|
12th May 1860, Page: 5, Column: 2 Weekly RetrospectRailway Monopoly RebukedThe North-Eastern Company has received a series of warnings — three, we believe, is the exact and ominous number — which can hardly fail to operate to its advantage. That railway Colossus, as our readers are aware, has strode out its huge legs pretty widely under both its old and new regimes, and seemed on the point of bringing under its gabardine almost every smaller undertaking in this part of the country when reverses have overtaken it which will undoubtedly very considerably impair its power and mar its prestige. The Carlisle amalgamation scheme is the avenging Nemesis, whose stroke will be surely and sharply felt. In plain words, the proposal to bring the line which connects Newcastle with the west into the embrace of the North-Eastern has been foiled both in the law and legislative courts. On Monday one of the Courts of Chancery decided that the compact some time ago made between the North-Eastern and the Newcastle and Carlisle Companies, which effectually shuts up the Liverpool traffic to one route, was pronounced illegal ; on the following day the same Court held that the North-Eastern had no right to act as an amalgamated company till it obtained legislative authority to that effect ; and on Wednesday, its bill for obtaining such authority was thrown out of Parliament by the decision of a Committee of the House of Commons. Of course the last is the most important, because, as we apprehend, an irrevocable decision. The sittings of the committee were protracted, and its patience and impartiality exemplary. Nearly a fortnight has passed since Mr. Denison, Q.C., opened the case on the part of the promoters, and the evidence of their witnesses, chief among whom were the familiar names of Captain O'Brien, Mr. T. E. Harrison, and Mr. Christian Allhusen, extended over several days. It was not until Monday last that the opposition promoted by the Border Counties Railway Company opened their artillery, and it very speedily did execution. Mr. Irvine, a director of the Silloth Bay Company, Mr. Jonathan D. Carr, biscuit manufacturer at Carlisle, a partner in the eminent firm of P. Dixon and Co., of that city, Mr. Alex. Wood, of Turubull and Wood, of this town, Mr. Walter Wilson, of Hawick, Mr. John Hills, of Sunderland, and the engineers, Messrs. Bouch and Blythe, were all the witnesses, we understand, who underwent examination. Mr. E. S. Hills, who holds several agencies for influential London and Liverpool houses, was called, but it was not deemed necessary to adduce additional evidence. Other witnesses were ready on Wednesday, morning, but on the committee then re-assembling they conferred together, and on strangers being admitted, the chairman (Mr. Adair) said (addressing counsel and agents), "the committee request me to inform you that they have decided to hear no more evidence in this case, as they are satisfied the preamble of the bill has not been proved." Of course this is considered a triumph by what is called, in railway phraseology, "western interests." With these, however, we have no concern. The ground on which the measure was opposed is, that it would be dangerous to invest a single railway company with the whole trade of a district and give it exclusive access to all, or nearly all, the ports on any particular coast. And it is impossible for any commercial community or Parliamentary committee, not to feel and recognise the force and weight of such an objection. Instances were adduced too, showing the injurious effect which the existing arrangement, proposed to be legalised, has already had on the business connections of Newcastle and neighbouring towns with the great emporium of Liverpool. We believe it will ultimately prove best for all parties that the two undertakings in this controversy and contention should be kept separate and distinct. The public ought to have the advantage arising from a healthy competition ; the Carlisle Company has, in its hands, a sound and useful line capable of much greater development ; and the North Eastern has already more than enough to exercise the industry and ability of its chiefs. At all events, we hope nothing further will be done, in the way of litigation, to disturb decisions which we are satisfied will give general satisfaction and be promotive of the general weal.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||