25th June 1857
The Late Poisoning Case at Cleator Moor
Adjourned Inquest
Inquiry into the death of Mrs. Armstrong, Joseph Armstrong, junr, Robert Armstrong, John Sloane, and Fenton Murray, all of Cleator Moor, near Whitehaven, adjourned on Monday week was resumed on Tuesday last before
William Lumb, Esq., coroner, and the jury whose names as such have already been published. A court was held in the Hematite Iron Company's schoolroom.
The result of the last inquiry having made known the fact that the Home Secretary had deputed Professor Taylor to attend and watch the proceedings on behalf of the Crown, considerable interest attached thereto, and a large attendance was expected; but
besides those whose presence in court was special or professional, and interested parties, we noticed few.
Mr. J. Postlethwaite, solicitor, Whitehaven, attended, as before, to watch the proceedings on behalf of the Hematite Iron Company; and Mr. George Armstrong, solicitor, Workington, on behalf of the owner of the houses in which the deaths
occurred.
Professor Taylor took his seat at the right of that of the Coroner, through whom he questioned witnesses who were examined on a former occasion, as their depositions were read over by the Clerk.
The Coroner re-opened his court by observing: — Gentlemen of the Jury, — Shortly after the last adjournment, I sent a copy of the depositions to Sir George Grey, who replied to my letter by stating that Dr. Alfred Taylor had
been instructed to come down here and assist in this investigation. Dr. Taylor is now here, and I am sure he will render that assistance which it is so desirable we should have. What I propose to do is to read over the evidence that was taken here the
last day; and as the witnesses are here present, Dr. Taylor will have an opportunity of putting any question, which he may deem expedient and necessary on the part of the government. I also wish it to be understood that Dr. Taylor does not attend here as
an ordinary witness, but appears here on the part of Her Majesty's government, to assist me, and also to assist you, in coming to a proper decision upon this inquiry. Every assistance you can obtain that will help you to come to a satisfactory conclusion
in this inquiry is unquestionably desirable; though I doubt not you will experience no difficulty in coming to a proper decision as to the real cause of the deaths of these unfortunate persons.
The Clerk then proceeded to call witnesses.
William Banton was the first witness whose deposition was read.
Cross-examined by the coroner: I live at No. 48 house. I have a wife and five children. All of my children slept in the back room. My children were all of them ill, more or less. They had never been attacked by a similar illness. The bedroom door was
generally open. It was always open. It was open on the night of their illness. The pane of glass in the lattice was shut that night. I think it would be sometimes open in the daytime. I cannot say whether it was open on the day before that night. I never
recollect smelling the sulphurous smell in the house so strong as I did on the Tuesday morning, I never recollect smelling it in the house at all before; I smelt it in the scullery house. I also smelt it in the yard. It was a smell something like powder
smoke, but a heavier smell. By a heavier smell, I mean that it was a smell more strong than powder smoke is. I still stick to it that it was a smell like sulphur. The smell I smelt on the night of the illness of my children was a sulphurous smell.
I was in the house yesterday with Mr. Clarke. The smell I smelt yesterday was the same I smelt on the night of the illness of my children. I live at No. 48, next door to Armstrong's. I was called into the house by Mr. Clarke. I am living now at No. 27 in
the same row. I would know the same sort of smell again if I smelt it. I supplied persons with meal and treacle beer from my shop, who never felt any bad effects from them. The weather was rather wet on Tuesday when my children were taken ill. I cannot
say whether there had been rain immediately before or not; it was very close weather. I do not recollect what the Wednesday previous was; I really cannot say. There was a great change in health of my family after I left No. 48 and came to live at No. 27.
I had lived at No. 27 before, and the health of my family was always better there than at No. 48. In No. 48 I was troubled with great weakness, and pains in my head. Sometimes I had a sort of trembling all over my body. This feeling would continue when I
went to work for a time. When I returned to the house, I was sickly, but not sickly enough to vomit. I did not take my breakfast heartily. I generally breakfasted on tea and dry bread. I cannot tell how much tea and bread I usually took; but I know
sometimes more and sometimes less, but never as much as a working man ought. When I first felt the illness came over me, I was in the front room. I slept in the front room, No. 48. No one was with me but my children and my wife. My wife was often in the
same way particularly on first getting up. I found her better when I came from work in the afternoon between three and four. I kept the door open generally throughout the day, the back door also. The doors were always open when we went to bed at night. I
never felt ill immediately after supper. My wife not being strong, I was frequently in the house at night. My wife has been ill for the last nine or ten weeks. My wife is ill now, but not as she used to be previous to us removing.
The Coroner intimated an opportunity for any gentlemen to put a question to the witness.
Mr. Postlethwaite (to the Coroner); Just ask him (witness) about the ventilation in No. 27 house; ask him whether the ventilation is the same in 48 as it is in No. 27.
Witness: There is one ventilating pane in the back window, and there is a sash window in the front. There is better draft in No. 27 than in No. 48. The back door and the front one is right opposite each other. I have not perceived the same smell in 27 as
I did in 48. I smelt the same smell last Sunday night. It was right in at the door. There is not a door at the bottom of the staircase in No. 27; there is in No.48.
By the Coroner: The staircase door at night is generally kept open, but is closed in the day.
Mary Hall's depositions having been read, she was cross-examined by the Coroner: I live at No. 49, I am quite sure that the smell I smelt is like the smell that comes from water thrown upon hot cinders. I didn't perceive the smell in any part of
the house except the back bedroom.
The depositions of Ann Sloane were next read.
By the Coroner: John Sloane had not taken anything to eat except what I and the others in the house had taken. He had taken the same a week before and was made ill by eating it. I mean by a bad smell, a weakly bad smell. The heaviness of it made
me sleepy. I think it was like sulphur. I had lived in the house three months. As soon as I went into the house, I felt it had a heavy smell. When first I went into Sloane's room that morning I felt a heavy sulphurous smell. I had smelt a sulphurous
smell. I don't know what a sulphurous smell comes from; but sometimes when I was lighting the fire I smelt it. I would be lighting a match, but the smell of sulphur came upon me before I lighted the match. Sloane was vomiting in the bed. He was also very
frothy at his mouth. It was more than once it would just bulge up out of his mouth. I saw it three or four times. I wiped it off three times, and it came again. I perceived a bad smell from it; and no other body would do it but myself. I was bad myself
at the time I helped Sloane. I was sometimes bad myself when I slept in the backroom. If I slept in the daytime I would have a sore head; sore and aching. Two children slept in the backroom. A little lad was taken ill in the room one night, and a girl
went to take care of him. She was sick and weak, and took bad every bit of her. She could eat none at all, only drink. The backroom door, when we sleeping in the room was generally shut. The windowpane was mostly shut, when I went up stairs, I went up
purposely to open the window, finding a bad smell. The bad smell in the room was the same when first we went to it. I always smelt a bad smell in the backroom. I have seen a kettle boil over into the fire. I think the smell in the backroom was worse than
would arise from the boiling over of a kettle of water upon the cinders. I lived at No. 37, next to Banton's. Sloane, during the time he lived with us, never complained of illness. I thought he was a man in fair health. He was always able to go and do
his days work as far as I knew.
By Dr. Clarke: I have lived three months in the house. I felt the same smell in the house the first night, or soon afterwards. When the pump goes wrong, the people to obtain a fresh supply would right it again.
By Mr. Attwood: Sloane was employed at the top of the furnace.
By Dr. Clarke: I don't know how long the houses had been completed before we went to occupy one.
The witness Banton was re-called.
By the Coroner: Since I went out, I have been in 48 and 49 houses. In 49, the smell is stronger than ever I smelt yet. No. 49 is now in the same state as on the morning when I found the Armstrongs dead, only there are two flags taken up. Not withstanding
the two flags being lifted, the smell is stronger a great deal than I first smelt. The back doors were both open. The depth of the holes where the flags were removed is about a foot in the back premises, and a little more at the front. I left a constable
in charge of the whole row. I do not know by whose orders the back doors were opened. When I left yesterday with Dr. Taylor, the doors were both shut.
Frank Sloane, his deposition read, cross-examined by the Coroner: When I went into John Sloan's room he was quite inseusible; I took hold of him, but he did not appear to know that I had hold of him. I saw that he had been vomiting, and was in the
room the night before. The child was taken ill about eleven o'clock at night. I got the child up. I did not go into the room after that until going to assist Sloane. The window was shut.
Mary Murray (mother of Fenton Murray, deceased) her depositions read, cross-examined by the Coroner: My number is 44. My husband is not fit to go to work. He got some medicine from Dr. Wilson yesterday. He has a bad cough, and his breathing
is bad. He mostly was the worst when we went to bed. The smell got worse at night, and we often had to open the windows at night when we went to bed.
By Dr. Clarke: I have always found the same smell in the back kitchen as upstairs.
By the Coroner: I have smelt a bad smell at the back of the house. I was always ill in my stomach. I never had bad health until I came to that house. My husband has had medicine from the doctor, but I have not. My eldest boy always had his health in No.
44.
By Dr. Clarke: I had a bad cough as soon as I went to that house, which has continued ever since. I think my cough has been better since I left it.
By Dr. Wilson: The back kitchen is damp. I was not so sick in the mornings as at nights.
By Dr. Clarke: I have been repeatedly ill since going into the house.
By Mr. Postlethwaite: The midding stead was cleaned nearly every week during the time we were there.
The depositions of Frances Armstrong were next read, after which she was cross-examined by the Coroner.
By Dr. Clarke: The beds were made that morning about 11 o'clock. The sash in the front room was put up before the beds were made. The back window was also opened. There was a draught through the window on that day.
By the Coroner: There were no slops left in the bedroom on that day. We did not wash ourselves upstairs.
By Dr. Clarke: My mother did not say anything about being attacked. She thought her illness was owing to the air.
By the Coroner: When the door was open there was no smell. There was no smell in the room at night either. There was no smell in the room when I came down in the morning. I didn't feel anything likely to choke me upon first going into the room that
night.
By Dr. Fidler: I do not remember what month it was my father went away.
By the Coroner: My father would be from home longer than six months, I think, but I don't know the exact time.
By Mr. Postlethwaite: The door at the bottom of the staircase was open on that night.
By Mr. Attwood: My brother and sister were not affected in the same manner as my mother.
By the Coroner: My brother and sister had been ill about a fortnight. My brother felt ill when he was at work.
James Kitchin, builder, Hensingham, was next called and examined by the Coroner: The foundations of the house are levelled in with slag. The outer wall is six or seven feet. There has been more slag placed there since the completion of the houses,
which may be three feet, and in some four feet. That slag was taken from the furnaces. The slag was carted from the furnaces. I haven't seen it smoke from fire. I have seen what we call a kind of reek. I have been there when the carts were thrown up.
Cinders were also used from the engine-house, but they were not warm when put in. The contract for the houses was, I think, 521 or 531. The rainwater is taken away just over the surface. The rain goes into the background; there are no drains. If the
slagheap is high, it will go into foundation.
By Dr. Clarke: The slag was not put in in a concrete manner.
By Mr. Armstrong: At the time the houses were built there was a descent channel to take the water off.
By the Coroner: The water would go down into the foundation.
By Mr. Armstrong: That would be in consequence of the slag not having been heaped up.
John Thompson was the next witness whose deposition was read over.
The deposition of Dr. Wilson, Fidler, Dickson, Thompson, and Clarke were next read.
Mr. Superintendent Clarke was the next witness called.
The Coroner, as Dr. Taylor would require time to make his report, suggested an adjournment till the following day.
The court adjourned accordingly.
Wednesday
The inquiry was resumed this morning at half-past twelve o'clock.
The Coroner was proceeding to take the evidence of Professor Taylor as he would that of an ordinary witness, when Dr. Taylor remarked that it would perhaps be better that he should read to the court the report he had prepared, as that contained nearly
the whole of the opinion it might be necessary for him to give. The Coroner acquiescing, the Dr. read his report. It was as follows: -
On Monday, June 22, 1857 in company with Superintendent Clarke, I visited and inspected certain houses in Bowthorn-row, where the various cases of death are reported to have occurred. The houses which were specially visited and inspected were those which
are numbered in the plan, No's 49, 48, 47, 46, and 44. No's 16 and 17 were also visited. There was a close unpleasant smell of a similar nature pervading these houses, especially observable in No, 49, which had been closely shut up. It was strongly
perceived in the closets, of which the doors had been closed; but particularly in the small back bedroom, except of the house No, 48 (Banton). In the window of this room, two panes of glass had been broken, which allowed of a certain amount of
ventilation. The pavement of the floor of the house No. 49 were taken up, back and front; that is, in the front room near the door, and in the back room or kitchen also near to the door an excavation was made to about the depth of a foot in each case.
The ground or soil beneath, and in immediate contact with the pavement, was black and damp. It consisted of a black material, resembling ashes, mixed with a quantity of loosely broken slag, the whole forming a loose and porous mass, into which water
could easily penetrate. There was no perceptible warmth in these excavations at the time of the visit. A very offensive smell escaped from both holes. It was more copiously emitted from the soil of the back room or kitchen than from that of the front
room. The smell thus emitted was similar to that which was perceived in the houses visited and in the closets, but stronger. Test papers were applied in both excavations, at the very bottom of each, and the result was that in the period of half an hour
from the time at which these tests were placed in the pit, they clearly, decidedly, and unequivocally indicated the escape of that deadly poisonous gas, sulphuretted hydrogen. In comparing the results it was remarked that the effects were stronger, or
the quantity of this gas which escaped was in the same period of time larger in the excavations of the back room than in that of the front room. It was not considered necessary to raise the pavements in any of the other houses. It was understood that all
were built on the same plan; that there was no drainage from any one, that the floors of were laid on broken slag, with a thin layer of ashes, and that all the rain water which fell was loosely discharged back and front without any means being provided
for this water being carried off. I may remark with regard to the house No, 49, that the window in the lower or front room was a fixture, so that it did not admit of the slightest current of air, and consequently, the only ventilation was by the front
door open through the day, but shut at night. The tiles forming the floor are porous, and the junctures are such as to allow of the passage of liquids and gases. The area of this floor I estimated at about 65 square feet, more or less. The upper back
room (bed room) was without any means of ventilation, excepting by the door and the small pane of glass in the window, 9 inches by 7 inches. In the houses numbered 49, 48, and 44, it was observed that there were spots of discolouration on the painted
woodwork. The doors of the front bedroom, back and front presented these black marks, or stains, in the strongest degree. Portions of the stained woodwork have been cut and tested, and the result of this chemical examination, as well as their appearance,
has led me to the conclusion that the black stains have been caused by the action of sulphuretted hydrogen gas upon the paint. The stains in fact, are due to the formation of sulphate of lead. In No. 49 they were found on the woodwork below and above. In
No. 48 and 44 they were found chiefly on the woodwork of the front bedroom door, and they unequivocally prove that the sulphuretted hydrogen, as a gas, has been diffused at some period or other in the air of the upper and lower rooms. The house No. 16
was visited. The tiles in the floor were very damp. I was informed that it had been shut up, and not inhabited for some time. On entering there was the usual close offensive smell, perceived more or less in all the houses. The junctions of the tiles in
the cement presented a remarkable yellow appearance. This was spread over from 4 to 6 square feet of the tiles, above the centre of the lower front room. A sample of this was collected and has since been analysed. It consists of sulphur, sulphuric acid,
oxide of iron, and a small quantity of lime. This is the residue of the decomposition of iron-slag, under the influence of air and water, and after the sulphuretted hydrogen, one of the products of this chemical change, has escaped.
Analysis Of Slag From No. 49
The slag taken from the excavations made in the back and front rooms of 49 contained lime, allumina, carbonate of lime, and a large proportion of sulphide, or what is termed sulphate of iron. There was no sulphide of calcium present.
The Slag Heap
I at the same time inspected the large accumulation of slag collected at the back of the houses. Samples were taken at various points, some from the surface, and others at from one foot to three or more deep. Samples were also taken from the part
farthest from the houses, as well as from the part near to them. They all presented much the same composition, and all yielded an abundance of the sulphide or sulphurate of iron. Some portions that were near the surface yielded a large quantity of
hydrosulphate of lime. Others from below the surface yielded sulphide of calcium. At a distance of 57 feet from the house No. 49 a hole had been dug to the depth of about three feet, and from this torrents of hot vapour, charged with a large quantity of
sulphuretted hydrogen, was at the time issuing. Other parts, when penetrated, also yielded vapour, showing that there was great heat in the mass below. In some parts towards the edge of the bank of slag, it was at a full red heat. About a foot below the
surface sulphur had sublimed the fissures of the surface of the heap, resembling the appearance seen in the crater of a volcano. The vapour produced by combustion consisted of aqueous, vapour charged with sulphuric acid.
I may observe that the slag taken from the house No. 49, as well as that from the heap was tested for arsenic, but there was no trace of that poison present in either sample. The slagheap is close to the back wall of the houses numbered from 44 to 49. It
is above the level of the back yard in each of these houses, and at the house No. 49 I estimated that it rose at no great distance to a height of from two to three feet above the level of the back yard; hence it follows that any large amount of rain
falling on the slag heap will penetrate through the porous slag and find its way under the floors of the houses, chiefly from No. 49 to 46. To a certain extent this would also happen with respect to the house No. 45 and 44, but the slagheap here slopes
rapidly in a westerly direction, so that a portion of the rainfall will pass out at the rear without going under the foundations. I caused the foundation of the back wall of the house No. 49 to be laid bare, and saw the bottom of it. The wall extended
but a very few inches below the surface of the slag, properly not more than five inches. I found that there was a complete and free communication from the slag of the heap under the back wall to below the whole of the floor of the back and front rooms of
the house, so that any large amount of water falling on this heap would find its way in part under the foundations of this and adjoining houses.
The rain discharged from the roof falls on broken surface of the soil, and penetrate into the slag beneath.
The road in front of the houses is raised in the centre so that on one side there is a tendency of the overflow to find its way to the front of the houses.
On Tuesday, June 23rd, 1857 I attended the adjourned inquest held in this place on the bodies of six persons, into the cause of whose death we are met to inquire. The depositions of all the witnesses previously taken were read in my presence. The
evidence of other witnesses were taken, and by the courtesy of Mr. Lumb, the coroner, such other questions were put as appeared necessary to the formation of an opinion of the cause of death in these cases.
Applying my mind to the evidence thus adduced, to the inspection of the houses, and the locality where these deaths occurred and aided by experiments which I have been enabled to perform, I have come to the conclusion already arrived at by the medical
gentlemen who have given their evidence at this inquest, viz.,
1st. That the six persons deceased, into the cause of whose death we are inquiring, did not die from any natural or unusual form of disease, but that they died from the effects of gaseous poisoning; and my opinion is that the noxious agent was
sulphuretted hydrogen.
This gas did not emanate from the iron furnaces, nor from the surface of the slag heap directly; but it proceed from the rainfall (about the period of the calamity) penetrating the heap and washing the sulphuretted hydrogen beneath the foundations of the
houses, at the back of which it is piled. Further the contact of water with the sulphide of iron contained in the slag produces this poisonous gas, so that the rainwater already containing sulphuretted hydrogen, produced by contact with the iron slag
beneath the houses, a larger amount of this gas would find its way through every crevice or porous material. Thus, then, the action of water on the iron slag is, in my opinion, the cause of the production of this gas. It is going on at all times, in a
ratio proportioned to the undercomposed sulphide of iron present, and the quantity of water which finds its access to the foundation. When once there, there is no escape for the gas but through the floor and the whole of the house. Its evolution at the
period of the calamity was greater by reason of the heavy rain preceding the occurrence, and the heated state of the atmosphere.
It has been given in evidence that the slag laid beneath the floor of the houses was taken fresh from the iron works when the houses were built, about six months since. As it had not been exposed to the air sufficiently long to decompose the sulphide of
iron, it was therefore used in a state most calculated, under a copious supply of water, to produce sulphuretted hydrogen in the largest amount.
That this was the source of the gas, which caused death, appears to me to be proved.
1st. By the discovery of the gas in large quantities, evolved with steam, at a depth of two or three feet below the slagheap.
2nd. By the discovery of the gas actually evolved when the floor was raised on Monday last in the house 49.
3rd. By the presence of such a substance as sulphide of iron in large quantities from the slag of the foundation of the houses as well as from the heap.
4th That there was no other source for its production if we except the presence of sulphide of calcium in the slag heap, which would considerably add to the augment the danger arising from heavy rain falling on the heap. This arises from the fact that
sulphide of calcium is instantly and completely decomposed by water, while sulphide of iron is more slowly decomposed.
That the deadly poisonous gas was evolved beneath the floors and penetrated the house, accumulating in those places where there was the least ventilation and no current of air, is provided.
1st. By the discovery of it in the porous soil beneath the floor.
2nd. By its action on patches of paint in the lower room.
3rd. By the discovery on the floor of a damp house, No. 16, which had not been disturbed for some time, of the oxide of iron sulphur, and sulphuric acid.
This material is the result of the decomposition of sulphide of iron in the slag under exposure to air and moisture. It is the solid part of the decomposed slag, while the sulphuretted hydrogen is the gaseous part.
That this gas was the cause of death is proved by the symptoms and appearances taken as a whole. They are similar to, but more severe and fatal, than those, which I witnessed in 1839 in men working at the tunnel under the Thames (Medical Jurisprudence,
5th edition, 791 pp.) The sulphuretted hydrogen was produced by the action of water trickling through the soil on sulphide of iron contained in the soil.
In conclusion, I beg to make this general observation. Every house built on this fresh iron slag is exposed to dangerous accidents of this kind according to the access of water beneath the foundation. The quantity of fresh slag present beneath the
foundation, the porousucess or imperfection of the floor, and general want of ventilation in the closets or chambers, having no current or air through there, becoming boxes for the reception and circulation of this poison, and the four houses from No. 49
to 46 are so situated, with respect to the slag heap as to the house of death to all who inhabit them with the doors and windows closed, and under heavy rain falls. None can inhabit them without injury to health, if not danger to life. This danger will
exist in all the houses more or less, until the slagheap is entirely decomposed. The houses 49 and 48 will always be dangerous so long as the washing of the slagheap can find their way beneath the foundations.
Alfred Swaine Taylor, M.D, F.R.S
Lecturer on Medical Jurisprudence and Chemistry, Guy's Hospital
Whitehaven, Wednesday, June 24, 1857.
The Professor having enlarged, viva voce, on some of the opinions expressed in his report, corroboratively bearing out those opinions, and answered the inquiries of certain of the jury.
The Coroner announced that the case for the Crown was closed, and wished to know of Mr. Postlethwaite whether he proposed to call witnesses.
Mr. Postlethwaite answering negatively.
The Coroner charged the jury at great length, remarking that from the first hearing of the case his opinion had been similar to that entertained by Dr. Bateman Wilson, who was the only medical practitioner who had gone so far as to give a decided
opinion as to the cause of death, and which opinion Dr. Taylor had unequivocally confirmed. The Coroner concluded by passing encomiums on various gentlemen, including the jury, whose time and services had been engaged upon no fewer than five occasions
during the inquiry.
The jury retired, and after about half-an-hour's deliberation, returned into court with the following.
Verdict
"We find that Joseph Armstrong, the elder, Mary Armstrong, Robert Armstrong, Joseph Armstrong, the younger, John Sloane, and Fenton Murray, have come to their deaths accidentally, and that the cause of death
in all these cases has arisen from the inhalation of sulphuretted hydrogen gas, generated from the slag underneath the houses in which they dwelt, and from adjoining heap of the same material.
"W. B. Clarke, Foreman."
In returning the above verdict, the jury recommend that the houses at Bowthorn-row, built upon the slag from the Hematite Works, should be efficiently drained, and all communication with the adjoining slag heap, through the foundations of the houses, be
effectively cut off; and the jury are further of opinion that the houses so circumstanced cannot be safely occupied till this is done.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Armstrong, —, Mrs. | | | |
| Armstrong, Frances | | | |
| Armstrong, George | | | |
| Armstrong, Joseph | | | |
| Armstrong, Mary | | | |
| Armstrong, Robert | | | |
| Banton, William | | | |
| Clarke, W. B. | | | |
| Grey, George, Sir | | | |
| Hall, Mary | | | |
| Kitchin, James | | | |
| Lumb, William | | | |
| Murray, Fenton | | | |
| Murray, Mary | | | |
| Postlethwaite, J. | | | |
| Sloane, Ann | | | |
| Sloane, Frank | | | |
| Sloane, John | | | |
| Taylor, Alfred, Dr. | | | |
| Taylor, Alfred Swaine | | | |
| Wilson, Bateman, Dr. | | | |