|
26th May 1860, Page: 3, Column: 1 The Burradon Colliery ExplosionThe Mining Journal publishes the following opinion of counsel as to the legal responsibility of the owner and viewer of Burradon Colliery with reference to the late explosion :— "Upon the facts stated in the case laid before us, and also upon those which have been mentioned to us in conference, we are of opinion that Mr. Bower, the owner of the Burradon Colliery, is liable to actions at the suit of the widows and orphans of those who perished by the explosions which occurred in March, last. "Whatever may have been the immediate cause of the explosions, whether it was the fall in the roof in the north return, or from a regulating door having been left open, or from a state of the atmosphere, of which meteorological instruments would give previous warning, or from any combination of these causes, it appears upon the facts stated to us that the mine shortly before the explosion was in so dangerous a condition, arising from defective construction, and from a bad system of ventilation, as to render it highly probable that any disturbance or obstruction, however trifling in itself, would produce the calamity which actually occurred. "It appears also that the dangers to which the miners in this case were exposed, and which resulted in such lamentable consequences, might have been avoided by the exercise of ordinary care, and by the adoption of those safeguards which have been suggested by modern science and by dearly-bought experience. Thus the airways appear to haven been too small to conduct full and free currents of air through the mine ; the main current was split and subdivided, so as unduly to diminish its force and divert its most useful direction ; the broken coal was so worked that the dangerous and accumulated gases escaped from the goaf into that part of the mine where the second explosion took place ; naked lights appear to have been used in that part of the mine where the first explosion took place, instead of the Davy or safety lamp, and this either by the direction or with the knowledge and approval of the mine owner and his agents ; there was no person whose sole duty it was to attend to important doors in the mine, essential to its due ventilation ; the stoppings against the escape of air are said to have been defective, and not to have been sufficiently tight ; whereby the main current of air was materially reduced. "It is also stated that many of these serious defects had been previously brought to the notice of the mine owner and his viewer ; that they had promised the Government Inspector of Mines to enlarge the airways, and he had suggested that an a additional shaft should be sunk, for the purpose of improving the ventilation, which promise and suggestions were not carried out ; that several of the men had complained of the foul state of the air near the part of the mine where the first explosion happened, and one or more of them had left the mine and refused to work in it, assigning this as the reason of their desire to leave ; and that, after the accident, two regulating doors were placed in one part of the mine, instead of the one door which had formerly been there. "Assuming that these facts are capable of proof, we consider that the mine owner has been guilty of negligence, and that he is answerable for the results of that negligence to those who have sufferer by it. "The ground of our opinion is, that a person who for his own profit employs others in a perilous occupation is bound to provide against those probable contingencies, so far as he can provide against them, by which the employed may suffer. "It may be said, and with truth, that some of the negligence complained of in this case was the negligence of the viewer, and not of the mine owner ; and reliance may be placed upon the rule of the law, now well established, that when workmen are engaged in a common work, and an injury happens to one of them through the negligence of another engaged in the same work, the master is not responsible, unless he has been negligent in the selection of the servant by whom the injury was caused. We doubt whether a viewer, considering his position and the duties which he is appointed to perform, and especially whether Mr. Carr, the viewer of the colliery, can be said to be engaged in a "common work" with the workmen in a mine ; but, however this may be, we think that in the present instance the main and substantial causes of the injury complained of were a defective system of ventilation of the mine for which the mine owner himself is responsible. "We, therefore advise than an action should be commenced against Mr. Bower, under 9 and 10 Vic. c.93, by the widow of one of the deceased workmen. It will be necessary for her to take out letters of administration for this purpose. Temple, May 15. "Henry MacNamara, "John Connon."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||