|
7th April 1860, Page: 5, Column: 1 Weekly RetrospectEpisodes In The Burradon InquiryThe rule generally adopted by the press of refraining from any remarks tending to exculpate or inculpate individuals whose acts or defaults form matter of judicial investigation is merely a mode and exemplification of the good old English principle of fair-play. One of our contemporaries at least, we observe, has flagrantly violated it in the case of the Burradon explosion, and cast his censures broadcast, without any regard to the justice or injustice of his observations, and of course utterly careless as to the pain which his assertions and insinuations may give to persons connected with the colliery whom he assumes to be implicated in the disaster. The cause of truth is not served by hasty conclusions and angry vituperation, albeit the production of editorial thunder may serve to attract people to the quarter from which it emanates. Being of a milder and we hope fairer spirit, we prefer waiting for the whole of the facts before we form and express a judgment, although we are afraid our patience will be sorely tried by the demands made upon it by the Coroner and his Court. The public, we know, are desirous that everything which transpires within the little chapel at Camperdown should be daguerrotyped (so to speak) in our columns, and we have sought to gratify this natural and laudable feeling. We are only sorry that so much time should have been spent and so much of our space wasted by professional sparrings and petty quarrels which are altogether out of place at a coroner's inquisition. In a Town Council or at a Select Vestry it is sometimes amusing to see local notables or would-be notables picking holes in each others' coats and trying to pick out each others eyes, but on an occasion when seventy-six poor fellows have been sent in the flower of youth or pride of manhood, to a premature grave, burnt by the scorching flames, or stifled by the choking after-damp, and when their desolate and desolated widows or other near relatives are looking, with anxious interest and concern, to proceedings which they fain hope will not only throw a gleam of lurid light on the tragedy of which they are the victims, but afford some protection for the future to those exposed to similar perils, it is indeed sad and sickening to read how gentlemen whose business it is to assist in this investigation disport themselves to each other. We only express the universal feeling when we say that decency is outraged and the sanctity of justice violated by such outbreaks of temper and outbursts of passion as we record elsewhere, and which, we hope, will operate rather as a warning than be regarded as a precedent. Joe Miller has a story of a company of Irish labourers who enjoyed themselves so thoroughly at the wake that they entirely forgot their duty to the body ; and we are afraid there is some danger, amid the wit and repartee, the snarls and sneers, the retorts courteous and uncourteous of the learned counsel engaged in the case, of their forgetting or overlooking the importance of the inquiry in which they are concerned, or at all events of their neglecting points which refer rather to the public than to party, rather to the protection and safety of those engaged in mining than to the affixing of blame upon deputies, overmen, or viewers. Plainly there are three "parties" represented at this board: the workmen, the colliery owner, and the Government Inspector ; each has his lawyer, and all the interrogatories are put, not simply to elicit the whole truth and nothing but the truth, but to create prejudices or remove injurious impressions, to impute recklessness and blame or to entirely free from stigma and censure. Thus Mr. Philipson, an astute tactician, who never yields or misses a point, is retained by Mr. Bower, and it is his business to prove that the colliery was in a perfectly safe and satisfactory condition at the very moment of this explosion, and that it was a misadventure against which no human foresight or skill could have provided. Then we have Mr. Blackwell looking out with a hawk's eye for faults and flaws, sins of omission and commission on the part of the management, and directing all his questions with a view to satisfy the jury that had Mr. Carr, the viewer in charge, been more assiduous in his attentions, more skilful in his management, and more liberal in his expenditure, the dreadful calamity which has thrown a whole village into mourning and cast a heavy pall over the mining interests of the country would never have occurred. We scarcely know the position which the Inspector of Mines holds in this controversy, but Mr. Matthias Dunn is also represented in this inquiry by our eloquent and dexterous townsman Mr. Lockey Harle, who of course looks to the interests of his client, which interest consists, we presume, in showing that Mr. Dunn is most vigilant and diligent in the discharge of his duties as a functionary entrusted by Government with the supervision of the collieries in the county of Northumberland. Mr. Harle was not present at the last sitting of the coroner and his jury ; and as Mr. Philipson then threw out a remark that Mr. Dunn employs his time in reading newspapers (no offence, we hope) and perambulating or, as a Sunderland shipowner used to pronounce the word, "padrambling" the streets of Newcastle, it was clearly needful that Mr. Harle should return to his post, and the little "scene" recorded in another place is probably the quid pro quo. Now on all these matters we reserve our opinion. The pit may have been clear or foul when it exploded — the men who indicated and intimated that the mine was unsafe previous to the accident may have been right or wrong in their surmises, clearly they were wrong in not communicating their opinions and fears to the viewer entrusted with the colliery or the officer appointed by Government especially for their protection — the Mining Inspector may have fully discharged his duty, or been guilty of laches in not visiting the workings of this pit since 1858 ; on these and collateral topics we reserve and indeed suspend our judgment. When the inquiry is closed and the jury have pronounced their verdict, our part in the adjudication will commence ; in the meantime we content ourselves with scanning the surface or touching the fringe of the several questions involved, most ardently trusting that the jury will fully and faithfully discharge their duty to their consciences and their country. There is, however, one point relative to the efficiency or otherwise of the inquiry in this class of cases which we submit deserves consideration. We value that cherished institution of England, trial by jury, and, as we stated in a recent number of the Guardian, we believe that coroners' juries have their uses and benefits, and, with some trifling alterations in their constitution and selection, might be rendered of still greater service to the common weal. We would not supersede their functions on any account, or under any pretence, however plausible ; but it occurs to us that a supplementary tribunal, in cases of this nature, might with advantage be appointed. A coroner's jury, taken indiscriminately from the nearest householders, and sitting in formal conclave at the nearest public house to the scene of fatality, may very properly examine and determine how and in what manner John Stokes or Thomas Smith, found dead, came to his death ; but when a colliery is fired, which involves not only the destruction of half-a-hundred lives, but which starts many questions, scientific in their nature but exceedingly practical and painful in their result, some other inquisition seems to us needed, in order that right conclusions may be drawn from properly authenticated facts and data. In a word, we submit that a Government commission would be the proper mode of collecting and testing evidence in such cases. We agree with Mr. Hugh Lee Pattinson that wherever blame exists in the management of a colliery, the owner should be held responsible, in pecuniary damages, for the consequences of his misconduct and mismanagement. But no court of judicature will affix civil responsibility on the random stories of witnesses taken down by a country attorney in his own words, and then signed by the deponent without (as is the practice of Mr. Stephen Reed) ever reading it over or having it read over to him before receiving his signature. The first point is to have the evidence taken by a competent lawyer and before a court composed of a due proportion of legal and scientific men ; the next to have that evidence secured by able short-hand writers, so that it may be, if necessary, satisfactorily proved ; and then an action might be brought, on such evidence, for defects or defaults in the management of collieries when those defects or defaults have led to the destruction of human life. A provision against factious or frivolous actions might be made by limiting the prosecutions to cases where such a commission had reported adversely to the management of the colliery. We venture to throw out these suggestions for thought and discussion ; clearly no such proceedings as many contemplate and desire can ever be taken on the rough notes of (in many instances) hearsay testimony made on a coroner's inquisition ; and hence we must have a supplementary tribunal, or an amended one, before we can expect to exact pecuniary compensation from persons guilty by themselves or their agents of acts or defaults leading to violent and premature death. Were such a tribunal formed, the coroner's jury might execute their proper functions without legal assistance ; and no court, constituted as we have suggested, would either indulge in or tolerate the personalities which unhappily form a leading feature in this Burradon inquiry. Dignity and decorum would be preserved, and a needful duty would be discharged with a fidelity and courtesy which would equally deserve and receive public consideration and respect.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||