|
31st January 1862 Hartley Colliery Accident(From Our Own Reporter.) Newcastle-On-Tyne, Thursday. In the discussions which have taken place in this neighbourhood on the causes of the recent accident at Hartley, there has been a disposition shown in some quarters to censure the Government inspector, and in one of the local journals the responsibility of the catastrophe has been ascribed almost exclusively to his too easy acquiescence in the principles on which the pit was worked. As I have already said, the omission to connect the upper and middle seam, which would have given an independent means of egress from the pit, will require explanation both from owners and inspector ; but no one acquainted with the real nature of the inspector's powers can blame him for the prevalence of the single-shaft system in his district. If the Mines' Regulation Act is to be amended in the coming Session, it may be a good opportunity to consider whether some extension might not be given to the system of Government inspection ; but, as the Act stands at present, to object to a pit simply because there was only one door to it is a step which probably not one of the inspectors ever dreamt of. A Government inspection of mines seems to have been first suggested by Sir H. de la Beche in 1845. It was strongly recommended by the committee of the House of Lords which inquired into the general subject of coal mines in 1849, and in the following year an Act was passed appointing the first inspectors. As yet, therefore, it can scarcely be said to have advanced beyond the stage of an experiment. Its success has undoubtedly been considerable, for by general admission it has induced owners and viewers to pay a much closer attention to the safety of their mines ; but, though it has been gradually and cautiously extended, it has perhaps not yet been carried so far as to enable the inspectors to do all the good of which they are capable. The system as it stands at present seems far from satisfactory to the men — speaking for this district at least. They appear to make very light of the safeguard it is supposed to afford them, and it is only on very rare occasions that they take advantage of it. The powers and duties of the inspectors, as defined by the last Act of 1860, are to visit collieries, to inquire into their state and condition, their ventilation, the mode of lighting, and into all matters and things connected with the safety of the persons employed. In the Act are incorporated certain general rules applicable to all collieries, equally relating to ventilation, lights, shafts, and the like matters ; and, in addition to these, section 11 requires each colliery agent to draw up a set of special rules applicable to the circumstances of his particular colliery, and these, when approved by the inspector, are to have the same force as the general rules. If the amendment which has been suggested by this accident, and on which all men's minds here are bent, is made in the law, it will probably be by the insertion of a general rule in the Act to the effect that no mine shall hereafter be worked until two shafts have been sunk, or, at least, until a second communication has been effected with the workings. The inspector is to watch over the observance of these rules, and any infraction of them, either by master or man, is punishable by penalties — on the master, of a fine not exceeding £20, with a further penalty of £1 per day for every day the defect continues unremedied after notice ; and on the men, of £2 fine, or three months hard labour. Beyond this, if on any visit an inspector finds any matter or practice connected with the colliery — other than the points provided for by the rules — dangerous or defective, so as in his opinion to tend to the bodily injury of any person, he is to give notice in writing to the owner or agent of the particular grounds on which he is of opinion that such matter or practice is dangerous, and also report the same to the Home-office. Should the owner object to remedy the defect complained of, he may state the grounds of his objection in writing, and nominate five mining engineers, not interested in the management of his colliery, from whom the Home Secretary may select one as arbitrator. As the Bill originally stood when introduced into the House of Commons, the Government and the colliery-owners were each to nominate an arbitrator ; but the coal interest, it appears, was strong enough to get the arrangement altered to its present shape. When the award is against the colliery owner — though the odds are clearly very much in his favour — he is liable to a fine of £1 per day for every day that he neglects to remedy the defect. This is the extent of the powers of the Home Secretary and the inspector, and it will be seen that they are neither very extensive nor summary. The coalowner has every security against undue interference in his own mode of management ; nay, if he is obstinate, and is lucky enough to get an arbitrator of his way of thinking — not very difficult when he has the choosing — he may even set the inspector and Government at defiance. It will be seen, then, what a slight chance Sir G. Grey or Mr. Dunn would have had of shutting up single-shafted pits without a special interference of Parliament. Still, it is not a very easy matter to decide on the exact amount of power which should be entrusted to the inspectors. They themselves are understood to be by no means eager for an addition to their authority, for increased power brings increased responsibility. The coalowners, of course, object, and on the very specious grounds that to put more power in the hands of the inspector would shift the responsibility of proper management from the shoulders of the viewer to the inspector ; in fact, the inspector, they say, would become the real manager of every mine in his district. The last committee which sat on the subject of coal mines, in 1854, also declined to make any recommendation to this effect, preferring to rely on the increased responsibility which is thrown on the owner of a mine who either neglects or refuses to carry out the suggestion of an inspector, and to have the names of those parties who neglect their duties brought prominently before the public by the publication of the inspector's reports. The stringent powers of direction and supervision with which the Government inspectors are clothed in France and Belgium are scarcely applicable to this country. There the Government is the proprietor or lessor of all the mines ; it can make its own conditions when it lets them, and from the very first opening of a pit the system of working is under the general control of its officers. The circumstances in this country are so different that the foreign system of inspection can hardly be quoted as an example. But, though our inspectors compulsory powers are so very slight — in fact, scarcely anything at all, yet the influence which they may exercise by advice and recommendation must be considerable. A colliery manager may differ altogether from the inspector as to the value of suggestions which he receives from him, but if an accident were to happen, and it could be shown that the inspector had at any time warned him of the defect or mismanagement from which it occurred, he knows that his responsibility would be terribly increased, and that it might probably go hard with him before a jury. As in this instance, if the Government inspector can show that he has at any time warned the owners of the Hartley pit that the connexion of the upper and middle seam was necessary to the complete safety of the men, the case would wear a very much worse aspect against them. There is no allegation that such is the fact ; and perhaps it ought to be mentioned, in fairness to the owners, that the suggestion of the inspector for the construction of the "staple" between the lower and middle seam was at once complied with. No prudent manager would neglect the recommendation of an inspector without good reason to show for it. If he does, he must take the consequences. Still, there will always be self-conceited owners and agents, bigoted in their ideas, and on whom no changes can be forced by a simple process of reasoning. For such men as these there ought undoubtedly to be a real controlling power somewhere, so that, though they may be allowed to remain of the same opinion, the lives of the colliers in their employ may not be sacrificed to their obstinacy. The want of such a power is the chief defect of the present system of inspection, and it is not improbable that one of the worst results of it is that the inspectors, knowing they must be worsted in the end, frequently refrain from making debateable suggestions, which might be of the greatest value in the saving of life. The single shaft system is an instance of this. Probably there are few of the inspectors who would not recommend two or more shafts for every colliery in their district ; but under the machinery of the present Act, if they were to attempt to enforce any such suggestion, the coal owners could defeat them with the greatest ease. It has been proposed at various times to put such a controlling power in the hands of a Central Board of Mines, to be composed of practical and scientific men, combining both kinds of knowledge, which should act as a court of appeal between the inspectors and owners. To such a board, it is contended, the direction of the whole system of inspection might be very profitably transferred. It would decide all disputes, frame general rules, and in cases of neglect leading to loss of life it might act as public prosecutor. This suggestion has been approved by some of the most eminent practical and scientific men. It is a notion very much favoured, too, by the men, and, though Boards are by no means popular institutions among us, it must be vastly more efficient as an ultimate tribunal than the present one-sided and illusory arbitration scheme. One of the chief complaints of the men with regard to the inspectors is that there are not enough of them. The complaint certainly appears to be well founded, for the number of pits at present under each inspector's charge is far too large to allow of anything like regular visitation. The theory appears to be that if there is anything wrong the men will complain to the inspector, who will then visit the mine, and desire the defect to be set right. This appears at the outset to be placing a little too much reliance on their knowledge and ability to discover cases of mismanagement, but as a matter of fact the men are generally altogether averse from making complaints to the inspectors. Most of the inspectors, and very properly, encourage the men by all the means in their power to look upon them as being on their side, but as a rule they have not yet succeeded in obtaining their complete confidence, and it is only in a few cases, comparatively speaking, that the inspectors hear of a mine going wrong through the colliers. The pitman has too much reason to believe that he becomes a marked man if he is found or even suspected of holding communication with the inspector, and should he fancy there is danger brewing he prefers to pack up and betake himself to another pit before it explodes, without saying a word. One would think that such a policy on the part of the managers, whose interest it must be to work the pit safely and to give timely warning of every danger, was a very unwise one — and no doubt there are numerous exceptions to it ; but I am told that in too many cases viewers and overmen not only take the first opportunity of discharging every man who complains to the inspector, but pass the word to their colleagues, so as to prevent him getting employment elsewhere. In this manner it is said that obnoxious men have been altogether hunted out of the coal trade and have had to betake themselves to some other means of getting a living. Be this as it may, the inspectors do not obtain much assistance from the men, and without some assistance of the sort it is physically impossible for them to keep themselves well informed of the state of every mine in their district. The workings of a colliery are perpetually changing, and, however assiduous an inspector may be in visiting some particular pit which he has noted down in his black-book, between one visit and another circumstances may have been entirely altered, and for all practical purposes it may be quite a new pit to him. There can be no doubt that the inspectors are far too weak-handed, and that without a liberal addition to the staff the work of inspection can never be performed with thorough efficiency. Anticipating financial objections to such a proposition, the men at one time, through their delegates, suggested the appointment of sub-inspectors, of a lower grade, to act in each district under the chief inspector. To each of them would be committed the charge of a certain number of mines ; they would have equal power with the inspector to descend them at any time, and, probably, would be physically more competent for a detailed examination. Keeping themselves thoroughly acquainted with what was going on in each pit they would report to the inspector and invoke his interference whenever it might be necessary. Being always on the spot they would be able to communicate much more unreservedly with the men, and any threatened danger would be pretty certain to come to their ears. I am not aware what are the opinions of the inspectors themselves on this proposition, but it is strongly opposed by the viewers, who contend that the discipline of a mine would be seriously injured by the perpetual loafing about of sub-agents of this description ; and they object altogether — perhaps not unnaturally — to having their management criticized by men of a lower grade than themselves, and probably of a lower standard of professional knowledge. The committee of 1854 — which contemplated an increase in the actual number of inspectors — reported against this proposition, but since it has been shown by events that that increase has been insufficient it may be worth a reconsideration. The colliers appear to attach considerable value to it ; and it is not improbable that they would impart their complaints and suspicions with more freedom and confidence to men nearer to their own grade than the present inspectors.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||