|
30th January 1862 The Hartley Colliery Accident(From Our Own Reporter.) Newcastle, Wednesday Morning. An announcement just made, that the Home-office will send down a special commissioner to attend the inquest, which opens next Monday, has been received with very general satisfaction. I find there exists among the mining population considerable discontent with the manner in which colliery accidents are for the most part investigated. Coroners juries, they say, are generally composed of persons directly or indirectly connected with the coal-masters, and interested in making things pleasant ; and "accidental death" is the stereotyped verdict, whatever the evidence may be. The presence of inspectors does not always give them an assurance that the inquiry will be complete and exhaustive, as it may frequently happen that he himself is virtually as much on trial as the colliery manager ; in fact, I may say in passing that the men appear to put a very slight value on the protection they are supposed to get from Government inspection, and Coroners take such different views of their duty on these occasions that it is quite a matter of chance whether the question — to them the most important of all — of the general management of the mine is ever entered upon. At various times they have asked for special commissioners, or special Coroners, to be appointed for mining accidents, and for changes in the law regulating the choice of jurors ; and if there is to be a revision in the Mines Regulation and Inspection Act, it may be well to consider whether some amendment might not be introduced into it to meet these objections to the present system, which in many cases — in this district, perhaps, not so much as in others, — are undoubtedly well-founded. There is nothing, however, in the present case which makes it desirable to remove it from the ordinary tribunal. The points involved are all plain and intelligible enough, the manner in which the public attention has been fixed on the case is sufficient to prevent any of them being passed over, and the presence of the commissioner from the Home-office will probably satisfy even those who have endeavoured from the first to fix the responsibility on some particular person — inspector or owner — and not on the system. It is to be hoped that before the inquest means will be taken to test the metal of the broken beam. Its quality is said to be of the best, and professional men maintain that no casting of that enormous size could have done its work better. It was one of the celebrities of the coal trade in this district, and I believe was calculated to bear a strain some eight or ten times greater than that which was being put upon it at the time of the accident. If this be the case, in addition to a double-shaft movement a further demand ought to be made — that for the future beams which work in that dangerous position should be constructed of malleable iron. This accident ought to be a final warning to put no further faith in castings, however enormous, when exposed to sudden shocks. In confirmation of the suspicion I expressed the other day as to the insecurity of the shaft, I may mention that at the pitmen's meeting on Saturday one of them is reported to have said, in reference to the shaft, that "she" was as rotten as a bunch of matches, and was certain to break in at the first touch. I am told that this is the case with not a few old pits in this neighbourhood, and it might not be amiss if Sir G. Grey called upon the inspectors to add to the return already asked from them a list of pits in which the special rule which requires every shaft "to be securely cased or lined" is not observed. There is no doubt that at least three-fourths of the time spent in getting up the men might have been saved if the sinkers had had to deal only with the broken brattice work, for the distance they had to penetrate the work was quite as difficult and infinitely more dangerous than sinking a new shaft. Great and deserved admiration of the indomitable courage displayed by these men has been expressed at all the public meetings held in the district, and it is suggested that a testimonial of some kind should be presented to them. The subscription list is rising rapidly to very respectable dimensions. The following sums have just come in :— His Royal Highness the Prince of Wales, £100 ; Lord Hastings, £400 ; Lady Hastings, £200 ; the Dean and Chapter of Durham, £200 ; Mr. R. W. Jackson, West Hartlepool, £105 : Mr. H. W. Peak, London, £105 ; the owners of Harton and Hilda Collieries, £105 ; Duchess Dowager of Northumberland, £100 ; Duke of Cleveland, £100 ; the owners of Backworth and West Cramlington Collieries, £100 ; the Marchioness of Londonderry, £100 ; Mr. Wentworth Blackett Beaumont, M.P., £100 ; Captain John Grant, Hyde Park-street, £100 ; Hird, Dawson, and Hardy, Low Moor Ironworks, £100 ; Losh, Wilson, and Bell, £100 ; Marchioness of Waterford, £50 ; Earl of Tankerville, £50 ; Lord Lovaine, £25 ; Earl Vane, £25 ; Sir F. Baring, £20 More than £600 has been collected on the London Coal Exchange, and Messrs. Dixon and Harris, of the coal trade, have in addition forwarded £400, collected by them in various quarters. In all the great establishments along the Tyne side, and in the towns about, committees have been formed for collecting subscriptions, and there are few individuals in the community who will not contribute something to the fund, however small the mite. It is reckoned that about £20,000 will be required for the effectual relief of all those who have been deprived of their means of support by the accident, and if the Burradon precedent be followed the scale will be somewhere about 4s. a week for the widows, with 2s. for every child, and an addition for schooling wherever it may be necessary. The coal owners have not decided yet what course they will follow, whether to subscribe singly or as a body. They are to have a meeting to discuss the matter some day this week. If there is to be any opposition on their part to the compulsory double-shaft system on the ground of its expense — and if any weight is to be given to the remarks of Lord Adolphus Vane Tempest at a meeting at Sunderland yesterday, this is not unlikely — perhaps it would be as well if they would employ an experienced actuary to calculate for how much a ton of coals raised they could afford to take the desired precautions. The public are now asked for £20,000 ; in 1860 large sums were raised for the sufferers at the Burradon and Risca explosions ; the year before that there was the Lundhill calamity, and next year there may be another ; in fact, these large accidents have begun to recur regularly once a year of late, so that it might not be altogether unwise, even in an economical point of view, to compound with them for an additional 1d. or 2d. per ton in the price of coal. Besides the subscriptions of money, presents of clothing have been forwarded from many quarters. One benevolent lady has offered to supply all the widows with a widow's cap. The Prince of Wales accompanied his donation with a very kind and sympathizing note to Messrs. Carr, and the letter from Her Majesty, read on Sunday, has called forth such expressions of gratitude from the bereaved, that copies of it have been struck off on mourning paper, and one furnished to each family.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||