Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th January 1862, Page: 3, Column: 1

The Boiler Explosion At Crookgate

Coroner's Inquest

The adjourned inquiry into the boiler explosion which caused the deaths of James Hunter and John Robson, at Byer Moor Colliery, on Tuesday, the 7th instant, was held, on Tuesday, at Mr. Mason's, Pack Horse Inn, Crookgate, before Mr. J. M. Favell, coroner. Mr. Matthias Dunn and Mr. Atkinson, two of the Government Inspectors of Mines, for the Northern District, attended the inquest, and there were also present Mr. C. Berkley, mining engineer, of the Marley Hill Collieries ; Mr. Thompson, jun., mining engineer ; Mr. Painter, Jarrow ; Mr. Walter Hannah, surveyor of steam vessels for the Board of Trade in the Northern District ; Mr. Coulthard, engineer and boiler maker, Gateshead ; Mr. Crowe, chief foreman in Messrs. Stephenson's engineering establishment, Newcastle ; Mr. Cleminson, engineer, of the Farnley Iron Works.

The Coroner having read over the evidence of John Thirlway, taken at the opening of the inquest, as to the question of fact.

Mr. Berkley was called. He deposed that he had seen Barrett, the engineman, who was unable to attend the inquest, since the explosion, and that he had told him that he (Barrett) had just tried the floats himself, and there was plenty of water in the boilers when the accident occurred.

John Thompson, jun., engineer, of Byer Moor Colliery, the property of Bowes and Co., produced a ground plan of the boiler seats and premises at Byer Moor Colliery. He said each boiler was 40 feet in length, and 5 feet 3 inches in diameter ; the plates were 3/8 of an inch thick ; the boiler was made by Palmer Brothers ; and the iron plates over the fire were made by Beale and Company, Parkgate, Yorkshire. One of the Farnley plates had been removed six weeks before the explosion, and we had replaced it with one of Bradleys, of Stafford, and had no stamp upon it. The Farnley plate had got out of form from being furred, and therefore was considered not safe. The whole plate 7ft. 3 in. by 2 ft. was taken out. This plate was over the fire, where the plates generally yield first. There was one 4-inch safety valve at the chimney, and weighted for 30 lbs ; one 5¼-inch safety valve at the fire end, pressed at 30 lbs. to the square inch ; one common stone float on the centre of the boiler ; one float, with Turnbull's whistle, about 9 feet from the flue end of the boiler. Those floats were believed to be quite right, because they were tried shortly before the explosion. Witness was with Mr. Berkley when Barrett told him he was just leaving the floats, and was quite satisfied the water was all right. The boiler ought to be safe at 401bs pressure, and was tested to that at Jarrow. She was generally worked at from 20 to 30lbs. pressure. There was a 4-inch feed-jug with stop valve. There is a steam gauge in the engine house. The boiler was set in brickwork. Was of opinion that the boiler had given way at the bottom, immediately over the fire, because the bottom plates of the boiler appeared to have been hot, and the other parts appear to have been cold and right. One of those was a Farnley plate, and the other a "Bradley." The furring was probably caused by the inferior quality of the water which we had drawn from the pit during the last fortnight. This fact was ascertained yesterday. It had changed during the fortnight in question. The boiler was examined by the engineman, breaksman, and foreman smith, and was cleaned four days before the accident. She was not much furred. (A piece of the deposit was shown to the jury. It was considered to be of a very peculiar character and composition, and was quite different to ordinary deposit.) That deposit (produced) was taken from one of the plates. Similar deposits had never been made in our boilers before. It was five-sixteenths of an inch in thickness, and had been produced in four days. This deposit witness considered would keep the water off the plate until it got hot, when the pressure to the steam and water in the boiler would bulge the boiler, and break the deposit, and the water would then come in contact with the hot plates over the flue, and would cause an explosion. The workmanship of the boilers was perfectly good. The water was drawn from the pit at night, and was put into a pond before being used.

John Sunderland, the enginewright at Byer Moor Colliery, was next examined: His evidence was to the following effect — Cleaned the boiler four days before the explosion, and was then inside the boiler. Did not detect anything peculiar in her ; she was in perfect order. There was no deposit similar to this produced to-day. The boilers were cleaned once a week. On that day the boiler was left quite right. In company with Mr. Thompson, examined the engine about an hour before the explosion. Could not form any conclusion as to the cause of the explosion. Witness was on the boiler about twenty minutes before the explosion, when the floats and valves were all right. Found the deposit produced by Mr. Thompson after the explosion near the fire end of the boiler ; it was not adhering to any plate.

By Mr. Dunn : The water is run off three times in the 24 hours. The boilers are fired at one end.

By the Coroner : There is still some of this deposit adhering to the plates. It would cause the plates to heat by preventing the water from getting to them, and the plates would then expand and the deposit would break off, and the water would get access to the hot plates.

By Mr. Dunn : There would be about 3ft 4in of water over the fire when the boiler was in working order. The boiler was three inches out of level in the 40 feet.

By the Court: The water in the boiler, when I saw it twenty minutes before the explosion, could not have boiled away in less than four hours, sufficiently to have rendered her unsafe. Had never seen a deposit like this before.

Christopher West, the fireman, saw the steam gauge in the engine house two minutes before the explosion, when it indicated 29lbs. pressure. The boiler had been fired about ten minutes before the explosion. The steam gauge works well.

Cuthbert Berkeley, mining engineer, of Marley Hill recalled, deposed that until the last five or six weeks they had had no complaint of the water. Since the new boilers commenced, about two months ago, they found a hard sediment on the plates thicker than had been before, and the boilers had been repaired in consequence of this. On Friday it was determined to have the water analyzed, and it was analyzed by Messrs. Richardson and Browell, Newcastle. Witness put in the following copy of the results of the analyzation :—

"Laboratory, Neville Hall, Newcastle-on-Tyne,

13th Jan. 1862.

"Dear sir, — The following are the results of out analysis of the sample of water received from you on the 11th inst., viz. :—

* Refers to boiling, concentration or evaporation being provided against.

"From the above you will see that the water is a very undesirable one for boiler purposes, both from the quantity and character of the matters contained in it, being calculated to form a considerable and injuries deposit in the boiler. The water has no acid reaction, so that its injurious character depends on the quantity and nature of the solid substance in solution. — We are, Sir, yours truly,

"Richardson & Browell.

"C. Berkley, Esq., Marley Hill."

Witness's opinion agreed with that of Dr. Richardson as to the deposit. From the chemist's opinion he was now quite satisfied that this deposit would be sufficient to cause a heating of the plate, and consequently an explosion.

In reply to questions by Mr. Dunn, Mr. Berkeley said that the pit was sunk five years ago, and the water in the shaft had been satisfactory since then until about five weeks ago.

Robert Coulthard, engineer and boiler maker, Gateshead, had examined the boiler that day, and seen the iron scraps of the boiler plates now produced. Was of opinion that the plate was not bad iron ; it seemed to be pretty tough, which was a sign of its being good. Farnley looked more brittle. That had been over the fire, and the iron appeared crystalized from the heat. Did not consider the iron objectionable, and would use such for a boiler, but would not have used it in the present state of the piece produced. The iron, originally good, would be brought into that state by being exposed to the fire. Had no doubt the iron had been brought into that state through the deposit. The workmanship of the boiler was, in his opinion, good, and the necessary fittings were what they ought to be. Witness testified to the general excellence of the Farnley and Park Gate iron.

John Cleminson, engineer of the Farnley Iron Company, at Farnley, near Leeds, had examined the boiler, and saw that the plates immediately over the fire had been red hot, or newly so. From that circumstance the plates would become crystalised to a certain extent, and would become weakened as the piece produced was. Would not make a boiler of iron in a crystalised state, as this now produced. Had the piece of crystalised iron been brought to him would have discovered it as Farnley iron. Examined all boilers made by the Farnley Company, and was of opinion that the workmanship and fittings of this boiler were good and sufficient to ensure safety. Agreed with Mr. Thompson as to the cause of the explosion.

By Mr. Dunn : Never knew a deposit take place so rapidly or of the same description.

By the Court (at the request of Mr. Berkley) Could not attach blame to any one connected with the works.

Walter Hannah, engineer, surveyor of steam vessels of the Board of Trade in this district. Examined this boiler yesterday, and found the different pieces of iron broken off the plate to be very good. The workmanship was also good. A plate on the bottom of the boiler at the furnace had been red hot, and there was not the least doubt that, from the plate getting hot it would bulge down, and, hot water getting in under the incrustation and coming suddenly in contact with the red hot plate, might cause the explosion, in accordance with the evidence of Mr. Thompson. Had not seen a deposit of this kind before. Considered no blame attached to any one.

George Crowe, chief foreman in the engineering establishment of Messrs. R. Stephenson and Company, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, examined the boilers yesterday, and had not the slightest doubt the plates had been very hot. The iron was very satisfactory, and the workmanship very good. The fittings were quite sufficient to ensure the safe working of the boiler. Agreed with Mr. Thompson's evidence as to the cause of the explosion. Considered that, through the deposit being so great, the water could not have absorbed the heat as it ought. When the water came suddenly on the heated plate the pressure of the steam, together with the unequal contraction, would cause the explosion.

At the conclusion of the evidence, the Coroner briefly summed up ; and the jury, without retiring, returned as their verdict — "That John Robson came to his death on the 7th inst. by injuries to his head, caused by the explosion of a boiler at Byer Moor Colliery. That the explosion was caused by a deposit having taken place in the boiler during the last four days, as stated in the evidence of Mr. Thompson. And we consider the workmanship, materials, and fittings of the boiler were good, and sufficient for the safe working of the boiler."

The Coroner remarked that it was seldom that boiler explosions were explained in so satisfactory a manner, and he thanked Mr. Berkley for having brought before him such good scientific evidence.


Per imperial gallon. grains.
Earthy carbonates (precipitated by boiling) 12.70
Fixed matters in solution (not *precipitated by boiling) containing 25.52 grs sulphate of lime besides other sulphates and chlorides 49.00
Total solid matter in a gallon 61.70
Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atkinson, —      
Berkeley, Cuthbert      
Browell, —      
Cleminson, John      
Coulthard, Robert      
Crowe, George      
Dunn, Matthias      
Favell, J. M.      
Hannah, Walter      
Hunter, James      
Mason, —      
Painter, —      
Richardson, —      
Robson, John      
Sunderland, John      
Thirlway, John      
Thompson, John      
West, Christopher      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Byermoor Colliery  Byermoor Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
11 Jan 1862  Boiler Explosion At Crookgate, Two Men Killed (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Jan 1862  Weekly Retrospect (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)
18 Jan 1862  The Boiler Explosion At Crookgate, Coroner's Inquest (Newcastle Guardian and Tyne Mercury)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Byermoor
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print