|
6th April 1860 The Burradon Colliery ExplosionNewcastle-On-Tyne, April 4. The adjourned inquest on the bodies of the 76 pitmen and pit lads killed in Burradon Pit on the 2nd of March by an explosion of gas was resumed this morning at Burradon, ample time having been given by a lengthened adjournment for a careful and scientific examination of the mine. The chapel where the inquest was held was crowded, and the proceedings were of an exceedingly exciting and singular character. Mr. Serjeant Ballantine should have been down to examine the witnesses on behalf of the relatives of the deceased persons, but he was unable to be present, being detained in town. Mr. Elliott, an eminent viewer, belonging to the county of Durham, who had examined the pit, and who was to have been a witness, had also been called away, having had to proceed to Paris to consult with the French Government upon some matter of business ; and Mr. Phillipson, who had heretofore conducted the inquiry on behalf of the owner of the colliery, refused to call any more witnesses that day. The responsibility of producing evidence was thus thrown upon Mr. Blackwell, barrister, who appeared for the relatives of the deceased in the absence of Mr. Serjeant Ballantine, and as he was not ready with his witnesses the Coroner threatened to commence to charge the jury, whereupon Mr. Blackwell said that he would go into the enemies camp, and examine Mr. Thomas E. Foster, the well-known north country coal viewer, a gentleman of great experience in the coal trade. Exception was taken to the remark made by Mr. Blackwell, and a scene followed. Mr. Foster said that he belonged to no party, and that he was only anxious to elicit the truth, so as to prevent accidents in future. Mr. Foster was then examined at length by Mr. Blackwell ; but when Mr. Harle, who represented the Government Inspector, who was present, got up to put some questions, Mr. Phillipson demurred to Mr. Harle appearing ; the Coroner also objected, on the ground that the Government Inspector should examine the witnesses himself. Mr. Harle then said that he would ask for an adjournment until he had consulted with the Home Secretary as to the course of proceedings. Mr. Harle was at last allowed to go on, but had not proceeded far before Mr. Phillipson interfered, when an extraordinary scene arose. Mr. Harle ordered Mr. Phillipson to sit down, and called upon the coroner to put him out. The Coroner, however, turned his wrath upon Mr. J. B. Langley, a gentleman who has taken an active part during the inquiry, and whom he espied whispering to Mr. Harle, whom he threatened to put out. The pitmen in the body of the chapel had by this time become very excited and commenced to hiss with great vehemence. The Coroner threatened them with expulsion, and there was every prospect of a riot if he carried his threat into execution ; but he fortunately did not attempt to do so, and Mr. Harle proceeding with the examination uninterrupted. Mr. Thomas Emmerson Foster, viewer, said that he had been down the pit several times since the explosion. The first time he was down was on the 9th of March, but the pit was not then in a proper state to make an examination. The stoppings and other things were so deranged that a proper examination could not be made. The next time he was down was on the 11th of March. The pit was not then in a proper state. The ventilation was not at all restored. The next day he was down was on the 21st of March. The pit was then in a much better state, but still the airways and stoppings were not properly restored. The last time he was down was last night. On the 21st of March he came to a conclusion, according to his view, as to the occasion of the accident. His view was that the first explosion occurred in Maddox's Board. That explosion was not a very serious one. It was occasioned by the gas accumulating between the east middle rolleyway and Maddox Board, to the north. The cause of the accumulation was a fall of stone immediately behind Maddox Board in the single part of the north return. The gas came from the solid coal. His view was this, that up to a certain time before the explosion there was sufficient ventilation from the middle east rolleyway to Maddox Board, to keep the workings at those two points clear of gas. At the time when there was a slight explosion on Williams's candle the fall had partially taken place. Between that time, and shortly before the explosion occurred, the fall of stones had so increased that it had almost if not entirely stopped the airway in the return. Hence the first explosion of gas between the east rolleyway and Maddox Board. The reason for his coming to a conclusion that the first explosion had not been a serious one was this, that he found that there were 24 people killed at the top of the inclined bank under a fall of coal ; and he was clearly of opinion that they had arrived at that point before the second explosion took place. He found William Urwin at that point, and he, when he was at work, wrought at the fourth board from the middle east, towards Maddox's Board. Thomas Beadlen wrought in the third board from the middle east towards Maddox's, and his body was found among the 24 lying under the fall. There were several more from the same district, and also from the middle broken. He came to the conclusion that the first explosion was not a severe one from the men having got to that point ; and so far from where the first explosion occurred. He thought the men had arrived at that point when Alderson, the back overman, came up the inclined plane. After hearing the explosion, his opinion was that he induced the men to remain there until he went to see what really was the matter. The consequence was that Alderson had not got 100 yards south from the top of the inclined plane before the second explosion took place. These 24 people that he had already alluded to were killed by the second explosion drawing the timber, and the roof came down upon them. That was the conclusion that he had come to with regard to the first explosion. With regard to the second explosion, he was of opinion that the first explosion took a south-westerly course from Maddox's Board, blowing out stoppings on both sides of the straight up east rolleyway, and which separated the whole coal from the broken ; that the first explosion disturbed some gas in the middle broken, which had been driven on to the middle east rolleyway, where, meeting some men from the south making their way out, the gas fired at their candles. He was of opinion that the men in the far south-east quarter had come out after the second explosion, and had got within a few yards of the air-crossing between the top of the first incline and the middle east rolleyway, when all of them had been killed by the after damp. If they had got nine yards further they would have been safe. He thought that he was corroborated as to the first explosion not having been a serious one by the fact that a number of the men in the middle broken continued at their work and were lost, whereas those who left the middle broken after the first explosion were saved. Mr. Foster was cross-examined at considerable length by Mr. Blackwell upon his evidence in chief. He gave various reasons for coming to the conclusion that the first explosion had been occasioned by a fall of stone in the return, which, deranging the ventilation in that part of the pit, had produced the second and destructive explosion of gas. He said that as soon as the fall of stone was removed Maddox's Board became clear and the gas all passed away. By Mr. Harle. — Has been a viewer 37 years. Had examined the Burradon Pit several years ago. It was at that time the property of Messrs. Carr. Examined the pit at the time for a professional object, on a financial question. From that time until his recent visit on the 9th of March he had not visited the pit. If he had been a viewer in that colliery he would have conducted the ventilation in the same way as it existed on the 2nd of March, the day of the explosion. If to-day they could place the pit at Burradon in the position in which it was on the 2nd of March at 8 o'clock, when Kerkley left, he should be quite satisfied. If the pit was in as good a state as on the 2nd of March, he could not suggest, nor was there any necessity for, any improvement. No human power could have prevented the fall of stone. Such accidents happened without any notice. He thought Kerkley acted prudently in setting on the "putters" with lamps, because they had to go into the whole workings and the pillar workings, and they might have gone into the pillar workings with the naked light. If six men complained of the ventilation in January or February of the present year he could give no reason for the complaint. Witness went down the pit on the 4th of March as a neighbour. His services had been volunteered. He had not been asked by the under viewer or the men to go down. Kerkley did not give him his theory as to the fall in the north return when he went over the place on the 4th of March. He had not formed an opinion on the 4th of March as to the fall, not having seen it. His opinion was that the explosion did not occur from the gas at the north goaf. If it had occurred there, there would have been one great explosion, and not two. He considered the pit perfectly safe if gas came within three or four pillars of Maddox's Board from the great goaf, where candles were used, provided a current of air passed along the face of the workings and down the north return behind Maddox's Board. This being the case he should have trusted entirely to the air and wrought with candles. He should not have calculated upon the contingency of a fall of stone in the single return course. Had no suggestion to offer as to a fall in a return course. If there had been two returns instead of one, if one had fallen the other might have been kept open. Unfortunately there was only one return. They were not in a position for two. If he saw gas upon the candle so that the use of it had become dangerous he would have discontinued it, and would have used the lamp. If there were 5,000 or 6,000 feet of atmospheric air passing into Maddox's Board it would be safe. If the air was flying three feet per second the place would be perfectly safe. If the air was slack in Maddox's Board the gas might come from the goaf to where the men were working. If there was no air at all in the board the gas would not explode. If there were four volumes of air to one of gas it would not explode. If you go on until there are eight portions of air to one of gas that would be the most explosive mixture. Then if you go on until there are 14 volumes of air and one of gas, then the gas will not explode. Mr. Foster having been examined at great length by Mr. Harle the Court adjourned at 4 o'clock until Thursday.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||