|
28th January 1862 Law ReportImportant Colliery CaseSenhouse v. HarrisCourt Of Queen's Bench, Westminster. January 20. (Before Lord Chief Justice Cockburn, Mr. Justice Crompton, Mr. Justice Blackburn, and Mr. Justice Mellor.) This case came on for trial at the Carlisle Summer Assizes, 1860; and, after the case was partially heard, a verdict was taken by consent for the plaintiff for the damages stated in the declaration, subject to the opinion of this Court upon a special case to be stated. — Messrs. Tyson and Hobson appearing for the plaintiff; and Messrs. Benson and Moordaff for the defendant. The case was argued last Michaelmas Term by Mr. Temple, Q.C. (with him Mr. Kemplay), for the plaintiff; and by Mr. Manisty, Q.C. (with him Mr. Crompton Hulton), for the defendant; and the Court afterwards took time to consider its judgment. The action was one of covenant, founded upon a lease granted by the plaintiff to the defendant in respect of a colliery at Ellenborough, and the plaintiff sought to recover certain rents and tonnage duties alleged to be due and payable to him in respect of the demised promises. To the breaches assigned by the plaintiff the defendant pleaded three pleas :– 1st. Non est fuctum. 2ndly. That the covenants alleged to have been broken by him had in fact been respectively performed; and 3rdly. That he had before suit paid and satisfied all rents and payments that were payable under the lease. Issued was joined upon all these pleas, and it appeared from the special case that in the year 1848 the defendant then being he lessee under Mr. Christian of a colliery at Ewanrigg, took a lease of the plaintiff of his colliery at Ellenborough, the two collieries being contiguous to each other, Mr. Christian's being the southernmost and the most distant of the two from the harbour of Maryport. It was amongst other things provided by the plaintiff's lease that the defendant should pay to the plaintiff certain rents called outstroke, watercourse, and shaft rents, amounting together to 1½d. per ton, in respect of all coals brought up the shaft of the plaintiff's colliery from the adjoining colliery of Ewanrigg; and it was also provided that the defendant should have the liberty of burning so much of the plaintiff's coal as might be necessary for carrying on the operation of the collieries and coalmines demised by the lease without being liable to the payment of any tonnage rent in respect thereof. And it was also provided that the defendant should pay the plaintiff for all coals raised within the Ewanrigg lands up the shafts of the Ellenborough collieries and conveyed over the plaintiff's waggonway, and shipped at the harbour of Maryport, the sum of 2½d. a ton for every ton of coals so conveyed. For several years the defendant paid this stipulated rent, but differences sometimes arose between the parties as to the amount of coal which ought to be consumed at the engines for the working of the Ellenborough and Ewanrigg Collieries. Defendant contended he had a right, under his lease from the plaintiff, to burn and use the coal raised from the plaintiff's colliery exclusively for supplying the engines, whereas the plaintiff contended that the lease only provided for such consumption in respect of the working of the plaintiff's own colliery thereby demised, and that, therefore, the two collieries, Ellenborough and Ewanrigg, ought fairly to contribute proportionally to the support of the engine fires, &c., as both these collieries were mutually benefited, and that the outstroke, watercourse, and shaft rents were paid for distinct easements or privileges apart from the coals required to carry on the works of the two collieries. This difference of opinion led to the consultation of the lawyers, and then the defendant started another objection. He contended that he had not only a right to use the plaintiff's coals exclusively, but also that he had a right to convey all the coals, the produce of the Ewanrigg Colliery, over the plaintiff's tramway, without paying the stipulated reserved rent of 2½d. per ton in respect of such carriage, inasmuch as the coals were not raised up any pit or shaft sunk in Mr. Christian's land and brought to the surface there, and that such carriage was covered by the payment of the outstroke, watercourse, and shaft rents. That the payments of 2½d. per ton hitherto made, in respect of such carriage, were made in ignorance of what the lease contained, and not in respect of any legal liability on the defendant's part to make such payments. This contention necessarily brought matters to an issue, and, after some vain attempts at a reference, plaintiff was obliged to bring his action to recover what he conceived to be due to him — the main cause of action being the non-rendering of the way-leave rent of 2½d. per ton. The Lord Chief Justice now delivered the Judgment of the Court — This case turns entirely upon the construction of two clauses in a mining lease. The defendant being the lessee of a coal mine, called the Ewanrigg Colliery under a Mr. Christian, took a lease of another coal mine called the Ellenborough Colliery immediately contiguous to the Ewanrigg mine. By the terms of this lease he was not only to be entitled to get the coal from the Ellenborough mine at a certain rent agreed upon, but was at liberty to bring the coal got in the Ewanrigg mine to the surface (as it is termed in the lease by way of outstroke) through the Ellenborough mine, on payment of a sum of 1½d. per ton for outstroke, water course rent, and shaft rent. By a provision in the lease no rent was to be paid for any coal got from the Ellenborough Colliery which should be used or consumed on or for any engine employed in working or carrying on "the collieries and coal mines thereby demised, or in any other way, or for any purpose necessary or proper for the carrying on of the said collieries and coal mines thereby demised." The defendant having availed himself of the privileges thus granted of bringing the coal got in the Ewanrigg Colliery through the Ellenborough Colliery, and by means of the shaft and engine belonging to the latter to the surface a question arises whether the immunity from payment of rent in respect of coal used in any engine employed in the working of the Ellenborough Colliery, extends to coal used in the engine when employed in bringing up the coal from the Ewanrigg, through the Ellenborough mine. We are of opinion that it does, in the first place, because as the engine must be kept at work, if not for the purpose of raising the coal from the Ellenborough mine, at all events for that of keeping that mine free from water. It seems that it would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, to determine how much of the steam power was appropriated to the purposes of the Ellenborough Colliery, and how much to the raising the coal by way of outstroke from the Ewanrigg mine. Secondly, because as in raising the coal got in the Ewanrigg mine to the surface by way of outstroke though the Ellenborough Colliery the engine fixed in the Ellenborough Colliery must necessarily be employed; the coal consumed in working such engines may fairly be considered as paid for in the amount agreed to be paid for per ton for the privilege of raising the coal by way of outstroke through the Ellenborough Colliery. A second question arises on a privilege granted to the defendant in working the Ewanrigg mine to carry the coal raised from that mine to the neighbouring port of Maryport by means of a private tramway leading from the boundary between the two collieries, but belonging to the plaintiff, — such privilege being by the terms of the lease to be enjoyed on payment of 2½d. per ton on the coal so carried. The question has reference to the coal got from the Ewanrigg mine, and raised by outstroke through the Ellenborough Colliery, it being contended on the part of the defendant that he is entitled to convey the coal so raised by the tramway in question, without payment of the 2½d. per ton payable as mentioned in respect to coal conveyed by the tramway direct from the Ewanrigg Colliery. Our judgment on this point is adverse to the defendant. The privilege of using the tramway is not in the lease in any way connected with bringing the coal to the surface by way of outstroke through the Ellenborough mine; it exists quite independently of the latter in respect of all coal whatsoever raised from the Ewanrigg mine, and the provision for payment to be made in respect of coal conveyed by the tramway is general without any distinction between coal brought to the surface direct from the Ewanrigg Colliery and that brought to bank by way of outstroke. The right to bring out the produce of the Ewanrigg mine to the surface through the Ellenborough Colliery, does not necessarily carry with it the right of using the Ellenborough tramway, as the coal might have been conveyed by the way otherwise appropriate to the Ewanrigg colliery. Lastly, it seems absurd to suppose that the payment for the right of outstroke being 1½d. per ton, and the payment for the use of the tramway 2½d. per ton, the proprietor of the Ellenborough mine should have been willing to give up the stipulated payment for the latter privilege in consideration of the payment of the former privilege — the two privileges being separate and distinct interests — thus forgoing altogether all payment in respect of a privilege in the exercise of which a higher money value appears avowedly to have been set. Not only, therefore, is there no provision to warrant the contention of the defendant, but the reason of the thing is the other way. An argument is, however, raised on the behalf of the defence on the wording of the clause of the lease relating to the payment to be made in respect of coal conveyed by the tramway. The payment is to be in respect of all coal "raised" on the lands held by the defendant under Christian, and the defendant contends that by the term "raised," must be understood "brought to the surface," and consequently that coal brought to the surface through the Ellenborough Colliery, is not in that sense coal "raised" on the lands of Christian; but there can be no doubt that the term "raised" has two meanings. It may signify, as well coal got or won, as coal brought to the surface. Had the passage stood alone, we should have been disposed to ascribe to the term the former of these meanings; taken, however, in connection with the other provisions of the lease, we entertain no doubt that such is its true interpretation. We are therefore of opinion that the defendant is liable to pay the stipulated amount of 2½d. per ton for all coal he produce of the Ewanrigg Colliery conveyed upon the tramway, though the same may be brought to the surface through the Ellenborough Colliery.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||