|
17th March 1860, Page: 5, Column: 2 Weekly RetrospectThe Burradon TragedyA coroner's inquest is a very ancient and useful, albeit not an altogether satisfactory institution. It is not so much a tribunal as a court of preliminary inquiry, charged with the onerous task of investigating what Rumour, with her thousand tongues, may choose to trumpet forth, and to separate the grain of truth from the chaff of error and falsehood. In the performance of this duty it sometimes subserves the ends of justice, and has a wholesome influence on society in disclosing facts and circumstances which convey valuable lessons or warnings, but which otherwise would be hidden if not unknown. We think, however, that the coroner's court, like other parts of our judicature, is capable of improvement. At present we have no guarantee that the presiding officer is, from education and experience, fitted to discharge his duties, and the jurors are too much selected from one class, and from the particular locality where an accident or fatality occurs. Besides, they are frequently ill-requited for the service which they render the State ; whilst the coroner is subjected to the caprice or arbitrary will of a Finance Committee, in town or county, as to whether he shall receive any remuneration for the inquests he holds. No doubt all this will be changed in due time; but, taking "crowner's law" and practice as we find it, we are not disposed to deny its utility, or to under-rate its importance. The Burradon inquiry, for instance, has already had its uses. Mr. Coroner Reed is a personage sufficiently apt to magnify his office, and it would seem that, when this inquest was opened, wroth that any gentleman should presume to interfere with his functions, he uttered some very foolish observations about closing his court and giving noisy and troublesome catechists, like Mr. Baxter Langley, into custody ; but either through the action of public opinion or the advice of the powers that be, he has subsided into a state of harmlessness and comparative amiability, and during the past week has undergone a pretty fair share of badgering from counsel learned in the law, and plodded on industriously, with occasional "tiffs" and fits of restiveness, in collecting and recording conflicting statements and opinions. Up to this time, the inquiry has certainly been full and searching. We believe this would have been the case in any event; for so terrible a catastrophe could never have been permitted to pass over without a thorough and rigid examination : nevertheless the public, and the pitmen especially, are deeply indebted to Mr. Hugh Lee Pattinson for his zealous and spirited effort on their behalf. Mr. Pattinson, having arrived at the conclusion that explosions of this nature could not occur if mines were properly ventilated, has nobly acted upon his convictions. Not only did he declare his opinions at the Guildhall meeting last Saturday, but he then and there pledged himself, with the solemn sanction of an oath, to see justice done to the miners ; and in fulfilment of that pledge, Mr. Serjeant Ballantine, one of the celebrities of the metropolitan bar, appeared this week at the inquest on his instructions, and at his cost, and materially assisted in laying the whole case before the jury — and we will add the public, for any one who peruses our report of the proceedings will not fail to observe that a much wider circle than that assembled within the little chapel was addressed by all who took a part therein. The inquiry now stands adjourned. Meanwhile a careful examination of the locale of the calamity will be made by competent and (we hope) disinterested persons, and when the court resumes, scientific evidence will be adduced which we hope will tend to clear up much that still lies enveloped in obscurity or doubt. So far as the case has gone, the evidence generally may be divided into two parts — that given by "the masters," as they are termed, viewers and agents, and that given by the workmen. Mr. Charles Carr, who had charge of the colliery, and his under-viewer and overman, declare the pit to have been in a perfectly satisfactory state. According to them it was regularly examined, and the ventilation sufficiently good. A point which was started by what we may call complainants' counsel relative to a double door being marked on a plan when only a single one existed, although a second was designed and about to be put up, unquestionably damaged Mr. Carr's testimony ; and it is unfortunate that when Mr. Johnson, the under viewer, undertook the charge of Coxlodge and ceased to go down daily "for his amusement" (as he was drawn into saying) this deplorable accident should have happened. Still their statement is, that all was right and proper, and that the disaster was altogether unavoidable. Their theory — or rather their suggestion is, that a fall had taken place in a part of the pit called the north return which, impeding the current of fresh air, allowed the gas to creep along up to a candle used by a workman named Maddox, and thus caused the explosion in which he and so many others perished. Their dictum is that the pit was thoroughly and successfully ventilated, and their hypothesis that the fire thus originated in Maddox's board. On the other hand some of the pitmen who have been examined set forth a different class of facts. They show that so long ago as December, 1858, Mr. Matthias Dunn, the Government Inspector, was brought to the colliery in consequence of complaints, and that after his visit the air was "better" than it had been before — we presume owing to some changes suggested or sanctioned by him. Then, it is proved by the evidence of a pitman named Wm. Dryden (who by the way was burnt there about six years ago) that towards the end of January in the present year he left his work from apprehensions of danger, that he communicated his fears to his companions, and that Kirkley, an overman, admitted the liability of which he spoke. When he took away his tools he had a conversation with the pick-sharpener which, in the light of subsequent events, reads like a prophecy. "There will be a misfortune there," speaking of the pit, "as sure as I'm a living man." The pick-sharpener looked serious. He continued ; "If it does not happen now it will happen, and will not be long, I will beg my bread before I'll go down that pit again." And so saying he walked off to West Moor. William Williams corroborates this opinion. "Since the 23rd of January," he says, "I have always had a dread on me ; in fact I lay idle a day or two, frightened to work." Several witnesses spoke to the air in the pit being "bad" five or six weeks in the north return ; and Williams, Jas. Maddox, John Maddox, John Thompson, and Ellis Jowett, who went to work earlier or later on the morning of this notable 2nd of March, have one story as to the air being then impure, only differing in their description of the precise degree of impurity. But on reading their evidence their conduct looks very strange. One of the Maddoxs' worked from one to nine o'clock in a place which he declared dangerous to life. Kirkley, the overman, too, visited him at his board, and yet he never mentioned the matter, the explanation which he gives being that "it went completely out of his mind." The absence of complaint — at all events of loudly expressed complaint and remonstrance — is a peculiar feature in this inquiry. We have the singular fact verified on oath, that men worked on for hours, if not for days, in a place of peril without communicating their fears to those who had the means of removing the cause of danger ! Strange this, but (as we believe) nevertheless true. When called upon to account for the anomaly their answer, generally, is, that it was the duty of the deputies to inform the masters, and that they considered the masters ought to know better than they did whether the pit was safe or otherwise. Another solution may be suggested. It is possible that the apprehension of losing their situations might tempt them into silence, but we don't find this put forward by the miners themselves. Almost with one accord they represent the pit as being, in the north return at least, "fiery," and however we may criticize their conduct or excuses, there is no way of destroying the force of their evidence save by attributing to them an intention to deceive. And not merely are the workmen pretty closely united as to the state of the colliery, they are also agreed as to the cause of the accident. Their notion of its origin is that the first east door (the door marked double on the plan) had been left open, and the air which ought to have gone up to Maddox's workings had been thus diminished. We have not had "pit education" sufficient to elucidate these matters ; but we have ventured to give a synopsis of the two sides in this exceedingly difficult as well as painful controversy, in the hope that it will aid the non-professional reader who peruses our report. So far this evidence must be regarded as ex parte. It may be hereafter modified or changed in its tone and character, and probably will be rebutted by other testimony. Of course we refrain from presenting any opinions of our own. Still more careful would we be to prejudge an inquiry still, in some sort, sub judice. All our remarks must necessarily be general and guarded. We deprecate all hasty and intemperate censures, and would entreat those who seem disposed to assume culpability and to set class against class to wait until the case is closed. Colliery owners have unquestionably the deepest interest in promoting the security of their property — to say nothing of the higher obligation which rests upon them, to adopt every means within their reach of preserving the lives and health of those whose toil ministers to their wealth. Parsimony and penuriousness may imperil life, but let proof of this niggardly spirit be afforded before we visit those who invest their capital in coal mining with cruel innuendoes or coarse invective. The public will act wisely in suspending their judgment until the whole facts are before them ; and if, in the result, it be found that the negligence imputed is substantiated, and that this dreadful catastrophe would have been prevented had ordinary care and caution been used by those who had charge of the colliery, we shall not be behind-hand in calling for the application of any penal provisions which the law may provide. If we understand Mr. Pattinson and his auxiliaries alike they seek to bring Lord Campbell's well known Act of Parliament, affixing pecuniary compensation to acts of negligence, to bear upon colliery owners. The step would be novel, but not on that account the less to be desired or the less exemplary in its effects ; and it certainly would not only render general subscriptions like that which is now proceeding unnecessary, (as was put before the meeting on Saturday,) but it would have a most salutary influence in inducing colliery owners to look more narrowly after the management of property then exposed to such greatly augmented hazards.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||