19th May 1860, Page: 5, Column: 4
The "Tommy" System
The system of paying
men in goods in lieu of money, has received its
death blow. The practice was attended with serious
drawbacks to the men who were made its victims. It
is, moreover, illegal, as Messrs. Snowdon and Hopkins,
iron-masters, in the Cleveland district, have found to
their loss. These gentlemen were sued in the Stockton
County Court, on Tuesday, by John Jones, one of their
late workmen, for whom Mr. Roberts of Manchester
appeared. The result was a verdict for the plaintiff for
£25. In the next case a workman named Goven recovered
£50 of the same parties — the amount due was
£80, but it had been reduced to £50 to bring it within
the jurisdiction of the court. Then there was a cross-action
brought by Messrs. Snowdon and Hopkins, to recover
of Jones and Goven the amount they had received
in "tommy tickets." Jones' "tommy" had varied
from 16s. to 30s. per fortnight; and Goven's was £1 per
fortnight, the latter extending over a period of five
years. The Judge (Mr. Blaine) remarked upon this
cross-action that there was not the slightest ground
whereon to rest it. It was a flimsy and futile attempt
to intimidate the men against brining these actions,
and it must utterly fail. A payment made in contradiction
of a statute was no payment whatever. Where any
portion of wages was paid in goods, as in this case, it
was really no payment at all. The actions were struck
out, the plaintiffs preferring this to be nonsuited, as a
saving of expense. This is hard law for the masters,
since these men have now got both goods and money,
but it will put an end to a practice in which the men
were not only liable to come in for short weight, but
had to "put up" with inferior articles of an edible
nature.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Blaine, — | | Judge | |
| Goven, — | | Iron Worker | |
| Hopkins, — | | Iron Master | |
| Jones, John | | Iron Worker | |
| Roberts, — | | Advocate | |
| Snowdon, — | | Iron Master | |