|
28th January 1860, Page: 3, Column: 1 Fatal AccidentThree Men KilledAn inquest was held, on Saturday last, at the house of Mr. James Cuthbertson, Royal Oak, Medomsley, before J. M. Favell, Esq., coroner, touching the deaths of three men, killed in the Busty Pit, at Medomsley, on Wednesday, the 18th inst. Matthias Dunn, Government Inspector, was present. John Hall Simpson — The Busty Pit of Medomsley belongs to the Consett Iron Works; and I am the resident viewer. Richard Teasdale, engine-wright, had the charge over the ropes and engines, but George Armstrong, brakesman, had immediate charge. Robert Kipling sworn, said — I am a hewer in the Busty Pit. On Wednesday, the 18th inst., I was in the Busty seam, about eight o'clock at night, and heard the cage beat on the bottom of the shaft, and the rope fall on it. I went and saw Thomas Pyle, Joseph Young, and Joseph Fenwick lying in the cage bottom. The sneaks were on Pyle and Fenwick, and the flat sheets were lying on Young's legs. Pyle died before he got to bank, and Fenwick before one o'clock next morning. He was bleeding from his head and insensible. Pyle's arm was broken, and Young's legs were broken, They were sensible. There was no on-setter, and they would rap themselves away. I consider the brakesman, Armstrong, a steady man, and I never had any fear of the rope. Richard Teasdale sworn, says — I am engine-wright at the Busty Pit. I have charge of the ropes and engines. George Armstrong had charge of the engine at the time the men were killed. I consider him a steady man. The plan produced is a correct plan of the drum. The depth of the pit is sixty fathoms, and from shaft to drum six fathoms. The rope is iron-wire, and in circumference three inches; it was made by T. and W. Smith, of St. Peter's, shipbuilders, and was filled on the 10th of September last. It is good right through at the fracture. It was the under rope. The diameter of the drum is 12 foot. There should be one-and-a-half lap on when she takes the lift. There are fourteen horns on each side of the drum, 2 feet 5 inches apart and 6 inches projection, to keep the rope in its place. One horn has been off before the accident. I was not aware of it. I have examined it when in motion as well as when it was standing. We kept a lap and a half on, in order to keep it from the shackle, at the rope is 1½ inch and the shackle 1 inch. It would have a tendency to throw it above the horn. The wide bevel of the horn is 1½ inch, and would be so much added to the drum. We have rollers in the spring-beam to keep the rope on the drum. The cage had been lifted 8 fathoms when the rope broke. The original size of the drum was 8 feet, and then increased to 10 feet 10 inches, and then to 12 feet, before I came. All the time, no change had been made in the size of the horns. There are two sharp bends in the rope below where it was broken, evidently made by the rope coming off the drum on to the shaft, which is 12 inches square. The edges are sharp. The engine had been pumping water during which time we look off the ropes. We pump every night. When men come to ride we put it on again. The shackle lies inside the drum, and is out of the way. When replaced there is a slack in the rope, and it is the duty of the engineman to lift his cage to see that all is right. My opinion is that when she was set away the slack rope lay outside of the horns, where there is a space of four inches, and then fallen on to the shaft, five feet and a half, and been cut by the angles. The slack is out of the engineman's view. Had the horns been longer there would have been less liability for this accident occurring. Mr. Dunn — What are you going to do? Teasdale We propose to put in two guides, to be placed against the wall of the engine-house, as we cannot increase the length of the horns, they being cast iron, and to diminish the space below the rope roll. Mr. Simpson, the viewer — I do not know how long the horn has been off. The Coroner — I think some one should know. The viewer does not, nor enginewright. Other evidence was heard, but it did not tend to elucidate the mystery. The Coroner, in addressing the jury, said. — Gentlemen, having heard the evidence, it is for you to judge. It is clear that ropes do not break without cause ; something is defective — not the rope, for that is sound now. The horns are too short, one is broken off, which makes a space of nearly five feet, where probably the rope has fallen off. This drum does not appear to have been examined as it ought to have been. The viewer and enginewright know nothing about it. The men have been killed by the rope breaking. How did it happen? These horns have been lessened by the increase of the drums, and now they propose to place guides on. The shackles and rope take nearly three inches off the depth of the horns. The enginewright thinks the rope has slipped off the drum — the brakesman that it climbed over the shackles; one man's opinion is as good as another. From both it appears the horns are too short. The workmen going up and down the shaft have to depend upon others for their lives. The brightest intellect is at their mercy. The men in the pit can form their own judgment as to the safety, &c., where they have to labour; but in this case he depends on those who have the care of the rope and drum. I feel very strongly myself. It is for you to say whether it is an accident or not The court was cleared. On reopening Armstrong was recalled. — He said he had been brakesman six weeks at the pit. It would take him 15 or 20 minutes to put the rope right. I never found the rope to ride one turn after another. Had not to take my hammer to knock one turn off. Not in the first week. No men had to get out of the cage because the rope was fast. The Coroner — Would you not be astonished if I prove that such has been the case ? Armstrong — Yes. It never has. The enginewright recalled — He never heard of men getting out of the cage or of the rope being fast. Mr. Simpson, viewer, recalled — He was not aware of any such circumstances. A Juryman then deposed that he was in the engine-house six weeks ago. Having left his can in the pit, he went in to see if two men might go down. I saw the brakesman take his hammer and knock off the rope because it was fast. No one else saw him. At another time there was a rap, three men got in the cage and went away. We got in and waited about three quarters of an hour, and then rode to bank. I went into the engine house, when the brakesman said it was a difficult thing. Armstrong — What I was knocking at was to knock it on. Coroner — You have kept all this from me. You hurried in your statements. Everything that you thought was in your favour you have answered readily; but when likely to be against you, have left it for others to look after. Everything that could be, has been kept from me. Very properly that gentleman, in reply to a question of mine, told me of these circumstances; and I believe him. He has only done his duty as a juryman. I am sorry that we have had so much difficulty in getting the truth out of you. The engineers and viewers in the North of England hold a high position for their skill and care in working the collieries, and very great credit is due to them, which won't belong to them long, if there be no better care exercised than at the Busty Pit. Mr. Walton — May I explain ? Coroner — No. You might have done so, Never mind the negligence of the men; I have seen enough here. You are in a good position; keep still, for you are the only man who saw anything, and it was not in your department. I will read the verdict, which would have been much stronger had I drawn it up. The verdict of the jury is — That we are of opinion that the three men named were killed in the shaft of the Busty Pit by the rope coming off the drum on to the shaft and breaking on the 18th inst. That the horns were too short to keep the ropes on the drum; and that the drum has not been examined for a length of time.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||