|
29th January 1857 Alleged Case Of AbuseCharles McGuiness was placed in the dock, charged by James McQuillim with having assaulted him, on his road home from William Pit, about eight weeks ago. Mr. Musgrave defended the prisoner; the complainant was unrepresented. Complainant stated that, about eight weeks ago, when he was returning home from William Pit, where he worked, he met the prisoner, Charles McGuiness, who stopped him until John McGuiness, a brother of the prisoner, came up. Charles McGuiness told complainant that his brother would fight him. John McGuiness set upon complainant, and, after a short tussle, complainant fell. While complainant was upon the ground, Charles McGuiness kicked him, and struck him violently. Since that period; he had been lame; and his lameness he attributed to the injury he sustained from Charles McGuiness. A witness, named Henry Hutchinson, corroborated the statement of complainant, and stated, that both complainant and Charles and John McGuiness had been examined before Mr. Bourne, colliery steward, who considered the boys were as bad as each other, and who assured them, that the next time they quarrelled they should all be sent to Bransty, and there be whipped. Mr. Musgrave addressed the Bench on behalf of the prisoner, contending that it was quite probable, such was the nature of chronic disease, that the lameness complained of by McQuillim, and alleged to be the result of McGuiness' violence towards him, was the development of past violence, it might be, of a blow struck by even the boy's own mother in his early life. Mr. Musgrave then proceeded to call witnesses. John Kirkbride swore that he saw the boys fighting, and that Charles McGuiness did not, as he saw of, either strike or kick complainant. The Bench, while of opinion that the evidence was incomplete, and insufficient to justify them in convicting the prisoner, directed the father to chastise his sons, and on the father promising to do so, the Bench ordered the prisoner to be discharged.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||