|
9th September 1858 The Late Accident In Croft PitInquest YesterdayThe adjourned inquest into the cause of the death of William Postlethwaite, which took place on the 2nd of September, and of William Shilton, who died on the 3rd of September, both from injuries sustained by an explosion of fire-damp in Croft Pit, on the 12th of August, was held on Wednesday, at the house of Mr. Cowx, Ginns, Whitehaven, before William Lumb, jun., Esq., coroner, and a jury of which Mr. Thexton was foreman. The previous inquest was adjourned to allow Mr. Dunne, the Government Inspector, to complete his survey. Mr. Dunne was again in attendance; and we are requested by the jury to express their entire concurrence in the able manner in which that gentleman from first to last has concerned himself in the inquiry. Taylor Swainson, colliery viewer, sworn, produced a plan of Croft Pit, and indicated thereon the part in which the deceased were working, and also where the accident occurred. Henry Fox, sworn, said: I am a deputy overman in Croft Pit, and live at Arrowthwaite. I made a search in the pit shortly after the accident took place. I did not notice any particular indication of an explosion; though I could see that an explosion had taken place. That part of the pit in which the accident took place is an old working, and about 150 yards from where other men were working. I found three lamps, two in the upbank. The tops of Shilton's and McMullen's lamps were off. Mr. Dunne: Did they appear as if they had been taken off before the explosion? Witness: Yes. Coroner: Do you think that they had taken off the tops of their lamps before the explosion? Witness: I believe that they had gone in with the tops of their lamps on, judging from the manner in which I found them. Mr. Dunne: When was the brattice taken out of this working? Witness: Six or seven weeks since. Mr. Dunne: Did it not occur to you that this place was likely to foul after the brattice was taken away? Witness: No, sir. Coroner: Were you there when the brattice was taken out? Witness: No, I was not. Mr. Dunne: Who ordered the brattice to be taken out? Witness: John Hinde, the overman. Mr. Dunne: Did it not occur to you that if the brattice was taken out it would foul? Witness: We did not think anything about it because no one had a right to work there; it is an old working. Mr. Dunne: Have you put in the brattice since the accident? Witness: No. There is no place where it is wanted. Mr. Dunne: Might not the absence of this brattice have proved fatal to parties working, say at 150 yards distance? Witness: Well, it might, I can't say. Mr. Dunne: Would it have been prudent to have left that place in its foul state without a brattice when it was in such close proximity to where men were working? Witness: No, I don't suppose that it would. Coroner: Who ordered the brattice to be removed? Witness: Hinde, I suppose. Mr. Dunne: Why has the brattice not been put in as I ordered at last inquest? Witness: I don't know. Coroner: Well, but would it do any damage as it is now? Witness: You could work in it. Coroner: Yes, but would it be safe to take a lighted candle into the working? Would it blow a man down. Witness: Certainly. Mr. Dunne: Supposing any person was to walk into the working today with a light, would not the same accident happen to it as happened to it before? Witness: I should say the place is just as liable to have as much foulness in it now as before. The reason why the brattice was taken out was because the place was not worked. Mr. Dunne: But I suppose that part of the pit is altogether abandoned since the accident. Witness: Yes, it is not to be worked for some hundreds of yards by that place. Mr. Dunne: But if so small an application as putting in the brattice would keep the working clean instead of foul, would it not be far better to keep in the brattice? Witness: Well, I don't know. The place is right enough if they'll keep out of it. Coroner: Aye, aye, if they'll keep out of it. But you couldn't have worked in it, could you? Witness: Yes, I could. Coroner: How could you? Mr. Dunne: I suppose you would bat out the foul air with your cap or your jacket, eh? Witness: Yes. Mr. Dunne: And do you call that good pitmanship? Coroner: Do you call that good pitmanship, the Inspector asks? Witness: No. The brattice was taken out of this working, and put into another. Coroner: What was that for? You are never refused anything that you want in the pit, are you? If you want material you have only to ask for it. You are never refused what you want, are you? Witness: Not that I know of. Coroner: Not that you know of. Was anybody else ever refused anything? Witness: I was never refused anything. John Hinde, sworn, said: I am overman in Croft Pit. I know this working well. I was examined at the last inquest. I know nothing about the finding of these lamps. I ordered the brattice to be taken down three months before the accident. We wanted it in a part of the pit that was likely to make more gas. At the time when this brattice was taken out, there was a notice-board put up. It was supposed that that would act as a warning; it was generally understood by the men, and those who went past it trespassed. The deceased could not help but notice the board. I don't know whether Shilton and McMullen could read writing. The board was not painted; the notice was chalked on. The brattice would have made the working safer as regarded the foulness, but it was quite as safe with the board, if they had not gone past it. The working was not very foul. Indeed, Postlethwaite's own son went to the far end only five weeks ago, and lifted the plate. Mr. Dunne: When I was down the pit I ordered you to replace the brattice. Why have you not done so? Witness: The reason why I did not replace the brattice was because we have abandoned the district altogether, and a notice board is put up. Mr. Dunne: If the working is thoroughly abandoned and its vicinity also, the brattice is perhaps not necessary. By a Juror: What became of the board? Witness: It was burned. Mr. Dunne: What did the board contain? Witness: "No person to go beyond here without permission." Mr. Dunne: Did Postlethwaite make any statement to you with regard to the lamps? Witness: Yes. He told me that he carried his lamp as far as he could, and then threw it away. I found it about fifty yards up the working. Mr. Swainson having alluded to the brattice as being to a certain extent unnecessary, The Coroner said: You must consider, Mr. Swainson, the general safety of your pit. The working might be quite safe enough for some men to work; but you know very well that your ignorant men, you cannot depend upon them. You must use caution and try to guard against such an accident as just happened; that is the only way. Mr. Swainson: Begging your pardon, Mr. Lumb, we have not such ignorant men in Croft Pit as you think. Coroner: I didn't apply the word "ignorant" offensively. You have all sorts of men in Croft Pit, I dare say. Mr. Dunne: You have removed from where this accident happened, about 1,000 yards, Mr. Swainson, have you not? Mr. Swainson: Yes, about 800 or 1000 yards. A Juror (Mr. Lewis) here observed that there existed amongst certain parties outside, a feeling that the jury in the previous case had not acted impartially, that they had not, in fact, done their duty in returning the verdict which they had returned. Such an opinion was very disagreeable to the jury, as he was sure they had all acted conscientiously. The Coroner said he believed the jury returned a very proper and a very correct verdict, and they were not to mind what any one might have said. Public opinion was sometimes worth something; at other times it was not. No man who had carefully considered the facts of this case could reasonably asperse the jury. Mr. Dunne: What do the people complain of? Mr. Lewis: Well, some parties think that Postlethwaite was to blame. Mr. Dunne: Well, and if he was, what of that? Supposing he had lived, the case would have been just the same. Nothing would have been done to Postlethwaite. He did not act wilfully. His own life was at stake. He could not have been committed for manslaughter. John Bateman Wilson, surgeon, sworn, said: I attended Mr. Postlethwaite during his illness. He died on Thursday night. He suffered from a low fever, as well as from burns. I think it was the fever that carried him off; the burns were not so serious. The fever was no doubt aggravated by the burns. Shilton died from burns. By the Foreman: Do you, Dr. Wilson, consider that Postlethwaite's death was accelerated by any excitement which the visit from us occasioned him? It is commonly reported that it was, and therefore we are anxious to have your opinion, as the medical gentleman who attended him. Mr. Wilson: Not in the least. Coroner: I am very glad that the foreman has mentioned that, as I have heard the same report; and the more especially because when it became necessary to have the evidence of Postlethwaite, I refused to sanction him being visited unless we had the authority of Dr. Wilson. Postlethwaite, I believe, was blind, so that anything he could see would do him no harm. It could only be from the few questions put to him by myself, and the Government Inspector, that he could be excited. Mr. Wilson: Postlethwaite did not die for nearly a fortnight after the examination. There occurred this circumstance, which might favour that conclusion, he was for three days afterwards delirious; but that was owing to the fever, engendered also in some measure by the shock of the accident. It was from the fever he had the delirium, not from any excitement consequent upon the jury visiting him. The jury, after a short consultation, returned a verdict of "Accidental death." The jury would recommend the appointment of a government inspector solely for this district. The Coroner said the jury had returned a very proper verdict: but with regard to their recommendation, it was no part of his duty to take cognisance of it in his inquisition. Mr. Dunne: I may just mention that I was inspector for all Scotland, all Durham, and all Northumberland. Since then they have taken the Scotch part of the business off my hands. They have taken the southern part of the county of Durham off my hands also. The present Act of Parliament expires in 1860; and during next year, there is no doubt, a revision will take place, and the lead mines, copper mine, &c., be added to the duty. I don't think you can do anything in the matter until there is likely to be a revision. Perhaps I might be allowed to recur to what I mentioned last time I was here. I understand that conveyances have been provided, or are to be, at each of the pits, for taking parties who meet with accidents from the pits to the Infirmary. There are to be two at each pit The Coroner: I am quite sure that anything that either the Government Inspector or any one else can suggest will be attended to immediately by Lord Lonsdale, whose disposition to do everything he can for his workpeople is most excellent. Mr. Dunne: I had an interview with Lord Lonsdale today. I told his Lordship that I had received a circular from the Home Office, requesting me to make a return of the number of fines that I had exacted. His lordship wanted to know what was my return. I told him my return was this. That I scarcely ever met with proprietors who were not perfectly willing to do whatever I recommended. The proceedings then terminated.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||