Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th January 1861, Page: 3, Column: 5

Drainage Of The Wallsend Coal Field

A meeting of coalowners was held on Wednesday at the Turf Hotel, Collingwood-street, to consider the details of a scheme for the drainage of coal districts of the Tyne, which are now under water. Matthew Bell, Esq., was in the chair.

The Chairman said he was glad to see so large and influential a meeting on a subject which was of very great importance, not only to the leassors and leasees, but to the whole district. It would be a great reflection upon the inhabitants and those more directly interested if they allowed these invaluable coal seams any longer to remain unproductive. He would not pretend to give any opinion on the condition of the coal mines, but would call upon Mr. Thos. John Taylor to state the case to the meeting.

Mr. T. J. Taylor said it naturally fell to his lot to describe the coal field on which it was proposed to operate, with a view to amend the exceedingly untoward state of things which now existed. He took the initiative in the matter several years ago, — not with a view to his own interest, for his own personal interest in the matter was nothing — but because he wished to see the Tyne placed in a prosperous position. Certainly at this time, that position, as regarded the coasting coal trade, was a declining one. The interests of the district, especially the manufacturing interest, would he promoted by the scheme now proposed. Beyond these, he had no interests to serve. His friend, Mr. Anderson, and Mr. Easton were coadjutors with him. They had framed a bill, and he hoped they would successfully carry it through. In the first place, he would describe the position of the coal field. They were all aware that the coal field east of Newcastle measured about 30 square miles. This, to use the emphatic language of mining was "drowned." Water had been permitted to accumulate till it had risen to from 100 to 120 fathoms above the high main seam ; so that, in point of fact, there was a lake of 100 to 120 fathoms deep underground, and the consequence was, that the high main seam is submerged and the lower seams were worked by a system ingenious, but which, however, was very uncertain. Cast iron caissons, or tubbing, which he need not describe, was used. Everybody was aware that these were in segments of 20 in. in height, and 4 or 5 ft. long. These were put together and wedged, and they constituted, to a certain extent, an efficient dam, but they were not to be depended on. At Hebburn Colliery, a fracture in the tubbing had occasioned the entire loss of the colliery, without any question as to the sacrifice of life, though that certainly was concerned, and very deeply, because, if the workmen of Hebburn Colliery had been employed at the time in the Bensham seam, there would have been a great sacrifice of life. Under these circumstances, which were illustrated by the plans and sections now in the room, it was desirable to adopt some general plan of drainage. The plan represented a district of 22,000 acres, bounded by the main dyke in the north, by a line on the south side, which, to a certain extent, was an arbitrary line fixed by the parties who promote the measure. It was also bounded by the sea on the east and the town of Newcastle on the west, beyond which the high main seam passes out — therefore, beyond which the promoters do not think it necessary to carry out the plan. It happened that this upper seam of the district had been to a very great extent worked out. He meant the old High Main — Russell's Wallsend Seam. Certain portions of this high main seam were left. He did not now go into details: these would be worked out in committee afterwards : but there was a portion of the high main and a considerable portion of the Bensham seam only partially worked. Then there was all the Low Main seam, and the Bensham Main. There were other seams which might not be suitable for the present state of the market; but the section would show that there was a sufficient quantity of coal in the district to justify the scheme which it was proposed to adopt. The Bensham seam was house coal; and, to a certain extent, as at Felling, it was a gas coal. Now, the coal they were speaking of lay immediately on the banks of the river; and, if they considered that coal, not of first-rate quality, was brought from a considerable distance at a cost of 3s to 4s 6d per chaldron, and even more, and that, the amount of charge for draining the coal bank eastward of Newcastle, would involve a maximum charge of only 6d per ton — probably much less — the difference between the mere leading or carriage, and the best of draining — as turning those distant coals to be not of better quality than those he was speaking of — would justify what they contemplated doing. In addition to this it must be remarked, that the manufacturers on the banks of the Tyne had reason to complain that they were not supplied with coals such as they required from the Newcastle basin. They were bringing their coal from a distance — defeating the proverb that "you need not send coals to Newcastle." Now if manufacturers could not be so supplied, the probability — he might say the certainty, was, that they would be removed to other situations (hear). That would be a loss, not only to the towns on the Tyne, but to the owners of property throughout the district. It might be said this was a commercial question, and that if these mines could be opened out to a profit, they would be; or, in other words, men who had capital would open them out as a natural result of the commercial state of things. This circumstance must be taken with a considerable degree of qualification. The fact was, the collieries on the Tyne had not been discontinued for want of a sufficient degree of commercial enterprise or demand ; but for the reason which they had met to counteract — for the reason that they had one by one been bowled down by the cost of water-lifting falling upon each of them. He need only appeal to the chairman. No one knew better than he did. — (The Chairman: I am sorry to say I do.") — At Percy Main Colliery, before it was discontinued, eighteen times the quantity of water was lifted relatively to the quantity of coal. — (Mr. Forster: "At a cost of 4s per chaldron.") — Compare this with the sum it was proposed to levy by this bill. The maximum charge was 6d — probably it might only amount to 3d. It was possible to lift at a charge of 3d per ton. That amounted to one shilling per chaldron. This might constitute the difference between continuing the colliery and laying it in. Next, then, there was the question of the barrier system. Upon this had hitherto depended the security of the individual coal proprietor — the security against the water that might come to them. It might surprise the gentlemen at this meeting to be told that there were not less than about a hundred miles in length of barriers in the high main seam only, and this waste of coal was exceedingly inadequate for the purpose — that of securing the deep workings against the excess of water. The value of this barrier in the high main seam was calculated at a very low degree of rent, 25s per ton amounted to £130,000 to £140,000. The coals were lost as far as present value was concerned. That was a sacrifice to the lessors of about the amount he had stated. He did not reckon the lessees' profit, which might amount to more than this. It really amounted to this, in one seam only, the lessors had sacrificed a sum amounting to three or four times the amount of £60,000 which they were now asked to subscribe towards the undertaking. This barrier system would have to be repeated in the lower seams. Another barrier would have to be left in the Bensham seam. In short, an entire system of barriers would have to be made in the low main, and whatever seam had to be worked hereafter. Possibly the value of the lower seam barriers might not be equal to the high main, which was the most valuable seam that had ever been worked; but even three fourths of the value was quite enormous. The proposed system of draining would do away entirely with this sacrifice. Another point was this. Notwithstanding the tubing by cast iron caissons, by which the lower seams were now protected, and which were exceedingly uncertain — they were a mere succedaneum — notwithstanding these tubings, or the duplication of them which might be done, for the seams worked below this great lake of water — which was 100 fathoms deep in the lower part of the basin, — and when it rose to the level of the Tyne would be 130 fathoms — and even more than this in its lower part — it was quite clear to common sense that the coal beds worked below this lake could not be worked, consistently with safety to life and property. They could not depend on cast iron. But suppose it was perfectly safe. Suppose they could depend every day on its continuing in an entire state, the inevitable result of an accident with the great weight of water resting upon it would be, that every man would be lost in the lower seams. No man had a chance of escape. The lower seams could not be worked on proper principles with this lake overhead — not only from the flats at Hebburn, but from any fracture occurring. They knew that, notwithstanding what naturalists said, there was no such thing as solid rock — there were fissures and fractures constantly occurring. But, besides this, there were dykes or troubles, as they were called, which might admit the water and drive out the men employed in the mines, and render the mines themselves valueless (hear. hear). Surely it was better, by a moderate expenditure of capital, and by the system proposed, to take away all chance of any accident happening which prevented the working of the mines in a proper scientific manner. This could not be done without removing the lake. This was what was proposed to be done, and it might be done at an exceedingly moderate expense. Some had apprehended damage to the surface from the lifting out of the great lake of water from the underground country. He would not go fully into that part of the question. The law would constitute a liability; but, however that might be, the danger in this case arose principally from the condition of the high main seam. It was in three conditions — either standing whole, in which case there was no danger; or it was worked in pillars ; and in that case also there was no danger, because the subsidence had taken place already, or, thirdly, it was standing in pillars. They could scarcely ascertain the fact exactly, as to whether these pillars were cleft pillars ; but they were sure that quiescence had already taken place, under these circumstances no material danger could accrue to the surface from the lifting out of the water. Another question related to certain rents — out-stroke rent, shaft rent, and way-leave rent :— They did not intend to interfere with these so far as the coal was concerned. But what they insisted on was that there should be free access to the water from one royalty to another. It was a concerted system of drainage that was required. This was not a new thing. It was a common thing on the Continent, though the Continental system was not an analogous one, because the Crown was the owner of the mines, and therefore did what it pleased. But it stood to common sense that they must have it throughout the district. There must be a free course for the water to these fire engines — one at Jarrow, one at Howdon, one at Wallsend, and another at Tyne Main, or Friar's Goose. There must be a free course to the water in all directions. Beyond this, they did not interfere with any right which a mine proprietor might have. It might naturally be asked, why was not a drainage company got up, irrespective of the lessors? The difficulty of getting up a drainage company was great — in reality insuperable. No set of men would undertake to lift the water and take all the risk upon themselves, whether the mines proved productive or not. The only chance was to combine a drainage company with one for working the mines; and observe how this would act on the lessors :— The Coal and Drainage Company would go to them and say, we are willing to work the water out of your mines, and to work them, but under these circumstances we will only give you half the rent you would receive if they were drained. That was a clear sacrifice of property. The only right system was for the lessors to take the matter up with a view to place themselves in such a position that the capitalist and the mining adventurer might come for them, and offer to deal with them under the most advantageous circumstances to the lessors; otherwise they would be in an inferior position. He might remark that perfect unanimity was required. It was quite clear that all must be brought under contribution, as all would share the advantages. Even the objection of one, though it might not be fatal, yet it would be most desirable to avoid (hear). With regard to the schedules, the promoters had drawn them up on a graduated scale — 7s 6d, 5s, 2s 6d, and 1s per acre. These had been done on a principle which was conceived to be just and equitable to all parties. He thought it would be found from the tenor of the resolution, some modification might be made in this bill under the arrangements of the committee proposal to be appointed; and in whose hands the subject would be, however, to a certain extent, at least, elastic.

The Rev. Dixon Brown said the promoters of the bill never intended that the coalowners should come here and adopt the scheme just as it stood, without any consideration, or without taking the details into close examination. They saw, however, that the project had something reasonable in it. It proposed to unite them altogether, with a view to bring into the market coal which, at present, was of no use. Therefore, there seemed to be a necessity to do something. They could not expect their coal to be worked by others, without expense on their own part. It was doing nothing now; and the question was, whether they would let it remain so, or adopt some plan. The gentlemen who had brought the matter forward seemed to have looked closely into it. They had made calculations of the quantity of water that had been turned into the upper main seam, and of the quantity that could be brought out. It did seem reasonable that the meeting should go a step further, though without committing themselves to details. The main question, and the most awkward one, was the money. £60,000 was a large sum to be raised by a rate on the owners, at so much per acre, and by a rate on the lessees, of so much per chaldron, on the coals brought up. This was the great point to be considered. It would cost this sum — were they confident it would cost only this sum? The engines would be worked profitably. He thought, therefore, he might conclude by reading the resolution, which did nothing more than affirm the principle of the bill. [The resolution, as amended, after discussion, we give below.]

Mr. John Craster seconded the motion.

Mr. John Clayton said all must agree in the desirableness of the object. £60,000 seemed a large sum; but three times that amount was often spent in winning one colliery.

Mr. R. R. Dees said, he appeared on behalf of Mr. Bewicke, and he only represented the instructions of other gentlemen. They were not prepared to commit themselves to any such declaration as the one now proposed. He had not intended to make these observations, but he felt bound to do so. Mr. Bewicke was neither a lessor nor a lessee — for the coal was that of other gentlemen. He thought it unfair that he should be charged £1,500 a year for a speculation, the result of which no man could foresee. It was out of the ordinary sphere of his (Mr. D.'s) information and inquiries — therefore it was quite impossible for him to express any opinion as to the feasibility of the scheme. The lucid statement of Mr. Taylor must have been listened to with great pleasure and instruction, but those he (Mr D.) represented could not assent to this principle. They were the owners of coal which was quite unoccupied — and the contemplated benefit was remote and contingent, and might never be realised ; he would, therefore, move the previous question. It would have been more correct to summon the lessors, who, it was said, in 1855, should take the initiative.

Mr. T. J. Taylor: Who is taking the initiative? This meeting is for the purpose of allowing the lessors to take part in the scheme.

Mr. Dees said he gathered from Mr. Taylor that the immediate cause of proceeding with this bill was the drownings of Hebburn Colliery. This bill had not been brought in by the lessors, and it proposed to tax them with a considerable sum for an indefinite term of years. They had not been consulted, and they must submit to it, or incur serious expense. He said it was not a proper position for them to be placed in — to have a bill brought cut and dry.

Mr. Taylor said all the difficulty might be met in the consideration of details.

Mr. Peel, registrar of the Dean and Chapter, said it proposed to tax coal in lease and not in lease. He was not prepared to agree to it.

The Rev. J. Armstrong, of Wallsend, said he had 40 acres of glebe, and it would cost him £15 per annum, though he would not receive any benefit from the scheme. Was there a probability that it would be laid on his successors ?

Mr. Clayton said the incumbent of a living ought to have the power of raising capital on the property of the living, and pay only the interest or a given portion of the interest. This provision might be introduced into the bill.

Mr. Philipson said the question was — assuming the thing was to be done at all — whether it should be by one general measure, or be split up into different portions, at a cost which would render the whole scheme abortive ! Inasmuch as he was associated with persons who were willing to investigate the subject, he could have no difficulty in assenting to the principle of removing the water, leaving the burden of details to the committee who were to investigate it.

Mr. Wm. Hunter said he happened to be a lessee of a colliery in operation, and he saw the bill contemplated taxing that colliery. As they were protected at present from any water, he objected to the taxation.

Mr. Clayton said the resolution might be framed so as not to commit any gentleman further than was desirable.

Mr. Edward Collingwood, of Dissington, said if they were to be committed to nothing by forming the committee, he would not object; but, as far as he was concerned, he would be injured by the scheme. His coal was worked out, and therefore, independent of the water, the coal mines were reported to be worth nothing. It was hard that he should be taxed in that case, though the mines came within the area to be taxed.

Mr. H. W. Fenwick, who represented Mr. E. J. Collingwood, said he had no authority to assent to the bill.

Mr. Hugh Taylor said there must be no committal by any one. The Duke of Northumberland was not largely concerned in the question, but, as far as he (Mr T.) was concerned, there would be no committal on the part of the Duke. But still it was a subject well worthy of consideration, and ultimately something of the kind might be done. Whether this was the proper time or the proper mode, he gave no opinion at this moment.

Mr. Forster said when he came into that room he fully expected they would have been unanimous. He was sorry any of the lessors did not see their own interest, for they would be the parties benefited: He went further than Mr. Taylor. If the high seam was to be worked, the water must be taken away. If it was only partially taken away, they would be great losers.

Mr. Clayton proposed certain modifications of the resolution, which then stood as follows :— "That the object of rendering productive a coal field at present lying dormant by reason of water, is worthy of the favourable consideration of all parties interested in that coal field. That, without committing any party to the bill now offered to Parliament, or any of its provisions, a committee be appointed to consider its clauses and the schedules annexed, and to report to a meeting to be held at the Turf Hotel Inn, on the first Thursday in the month of February next, at one o'clock.

Mr. Peel: Would it not be better to withdraw the bill for the present ?

Mr. Clayton : You had better not commit yourselves to do that. You might find it expedient to go on with the bill. If you don't agree it will not be gone on with.

After some further conversation, the resolution was adopted by a show of hands, with one dissentient.

The following gentlemen constitute the committee :— Mr. Matthew Bell, Mr. Edward Collingwood, Mr. John Craster, Rev. Dixon Brown, Mr. Hugh Taylor, Mr. Clayton, Mr. Rea, Mr. Thomas John Taylor, Mr. Nicholas Wood, Mr. Thomas E. Forster, Mr. Edward Potter, Mr. Edward Boyd, Mr. John Johnson, Mr. Matthew Liddell, Mr. William Armstrong, Mr. Thomas Jobling, Mr. Wm. Barkus, jun., Mr. Chas. Carr, Mr. Wm. Hunter, and Mr. Dees.

Mr. Hugh Taylor proposed a vote of thanks to the Chairman, which was seconded by Mr. John Carr, and carried by a show of hands.

The Chairman said, there was a gentleman in the room more entitled to their thanks than he was, namely Mr. Thomas John Taylor, for his lucid, able, and scientific statement (applause). He was the person who originated the scheme, and he (Mr. Bell) hoped he would live to see it successfully carried out. If it were so, it would be mainly through his exertions in this good cause.

Mr. Clayton seconded the motion. which was carried by acclamation.

Mr. Taylor said it was a scheme which he had very much at heart. He could not benefit from it individually, but he promoted it for the sake of the district. From the public position in which he stood he only hoped he would succeed (applause).

The meeting then separated.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anderson, —      
Armstrong, J., Rev.      
Armstrong, William      
Barkus, William, jun.      
Bell, Matthew      
Bewicke, —      
Boyd, Edward Fenwick      Whos Who Page
Brown, Dixon, Rev.      
Carr, Charles      
Carr, John      
Clayton, John      
Collingwood, E. J.      
Collingwood, Edward      
Craster, John      
Dees, R. R.      
Easton, James      Whos Who Page
Fenwick, H. W.      
Forster, Thomas Emerson      Whos Who Page
Hunter, William      
Jobling, Thomas W.      Whos Who Page
Johnson, John      
Liddell, Matthew      Whos Who Page
Northumberland, Duke of      
Peel, —      
Philipson, —      
Potter, Edward      
Rea, —      
Taylor, Hugh      Whos Who Page
Taylor, Thomas John      Whos Who Page
Wood, Nicholas      Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hebburn Colliery  Hebburn Colliery
Howden Colliery  Howden Colliery
Jarrow Colliery  Jarrow Colliery
Percy Main Colliery  Percy Main Colliery
Tyne Main Colliery  Tyne Main Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print