|
12th January 1861, Page: 3, Column: 2 The Hetton Colliery ExplosionThe Coroner's InquestThe inquest on the men killed by this explosion, adjourned from the 20th December, was resumed on Tuesday at the "Colliery Inn," Hetton, before Mr. Maynard, Mr. Dickinson, Inspector of Mines for the Lancashire District, was in attendance, having been ordered down by the Secretary of State, and Mr. M. Dunn was also present. The first witness called was George Lowden, overman of the colliery. He said :— On the morning of the explosion he descended the pit at twenty minutes past two and examined the workings. He had charge of two men and two boys in the south way at the time of the explosion. He had minutely examined the workings that morning without seeing any gas. Left the pit at eight o'clock. The return was then all right — no gas. Thought that the explosion arose from the furnace flues, because the injury done to the workings had spread both north and south. Had had charge of the pit for three years. Had not seen gas for four months prior to the explosion. The ventilation was all right last time witness saw the pit before the explosion. Did not know what quantity of ventilation there was by actual measurement; but it was quite sufficient. — By Mr. Dickinson: The gas he saw four months ago was in the west portion of the pillar workings. The returns do not go from those places to the flues. There were no men working where that gas was seen, and if the ventilation was perfect, the gas could not have reached the men. On the day of the explosion the men were working with Davy lamps, and not with candles; but when he left the pit on this day, it was in such good condition that he should have had no fear of them if they had worked with candles. — By the Foreman of the Jury: Was down examining the pit from four to five hours. — By the Coroner: I found the bodies of James Boux, William Richardson, and Robert Hall, in the return on the south side of the return way. They had died from after-damp. The other two, John Ferguson and Anthony Young I found in the main way, near to the bottom of the bank, rather beyond it from the new shaft, the place where I found the bodies would be nearly 600 yards distant from the furnace. Thomas Smith, shifter, said :— I examined the lamps of all the men under my care in the pit a while before the explosion. The lamps were all perfect and there was no indication of gas in that part of the pit. The explosion came from the west of where I was. I was thrown down by the violence of the explosion, and when I got up I put up my hand to ascertain which way the air was going. It was going west; the strong way. About a minute afterwards I found the air going in the right direction. I proceeded north to make my road to the Eppleton pit. Other men joined me there and we found the after-damp until we proceeded about 300 yards of the east minor pit. We were obliged to return to the west minor pit, in consequence of the after damp. We remained there until seven o'clock the following morning, when we were taken out. During the whole time I was in the pit I did not observe any gas in my district, or near the furnaces. I cannot say what was the quantity of air circulating at the time of the explosion, but I think the air was good. I had no fear at the time the explosion took place. In my opinion, the explosion first made the blast at the crossing of the north waggon-way, — it is the first place where tne injury took place. I cannot tell exactly where the gas first exploded. From the crossing of the north waggon way it extended north and south. The damage is very extensive on both sides of the crossing. I cannot form any opinion as to the cause of the explosion. It would require the explosion of a large quantity of gas to cause so extensive an injury as I observed. I don't think so large a quantity could have accumulated from the "in-by" working of the pit. — By Mr. Dickinson: Open lamps (not "safetys") were used at the stables. Candles would have been safe, there. Cannot say that so large a quantity of gas as that which exploded could have been generated in the boilers. Don't think it could have come from the upper seam in the shaft which is not worked. My idea is that the gas came from the neighbourhood of that shaft. The air currents were as usual when I placed the men. — By the Coroner: I found the first after-damp at the separation door in the east shaft, which is 900 yards from the downcast shaft. It was then proceeding east. — By Mr. Dickinson: The after-damp in the east level was mixed with smoke ; but there was no smoke going along the north level with the after-damp a which was making that way when I passed the stables. It was not like gunpowder smoke. — By Mr. Dunn: The boiler fire was fed with fresh air. If the foul return had come from the west way, loaded with gas, it could not have got into the engine chimney. To the best of my judgment the explosion took place at or near the flue. Whilst the ventilation continued perfect, no explosion could take place from the rolley-ways where the men were. James Currie furnaceman, said :— When the explosion took place I had charge of the east furnace in the east minor pit. When I took charge there was no appearance of gas. I had observed nothing previous to the explosion to lead me to think there was danger. I had a good fire on at the time, and had supplied it with coals about five or ten minutes previous to the explosion. After the explosion took place the air came back from the furnace instead of going through it. As soon as I found the wind I made the best of my way to the first door coming out at the downcast shaft. The force of the explosion was very strong before I get through the first door, but appeared to cease after. I got past it. I can form no opinion as to where the explosion took place. The force of the explosion came from the direction of the upcast shaft. Thomas Smith recalled, said, we take gunpowder in in quantities of about 7 lbs in two bottles. The two men on the north waggon-way had come on the night of the explosion. The supply from which the men got what they needed was kept above bank. There was about 2 or 3lbs in each of the men's bottles. After I gave the men the powder, which weighed about a pound, it was left in my cabin. — By Mr. Dickinson: That powder has since been found unexploded. John Laverick, a master-waste man at Eppleton Pit, and residing at Down's Lane, thought the explosion commenced at the flues. Mr. Isaac Lowthian Bell said :— I reside at Washington, and am an ironmaster and chemical manufacturer. I have not been accustomed to investigate explosions connected with collieries, but in my business as an ironmaster I have something like 3,000 cubic feet of gas per minute to contend with, and this has led me to study the gas particularly. Since the explosion I have been down the downcast of the West Minor pit. I spent two hours and more in examining the flue in which the explosion is said to have taken place. I found a damper about six feet from the engine. It was broken. The lower portion was resting in its place, and the upper portion was swung up at the other end, I found some woodwork which was charred, and woodwork and stone in the eastward direction from the boiler. I found the separation doors blown away, and all things indicating the current of the explosion to have come from the boiler. I found thirty feet of flue, from the damper towards the upcast shaft, blown out. I found the whole of the lateral flues in the pipe-drift also blown out. From that point the flue and travelling ways were whole. Then about fifteen feet of the top, of the flue blown outwards, and about ten feet of covering of travelling ways also displaced. I had now got to the crossing over the waggon-way leading to the downcast pits. Here the flue, being unsupported on the one side or the other burst the whole thing. The walls on the north side were blown to the north, and the walls on the south side were blown to the south ; and generally the indication of the explosion at the crossing was as if it had proceeded from the crossing as a common centre. From there I continued along the flue towards the furnace going to the upcast shaft. The soot had evidently been displaced, the flues being as clean as though they had been swept. At the bed next to the furnace there was a little displacement of brickwork. At the end of the north furnace a bridge of brickwork was blown over in the direction in which an explosion in this flue would render probable. Immediately opposite there is a flue proceeding from another furnace, in which, as it crosses a road, I found the arch displaced. The question which presented itself to my mind was, could the flues contain sufficient gas to cause the explosion, and, secondly, if so, where did the gas come from? I arrived at the conclusion that the gas could not come from the workings, because this boiler furnace always has been, and is now, exclusively fed by air proceeding directly from the downcast shaft, without going into the old workings. I find, by computation, that this flue contains 7,000 cubic feet; to fill the flue with light carburretted hydrogen, leaving a sufficient content for the necessary atmospheric air to thoroughly explode the light carburretted hydrogen, so contained in the flue, 150lbs of fresh coal would furnish the whole gas necessary. The length of time would depend upon the heat applied. I find, to fill the same flue with another explosive gas — carbonic oxide, 40lbs of coke would be sufficient. Supposing the flues to be filled with either of these gases, together with the necessary atmospheric air required for their explosion ; and supposing the flue so filled at a time when there was no matter sufficiently heated to cause the explosion, a state of things which might readily occur from damping the coals, then the combustion of the coal at the boiler's end, or on the furnace at the far end could supply the flame for setting on fire this magazine of inflammable gas. I have had a wrought iron pipe three feet in diameter and 100 feet long filled with an explosive compound, in which the combustible gas was carbonic oxide, the less explosive of the two; in round numbers it had about half the power of the other explosive ingredients. That pipe fired at one end, at a lamp, blew the man holding the lamp many yards into the air, breaking every bone in his body, destroying almost the whole length of the iron pipe, and splitting the blowing apparatus, of metal three quarters of an inch thick, at the far end. My opinion is based upon these facts and upon philosophical calculation of the power of such a quantity of gas. All the results I have this day seen are easily accounted for. As soon as ever the contents of the flue, supposing it to be filled with an explosive mixture, of light carburretted hydrogen fired, the 7,000 feet contained in it would instantly become about 56,000 feet; and of course the increased volume would rush down the most ready access, and that was towards where the men were killed ; but in addition to that, the contents of this flue would be instantly converted into after-damp, and this being taken up the natural ventilation of the colliery would be carried into the workings, and thus cause the death of every man it passed. I think it highly probable that the explosion might have set fire to the north stables, not because flame would travel that far but because particles of inflammable matter, set fire by the explosion, would be driven in the direction of the stables ; and besides, the temperature of these exploded gases being about 1,500 of Fahrenheit, or a very bright red-heat, would of itself, if coming near hay or straw, immediately set fire to it, and in this way I think everything that has occurred can be accounted for. Gunpowder might have caused the explosion, but it would take 75 quarter barrels of 25lb each to produce anything like it. — By Mr. Dickinson: Assuming no steam to be present, then no soot could have added to the violence of the explosion ; but supposing the contrary, I think it possible that the explosion might have been increased somewhat in its intensity. No reason suggests itself to me as to how the gas might have accumulated in the flue when it has not done so for so many years — it is one of those things affected to some extent by the doctrine of chance. I think the frosty weather would have increased the intensity of the explosive gas. — By Mr. Dunn: If the damper had been hermetically sealed, inflammable gas would not have been found there — it being partly open would have accelerated the generation of gas, and also supplied air. — By Mr. Dickinson: The explosion could not have occurred at any other place than the flue from the direction the materials were lying, and from the other appearances in and about the flue. — By the Coroner: If no large quantity of gas came down the down-cast nor from the in-line workings of the pit to fire the flues, I do not think it possible the explosion could have taken place from any other native elements, except the boiler. — By Mr. Wood: 160,000 cubic feet of air going down the downcast shaft would have to meet 16,000 cubic feet of firedamp to bring it to the full explosive power. The inquest was then adjourned until next morning.
The inquest was resumed on Wednesday morning at the same place. The following witnesses were called:— William Gardner was working about 100 yards from the shaft when the explosion took place. He and others went up the return way after the explosion and met the afterdamp. Could form no opinion as to the explosion. There was good ventilation prior to the explosion. At first they thought it was only a boiler exploded. — Ralph Hope gave similar evidence, as did also Robert Simpson. The latter said that in his opinion the explosion came from the flues. He afterwards said that 17 feet of brattice was blown out. — George Cleghorn and Robert Gardner, who were in the pit when the explosion occurred, gave similar evidence, but could not account for the explosion. William Anderson, stone-mason, was working a mile and a quarter from the shaft. The explosion was so slight there that he and his marrow took no notice of it. He thought it quite possible that the explosion might have originated from an accumulation of gas in the flues. The gas, if it had come from the goaves would have blown the furnace out. The furnace had been out one or two days, but this did not appear to have affected the ventilation. — By the Coroner: In my opinion the explosion took place in the flues — there is every appearance of it. We are at work now, without the furnaces, and have sufficient ventilation, though there is not half so much air now as there was when the explosion took place. Robert Young, back-overman, examined the pit during the day prior to the explosion. All was right then. There was no gas escaping from any of the goaves. In his opinion the explosion took place in the flues, but as to how the gas got there he could not say. It could not have arisen from a discharge of gunpowder, because there was none there. Had never known such a quantity of gunpowder be in the pit at one time as would cause such an explosion. The crossing having been blown down allowed the after-damp to get into the workings. — By Mr. Dickinson: Did not observe any "tail" on any of the lights. The ventilation was very different when the furnace was out. The quantity of air in the low main was so great that it would have destroyed any gas that might have accumulated there. James Reid, wasteman, was down the pit prior to the explosion and saw no gas. In his opinion the explosion came from the flues, gas having accumulated there by damping the coals. He did not think it possible that the gas could have come down the downcast shaft when the ventilation was good ; but if the ventilation was not perfect, and it came down, he did not think it could have got to the flues ; it must have accumulated from the damping of the coals in the flue. Some repairs were commenced at the upcast shaft on the Sunday previous to the explosion ; but that would not have damaged the ventilation to any considerable extent. — By Mr. Dickinson: At the time the repairs were going on, the high main furnace was in full operation; the west furnace was also working but not in so powerful operation ; the east furnace was out; and the three boiler fires were on to ascertain the extent of air. The air which went to the Eppleton Pit was a benefit to the East Minor Pit; that which went to the Blossom Pit was a benefit to the West Minor Pit. 57,668 cubic feet of air per minute was coming down the East Minor Pit a fortnight ago when it was measured. In his opinion, the furnaces did not to assist to make afterdamp, but the burning in the stables would do so. He did not think any other gas caused the explosion except what was in the flue. The area of the upcast shaft was 128 feet; 48 feet of that was occupied by the cradle, leaving 80 feet for the ventilation to come down the pit. — By Mr. Boyd: There was no possibility of the gas getting from the low main to the flues, because the flues were shut off. If it did it would have to pass over the boiler fire and although the dampers were in, there would have been sufficient fire to cause an explosion. By Mr. Dunn: 20,000 feet of gas could not retain its qualities in so large a quantity of air as I have stated. — By Mr. Dickinson ; When ventilation is broken, it is possible for such a quantity of gas to give as much after damp as was found on the occasion of this explosion George Davison, engineman, was of opinion that the explosion did take place at the flues. — By Mr. Dickinson: Never knew a case of a pit firing at the flues — either behind the damper or in front of it. He had seen a little when breaking at bank on the fire. It was a bit of a "flisk" when the damper was in, and when it was lifted it gave a bit of an explosion. — By the Coroner: He could not form an opinion as to where the gas came from that exploded. — By Dr. Richardson: He noticed that the fire burnt a little sharper in the frosty weather, but did not make any change in the damper. His fire burning brighter in the cold weather might cause a flame to play upon the fire after it was damped. There was a little flame playing upon the coal after it was damped on the night of the explosion. In letting the damper down he never observed it catch any projection on the wall, and could not tell to an inch how far the damper was down. — By a Juror: It usually required a tub containing 8 cwt. of coal to damp the fire. — By Mr. Dickinson: About one quarter of that might have been burnt by the following morning — 11 hours from the time of damping. — By Dr. Richardson: There would be about a tub of fire in the grate when they began to damp. Wm. Clennell, a fireman, residing at the Downs, and employed at the pit in the same capacity as last witness, was called, and corroborated the evidence of his fellow workman. Dr. Thos. Richardson, Newcastle, was next called. He said: I am an LL.D., and a reader in chemistry of the University of Durham, and chemical manufacturer on the river Tyne. I have been down the east and west minor pits at Hetton Colliery, for the purpose of giving my opinion as to where the explosion took place. I found the flues connected with Davison's engine much damaged. I believe that the destructive effects which we noticed at the various points arose from an explosion of gas in the flue, between the boiler of Davison's engine and the crossing at the north rolley-way. There are 3,000 cubic feet of space between the boiler and the crossing, which would, consequently, contain the required quantity of gaseous matter, which might consist of carbonic oxide, carburetted hydrogen, or Olipheiant gas. These gases might be generated from the destructive distillation of the fuel used in firing the boiler, and might proceed from the fire grates under the boiler, and pass up into the flue by way of underneath the damper. The space between the bottom of the damper and the sole, the heat of the flue, the draught of the upcast shaft, the temperature of the air admitted into the grates, the quantity and condition of the fuel used previous to damping, are all points which would affect the filling of the flue with explosive gas, and if the combination was favourable, the flue would be so filled. I believe the results prove that the combinations were favourable. There is no other mode of accounting for the explosion, except that which I have given. 300 or 400 cubic feet of the gases I have mentioned, or a mixture of them, might cause the consequences which have resulted. That amount of gas could have accumulated in the flue from the workings of the pit. If gunpowder in a sufficient quantity had been in the flue, it might have caused a similar explosion. I agree with the statement of Mr. Bell, that it would require 75 quarter barrels of gunpowder to produce effects like those caused by the gas on this occasion. The first effect of the explosion would be to interrupt the ventilation of the pit, the afterdamp would be carried by the current in the direction in which it was going, and as only ten per cent of carbonic acid gas is sufficient to cause almost instantaneous death, a small quantity of the after-damp would vitiate a large quantity of air. It would be impossible to estimate the quantity of carbonic acid produced by the explosion, without knowing the composition of the explosive nature of the flue. The combustion of the soot would increase the production of the carbonic acid, and there would be sufficient heat generated in the flue, by the explosion of this gaseous mixture, to ignite the soot. I find in a work, entitled "Gasometry," by a German chemist, named Busson, that his statement about what is produced by the explosion of these gases is more than Mr. Bell and I had previously calculated upon. According to his calculation the power of the gases would be very much increased ; and this strengthens my opinion. If the explosion had been caused by gunpowder the flame would not have extended so far as to set fire to hay and straw in the north stable, a distance of 300 yards from the flue where I suppose the explosion took place. It is my opinion that the stables were set on fire by hot particles from the explosion and heated air. The burning of the men is very slight — just as much as would account for their coming to their death by the highly heated state of the gas or air. I have no doubt that their deaths were caused by after damp, because I have known where an explosion took place at Gateshead the concussion of the air blow out lights at Jarrow Slake, a distance of eight miles. Again, the concussion of the air having knocked the men down insensible, the carbonic acid would more easily affect them than a man who had not been knocked down in that manner. By Mr. Dickinson ; Olipheiant gas is much more explosive than the other gases. I have never met with it, nor ever heard of any eminent chemists finding it in their analyses of the fire-damp, although it has been found in the coal works on the Rhine. It might be produced by slow distillation. By the Coroner: It might be so distilled by the manner I have heard the coal was put upon the fire in damping. By Mr. Forster: It was possible that the concussion of the air might have caused the death of the men independent of the after damp. By Mr. Dickinson: There is an analogy between the putting not of a candle and life by carbonic acid. It takes 10 per cent. of carbonic acid to put life out, and that quantity will also put out a candle. I have passed up the north rolley-way and seen the effects of the explosion. I believe that when the products of the combustion in this flue found vent in the north rolley-way by the destruction of the crossing, they would fill the rolley way to such an extent as to interrupt the ventilation, and pass in and suffocate the men who were killed. The after-damp is a mixture of carbonic acid and nitrogen. I cannot say what deficiency of oxygen would be sufficient to kill a man. I don't know nor have I heard of a man being killed by heated air while underground, but it is possible to do so. It is possible but scarcely probable that the explosion took place as a secondary action in the north rolley-way. The ignition at the damper might arise by a "tailing-back" of the gas in the roof of the arch from the furnace to the crossing. The inquiry was then adjourned to Thursday.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||