|
16th October 1858 The Page Bank Colliery CatastropheWillington, Near Durham, Thursday p.m. After the Ordinary evidence was concluded to-day at the inquest the Government Inspector was examined as to the cause of the accident :— Mr. J. J. Atkinson, Government Inspector, said, that he had visited the colliery some time after the coal was got. About two years ago he examined the shaft and had his attention called to the blower of gas in the shaft, and was satisfied with the means of carrying it away. Having examined the shaft since the accident as far as he could get down, he found it as described by the previous witnesses. It was customary on first opening coal mines to establish a small temporary furnace to produce ventilation as near and, he believed, often much nearer to the shaft than that which was in use at Page Bank Pit at the time of the accident. Shaft brattices occasionally caught fire from the heated air of the furnaces at a point opposite to the furnace drift, and not, as in this case, many fathoms above the furnace drift. But during 22 years' experience he was not aware of any lives having been lost in consequence of the shaft brattices taking fire. In his opinion, if the men in the pit, with the exception of Kellett, who was killed, had opened the shaft doors, or, in the event of not being able to get there for smoke, if they had knocked out the stoppings between each intake, and returned as near to the shaft as they could for smoke, they could all have been saved. The fact that Kellett smelt burning wood in the shaft led him to the conclusion that the explosion of gas in the shaft was not the cause of the fire. He was of the same opinion as Mr. Wood, Mr. Armstrong, and others, so far that the fire had originated from a spark in the shaft, but he did not agree with those gentlemen in thinking the spark more likely to have come from the torch used by Bird and others on the Saturday preceding the accident ; as it might have occurred from a spark being blown from the surface lamp, or from the furnace, nearly in a horizontal direction, along the surface drift, and then vertically up the shaft by the upcast air ; and although he admitted the latter to be improbable he thought it just possible, and his opinion was, that a spark from either of the sources he had last mentioned might have come in contact with and ignited some small jet of gas in the shaft, which would continue to burn, heat and ultimately ignite the brattice and other timber in the shaft. From the appearance of the shaft since the accident he was of opinion that the fire had originated not less than 60 yards from the furnace, and, probably, many fathoms up the shaft above the furnace drift. His reason for thinking that was that if the had been smouldering since Saturday morning the smell of burning would have been discovered much earlier. In his opinion the spark from the torch was not the origin of the fire. He felt confident that the pit was well ventilated. He did not expect, in consequence of the dampness of the shaft, any such accident could have occurred. He was of opinion that there had been no more undue risk in the management of this pit than was the ordinary practice of the trade. If the furnace had been further off the shafts it would have been a less efficient ventilator. Torches were generally used by the trade in engine pits, though he thought them dangerous, and that a more safe description of light should be used. He considered the general safety of the mine was increased by having two shafts. Though had this Page Bank pit been a downcast pit, and there had been a separate upcast, in the event of the downcast taking fire he very much doubted if any of the lives would have been saved, acting as the men had actually done. He quite concurred in what had been done to rescue the men from the pit. He did not think that there was anyone to blame for the accident. He thought that the general arrangements of the colliery were proper and efficient. After the Government Inspector's evidence :— The Coroner summed up at great length, and the jury, after about an hour's consultation, returned the following verdict — "The jury are of opinion that the brattice in the shaft was ignited by a spark, but from what cause the spark came there there is no evidence to show. They are further of opinion that the whole of the men, save Kellett, died from fear and suffocation, arising from the fire in the shaft, Kellett being killed by falling down the pit ; and, further, they are of opinion that no blame can be attached to any person whatever. They, therefore, give a unanimous verdict of 'Accidental Death.'"
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||