Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th December 1856, Page: 2, Column: 4

Blaenavon

Four Men Suffocated In A Coal Pit

Inquest Upon The Bodies

On Saturday last, an inquest was held at the King's Arms Inn, Blaenavon, before C. M. Ashwin, Esq., deputy coroner, on view of the bodies of Charles Young, aged 51, married ; William Evans, 37, married ; James Young (alias Taylor), 28, single and John Taylor, 47, married ; who were suffocated in Dick Shon's Level, the property of the Blaenavon Iron Company, on Monday, the 15th inst.

The following gentlemen were sworn to serve on the jury :— Messrs. William Henry George (foreman), William Anthony, John Edward Williams, John Morgan, James Young, William Harris, George Harris, William Rees, Charles Smith, John Wheeler, William Davies, and William Morgan.

Mr. Llewellin, of Newport, appeared to watch the proceedings on behalf of the company, and Herbert F. Mackworth, Government Inspector of Mines, was also present.

After the jury were sworn, they proceeded to view the bodies, and were absent about an hour. Upon their return, the following witnesses were called :—

Edward Prosser said : I am the overman at the Blaenavon collieries ; on Tuesday morning last, the 16th inst., about ten minutes past six o'clock, I went into Dick Shon's Level, which is the property of the Blaenavon Iron Company. Richard Jones, I think, is the name of the man who accompanied me. After I had got about three quarters of a mile from the mouth of the level, I found the body of John Taylor. He was lying upon his face, with his head towards the mouth of the level. [Witness pointed out upon a plan produced the place in which he found the body.] I found the body about ninety yards from the flue. I turned back, and met some of the colliers who were coming in, I procured assistance, and returned with James Parker. We found the other three bodies close together, not far from the old flue — about twenty or thirty yards. [The relative position of the bodies and the flue or furnace were pointed out upon the plan.]

Mr. Llewellin explained that the object of the flue, which was placed at the extremity of the works, was to provide for the ventilation of the level. At this time the flue was being repaired, and there was no fire in the furnace.

Examination resumed: The men were all dead, and appeared to have been so for many hours, for the bodies were quite cold.

By Mr. Llewellin: On Saturday, the 13th, I was improving the flue, enlarging it from 2ft. 6in. to 5ft. John Taylor was the contractor for doing the work, and was paid 18s. per yard for cutting. He employed men to assist him, and that night the three other men deceased were assisting him. On Saturday I found that the coal in the old flue pit had become ignited. It caught fire from the flue, and blazed up into the shaft of the pit. The flames were to be seen at the bottom of the pit. We turned the water into the pit about mid-day on Saturday, to endeavour to put out the fire. This had the effect of turning the air back in the pit. Charles Young (one of the deceased) and Richard Keir were with me. When we found the air was affected, we turned off the water, and I sent Charles Young into the pit to request the men to come out. They did so, about four o'clock. Afterwards we again turned on the water into the pit, and it was allowed to flow until Sunday night, when it was stopped about nine o'clock. On Monday morning, about seven o'clock, I went into the level, and found that the fire had not been extinguished. I found John Taylor, James Young, George Young, John Evans, jun., John Jackson, and Richard Keir at the flue. William Evans was about ninety yards from the flue. We had some conversation about the fire, and John Taylor proposed that I should put a dam across the drift, so as to keep the water up. He asked me to allow a boy to be sent for a mason to get it done directly, but I would not allow it until the men were just coming out. John Taylor said it would not be dangerous, but I said it would be certain death to them if they staid there after the wall was put up. I told them the water should run until the fire was quenched, and they were not any account to go in the level until I saw in the morning whether it would be safe, and we agreed to meet in the morning. The dam was put up, and the water turned into the pit ; but at that time there was no person in that portion of the pit. The water was turned in about six o'clock on Monday morning. As soon as I turned the water on, I was told by Benjamin Eynon, a haulier, that there was no person in the pit. If there had been any person in the pit, I could hear those who were working at the dam. I had before been in conversation with them ; the pit was only about twenty yards deep. The deceased went in of their own accord, notwithstanding my warning. Before turning on the water I told John Evans, the mason, who was making the dam, to be careful to see that all the men came out after putting the dam in.

By Mr. Mackworth: John Taylor was a contractor, but the other three usually worked for the company by the day. Upon this occasion, however, they were paid by Taylor, and worked for him in order to get a little extra money. They were labourers engaged in the windway, but this was extra working they were doing for Taylor. I did not set these men to work for Taylor. When the men were found, their dinner wallets were upon their backs ; they appeared to have been overpowered before they had time to take off their upper clothes. I could not tell from the appearance of the candles whether they had been lighted for any length of time. When I went in on Tuesday morning, I did not smell the bad air until after I had passed the place where the body of John Taylor was lying. The water was running the whole of the time ; the stream was not larger than my wrist. The air was very bad where the other three bodies were found, and one of the men who went with me fainted ; he, however, soon recovered after being removed some distance from the spot. The candles burnt very well. The smell was very similar to that of fire-damp, and therefore not easily distinguished. There was no smell of sulphur. The coal was on fire on Tuesday morning, when I went into the level, and is burning still. The flue was put out about six weeks ago, and since that time we have observed a considerable heat in the pit, but the coal was not discovered to be on fire until Saturday morning. The wall which was put up was not water-tight, although it was intended to be so — it allowed the water to soak through, and did not stop it at all. The gas from the fire must have come through the dam to the place where the bodies were found, for thera was no other way for it to come there. For five weeks past, John Taylor had been engaged in improving the furnace drift, and the aircourse generally. He was to put in a furnace 5 ft. wide, instead of one of 3 ft. 6in. He was also to increase the width of the shaft to five feet. The old flue was in the three-quarter coal, and the air course went nearly perpendicularly up about five yards, to the big coal. I think the size of that course was about twenty inches to two feet wide. I have been through the flue to the big coal, and it was as much as I could do to get there by creeping upon my belly. It is the big coal which is now on fire. I have only been a little way through the flue into the big coal, but not to the bottom of the upcast pit, where the coal was on fire.

By the Jury : The flue is driven in the solid coal.

By Mr. Mackworth: The dam was put in the strata near the top of the three-quarter coal. John Taylor ought not to have gone in on Tuesday until I had seen that everything was safe. The colliers generally went in about six o'clock in the morning, but some of them, I have been informed, go in about four or five o'clock, for as it was a level they could go in when they liked. I have never seen men go in so early. The level was open, the same as all other levels in the country. I am the overman over the whole of the collieries of the company. Richard Keir is under me, and to him is entrusted the safety of the men in the work. He had roadmen under him, who had to go into the levels to see that everything I was safe. I have had the rules of the colliery, and I have given a copy to every man in the work, through the contractors. It was Richard Keir's duty to see that the level was free from gas, and that it was generally safe. It was the duty of the fireman, if he saw any danger, to put up cross timbers and a board. On Tuesday morning, as I went into the level, I saw no cross-timbers or a board put up.

Mr. Mackworth read the rule which showed that it was the duty of the proper person appointed to put up cross timbers and a board to prevent persons from going to any place which the workmen were not to enter.

Witness : The men had no business to go into the flue.

Mr. Mackworth: And yet no timbers and a board were put up.

Witness : I might as well have put the timber at the mouth of the level.

Mr. Mackworth : I think that would have been the better course. Could you not have put up a gate at the mouth of the level ?

Witness : I might have done so ; but if I did the men would have broken it down. Where there is fire in a pit a board is put up, with the word "Fire," upon it.

Mr. Llewellin thought the witness no doubt conceived that his caution was sufficient to prevent any person from going into the pit.

Mr. Mackworth said proper precautions should have been taken to prevent any person from going into the level under the circumstances.

The witness, in answer to Mr. Llewellin, said he never saw a gate upon the mouth of a level.

Mr. Mackworth said a man ought to be constantly kept at the mouth of the level to prevent men from going in at improper periods.

Witness, in answer to Mr. Mackworth : There is nothing to prevent a man from walking into firedamp or any other danger, if they choose to go in before the regular time. The men should not go in until after Richard Keir has been round to see all safe — or at least until the men under him have been around. There is no particular time appointed for the firemen to meet the colliers at the pit, nor do the colliers, wait for them, because there is no fire in the pit. If there is any other kind of danger, the firemen return and caution the colliers. Mr. Dodd is the viewer of the colliery, and it was by his orders that I commenced enlarging the flue. I received no directions from Mr. Dodd to extinguish the fire, for he was not at home at the time. One of the rules states that the overman shall suspend all works of a dangerous nature until he receives directions from the viewer. When I discovered the fire I did not wait for instructions from Mr. Dodd, as it would be dangerous to delay. I did not turn on the water before holding a consultation with others engaged in the work.

Thomas Jones said : I am a labourer in the employment of the Blaenavon Iron Company. I met the deceased on Monday evening, about half-past seven o'clock, on the rubbish tip, and gave them a light from my candle. I asked John Taylor the reason he was going to work double turns, and he said he was not to go in, but he had a reason for it. That was all which passed between us, and I wished him good night. When Taylor said he was not to go in, I understood him to mean that he had orders not to go in. I did not speak to either of them except Taylor. My duty in the level is to kepp the fire in a flue, but not in the part where the men were suffocated. It was about six o'clock on Tuesday morning, when I heard that the men were dead.

Benjamin Eynon said : I am a haulier, and work in Dick Shon's level. I saw the deceased and other men coming out of the pit on Monday afternoon, about five o'clock ; but they did not say anything to me about their going back to work that evening. I saw the deceased again about seven o'clock the same evening, but did not speak to them. I heard Taylor talking to the last witness, but did not hear the words used. I met him about two hundred yards from the level, but did not see them going in. I did not know whether there was any danger in the level, and was not cautioned about going in. I had nothing to do with that portion of the pit, and was never at the flue.

Richard Keir said: I am contractor for getting coal, under the Blaenavon Company. I have contracted for Dick Shon's level. I know where the flue was being repaired, but I had not contracted to do any of the work, and had not the charge of the safety of the men there. I had charge of the colliers and hauliers, wherever coal is got in the level. I went with Prosser, on Monday, to the flue, about seven o'clock. We had a conversation with John Taylor, Charles Young, and James Young. Evans was not present. There were two or three boys there, and I believe Jackson was there. We had been trying to put out the fire on Saturday, and as it was not extinguished, we had a conversation as to the best mode of doing so. Taylor proposed that a "bay," or dam, should be built across the wind-drift in order to smother the fire. I stated objections to the plan, observing that I did not know how the bay was to be afterwards taken away, because foul air would be accumulated, and that the water would be kept back. John Taylor said there would be no difficulty ; he could get the bay out. It was ultimately agreed that the bay should be placed there, and Prosser and myself charged the men not to go near the flue or dam until the water was from there. I expected there would be foul air there, in consequence of the ventilation being stopped. There was danger from both the air and water ; but I expected the water would have found its way from there, either through the earth or the pit, and that in a few days we would be able to remove the bay. We had a conversation as to the capability of the dam to keep up the water. Both myself and Prosser cautioned the men not to go to the spot after the bay was placed there, and pointed out to them the danger of doing so.

By Mr. Mackworth: I expected three or four days would elapse before the water would have entirely gone away. I am sure that John Taylor perfectly understood he was not to go to work until the water had gone away from the place. Prosser never gave me any directions to attend to this part of the work, but he one day asked me to go up to the flue and see that the coal was properly taken out before the flue was made, so that there would be no danger of its taking fire. I had charge of the wind-road in my own work, but not in this. I have nothing to do with the flue, but I must maintain the horse-road to get out the coal. If there is an old heading in the work I consider it my duty to put up the timber for the sake of the safety of the men. Isaac Evans, who is employed by me, goes round one portion of the work to see that it was all safe. John Evans goes upon that side where the accident happened ; he is a labourer, and I have charged him to go round the work every morning. He goes in about six o'clock, and meets the men at different places. Sometimes the men would go in before him — occasionally as early as two or three o'clock in the morning — but we have no means of preventing them from doing so. If locked gates were placed to prevent men going in they might succeed in doing so, but they must be very strong indeed, or they would soon be broken down. If the roof is bad there would be no means of cautioning those who went in before the fireman.

By Mr. Llewellin: It is unusual to have gates upon levels. I have never seen fire-damp in this level ; but I have observed black damp.

By Mr. Mackworth : If we find that the black damp is dangerous we put up signals. I had a copy of the rules produced given to me for the first time about three months ago. There has been sufficient time since then to put up gates, but they have not been thought necessary. Since the rules were distributed, I have had directions to caution the colliers not to go to work until they see, by a chalk mark, whether the fireman have been in their stalls. I cannot say whether the men have been told they are not to go in until they meet the fireman.

By Mr. Llewellin : The men understand perfectly that they are to be under the directions of the fireman.

By Mr. Mackworth : If there is danger in a stall a board is put up with the word "Danger" written upon it. If they go in before the fireman goes into the work there is nothing to prevent them from going into danger ; but they have no business to go in until the fireman has been there.

By Mr. Llewellin : I have had no complaint that the firemen do not do their duty. The men rely upon the firemen and myself attending to them.

By Mr. Mackworth : I should think it was Mr. Prosser's duty to put up cross timbers and a board at the flue. No workmen had any business at the flue except the men who were themselves cautioned. Since we have had the rules we have always put up danger signals where necessary. I should not consider it necessary to put up cross-timbers at the flue, as the only men who worked there were charged not to go there.

John Evans, said : I built the "bay" or dam in the flue of Dick Shon's Level. Mr. Prosser told me to build the bay, and cautioned me after going out that I was not to go in again. The four men deceased, and two boys were present, and heard the directions. John Taylor said he had been well acquainted with underground work for many years. By that I understood him to mean that he knew when there was danger. I saw the whole of the men leaving the pit that night but did not hear any of them saying that they would go to work again. I understood Prosser to mean that the work at that was to be stopped, until he gave fresh directions. The wall was built of nine-inch bricks, and was built quite up to the roof. The water was not turned down before we left the place. When Prosser gae the caution he was at the top of the pit, but we could hear him very well, and it was then that John Taylor remarked that he knew all about underground work as well as he did.

The Deputy-Coroner said if the jury wished to have the evidence read over he would read it to them, but he thought himself that it was quite unnecessary after the patient investigation which had been made.

The jury concurred in this opinion, and retired to consider their verdict. After an absence of ten minutes they returned into the room with a verdict of "Accidental Death."


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Anthony, William      
Ashwin, C. M.      
Davies, William      
Dodd, —      
Evans, Isaac      
Evans, John      
Evans, John, jun.      
Evans, William      
Eynon, Benjamin      
George, William Henry      
Harris, George      
Harris, William      
Jackson, John      
Jones, Richard      
Jones, Thomas      
Keir, Richard      
Llewellin, —      
Mackworth, Herbert F.      
Morgan, John      
Morgan, William      
Parker, James      
Prosser, Edward      
Rees, William      
Smith, Charles      
Taylor, John      
Wheeler, John      
Williams, John Edward      
Young, Charles      
Young, James      
Young, James      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
20 Dec 1856  Blaenavon, Four Men Suffocated (The Monmouthshire Merlin)
27 Dec 1856  Blaenavon, Four Men Suffocated In A Coal Pit, Inquest Upon The Bodies (The Monmouthshire Merlin)

Links to related pages

 

Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 18 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print