. The present system of arbitration clearly requires alteration, and there ought to be an ultimate controlling power placed somewhere, either in the Home secretary or a Council of Mines. I have not yet heard any sufficient argument for removing these inquiries from the Coroner's juries. Every objection made to the Coroner on the ground of want of requisite knowledge would apply with equal force to any judge in the land, and, without referring to any of the complaints I have heard made against the Coroner of this district on other grounds, I should say he had more experience of these inquiries than any other judicial officer in the kingdom. The ancient law which regulates the selection of jurymen might be amended with advantage, so as to allow of their being drawn from a wider circle. In this way the suspicion of partiality and interested motives too often entertained by the men might be avoided. A higher class of jurors might be obtained, and perhaps there would then not be any objection to intrusting them with the power of awarding damages, on which I find much stress is laid as a powerful stimulus to increased vigilance and precaution. On the advantages of giving a better education to those who are placed in charge of mines it is unnecessary to dwell, and it is an object which the Government might very fairly call upon Parliament to assist. All improvements in the management of mines must ultimately add to the profits of the owners. The best managed mines are not only the cheapest in the working, but give the largest ultimate lead. The steady, good workers, are keenly alive to the dangers of a badly conducted mine, and leave it as soon as possible ; where the arrangements are unsafe, and the discipline lax, it is only the reckless, unreliable men, who willingly remain. Where ventilation is deficient the health of the men suffers, and they are not able to bring to bank the same amount of coal. At a dangerous mine, moreover, the rate of wages always rules higher. Subscriptions pour in from all parts of the country, and the list must amount now to more than £12,000. Subscriptions are also being raised to present testimonials to Mr. Coulson and his brave band of sinkers, of whose courage and endurance I have before spoken. Some have proposed to strike a medal for them ; others, to present them with their portraits, with suitable inscriptions ; but in all probability the testimonial will take the more acceptable shape of a donation of money. It is also suggested that the valuable services rendered by Mr. Turnbull — a man most remarkable in character and appearance, who I see has been immortalized this week in the pages of the illustrated papers — should be suitably rewarded. He is a common pitman, but possesses great influence with his mates, and when the impatience of the crowd which surrounded the pit-heap night and day threatened at one time a serious outburst, it was he who calmed them down and induced them to leave the work of deliverance to those best able to conduct it. The services of the medical men, too, ought not to be forgotten. Dr. Davidson, the colliery surgeon, scarcely left the pit's mouth night or day for the first four days, and he was nobly aided by Mr. Ward, of Blyth, and other volunteers from among his professional brethren in the neighbourhood. Four of them — Dr. H. Ward, Mr. Ambrose, of the Arctic yacht Discovery, Mr. Nichol, and Mr. Lambert — when the first opening was made in the ruins, volunteered to go down and force their way through the stifling gas, on the chance of finding some of the men alive.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||