|
6th March 1858, Page: 5, Column: 1 Northumberland AssizesMarch 2ndBefore Mr. Baron Martin, and a Common Jury. — Keen v Harrison. — This was an action in which the Plaintiff Mr. Matthew Keen, a farmer at Eshott Brocks, sought to recover damages from the Defendants who are the owners of Radcliffe Colliery, near Amble, for breach of contract, in not accepting certain Hay sold to them by the Plaintiff. Mr. Overend, Q.C., and Mr. Price, appeared for the Plaintiff ; and Mr. Temple, Q.C., and Mr. Udall, for the Defendants. It appeared from the Plaintiff's evidence, that in August last, Mr. Joseph Harrison, one of the Defendants, and who was manager at the Colliery, came to Eshott Brocks while the Plaintiff was busy with his Hay, and contracted to purchase 40 tons of old land Hay, and 5 or 6 tons of new land Hay, at £3 5s. 6d. per ton, out of which the Plaintiff was to make some return. About the 13th of August, the Plaintiff delivered the new land Hay which was approved of by Mr. Joseph Harrison, who paid £30 on account of his contract, being about £10 more than the value of the Hay then delivered. On the 17th of August the Plaintiff delivered about 7 tons of the old land Hay at the Colliery, which the Defendant's men did not consider sufficiently well won, and Mr. Joseph Harrison, then wrote to the Plaintiff to send no more Hay, until it was seen and approved of. The Plaintiff made several applications to Mr. Harrison to go and examine his hay, as the delay affected his harvest operations, and at last, about the 7th September, a man named Taylor was sent by Mr. Harrison to examine the hay in the Plaintiff's fields. It did not appear that he objected to any of the hay afterwards delivered, and next day about 9 tons of hay were sent by the plaintiff to the Colliery. The Defendants' men not being sufficiently prepared to stack it, it was emptied out of the carts into the yard, and about 12 o'clock, a heavy rain came on, which continued for a considerable time, and reduced the hay to the condition of manure. The defendants after this, refused to receive any more hay from the plaintiff, who, however, insisted upon his contract, and after making a tender of the rest of the hay at the Colliery, weighed and stacked it, to the amount of about 23 tons, and then commenced this action, to recover the value of the Hay delivered, and also for damages sustained in consequence of the defendants having broken their contract; the Plaintiff having been deprived by that contract, of the opportunity of selling his Hay in the country, and compelled to take it to Newcastle Market, at a great expense for carriage, and there being a fall in the price of Hay between the time when the contract was made and when it was broken. The Defendants pleaded among other pleas, a denial of the contract as stated by the Plaintiff, and that the rest of the Hay which they refused to accept, was not of a merchantable quality, and these were the material questions in the case, but the Defendants paid into Court £45, being rather more than the full contract price for the Hay actually delivered, and which they had alleged to be bad Hay. The Plaintiff gave evidence as to the contract, and he and his men spoke to the good condition of the Hay delivered to the Defendants, and of that put into stack, and Mr. March, of Cauledge Park, and Mr. Bell, of Amble Hope House, proved that they had in February last, thoroughly examined the stack containing the Hay refused by the Defendants, and that it was then, in excellent condition, and must have been well won and in good condition when stacked. Mr. Temple addressed the jury for defendants, and called Mr. Joseph Harrison, who swore that he did not contract to purchase 40 tons, but that the bargain was, that he would take 30 or 40 tons of old land Hay if he found it satisfactory, and he and his men gave evidence as to the bad quality of the Hay delivered, while two persons who had seen the Hay in the Carts on the road when it was rejected were also called to prove that they considered it bad Hay. Mr. Temple having summed up the evidence for the defence, Mr. Overend, replied on the case in a forcible speech, and commented strongly upon Mr. Harrison's testimony as to the contract, and the trumpery nature of the evidence of the bad quality of the Hay. His Lordship then summed up the case to the jury at some length, and after contrasting the evidence of the Plaintiff, and Mr. Harrison, as to the contract, left it for them to say, which version they believed, and whether it was proved that the Hay refused by Defendants was of merchantable quality. The jury retired for a short time, and then returned a verdict for the Plaintiff, with £30 damages, in addition to the £45 paid into Court. Attorney for the Plaintiff, Mr. Wilkinson, Morpeth ; for the Defendants, Mr. Hoyle, Newcastle.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||