Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th December 1860

Adjourned Inquest

The adjourned inquest upon the bodies of Leonard Bell, John Wales, and Joseph Beckett or Bethwaite killed in the explosion at Guslet pit yesterday week, was resumed in the assembly room of the Golden Lion Hotel, Maryport, on Saturday last, before Mr. Lumb, coroner for the western division of the county. Mr. Dunne, Her Majesty's Government Inspector of Mines for the Northern District, was present during the inquiry; the following gentlemen were upon the jury: — Joseph Fletcher (foreman), James Millican, W. J. Twentyman, Jno. Walker, Francis Walker, W. Wilson, Thos. Cockton, Robt. Adair, Thos. Boyd, Jonah Dobie, Jos. Armstrong, Jno. Benson, Geo. Gregans, Jos. Temple, Jos. L. Fawcett, W. Tinnion.

A short discussion arose between the Coroner and the jury as to whether the pitmen and those connected with the management of the colliery should be present.

The Coroner thought it would be hard to exclude the owners of the colliery.

Mr. Adair thought that it would be one-sided justice to admit the one party and exclude the other; but he thought some guarantee should be given by the masters that any evidence given by the men should not be used against them.

Mr. Johnston gave that guarantee on the part of Capt. Harris.

The Coroner said he thought public opinion would be a sufficient check upon anything of the kind.

Mr. Adair said he was informed that at a large meeting of pitmen one of the company was chosen to be their organ and express their opinions, and he was discharged, although a good man and a clever workman.

The Coroner: In this pit?

Mr. Adair: I don't know in what pit; but a man was discharged for taking a prominent part in that meeting.

The Coroner: If any of the men will intimate to us that they have any fear, we will take their evidence in such a way that they need not be afraid.

The first witness was then called, both pitmen and the representatives of the company being present.

Thomas Rogerson, of Maryport, shiftsman, said: I know Ellenborough pit, in the parish of Dearham, in the occupation of Capt. Harris. On Monday morning last I was in the pit. I went into the pit about ten o'clock on Sunday night. I go into the pit at eight o'clock on other nights. The pit is worked at nights, but there is not a shift of colliers on. John Wales was a deputy overman; Beckett and Bell were coal haggers. I had no conversation with Bell that morning in the pit; I never spoke to him. John Wales went into the pit with me at the same time, we went up the incline plane together. Before that, Hughie Brown was in. When we first went in there was no indication of fire. At twelve o'clock we went up the incline plane to the new coal; we perceived there was gas. John Wales first found some gas in the new "robbery." He went up to the gas himself. He had a Davy's safety lamp with him. He lost his light, and returned to me and I gave him a light out of my lamp. We opened both lamps at the break. Wales' lamp was fast when we went into the "robbery." I went back with him, about 85 yards, to the "robbery." He tried the gas again in my presence. The gas showed in his lamp, and the lamp went out, either put out by the gas or by him pulling the wick down. My lamp was affected. I put it under my coat and pulled the wick down. We returned to the fresh air to light the lamps, as it would have been dangerous to have opened the lamp where we were, near the "robbery." We returned again with both lamps lighted. Wales said there had been a door left open. We found it open further in than the "robbery," about ten yards from it. I got some "brattices" and nailed the door up, and then we both came out to the break. No explosion had taken place. We waited at the break for Leonard Bell. John Wales was going again to the "robbery" and I told him that Leonard Bell was coming. He came and they went together. That was the last time I saw the two deceased men alive. It would be about three o'clock. Wales said I was to stop at the break and stop the men from going further into the pit until I had directions from Bell. I knew why I was to do so.

By the Inspector: Do you know what effect the closing of the door would have? — No.

Examination resumed: A workman called Mossop, going to his work, first came to the break. I told him he was not to go. He said "There is no fear of my head so long as it is right at the top." The furnace man was ill, and I had to go to the furnaces, which are about half a mile off. When I left him I thought Mossop would stop. When I left there was no one there but him. I did not tell him why he was ordered to stop. On going to the furnaces I met two men going to the same working, Oliphant and Beckett, both of whom I told not to go on. They proceeded on the road, but how far they went I don't know. I told them to stop at the break, the usual place for stopping. The orders given were that all the men were to stop at the break till Bell came back, but whether he ever came back I do not know. I went on to the furnace which I found all right. The furnace man, Joseph Thompson, was there. Both fires were good, one better than the other; the fire that was low having been cleaned out. The furnace-man was ill, and I was going to assist him. If I had not been there I would have been waiting for fresh orders at the break. There were only three men to go into the new coal part of the pit, and I am sure I stopped them all. It would have been after three o'clock when I got to the furnace. While I was on the road to the furnace I heard the explosion. I could not tell where it came from. There were then in the pit six or seven men. After hearing the explosion I went on to the furnace and I and the furnace man did our best to keep the fires up, to increase the ventilation. The man at the furnace felt the explosion; I felt a shake myself. After making up the furnace I went back. They were bringing Oliphant out. I have been in the pit about two years. I know nothing about ventilation. I never saw any fire.

By the Jury: I am not a regular miner. I was aware that the pit had exploded before I got to the furnace. No one stopped me when I went in at ten o'clock. I did not see the furnace between ten and two o'clock.

You nailed some brattice up. Was the door off altogether? — No, it was just open.

Am I to understand it was insufficient to keep the air out till you nailed it up? — I don't know whether it was good or not. We shut it before we nailed the brattice on it. There is no latch on the doors. That door shuts against the post. It should have done so or we would not have had to nail the brattices on. We nailed it on both sides, so that it could not be opened, and so that it would stop the air. The door was not sufficient to turn the air if it had been shut. When Wales' lamp went out I knew there was danger. When Bell came up why did you not tell him? — It was not my business.

The Coroner: This man might naturally not say anything to Bell, as Bell was an overman and going along with an overman.

By the Jury:- I have never known a scarcity of wood or "brattices" in the pit when they were wanted. I didn't know anything about the furnaces before I went there. It is Leonard Bell's duty to stop the men. Wales told me not to tell the men there was danger. [Witness was asked several times whether he was sure about his last answer. He repeated it several times.] It is Bell's duty to stop the men, but the men came too soon that morning. I know nothing about the place the fire was.

The Coroner said he was not satisfied about witness's evidence about what Wales had said, and as Wales was dead it was only right they should have this properly explained. He asked witness again what were Wales' words.

Witness replied: He told me to stop the men from going from the break till Leonard Bell came out.

He did not say anything like "Mind you do not tell them the reason?" — No.

By the Jury: Is there any one at the top of the shaft to stop the men from riding down the shaft? — There is no occasion, they dare not go down till Wales rings of them by the bell at the bottom.

By the Coroner: I never had any rules given to me. I never saw a book like that [a copy of the rules] before. It is Bell's duty to fasten the lamps when the men come down.

William Martin, of Steer Cottages, near Maryport, said: I am an overman in Ellenborough pit. I found the bodies of the three dead men. We found Beckett about four o'clock on Monday morning, Wales a quarter past seven at night, and Bell on Wednesday, about two o'clock in the afternoon. They were all near the "robbery." Wales was found near the door which had been "bratticed" up; Beckett was found nearer the break, he had not gone so far. We found Wales, and Bell's lamps. We also found Beckett's lamp all blown to pieces. The top had no doubt been on, because it was locked. I think it fired where Beckett came in contact with the gas. Beckett should not have left the break by coming up there. I think he caused the explosion, because his lamp is blown to pieces, and the other men's lamps are good. The door near which Wales and Bell were found was blown away, and their bodies were through on the other side of it. Witness described the distribution of the air in the pit. He said the ventilation of the part of the pit where Wales and Bell were, depended upon the door which Wales and last witness had bratticed up. The effect would be to render the air more inflammable and drive it in Beckett's face as he was approaching.

Last witness Rogerson re-called, said he and Wales had not fastened the door so that it could not be opened. They only made good the crevices.

The lamps of Wales and Bell were produced. The inspector pronounced Wales's to be right with the exception of the screw, which was very imperfect. Beckett's was broken in pieces; but what remained showed it had been locked.

Examination of Martin continued: Beckett's lamp had not been examined that morning. Bell should have examined it at the break, but he was in the new coal working. I know the rules of the pit [rules produced]. There is no rule providing for what is to be done on men going into the pit in the morning.

Mr. Steel, overman: The night shift men were to knock for the men, but these three miners were allowed to go in to the overman on account of having "partners" to follow in the middle of the day.

Examination of Martin resumed: It was Leonard Bell's duty to examine the lamps.

The Coroner said it would have been much better if Bell had not gone into the working.

Mr. Steel said, in reply to the Coroner, that the air course of the pit would be a good mile long before reaching the part where the explosion took place.

Witness, Martin, continued: The pit is a good ventilated pit. She is making gas but not dangerous to work in. I have been in other pits. She makes the most gas of any pit I was ever in, in my life. Therefore it is necessary to work with great care. I consider the present ventilation of the pit after travelling that distance is sufficient to ventilate those workings. We put that door (before referred to), to drive the air into those workings, and if it was not there, the air would not go into the workings. The workings would be examined after the men left on Saturday night by John Bell. He should be able to tell whether that door was then open or not.

In reply to the Coroner, the Inspector said that the sufficiency of the door appeared to be an important point in the inquiry as the gas would accumulate on Sunday. But then again how would it fire Beckett's lamp if the lamp was perfect.

The Coroner: So far as we have gone on, that door is the primary cause. If that door had been right, and if Beckett's lamp was sufficient there would have been no explosion.

Witness continued: If they were certain no one would come in, it was proper to brattice up the door. The pit has not been more fiery lately than formerly. I have not had complaints from the workmen, and have never heard of any complaints. The door in question opened with the air.

By the Jury: If Beckett had not left the break, in my opinion the explosion would not have taken place. It is not usual for men to go in that way without having their lamps examined.

The Inspector said that when there was a fault with the colliery before, he had suggested that they should have a lamp cabin. He did not know why that suggestion had not been carried out.

The Coroner remarked that in having three or four men to examine the lamps they ran double or treble the risk.

The Inspector: I think so too. It is usual in most collieries to have lamp cabins.

Examination of witness continued: There was a certain portion of the door left off to allow air to pass through in case of a fall. The engine man on the top of the shaft will not let the men down before Wales rings; but there were a few men privileged to follow the overman on the understanding that Leonard Bell was to examine their places and lamps before they went to work. Beckett, Mossop, and Oliphant were allowed to go down before the signal was given that all was right. They had not to pass the lamp station without examination. There are four different quarters of the pit. It takes the men two hours to examine them before the men go down. There were only five men who had the privilege of going down before the signal was given to the engineman.

Rogerson, recalled, said his wages were 15s., a week, and he was engaged 8 hours a day.

Martin, re-examined, said that the current was 14,000 cubic feet per minute in the new working.

John Bell, brother of the deceased Leonard Bell, said: I knew the 10 quarters band (the workings in the new coal pit). I knew the "robbery." There was a door not far from it. I was there on Saturday night about six o'clock, after the men had left the pit. I am a deputy. It is my duty to examine every night after the men have left. Word came for the men to "knock off" work about half past five. I would be nearly an hour in examining the pit. I stayed in all night; we had to repair a siding. I examined the "robbery." There was three or four working in it at a time, early on. When I was in the "robbery" in the evening it was very decent. There was no gas that I saw when I went in. I was in the workings and tried them. I did not make any particular examination. The men were all gone out. I had a lamp with me. I came right down the "return." I went through the door after I had been in the "robbery." At first when I came it was partly open. I close it; it was my duty to do so. It ought to have been shut. I could have got through it without touching it. The door should be shut so that the wind will shut it. No one had any business there after I shut that door at six o'clock on Saturday night. The only man who had to go through that door to his work was Scott. The door was just put there to turn the current of air. It was an improper door. I have mentioned it several times to my brother. It was a nice door at first; but it had got out of order.

The Coroner: The more safe the ventilation was for the other part of the pit, the more dangerous it was for this part of the workings.

Examination resumed: I was in the pit on Monday. I think the explosion must have taken place from Beckett's lamp. It would have required a great body of air sweeping down to blow the flames through the gauze. It was a few days before I told my brother about the door. He said he would see about it. The door would have done if it had been kept shut.

By the Jury: I did not observe anything of a fall in the new "robbery" on Saturday night, but it was falling constantly.

By the Inspector: I cannot say where the gas came from that fired. I have not taken notice of anything bad in that "robbery." The pit has been very bad these last few weeks.

The Inspector: The state of the barometer has been very low, which would affect the gas.

By the Jury: She was making more gas generally throughout the seam for the last few weeks. The other deputies knew it as well as myself. I reported to my brother and Walter Little. I did not observe any "brattice" thrown down on Saturday night. There was no latch on the door. There was dirt, I think, at the bottom. We have about thirty trap door keepers in the pit. There is not a trapper for every door. I think there will be one for every three doors. I never saw a boy at this door.

By the Coroner: I have not had complaints from the men lately that the pit was getting bad.

By the Jury: Witness corroborated the evidence of the last witness as to the men privileged to go in before the signal. He continued, they have used gunpowder in the solid part of the pit, but not in the "robbery."

The Coroner: But no one had been in that morning.

Mr. Steel, in answer to the Inspector, said that there was a barometer in the pit, but it had not been working right since it came from Newcastle, a fortnight ago.

William Holmes, better known as Scott, said: I am a coal-hagger, and have worked in Ellenborough pit nearly 18 months. I have been a collier all my life. I left the working about five o'clock. I had to come through the door when I left. I came out with a lad named Hills. It was shut when I came to it, and I shut it to me. It would not stand open unless propped open. This is a good aired pit, so far as I have worked in it. I have never seen any gas while I have worked there. There have been a good many falls in it. We were following on. It is not a custom in this country. We got leave to go down after Leonard Bell. One of us went in about one o'clock in the morning and the other came about ten. I cannot tell where this happened.

By the Jury: I have worked before, where gas was, in other pits. I have never discovered any "blowers" in this pit. As I come out to come away the door opens from me. It did not seem out of repair.

By the Coroner: I cannot tell where the gas came from.

By the Inspector: I and my "marrow" are the only men working through the door.

Joseph Mossop, coal hagger, said: I was in Ellenborough pit on Monday morning. I went down into the pit with Leonard Bell. I was one of the privileged men. He left us and we went for our picks. Wales afterwards called out "We are going in the low end and you can follow in." I did so after waiting a few minutes. Rogerson told me none of us were to go in till they came back. They did come back, and shouted "Are you there, Mossop?" and said they were going in the low end and I was to follow in. I went on and felt the explosion. After Rogerson told me I was not to go in till I had further orders, I swear that they said I was to follow in. That is the truth. I never told any different story. I waited for their orders. I have worked in the pit about eight years; it was safe enough for anything that I ever saw. I told Rogerson that the furnace man was badly, as Hugh Brown had told me, and he said I was to wait till they came back, and I did wait.

John Oliphant, coal hagger, the man who was carried out of the pit stunned by the explosion, said: I went down into the pit about ten o'clock with Leonard Bell and Mossop. Rogerson stopped me before I got to the break. I went to the break top and saw Beckett. He asked what Rogerson had said to me. I said he had told me we were not to go. He said he would go. I said I thought we had better not. He had a lamp with him. He locked it at the break top. I cannot say whether his lamp was good or not. He went before me. We both of us disobeyed orders. He went right up and I went on the level. I had gone about 200 yards when I felt the effects of the explosion. If Beckett's lamp had been in good order I think the force of the air would blow the flame through the lamp. Even with a locked lamp it was not safe for Beckett to go. Neither of us knew there was any foulness. They should have told us that. If we had been told we would have remained behind. They were all gone but myself, and I thought I might as well go and all.

A Juror: You would be quite sure that there was something wrong? — I never gave it a thought.

Did you often pass in without your lamps being examined? — Not still. In a certain time in the morning.

By the Inspector: If our lamps go out we come back to the break and get a key.

Joseph Thompson, furnaceman, said he had been taken ill with cramp in the stomach on Monday morning. Rogerson came to assist. The furnaces were quite full of fire and had been all Sunday. The air was travelling as quickly as ever since he went to the place. He had been there six weeks.

By the Jury: We have a couple of wheels to indicate the travelling of the air.

The Jury were trying to get further evidence about the foulness of the pit, when the Coroner said they had the evidence of John Bell that the pit was in a bad state and worse than usual for the last two or three weeks; and what was the use of asking whether there had been any complaints to overmen when they had it proved by overmen themselves?

Hugh Brown, pitman, said, I have wrought in the pit about 18 months as coal hagger and repairer of roads. I have worked in many pits, and she was as good an aired pit as ever I have wrought in. I durst have worked in her with an open lamp, in the new coal, when I worked in it the seven weeks. I did not try to do so. I would rather work with an open lamp if all is right, and it is allowed. It is my belief the explosion happened towards the new "robbery." I cannot say whether it had fired there. I think it must have fired on Beckett's lamp which was injured. I think it returned to Wales and Bell. Their lamps were right. As to how the gas accumulated, a fall at the end of the week might knock a stopping down.

By the Jury: I went in a little after ten o'clock on Sunday night.

By the Coroner: My lamp has not generally been examined for the last six months. I have generally been working on the "rolly ways," and I there used an open lamp.

William Burns, collier, said: I had been working in the new robbery on Saturday. I have worked about two years and a half in the pit. I have worked six months in the new "robbery." I never saw any dirt in it of any consequence, or anything to make us fearful. We worked with safety lamps. I know the door. It was right as far as I could see at it. Eleven of us worked there. I have worked there since Monday. The door was there to ventilate the "robbery." I don't think it would hang open without it was propped.

By the Jury: Leonard Bell examined our lamps. When I went down I waited for him if he was not there. I never went down before the signal unless I got liberty from the overmen to go down with them.

The Coroner having asked if any of the pitmen wished to make any statements about the pit or ask any questions, no one came forward.

Charles Richard Steel, the overman and principal manager of this pit, said: Before the explosion I was in the "robbery" a fortnight ago. They have been working there six months. I have been there thrice. I enquire every night how the pit is, and if the overman gives me the idea of anything being wrong I go down, if all is right I do not go. I have heard the evidence about a check-door. It is proper for the air in that "robbery." I think it is sufficient to ventilate it. I cannot tell what made them "brattice" that door on Monday morning. I think it was not a proper thing to "brattice" the door. If the "robbery" was so foul, and the air was pinched from a fall, they were decreasing the quantity of air. I think it exploded at Beckett's lamp.

Inspector: The whole return must have been foul, then.

Witness: He was in a direct line where he would come in contact with the gas. [Witness described the currents on the plan of the pit] The door was hung so that it had a good fall to.

The Coroner: Do you think that door was a proper and sufficient door for the purpose? — I do.

Inspector: Would it not have been well to have had a trapper there? It was a very important door. — There was just one man working there, and the pony driver kept it himself.

By the Jury: I have never heard any complaint of the insufficiency of the door. The Inspector was there 18 months ago.

Did he then suggest having a place for hanging the lamps? — It was spoken about, but that was before then.

That has never been carried out? — The stations were made according to the customs of the country.

The Coroner: Has not the Inspector power to set aside the customs of the country?

Witness: It was only a suggestion of the Inspector.

By the Jury: If Beckett's lamp had been sufficient I don't think it would have happened. It depends what use he would make of it when he met the gas?

A collier who was in the room said: He would throw it away. He did so with me once.

Witness: Between Beckett and where the other two men were must have been one mass of foul air. I don't think it would have gone through his lamp unless he had thrown his lamp down. If he had thrown it down there might be damage done to the lamp. (Pointing to the gauze of Beckett's lamp) — There is a hole in the gauze, but whether it had been done before or since I cannot tell. It is like a damaged part. At first I thought it had been done with a pick, but now I don't think so.

The Coroner suggested that if Beckett's lamp had been injured by being thrown down on the ground it would not have been so likely to do damage in that position, as the gas ascended, unless the whole air-course was filled from top to bottom with gas.

The Inspector: I am confident no speed of the current would drive the gas through the gauze.

By the Jury: The overman has to be down to start the pit at six o'clock, but the deputy overmen are obliged to go down at two o'clock. Nothing has been done since the accident in the way of further precautions.

By the Coroner: There are 230 persons altogether in the pit, out of which there are only five privileged persons who can go down without the signal.

The Coroner: It is five too many, Mr. Steel. These privileges are very dangerous. You don't know where they may end.

By the Jury: It is usual to use gunpowder in the pit, but they have orders not to fire where there is any explosive gas.

The Coroner: You have heard the evidence that the gas was worse than usual for a fortnight or three weeks before the accident? — Yes.

Was there any report made to you? — No, I knew there was a little more gas being made, but there was none in the return air.

A Juror: You knew there was a little more gas being made? — No.

I thought you said so? — I said there was none in the return air if there was any more being made.

Is it not usual to have a barometer? — I have never had one in the 20 years I have had the management of collieries.

The Inspector: It is generally recommended.

The Coroner: It is a good precautionary measure.

Mr. Adair: I hope the suggestions of Mr. Dunne will be attended to.

The Coroner: There are 230 people working in the pit. They might all be examined but one, and if he went unexamined he might do all the mischief. Do any of you men know of any one who has been working in the pit and has left it for fear of danger?

None of the pitmen present replied.

Inspector Carruthers said that he had heard of none.

Mr. Adair said he had not seen many colliers, but two of those he had seen were of that opinion.

Mr. Dunne, Her Majesty's Government Inspector of Coal Mines in the Northern District, was next sworn and examined. He said: I have been down the pit. I have long been intimate with it, ever since the beginning of these workings, and there is no doubt that at first it was one of the most fiery pits I know. There has been another shaft put in since I first knew it, which has mended the whole subject. It is now greatly extended, and much depends on the doors. The pit requires great care and attention. I have not seen the "robbery"; the quantity of air that was flowing was my great object. It was not measured. It would be about adequate to keep the colliery right with proper care and attention. The larger it gets the more dangerous it becomes. I have heard the evidence this morning, and I am of opinion the explosion originated upon Beckett's lamp; that the gas originated in the "robbery," and that it might have fired upon one of those two lamps or upon Beckett's. I think from Beckett being so far from where the foulness came from there would have been no harm done if his lamp had been perfect. That door seems to have been very necessary, so long as it was properly kept, to air this place. I should say, from the evidence of the overman, that it was not properly constructed; and was hung against the right principle. The ventilation of the robbery depended upon the adequacy of that door; and if there was foulness it depended on that door I should think. I have heard what was said about allowing these privileged people to go down. I think they ought to go down at certain times and seasons, and with the approbation of the persons who have the management of the pit. There is a law against them going down before the signal is given; it is one of the special rules of the Act of Parliament.

The Foreman: Then this is an infringement of the Act.

The Inspector continued: It is a standing rule that these places must be examined by competent persons before the men go in. I cannot help repeating my suggestion for a general lamp cabin, with a proper person to take the management of the lamps. They would thus be better cleaned and everything, than being in so many different hands. The general custom seems to be that the bottom of the lamp should be kept in the cabin and the barrel taken home by the men to clean it. The man in charge of the cabin examines them all.

By the Jury: There was surer to be an increase of gas during the past few weeks from the state of the barometer. This was at one time one of the most dangerous pits I knew, and I wrote specially to Captain Harris about it, and urged certain recommendations, which were carried into effect. I have known the gas come roaring out in some parts.

Mr. Adair enquired whether the making of another shaft would not be very advantageous.

The Inspector replied: So long as the air courses are kept right it does not signify. The great thing is the proper distribution of the air when it is got into the pit. I would recommend the barometer to be adopted, and I think there should be trappers at all the doors.

The Coroner: As Mr. Dunne tells us there is only enough air to ventilate the pit and no more, a very small affair might set the whole thing off and therefore great care is required.

Mr. Adair asked the Inspector what course he would recommend to be adopted if the pit became much worse.

The Inspector: It is a great thing to keep the "brattice" well up towards the face. In some collieries it is a rule not allowed to be less than a certain distance from the coal. In the workings where the pillars are you cannot have "brattice" but you have doors. In my opinion that door has had a great deal to do with it, if the evidence is to be taken for granted.

The Coroner: Mr. Steel said it was an improper proceeding to brattice that door. Was it so?

The Inspector: If no one had been there, where Beckett was, it would have been very well.

The Coroner: And if he had done right no one would have been there.

The Inspector: I think the head overman should be in the pit before five o'clock. The furnaces are very well. That is the best means to adopt in such pits as this. If the furnaces were let down it would slacken the current. I think there must have been some production of gas either by ordinary or extraordinary causes. As to the lamp that the man was possessed of, if it had been a perfect lamp the gas would not have gone through it, and it would not have happened anything. I would not say whether it was caused by that lamp or any other lamp.

Mr. Steel said that when he came here there was only one furnace, now there were two, which increased the ventilation twofold.

The question now arose whether the jury deemed the evidence they had heard sufficient.

A Juror said it was the opinion of the jury that they should have more evidence from men working in this part of the pit, as some of the evidence they had had was contradictory, both as to the door and as to the state of the gas in the pit.

The Coroner said if no more evidence could be got they would have very little doubt whether they would take the evidence of the man who had the thing in charge and who was speaking against his own interest. If that man was speaking the truth the pit must have been in a very bad state.

Mr. Adair: I think it is desirable to have an adjournment that we may express our individual opinions.

Mr. Johnston requested the Coroner to recall John Bell, whose evidence he thought must have been given under some mistake.

The Coroner said that he thought it would be a bad precedent to recall him, when he had heard what had been said, and that what he had said was likely to give dissatisfaction to his employers. The Coroner then desired the jury to consider whether or not they would adjourn the enquiry further. He would be sorry that any one gentleman of the jury should go home dissatisfied.

Mr. Johnston said he wished it to be understood that he was not dissatisfied with Bell's evidence, but he thought it conveyed what he did not mean.

The Coroner: The jury have heard it, Mr. Johnston.

The Jury were left by themselves for a few minutes to consider whether or not they would adjourn.

Upon the admission of the public, the Foreman said that they wished to know if Little could attend.

Police Inspector Carruthers said he had gone away, unwell, for a few days, but he thought he would be able to attend.

The Foreman said it seemed a complaint about the defective door seemed to have been made to Little.

John Bell was recalled, and said in answer to the Coroner that he was very nearly sure that Little was present when he spoke to his brother about the door. He added that as a deputy he was of the opinion that the "robbery" depended upon that door.

The majority of the Jury were in favour of an adjournment for the production of Little, and to have any further evidence that could be obtained.

The inquest was then adjourned till Monday, the jury having sat for six hours.

Conclusion of the Inquest

The inquest was resumed on Monday afternoon shortly after three o'clock. Mr. Tyson, solicitor, watched the proceedings on behalf of the owners of the pit.

After a great deal of further evidence had been heard, the Coroner addressed the jury and concluded by saying that the only question they had to consider was how, when, and by what means the men came by their death.

The jury retired at a quarter past six, and, after a consultation of about an hour, returned a verdict that "The three men were killed, at Ellenborough pit by an explosion, but how that explosion originated does not appear."

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Adair, —      
Adair, Robert    Juror  
Armstrong, Joseph    Juror  
Beckett, Joseph      Deceased, Individual Page
Bell, John      
Bell, Leonard      Deceased, Individual Page
Benson, John    Juror  
Boyd, Thomas    Juror  
Brown, Hugh    Pitman  
Burns, William    Collier  
Carruthers, —, Inspector      
Cockton, Thomas    Juror  
Dobie, Jonah    Juror  
Dunn, Matthias    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Fawcett, Joseph L.    Juror  
Fletcher, Joseph    Juror  
Gregans, George    Juror  
Harris, —, Capt.      
Holmes, William    Coal Hagger  
Johnston, —      
Little, Walter      
Lumb, William    Coroner  
Martin, William    Overman  
Millican, James    Juror  
Mossop, Joseph    Coal Hagger  
Oliphant, John    Coal Hagger  
Rogerson, Thomas    Shiftsman  
Steel, Charles Richard    Overman  
Temple, Joseph    Juror  
Thompson, Joseph    Furnaceman  
Tinnion, W.    Juror  
Twentyman, W. J.    Juror  
Wales, John      Deceased, Individual Page
Walker, Francis    Juror  
Walker, John    Juror  
Wilson, W.    Juror  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Ellenborough Colliery  Ellenborough Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
05 Dec 1860  Colliery Explosion in Cumberland (The Times)
06 Dec 1860  Fatal Colliery Explosion at Maryport (Ulverston Advertiser)
06 Dec 1860  Fearful Colliery Explosion at Maryport (Whitehaven News)
10 Dec 1860  The Colliery Explosion in Cumberland (The Times)
12 Dec 1860  The Colliery Explosion in Cumberland (The Times)
13 Dec 1860  Adjourned Inquest (Whitehaven News)
15 Dec 1860  The Recent Colliery Explosion in Cumberland (The Times)
20 Dec 1860  The Maryport Colliery Explosion (Ulverston Advertiser)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Guslet Pit, Maryport
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print