Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th January 1862

The Hartley Colliery Accident

(From Our Own Reporter.)

Newcastle, Monday Night.

The strong feeling which has been excited here during the past 10 days by the heartrending incidents of this great calamity appears likely to resolve itself into an agitation for a compulsory double-shaft system, and Parliament will probably be asked in the next Session for an Act to prohibit, for the future, the "winning" of coals in any mine until two shafts have been sunk. The proposition is by no means a new one ; it has been advocated for years past by the miners themselves and by their friends ; but, either because the influence of the coalowners has been too strong, or because public attention has not before been so forcibly directed to the subject, it has never yet been put into so tangible a shape as it is likely now to assume. Nobody has denied that it would be a beneficial reform, but hitherto its advocacy has been confined to a few enthusiasts, whose general views with regard to mining operations practical men would pronounce Utopian. No doubt, the subject is attended with some difficulties. Parliament is generally slow to lay down rules for the regulation of any trade without a paramount necessity proved, and in this case an attempt will very probably be made to show that such an interference would so seriously affect the profits of the coal trade as to amount to a virtual prohibition of the working of many pits. The colliers may be threatened with a reduction of wages ; the public with the alternative of a strike, or an increase in the price of coal. It is hoped, however, that the coalowners will not oppose to the general feeling such arguments as these, which, even if they were well founded, could have little weight in comparison with the safety of the men whose industry and endurance have so large a share in the material prosperity of the country. Single-shafted pits — though there are too many of them — are fortunately the exceptions, and I have not heard that the coal won from them costs consumers any less than that which is got by a double shaft. In the case of some pits, where the seam is pretty well worked out and very little coal remains to be got, it is probable that to require another shaft to be sunk might stop the work altogether ; but the number of these pits is not very large, and it is just such collieries where there is a large extent of old workings or "goaves" which require the strictest regulation, particularly if firedamp be generated in them. If the question is discussed while the memory of the recent disaster is fresh, profit and loss are not likely to have any great weight in its settlement, though I believe it would not be difficult to show that the double-shaft system is not only the safest but the cheapest and most advantageous method of mining. The best managed pits are always the most remunerative in the long run, if coalowners would only be convinced of it. It is, no doubt, a great temptation to a lessee, when he has sunk his first shaft, to set work drawing up coal at once to repay himself for his outlay ; but generally, in the end, he has either to leave a large percentage of the coal, or to go to the expense of the second shaft from which he shrank at the outset. Hand to mouth mining is a very poor business, but where no expense is spared to lay out a pit on scientific principles there is always a return in the shape of an increased yield of coals at a cheaper rate.

None of the scientific or professional men who have been examined before Parliament committees have ever had a word to say for single shafts ; in fact, the strongest condemnation of the system might be quoted from the evidence of some of the most eminent of them, even so far back as the time of George Stephenson, who was a strong advocate for the substitution of several pits, though of smaller area, in the place of one large one, bratticed off into two or more compartments. I am sure the viewers and others, on whose shoulders the responsibility of the practical working of collieries rests, would rejoice if an Act of Parliament abolished the single-shaft system to-morrow. The expense of sinking a shaft varies so much according to the strata that it is difficult to fix an average, but to put it at from £10 to £15 a yard is to allow a very fair margin. The second shaft generally costs less than the first, for, as the water is drained off by the first sinking, if the two be within a reasonable distance there is none of the expense of tubbing &c. At Hartley, it is said, a new shaft to the depth of the old one might have been sunk for £2,000 But, whatever might be the first outlay, it is contended that it might be saved in a very few years. As the workings of a pit extend a very large item in the price of the coal is the cost of bringing it up from a distant gallery to the bottom of the shaft. In the course of time the saving of the expense thus incurred in tramways, labour, and time, would go a long way to pay for the sinking of a new shaft. Again, the "bratticing" or wooden partition, by which the single shaft is divided into two parts, is continually requiring repair or renewal. Either it gets rotted or a part of it gets knocked out by some of the small accidents which are perpetually happening in shafts, or there is a leakage which weakens the ventilation ; but it is always requiring tinkering of some kind. I have seen £1,500 a-year put down as the cost of keeping the bratticing in one pit in order, though I should be inclined to think that that was a case which stood pretty nearly alone. But that it is ordinarily a perpetual source of expense, amounting, before the pit is worked out, to much more than a second shaft would have cost, there cannot be a dispute. To the other economical advantages of the double-shaft system may be added the assurance it offers against loss by accidents such as this. It is generally believed that the Hartley Pit will never be worked again — certainly not by the present owners — so that for the saving of some £2,000 all the coal remaining unworked will have to be abandoned, or, to get at it again, an enormous expense will have to be incurred in pumping up the 1,000 gallons of water per minute which have been rushing in ever since the beam broke. It is almost a wonder that lessors, who in most cases get a royalty on the coal raised, do not, for their own interests, stipulate in each lease that two shafts shall be sunk ; and, if Parliament should interfere to remedy their shortsightedness, neither they nor the lessees can have a reasonable ground of complaint at having a mode of working forced upon them which is not only cheapest in the long run, but best calculated to extract the fullest value from the property itself. Passing from economical considerations, as a security against accidents and loss of life, the argument for Legislative interference of some sort becomes almost unanswerable. The importance of having a front door and a back door to every mine is so obvious, that when the news of this accident was first spread people unacquainted with colliery operations could scarcely comprehend how it had happened. It seemed so absurd that men should be so fool-hardy as to trust themselves in the bowels of the earth with only one means of exit that it was with difficulty that the exact position of the miserable captives was realized. Unfortunately, it is not necessary to wait until another great casting breaks in a similar manner for this terrible catastrophe to be repeated. Where there is furnace ventilation — and that is the mode generally adopted here — to obtain a good current of air through a bratticed shaft against the obstructions it meets with, it is necessary to drive the furnace so hard that there is always risk of the brattice catching fire, in which case the whole ventilation of the pit is destroyed, the communication with the bank is cut off as completely as in the Hartley case, and before fresh cages can be rigged and the ventilation restored those of the men who have escaped the fire perish by the insidious after-damp. When an explosion takes place some part of the brattice is pretty nearly certain to go, and the same fate awaits the men. This was the case at an explosion at Killingworth, when it was 23 or 24 hours before the bottom of the pit could be reached. At an explosion at Wall's-end Colliery, in 1835, 60 yards of the brattice were blown down, and of the 102 lives lost there it was admitted by no less an authority than Mr. Buddle that 50 might have been saved had there been a second pit. At Heaton, near here, years back, 75 men and boys starved to death in an upper seam, where they had been driven by an irruption of water. There was no communication from the surface with that seam, just as in this case, and after subsisting some time on their candles and the carcasses of the horses, they perished by the lingering pangs of hunger. At the accident at Burradon, which is not yet two years old, had there been a second communication with the seam, at least two-thirds of the sufferers might have been saved. I might give other instances ; in fact, when one comes to read down the long list of lives which have been sacrificed for the want of this simple and obvious precaution, one is tempted, in the first glow of indignation, to pass a stronger condemnation on the blind obstinacy of those who persist in the single shaft system after so many fearful warnings than perhaps would be altogether justifiable. But apart from the necessity of providing a second passage from the workings, as a means of ventilation the double shaft is a matter of most vital importance. In all cases the bratticed shaft is a bungling inefficient expedient for ventilation purposes, but where the miner's terrible enemy, the carburetted hydrogen, is generated it amounts to almost a crime to trust the safety of the men to it. The passage of the cages up and down and the working of the pumps detract so much from the sectional area of the upcast and downcast that it may be said to be almost impossible to drive air enough down a single bratticed shaft to sweep the faces of the workings clear of the noxious gas. Looked at in this light, it is not merely a second shaft, but several shafts which in many cases might be insisted on. More shafts, more air, are synonymous terms. Without an adequate number of shafts it is possible in fiery mines of any extent to obtain that amount of ventilation which is necessary for the safety of the miner ; and the majority of explosion might very easily be traced to a neglect of this principle. With a powerful furnace, or fan, or pump, it is easy enough to get the anemometer to register 60,000 or 100,000 cubic feet of air passing in and out of the mine ; but how much of that passes round the workings, and at what rate, are the material points. Since the days when Mr. Buddle introduced "splitting" we certainly do not hear of the air being coursed 30 miles round a mine ; but there is no doubt that in many cases the currents are far too long and languid to do the work of clearance effectually. The true security against fire-damp explosions is to be sought, not in safety-lamps, which too often lead men into danger, but in perfect ventilation, and this can only be obtained by additional shafts, according to the area of the workings. There are many mines in this neighbourhood which could not be considered safe with two shafts, much less with one. Some enthusiastic advocates of this principle have gone as far as to lay it down that a shaft ought to be sunk for every 40 acres of working, and that no gallery should be carried more than 300 yards from the bottom of the shaft ; but the circumstances of mines differ so much that it would be impossible to lay down a general rule. Parliament, probably, will not be moved to go further than to require a second shaft in all cases ; but if it were inclined to carry a reform more extensive than that simply which the late accident has demonstrated to be necessary, there would not be much difficulty in empowering the Inspector, with proper securities for the interest of the coalowners, to fix the number of shafts needed in each case. The area is not so important as the number, and in many instances it would not cost more to sink two or three narrow shafts than a single one of larger diameter. An additional advantage of this arrangement would be the complete isolation of each district of a mine, so that when an accident happened its effects would be confined entirely to one district, and the ventilation of the rest of the mine would remain uninjured.

All further search for bodies has been abandoned, and I am glad to say that there is good reason to conclude that the number which has been recovered — 109 — (with the five killed in the shaft) represents the whole extent of the calamity. It was conjectured that some eight or ten had been cut off by the falling beam and drowned in the lower workings. Every inquiry, however, has been made at the surrounding villages, and as far as can be ascertained, there are none now missing. The number of lives lost may therefore be put down at 204. Large numbers of people still continue to hang about the pit, and about £40 has been got for the benefit of the relatives by charging 6d. a head for admission to the pit heap. Yesterday a large collection of tin flasks, candle boxes, and other articles which miners use, was brought up, and all day long the heap was wistfully turned over by the poor widows and orphans, each anxious to discover some memorial of their lost relatives. On one of the tin flasks was found, scratched in rude characters — probably just at the moment when the writer had discovered the full horrors of his situation — "Mercy, oh God !" On another were scratched the words, "Friday afternoon. My dear Sarah, — I leave you," — as though the poor fellow had succumbed in the act of taking an affectionate farewell of his wife.

The inquest is not to commence before Monday next.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Buddle, —      
Stephenson, George      Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hartley Colliery  Hartley Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
16 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Annual Register for 1862)
18 Jan 1862  Terrible Colliery Accident (The Times)
20 Jan 1862  The Dreadful Colliery Accident In Northumberland (The Times)
21 Jan 1862  The Catastrophe at Hartley Colliery (The Times)
22 Jan 1862  The Calamity In Northumberland (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
23 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery (The Times)
24 Jan 1862  The Terrible Calamity In the Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  The Awful Calamity In New Hartley Colliery (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Sufferers By The Accident At Hartley Pit (The Times)
25 Jan 1862  Dreadful Colliery Accident, Loss of Two Hundred and twenty lives (Illustrated London News)
25 Jan 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., Terrible Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
28 Jan 1862  Letters to the Editor, Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
29 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
30 Jan 1862  The Sufferers By the Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
31 Jan 1862  Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Pit Tragedy (Illustrated London News)
01 Feb 1862  Meetings At Consett and Blackhill (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Hartley Calamity, Mr. Elliott On Insurance (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  Mining Accidents, Government Inspection And Public Sympathy (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Feb 1862  The Heroes Of Hartley (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
03 Feb 1862  The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
05 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Disaster (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  Letters to the Editor, Accidents In Coal Mines (The Times)
06 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Disaster (The Times)
07 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Times)
08 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Complete Report Of The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
08 Feb 1862  Photographs Of The Hartley Catastrophe (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
12 Feb 1862  Comment (The Times)
15 Feb 1862  Topics of the Week (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Home News (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Accidents, Inquests, etc., The Inquiry into the Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
15 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Feb 1862  The Hartley Fund, Meeting Of The Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Accident (Bury and Norwich Post)
20 Feb 1862  The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Western Daily Press)
22 Feb 1862  Sayings and Doings in Parliament, The Hartley Colliery Accident (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
22 Feb 1862  The Hartley Accident, Honour To Whom Honour Is Due (Morpeth Herald)
22 Feb 1862  Miscellaneous News (The Leeds Times)
22 Feb 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
22 Feb 1862  The New Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
01 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Calamity (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  Home News, The Hartley Widows and Orphans (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
08 Mar 1862  The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
15 Mar 1862  Sunderland Contributions To The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 Mar 1862  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
29 Mar 1862  The Hartley Relief Fund At The Mansion House (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
05 Apr 1862  The Hartley Relief Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
26 Apr 1862  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 May 1862  Poem On The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
14 May 1862  The Sinkers' Testimonial (Newcastle Daily Journal)
14 May 1862  The Survivors At New Hartley (Newcastle Daily Journal)
17 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonials, Presentation Ceremony (Newcastle Daily Journal)
20 May 1862  Sinkers' Testimonial Fund (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  News (Newcastle Daily Journal)
21 May 1862  The Reward Of Merit (Newcastle Daily Journal)
22 May 1862  Presentation To The Hartley Sinkers (Shields Daily Gazette)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Heroes (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  The Hartley Calamity (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
24 May 1862  Presentation Of Testimonials To The Hartley Sinkers (Morpeth Herald)
27 May 1862  The Hartley Colliery Catastrophe (The Times)
30 May 1862  Hartley Sinkers' Testimonial Fund, Notice To Workmen, Tradesmen, And Others (Newcastle Courant)
07 Jun 1862  The Hartley Pit Catastrophe (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
02 Aug 1862  Model Of The Hartley Colliery (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
30 Aug 1862  "Reading The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  North Of England Mining Institute (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
11 Oct 1862  "The Reading Of The Queen's Letter" (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Oct 1862  The Hartley Accident (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Jan 1863  The Hartley Sinkers (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
03 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor, The Hartley Colliery Relief Fund (The Times)
07 Feb 1863  Letters to the Editor (The Times)
14 Feb 1863  The Hartley Surplus (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Feb 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  Hartley Relief Fund Committee (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
28 Feb 1863  News (Newcastle Daily Chronicle)
08 May 1863  The Hartley Fund (Newcastle Courant)
27 Jun 1863  News (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
21 Nov 1863  The Hartley Relief Fund (The Penny Illustrated Paper)
27 Apr 1880  Hartley Colliery Accident Fund (The Times)
25 May 1886  Death Of One Of The Hartley Heroes (The Middlesbrough Daily Gazette)
27 Jun 1910  Aged Miners' Cottages, Hartley Disaster Memorial (Sunderland Daily Echo)
08 Jun 1927  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for New Hartley
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print