12th October 1861
Colliery Explosions
Members of the great colliery interest should be given distinctly to understand that they are put on their defence before the tribunal of British public opinion. They are accused of not doing all they might have done for preventing those terrible
accidents which outvie the casualties of war, and which, during the last five years, caused no less than 856 deaths. They are accused of vaunting the safety of a lamp known by many of them to be unsafe, and of leading the public to put faith in dogma
that, the Davy lamp being exclusively used, accidents from firedamp can only accrue from the maltreatment of it. Finally, they are accused of suppressing evidence that might tend to lay bare the causes of some of these disasters by an expenditure of
money at the proper season, ostensibly as a charitable offering, but virtually as a bribe. All this has been alleged ; and, moreover, the opinion has been gaining ground for some time past, that the great coalowners of the north and west have, to say the
least, not courted that Parliamentary investigation relative to the immediate cause of colliery explosions, and the means of preventing them, which the gravity and the frequency of those calamities so imperiously demand. When we made some remarks on the
Risca explosion we felt it our duty to direct especial attention to two points — firstly, the non-safety of Davy's lamp ; secondly, the probability that coal-mine safety might be ultimately found and secured by bringing into operation more powerful
systems of ventilation than any now commonly employed. We, moreover, noted the circumstance, not well heeded hitherto, that to a very considerable extent the Davy lamp and ventilation are antagonistic. If a mine be actually swept clear of explosive gas,
then it is superfluous to announce that the Davy lamp may be safely employed. But so, in like manner, might any source of illumination ; and no person would elect to work by the always insufficient light of the Davy lamp, when he could with equal safety
employ an ordinary candle. The condition of perfect ventilation being discarded as not concerning our argument, and the state of imperfect ventilation contemplated, there can be no doubt that the explosive tendency of the Davy lamp will be much
exaggerated. It is surprising not a little to reflect upon the persistent manner in which the tendency of Davy's lamp to explode under the influence of current has been ignored, notwithstanding the teaching of good and sufficient evidence. Twenty-five
years ago we remember seeing the late Dr. Pereira explode a Davy lamp by simply jerking it ; and this experiment was performed as an illustration year by year until Dr. Pereira ceased to lecture on chymistry. That which the lecturer
purposely accomplished, the coal-miner may accomplish accidentally at any instant. He has only to jerk the lamp intermittently during his passage along the galleries of a mine and the deed is done. Whatever may be the dangers attendant upon coal-mine
explorations, there can be no doubt that much could be effected in the way of reducing them to a practical minimum by codifying the principles on which they may depend, and making the result known among miners. At present, all relating to this
matter is no less vague and unsatisfactory than if the firedamp were a novelty instead of a source of practical evil, making itself known to the coal-miner in the earliest days of coal mining, and growing stronger and stronger with every successive year,
and every advance in science. Investigations of firedamp accidents have degenerated into the merest routine. Inquest after inquest takes place, and evolves no more than a hypothesis. The hypothesis is a most valuable one — viz., that if the Davy
lamps be employed, be in good order, and never tampered with, firedamp explosions cannot occur. Amid the desolation of the Risca catastrophe, it is a small source of satisfaction to be made aware that some few tenets of belief were expounded last
Saturday at Newport, in the course of a meeting convened for the purpose of providing funds for the relatives of the mangled dead. Mr. Brown there stated it as his opinion that a coal-mine ought to be maintained by ventilation in a condition of
such purity that naked candles might be employed without fear or possibility of accident. He would, if we understand him rightly, be understood to desire the limitation of the use of safety-lamps to the purpose of a preparatory exploration conducted by
an overseer for the purpose of ascertaining whether the mine were in a fit condition to be worked. And now it is most important to observe that Mr. Brown condemns absolutely the Davy lamp. He tells those assembled that the Davy lamp would explode.
The conditions under which explosion could be brought about he did not mention, but he stated the ultimate result as being a fact, one concerning which he had no doubt whatever ; and the terms of his assurance were such as to convey an assumption on his
part that the non-safety of the Davy lamp was a fact too well known for doubt or comment. All this is identical with our own views. It is our deliberate conviction that the onus should lie with the owners of coal-mines to assure themselves that each and
every mine should be demonstrated pure day by day. This demonstration may be effected by means of Stephenson's or some other really safe lamp. There are many such lamps which cannot be exploded under any conditions — natural or artificial. These
absolutely safe lamps are too delicate for working by, inasmuch as their flames go out on the first touch of dangerous gas ; but they might be used as mere testing instruments, and to that application we would restrict them. Not so satisfactory were the
observations made last Saturday by the chairman of the meeting, Sir Thomas Phillips. His remarks tended to imply that every measure of precaution capable of being taken against the dangers of fire-damp had commonly been taken, and that the economy
of coal-mines must remain in its present unsatisfactory state. He deplores the casualties not unfrequently arising, of course ; but he would seem to desire the public to regard them as inherent, inevitable casualties, that, when occurring, should be
looked upon in somewhat the same light as the casualties of war. If thus inevitable (which we do not believe), it is high time for the community of coal-miners to be made to understand that science in relation to their calling has gone to the end of its
tether, and reached its limits. It is time, also, for Parliament to take the coal-mining interest in hand, and lay down some graduated scale of death pensions to be forthcoming hereafter as a right — not in the shape of a mere imaginary
constitution. — Mechanics Magazine.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Brown, — | | | |
| Pereira, —, Dr. | | | |
| Phillips, Thomas, Sir | | | |