|
15th October 1858 The Fire at the Page Bank CollieryWillington, Near Durham, Wednesday Night. The Inquest. After our despatch left to-day the following additional evidence was called :— David Bolam, one of the deputy overmen, corroborated the overman Mould's evidence as to the pit being in a good condition when they went down it at 2 o'clock on Thursday morning. He said that he met the men and examined their lamps, and set them to work. Was coming out of the north headway going towards the west drift about 3 o'clock, when a driver lad shouted that witness had to get the men "out-bye," as the furnace-shaft was on fire. He went all round to tell them. As he was going out he met some of them coming back again. They said that they could not get to the shaft for the "reek," or smoke, which was coming "in-bye." They all then went to the furnace. There were some men already there. There was no reek at the furnace. Saw smoke coming down from the shaft and through the separation doors. He and Thomas Hornsby, George Pattison, and George Wilson agreed to put the furnace fire out. About 1 o'clock, about an hour after, they put the furnace fire out. Something fell down the shaft and threw the air back upon them. Robson shouted "We have only a quarter of an hour to live," and began to pray. They then went out of the workings about 50 yards from the furnace. The lamps went out about 9 or 10 o'clock on Thursday night. After the lamps went out the men wandered about. He (witness) slept a long time on Friday. He heard some of the men walking about the pit on Friday. He was the last to come out. Heard some of the water and some of the burnt brattice fall. Could see the sparks fall from time to time. Heard no explosion, or report of one. If there had been one he should have heard. About 3 o'clock on Thursday afternoon he and the waggon wayman went to the shaft, and shouted up, but the smoke drove them away. Robson prayed with the boys, as they were afraid. The ventilation was not only good but stronger in the mine, from the fire burning in the shaft and the water that was coming down. He believed most of the men died from fear. He begged the men to stay about the furnace, where the air was good. He had no idea how the fire occurred in the brattice. He had wrought in the colliery since it started, and there had been no accident before. The men never complained about not having two shafts. Thomas Brown, breaksman at the pit, was then called. He said he went into the pit on Thursday morning the 30th of September, and relieved James Watson, "set away" to draw coals. Two boys were drawn out before Kellett came. He came between 8 and 9. After Kellett went down three tubs were drawn. There was then a rap for men "to ride," and a second rap to "draw away." As he was drawing the men up he heard something fall, but could not tell whether it was in the shaft or not. After he heard the rattle he observed smoke coming from the mouth of the pit. Thought he saw it in the "cap-head" side first. It came into the engine-house. Could not see Mould when he drew him up for the smoke. Heard him shout "to fetch her up," and he brought him to bank. When Kellett came to go down in the morning witness observed no fire or smoke. Up to the time that Kellett came saw nothing wrong at the pit's mouth. If there had been any fire he must have seen it. The men went down sometimes with Davy lamps, but most often they went in the dark. If there had been any fire in the pit when Kellett went down witness must have seen it. A great quantity of smoke came up "all of a sudden." Thomas Bird, enginewright at the colliery, was at the pit about half-past 10 o'clock on Thursday. His duty was to look after all the ropes and machinery connected with the shaft and the colliery generally. He examined the shaft every night. He was busy at the bottom of the shaft nearly all day on the Saturday before the accident. He was changing the "low set clack" with two men named Waller and Robson. On Sunday he and Waller were engaged tightening the inside of the low set clack door. In examining the shaft they used large "Davys," which were provided for them. Were prevented using a naked light except at the bottom. No smoking was allowed. While working at the low set clack on Saturday they used a lighted torch. It was at the bottom of the engine upcast shaft. The torch is a large tin vessel containing oil and having a long spout an inch and a half in diameter, and burnt with a cotton wick. When it was burnt down the top was shaken off, and the sparks flew off, but he did not see it done that day. On going down on the Sunday they passed through a sliding door in the brattice, 3 feet high and 18 inches wide, into the other shaft to get to the low set clack. Was down on the Monday. Was looking into the delivery end of the siphon into the pump. Got a small oil lamp at the bottom of the shaft for the purpose. Was at the pit every day after Monday, but was not in the shaft after that day. He was very poorly and could not go down. Was at the pit on the Thursday at the time the accident occurred. He was standing at the shop door, when he heard a rush and saw the smoke coming out of both shafts. About a quarter of an hour after he saw smoke he observed flames coming up the downcast shaft. Were allowed to use torches at the low clack door. The onsetter has his lamp burning there constantly to light the Davy lamps. Never set anything on fire by those torches. By Mr. Atkinson. — It was a common thing to use torches in engine pits wherever he had wrought. The reason why they did not use candles in the back pit was because it was so wet the light could not be kept in. When the sliding door at the low clack is open there is a steady draught of air. John Mackay, sinker at the Page Bank Pit, went down the shaft about half-past 9 on Friday. Went to examine the pit to see if it were in a fit state to bring the men up. Found the brattice was nearly all burnt out above the staple drift. The fire was burning at that time three fathoms below the staple drift, but mostly on the back side of the engine pit. There had been no body of fire below that, and from there to the bottom of the pit the brattice was quite perfect. The fire had been strongest just above where a "blower" of gas was burning. Could not tell what had caused the "blower" to ignite. From the "blower" to the low clack door was about 18 or 19 fathoms. There was no appearance of burnt brattice opposite to the furnace drift end. Mr. Armstrong, viewer at Wingate Colliery, said that he was sent for on the morning of the accident. When he arrived he examined the working pit and found a very considerable discharge of smoke from it. From the colour of the smoke and the smell of it he was satisfied that it was from wood and not from coal. He was then sure that it had not arisen from an explosion, but from a fire in the shaft. He then examined the chimney and the smoke from it, and from the traces of coal smoke in it he came to the conclusion that some small seams of coal were on fire. He knew the colliery well. He was check viewer to it. Mr. Atkinson, the Government inspector, and Mr. Johnson and himself had a conversation as to what was best to be done, and they decided to check the fire in the staple by putting in a stopping to the chimney end of the drift, to give a current to the smoke to prevent it going into the pit again. There were but two modes in which the fire could be accounted for ; one was that it had been caused by a spark from the torch used by Thomas Bird on the Saturday morning, and he must say those sparks were very common, for he had often observed them himself. They had a fire at Wingate Grange of considerable magnitude four or five years ago, which they traced to a torch. The fire took place four or five hours after the torch had been used. It was possible that a spark from Bird's lamp had been carried through the door by the strong current of air into the upcast shaft, when it might lodge in some recess in the plank tub, and smoulder and burn there until it burnt through the tub, and it would then communicate with the gas behind the tub to some extent, and the explosion of that gas was in all likelihood the cause of that rush spoken to by Bird. The second theory or conjecture was that it was quite possible that a spark from the furnace might be carried into the upcast air up the other compartment of the shafts, and might produce the same consequences. Torches were very common, and he thought very dangerous. He had discarded them altogether, and only allowed them in extreme cases. The Coroner. — Do you think if a spark had flown from the torch on Saturday, that a fire would not have broken out until Thursday ? Witness thought it very probable. The tubbing was wet, and there was no one to examine it, as Bird was unwell. The back shafts were not examined every day. Coroner. — Don't you think brattice shafts dangerous ? Witness. — It would be better without them, but in my experience I don't remember a single instance where life has been lost by these shafts. By Mr. Atkinson. — Was down Page Bank Pit in August last, and found the ventilation very good. Noticed the furnace when he was down. It was a very good one. Long before this occurrence we had intended to sink a second shaft, but there was considerable difficulty to be overcome before it could be done, and as soon as these important difficulties were overcome a second shaft should be made. He thought it would be practical to adopt some incombustable material for a brattice. He would suggest either iron or metal. He did not think a "blower" had to do with the accident until the tubbing was burnt through. He did not think any blame was attached to any one connected with the colliery. He believed every precaution had been taken. The pit had only been working since May, 1856. Assuming that there had been a second shaft, and the fire had occurred in the down cast, and the smoke, instead of coming up the shaft, should have extended over the workings, he did not think a single man would have been got out alive. Mr. Nicholas Wood, colliery viewer, of Hetton, said that he was sent for on Thursday afternoon to come to the colliery. He described what had been done when he arrived. He found the parties at the pit pouring water down the pit and the staple. After a consultation it was thought prudent that a second attempt should be made to put in the brattice, and that the whole of the force of the water should be applied to the pit, in order to enable the men to work, that the air should not be obstructed passing along the drift up the staple, and that the water should not be used in the staple unless it could be spared from the pit. The brattice was then commenced to be in, and Mr. Foster arriving at the time, he concurred in what had been done. He left at 12 o'clock. At that time it was thought that the fire had occurred at the furnace. He was agreeably surprised the next morning when he arrived to find one of the boys brought to the bank. The fact turned out that 16 or 17 fathoms of the bottom of the brattice had not been burnt. On Monday last he went to the colliery with Mr. Foster, Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Johnson, and Mr. Atkinson, and made a rigid inquiry of all the men in charge of the different departments, and they found no lights except safety lamps had been allowed either to be taken up or down the shaft. They found that a torch had been used by Bird in the engine shaft, and up which the air would rush with great velocity. Knowing it was a common occurrence for cotton to be blown off from the lamps into the upcast, it was his opinion that this had been the cause of setting fire to the timber in the shaft, which when burnt through, would explode the gas in the cavities of the tubbing, and in his opinion accounted for the rush of wind described by Bird and for the falling deal which killed Kellet — the other case alluded to by Mr. Armstrong, and, looking at all the circumstances of the furnace, and the quantity of air passing near it, there being a side drift, along which one-third of the air passed, he could not come to the conclusion that the brattice had been set on fire by a spark from the furnace. Torches were used in the trade when the passage up and down the section of the shaft was very frequent. He was astonished that there was any one lost at all in the pit, as there was plenty of air in the pit. He did not agree with one of the witnesses that the deaths had been caused by fear. The smoke would be exceedingly soporific. He thought that the men had put their faces to the water to catch the current of air, and had fallen asleep and dropped into the water, and had thus been suffocated. In fact, they had been drowned. Mr. Foster, viewer, of Newcastle, gave corroborative evidence, and the inquest was adjourned until to-morrow.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||