|
7th April 1860 The Burradon Colliery ExplosionNewcastle-On-Tyne, April 5. The inquest on the bodies of the men killed at Burradon Colliery was resumed this morning in the village chapel. There was a large attendance of viewers and pitmen, Mr. Phillipson appeared for the owner of the colliery, Mr. W. L. Harle for the Government, and Mr. Blackwell, barrister, for the relatives of the deceased. Mr. Dunn and Mr. Atkinson, Government inspectors, were also present. Before the proceedings commenced the coroner gave the audience fair notice that, as long as they conducted themselves with propriety they should remain, but if there was any cheering or hissing, as on the day before, he would clear the court. Mr. Thomas E. Foster, viewer, was recalled, and further examined by Mr. Harle. — Mr. Foster said that all the doors were closed when they measured the pit, and 42,000 feet of air were taken. The air would not return by the shorter way. The air was two and a-half seconds in travelling 50 feet. Mr. Foster went into detail of measurements he had made in the pit. He said that there was some discrepancy between the ingoing air and the return air, which he accounted for by the fact that the stoppings and crossings had been so shattered by the explosion that the air leaked through them. It would be months before the pit was restored to the condition that it was in on the 2nd of March, before the explosion. In his opinion, supposing that the middle broken was troubled with gas, it would not cause the far bank broken to be foul, by reason of the regulator being there. He believed that the fall in the return behind Maddox's Board had occurred before the explosion, because the tail-end of it was covered with dust. He did not believe that it was caused by the second explosion. In answer to Mr. Blackwell, Mr. Foster said that there was a good ventilation in Haswell Colliery, though 36 persons were killed there some years ago. The accident at Haswell was caused by a safety lamp. The ventilation was as good as at Burradon. The explosion took place in the pillar working there, so they saw that there was the same danger as with candles. This explosion would cost Mr. Bower, the owner, a large sum of money. Splitting the air in the pit might be carried to excess. That was not so at Burradon. By the Coroner. — Had many collieries in his charge. Falls occur in every one of them. No human agency can prevent falls of stone. Mr. Kirkley, the overman, was recalled, and examined by Mr. Harle. He said that they had been troubled with "styth" in the far bank broken. The far bank broken was not unusually troubled with styth on the morning of the explosion. The regulator on the far back broken door was wide open. The deputy informed him that it was not more than ordinarily troubled with styth that day. Mr. James Mather, of South Shields, who, acting on behalf of the relatives of the deceased, had, in company of the Government inspectors and others, made several examinations of the pit since the explosion, was recalled by Mr. Blackwell, and produced a written report. The coroner in the most positive manner refused to receive the report, and another of those scenes which have repeatedly occurred took place. Mr. Harle and Mr. Blackwell urging that the report should be read, and the coroner and Mr. Phillipson opposing it. Ultimately Mr. Mather agreed to give visa voce testimony. Mr. Mather said that in 1832 there was a terrible explosion and loss of life in St. Helda's Colliery, South Shields. Fifty-two persons were killed by it. In consequence of his former University studies, he went down the pit to attend to the men below brought out alive ; and, arising out of the accident, a committee was formed in South Shields to investigate into the causes of explosions in collieries. He was one of the secretaries of that committee, and was occupied three years in investigating into the causes of accidents in mines. He was examined before a committee of the House of Lords, and he received the thanks of the committee for the evidence given on that occasion. He (Mr. Mather) was asked by the pitmen and relatives of the persons killed at Burradon to examine Burradon mine. He went down the pit. The first day he went down was the Thursday after the explosion. The pit was then foul. The second day he went down was the 22nd of March, the last the 2nd of April. On the 22nd of March he, accompanied by Mr. Dunn and Mr. Atkinson, the Government inspectors, and other gentlemen, examined the pit. The correct measurement of the air was considered the most important ; and Mr. Mather entered into a long detail of the measurements he and the other gentlemen made, and the experiments they tried with the air currents in various parts of the pit. He went down the upcast shaft. The reason why he went down the upcast shaft was to increase the temperature in it, as it is the main-spring of all the operations, and to settle a disputed point in ventilation. He found the temperature at 40 fathoms down 120 deg. ; at 70 fathoms down it was 135 deg., and finding it tolerably hot the man that accompanied him thought that it would go and he would go too, and he left him. There has been some misunderstanding among the viewers as to the powers of a furnace. Sometimes the more a furnace is driven a less proportion of air is produced, owing to the drag of the mine. In examining the pit and in passing up to a narrow board at the middle end, "Mother-gate," he and some other persons heard the gas distinctly passing from the backs or crevices of the coal. They also observed gas coming off at "a nicker." After a consultation the lamps were unlocked, the gauge unscrewed, and the naked light applied. They had an immediate explosion. The space that this explosion filled was 3 feet long and 9 inches wide, and about 3 inches deep. This experiment was more than once repeated. From each side of this "nicking," where the explosion took place, they had seven beautiful gaslights burning, and they continued to burn. They were "dadded" out with caps several times, and in the last experiment he calculated that in a quarter of a minute by a stop watch there were 972 cubic inches of explosive mixture evolved. He desired those in charge to take him down the north return, and they went to Maddox's board and passed it. He went there to see the edge of the north goaf. Four pillars down from Maddox's board, in the headways toward the goaf, eight or ten yards in, they found the gas standing like a wall. Upon application of the lamps the gas exploded twice in the lamps. Two pillars further they passed again towards the goaf. About 27 yards from the east incline their lamps were exploded out. By Mr. Harle. — He thought that there was too little air and too much gas in the pit. That was the cause of the explosion. He found from 50 to 60 acres of coal workings in the south-eastern district, and a goaf of 22 acres filled to the throat with gas, and a goaf of four acres in the same condition as the other. He found by other measurements that only 16,000 cubic feet of air per minute went into these workings. He found the air so slack in the east workings, and so little passing down the dangerous part of the mine in front of the 22-acre goaf, either to dilute the gas when it presented itself, or to sweep it away by its force. The weakness of the air down this return enabled the gas, by its own natural force, to creep up into the coal workings. They found gas so near those workings that on the fall of stone or of the barometer the gas would flow freely into the higher workings, and falling there would explode at the first naked light ; and so also the small quantity of air passing into the four-acre goaf would leave the natural force of the gas to present itself in the surrounding parts ; and, again, the stoppings which were said by some of the witnesses to be imperfect would allow the gas to spread into the waste and upper workings, making foul a large portion of that district between the first east incline and the middle. Hence, he would say, the cause of the two explosions. If the mine were in the same state as he had seen it, it might produce the same result at any hour now. With the same cause for an explosion now in existence, they had less power in the mine to resist. He would not have allowed naked lights to be used at Maddox's board if he had been in charge of the pit on the 2nd of March. He believed that the ventilation was imperfect on the 2nd of March, but there was an assisting cause, there was a fall of stone so far down the north return that to a certain extent it would impede such air as was passing down at that return, and, probably, as the passage was not closed entirely, the gas from the large goaf, no longer guarded, would pass freely into Maddox's and the adjoining boards. At the same time these boards having a less and almost stagnant supply of air, gas would be made and supplied from the whole coal workings, acquiring such force as to make it fire at the naked candles. This, in his opinion, was the cause of the first explosion. He inferred from the direction of the fire that the 4½-acre goaf was heavily charged, and that the expansion of the air in the exploded parts would drive the gas into the east whole coal workings, and the concussion of the air probably would discharge the gas, first by expansion, and then by compression among the workings, and it would fire at the men coming out with the naked lights. The inquest has been further adjourned until Wednesday next. Two more men, making four in all, have died from the effects of injuries sustained by the boiler explosion at Seaton Burn Colliery on Monday.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||