|
29th January 1859, Page: 4, Column: 3 The Boiler Explosion At BarringtonThe following is the evidence adduced before L. M. Cockerill, Esq., deputy-coroner, concerning the death of Edward Nixon, at the inquest held at Choppington, in the parish of Bedlington, on Tuesday last. Mr. M. Dunn, Inspector of Mines, attended in company with Cockerill, and elicited from the witnesses examined some useful and practical suggestions, with the view of preventing the recurring of such serious accidents. Deceased, on the morning of Wednesday the 19th inst. was employed in filling some small coals ; and while he was so engaged, one of the boilers, attached to the colliery suddenly exploded. A workman, named Joel Martin, observed deceased lying on his right side among a lot of bricks and rubbish. He then appeared alive ; but in about five minutes afterwards life was extinct. Daniel Cansodine, the first witness examined, deposed that he was a fireman at Barrington Colliery. There were five boilers, the firing of which was left between another fireman and himself. He had to look after the boiler which had exploded during such time as his neighbour was cleaning his fires. The explosion took place between 10 and 11 o'clock, and witness had fired the furnace of this boiler about nine. He did not fire it after that but he believed it had been fired. He could not say how long before the explosion it was that the boiler was fired. By a Juror — Never heard any remark as to the safety of the boiler, nor did he himself ever say anything as to its being unsafe. By Mr. Dunn — Robert Davison and John Bogue have charge of the boiler. Robert Davison examined, deposed — I have had charge of the boilers at Barrington Colliery for four years. I had only the charge during the day shift, commencing at six o'clock in the morning till five in the afternoon. (Witness put in a drawing of the boilers, which were five in number and all connected in both water and steam.) Each boiler had a separate feed-pipe. There is not more than one boiler fed at a time. This boiler was fed about ten minutes or quarter of an hour before the explosion took place. The boiler that exploded was six feet in diameter by forty feet long. It had two safety valves, both of which were in working order on the morning in question. The pressure upon them was 35lbs to the square inch. That was generally the pressure at which they were wrought. There is not more than one float apparatus in each boiler, which consists of stone, and was acting freely two minutes before the explosion. The water had not got below the usual level before I put on the last feed. The water which we used is good; it does not create a great deal of sediment. None of the boilers have stays inside. I never did consider that the boiler which exploded was unsafe; nor did any one ever say to me that it was unsafe. She was blowing off her steam as freely as usual before the explosion took place. No one had control over the safety-valves but myself. The boilers are usually inspected once a fortnight. The interior of the boiler which exploded was inspected by myself a fortnight before the explosion took place. The boiler which exploded has been working four years to my knowledge. It is about six months since she underwent some repairs, when some new plates were put into the bottom. We were putting no additional pressure on the boilers when the explosion occurred. I do not know the thickness of the plates; I have not examined them since. There were no lead plugs in the boiler bottom. The engines were working at the time the explosion happened, — the one pumping water, the other letting down a man. I can form no idea of the cause of the explosion, unless it was that the boiler was weaker than the others. By Mr. Dunn — The boiler is blown about 100 yards from the place in two or three portions. I think stays inside the boiler would have been the means of preventing the explosion, I have had the charge of boilers for 46 years. The agent had no superintendent over the boilers. The boiler had only one float apparatus ; I never saw one with two. When I come to my shift in the morning I examine to see that all is right, and then I have the responsibility on myself. There was no unusual quantity of water leaking when the explosion occurred. I think an additional float apparatus might be the means of preventing an explosion. Anthony Mowbray, principal enginewright at Barrington Colliery deposed — I had charge of collieries for ten years. I examined this boiler about an hour before the explosion took place, when it was in working order. I did not examine the boiler on the last occasion of her being cleaned. It is a month ago since I examined the internal part of the boiler, I did not then observe any indications of any fault. I do not consider it incumbent for me to examine the boilers internally unless some representation is made of their insecurity. I heard of the boiler being a second-hand one before she came to this colliery. I cannot from her appearance, form an idea of how long she has been worked. I have examined the boiler all over since the explosion took place. From that examination, I cannot form any idea as to where it first gave way. At the edges, where it appears to have burst, the thickness varies from 5.16 to 3-8 ths. One plate in particular seems "leafy" and unsound, where the action of the flame comes. The action of the flame would not give it that appearance, I cannot say whether the water and steam went down into the fire. The calculation I have made shows a pressure on the safety-value of 36 lbs. It would have been safe to work it at 40 lbs. I do not find any indications of the plates having being over-heated when the explosion took place. The feed-valve was tight in its place, as it ought to be, when the explosion happened. There have been no repairs since I went to the colliery. I have been there only four months. I cannot form a just conception as to the cause of the explosion, I think the boiler, for its size, was strong enough in its plates. By Mr. Dunn —I do not think a 6 feet boiler requires stays through the diameter. I do not think the stays would prevent an explosion, although they would do no harm. The engines are never wrought at a pressure lower than 33 lbs. Robert Davison re-called, and examined by Mr. Dunn, deposed — I know the pressure at which I was working from the spring-balance. We had a little more work at this time, and consequently required extra firing. At this time all the engines were going, and ordinarily we had only four. Thomas Mallaburn, smith, but not now working, said — I examined the boiler about three hours after the explosion took place. I could see no indication of overheating. Two of the plates seemed to be defective. When the boiler was made that unsoundness could have been detected. I do not think the explosion took place at that portion of the boiler. The thinnest part of the plate, I observed, was only 4-16ths, and that was one of the parts where the explosion seems to have taken place. By Mr. Dunn — I think the boiler would be strengthened by stays. I have put them in myself. I think it would be a very good precaution, and would recommend it very much. This concluded the evidence ; and the jury, after being briefly addressed by Mr. Cockerill returned a verdict of "Accidental death," being of opinion that there was no evidence to show how the explosion had been caused, from which that death had resulted. They also submitted a recommendation that the boiler should be furnished with stays inside, for the purpose of strengthening them, and that an additional "float" should be put into each. Mr. Dunn read the following short statement suggestive of the means of preventing boiler explosions, which may be of interest as bearing on the present case :— "Boiler explosions arise either from excessive pressure of steam or an inadequate supply of water, in consequence of which an over-heating of the boiler takes place, which, coming in contact with the water, produces an irresistible power within the boiler. The over-pressure of steam may be avoided by duplicate safety-valves, or by a steam indicator or whistle, of which there are now many varieties. The irregularity of the feed may be affected by one boiler priming into another, where two or more are connected, or by inadvertently having more than one feed-valve open at the same time. To guard against the want of feed, I have come to the conclusion that a duplicate float apparatus is one of the most simple and practical appliances, although gauge-cocks, whistles, &c, are preferred by many : but a boiler fitted up without a check upon the ordinary apparatus, is always liable to go wrong. A good safeguard against the water of one boiler being forced into another, consists of a flap at the bottom of the feed-pipe, opening inwards, which will shut in case of interior pressure."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||