26th May 1860, Page: 3, Column: 1
The Miners' Provident Institution
The adjourned meeting of the miners was held on
Saturday last, at Potts' Temperance Hotel, Newgate
street, Mr. R. Fines, of West Cramlington, in the chair.
The meeting had been adjourned from Seaton Delaval
to allow time for the delegates to communicate with
and obtain the opinion of their several constituencies
upon the fundamental basic of the proposed association,
as submitted to the former meeting by Mr. J. B. Langley.
The Chairman said that the great majority of men
of this district were now of opinion that it would be a
good scheme. There were about twenty persons who
were willing to put their names down to help the institution
forward, and he thought if they could get half that
number from every colliery, they could speedily
accomplish their object.
Mr. Watson, of Blue Quarries, said he had laid the
case before the men with whom he was connected who,
since the masters had refused to give their countenance
to the matter, had requested him to act as their representative.
They were at present engaged in watching
the progress of the Mines Inspection Bill ; and they would
like to have the miners' meetings all classed in one — two
societies to meet together, leaving it at the same time
optional to every colliery to pay to either the bill or the
Provident Institution, whichever it had a mind. They
had already paid a good deal of money towards that act ;
and as soon as it was passed they were quite willing to
go forward in the support of the Provident Institution.
In fact, the men at present paid so much a fortnight
to a fund on a similar principle ; and if the association
were established, that fund would be ready for those men
to fall back upon.
Mr. Messer (secretary) did not see how they could
class the two societies together. They were two different
societies ; and although he was willing that they
should both meet on oen day, he thought they should be
kept separate and distinct from each other.
Mr. Watson said that was exactly his opinion, and
the wish of the men whom he represented. He therefore,
moved :— "That for the convenience of the miners
it is considered desirable that the meetings of the men
who are engaged in promoting the Miners' Provident
Association, be arranged as far as possible on the same
days as those of the miners promoting the Mines
Inspection Bill. At the same time it is considered
desirable that the two movements be kept distinct, leaving the
pitmen to join either or both, being separate and
independent of each other in all respects."
Mr. Messer seconded the resolution, which was
carried unanimously.
Mr. J. B. Langley said that the Miners' Provident
Association, from which the masters had now withdrawn,
was vested wholly in the management of themselves ;
and that day they had simply to settle what way the
guarantee fund proposed to be established could best be
raised ; secondly, what rates should be adopted as to
the payment of those joining the society, and what benefit
they would receive in consideration of those payments.
The guarantee fund must depend on voluntary contributions ;
and he believed a very small occasional contribution
from the miners to that fund would raise as large
as amount as would do for the present necessity. In
addition to that, be believed subscriptions could be raised ;
and if the society were explained to the public, he had
very little doubt they should be able to receive a
considerable sum from persons interested generally in the
welfare of the working classes. With regard to the tables
of rates, the elements upon which the calculations must
be based differed from those of ordinary life assurance
companies, in which the risk increased from those of
a fire insurance company ; and at the end of each year
the society might strike a balance and begin anew for
next year. The tables of deaths in the northern
counties showed that for some years past the mortality
was below the average ; and upon the supposition
originally, that the Miners' Provident Association would
be confined to those counties, he based his calculations
on those tables. Now, however, it was proposed that
the society should at some future say extend its operations
to the whole kingdom ; and it was, therefore,
desirable to have the tables as recorded in the whole of
Great Britain. It was shown by the tables of the
Inspectors, by those of Mr. Phillip Holland, and his own.
that about one in every 220 were killed every year, or,
in other words, that there were 1,000 colliers killed
by accident every year. On this the calculations for
death insurance would be based. If 220 persons paid
a levy of one penny weekly, there would be for the
representatives of the deceased who would be killed in
each year, £47 13s 4d., putting out of the question any
expense that might attach to the society. Assuming
that the youngest ages were excluded, the deaths would
be about 1 in 240, which would give, at 1d. per week,
£52 for each death, for all ages over 18. For disablement
insurance, the calculations were based on the
information derived from two of the largest Friendly
Societies, some of the lodges of the Odd Fellows'
Society, and two Accidental Death Insurance
Companies, and such information as could be obtained from
coroners' inquests, &c. From these the information was
not so extensive as could be wished ; but they showed
a maximum of maimed and killed as 1 to 10, or 1 to 12.
To be on the safe side, it had been assumed that for 8
persons killed 1 was permanently disabled ; and it therefore
followed that, if 1 in 240 were killed, there were 1
in 240 multiplied by 8, permanently disabled, which
was equal to 1 in 1,920 to be provided for. 1,920 paying
a weekly contribution of 1d would give to each disabled
person £446, to be invested for the purchase of
an annuity. To prevent the tables from being complicated,
they would stand thus:— Youths from 15 to
18 inclusive, by a payment of one farthing a-week,
would received £10 at death, if that death occurred by
accident ; adults, from 19 to 50, would, by a payment
(including one farthing for expenses) of 3d. per week,
receive £100 for the widow, or widow and representatives ;
and in case of being permanently maimed, the
sum of £300 to be invested as a permanent annuity.
Those were the rates which he thought were the only
ones that could be adopted practically in connection with
the Miners' Provident Association ; but as some persons
had wished to know the rates for old age he had
prepared the calculations to secure 3a. a-week at 70 years
of age. He took this as an extreme age, and any younger
age that was wanted would require a still larger rate of
payment. At the age of 15, to provide 5s. a-week for life
after 70, would require a payment of 2½d per week ;
at 20, 3½d ; at 30, 5½d ; at 40, 9½d ; at 45, 1s 1d ; and at
50 years of ago, it would require 1s 7d. They might,
if they liked, include an old age allowance ; but he
suggested that, for the present, they should give their
attention to that which was not done by other societies.
Mr. Messer moved — "That steps be taken at once to
raise funds to pay for the present expenses of the
society, and that the men in each colliery be requested
to co-operate by subscriptions to pay for the immediate
enrolment of the society upon the basis proposed by Mr.
Langley, and approved by this meeting."
Mr. W. Nichol seconded the motion, which was
unanimously adopted.
Some conversation subsequently took place as to the
next meeting, which it was resolved should beheld in
the open air (on Newcastle Town Moor) that day five
weeks, and with a vote of thanks to the chairman,
the proceedings terminated.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Fines, R. | | Miners' Delegate | |
| Holland, Phillip | | | |
| Langley, J. B. | | Miners' Delegate | |
| Messer, — | | Miners' Delegate | |
| Nichol, W. | | Miners' Delegate | |
| Watson, — | | Miners' Delegate | |