Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th October 1856, Page: 3, Column: 3

The Fatal Accident At Brynmally

On Saturday last, an inquest was held on the body of Robert Kenrick, the unfortunate man who was killed on the previous Wednesday, whilst changing the buckets in the engine-pit of the Brynmally works, at the house of Mr. John Clay, the Tunnel Tavern; before B. H. Thelwall, Esq., coroner. The following were sworn on the jury :— Mr. Thomas Lloyd, (foreman) Messrs W. Griffiths, John Clay, Patrick Nolan, David Hughes, Ephraim Clay, Edward Rowe, William Williams, Henry Jones, Richard Jones, Robert Griffiths, and Jonathan Hughes. — The jury after being sworn proceeded to the house of the deceased to inspect the body, and after their return

John Kenrick, brother of deceased was first examined. He is a collier, and works in No 1 pit at the Brynmally works. On the evening of Wednesday, the 8th inst., his brother, the deceased, with another man went down the engine pit to put in new buckets to the pump. This pit altogether is about 160 yards deep, but he was standing on a shaft or stage from 50 to 55 yards down. He, the witness, was close at the pit's mouth and could see his brother below on the shaft. He was then lifting up the rod in order to change the buckets, but from some cause he could not get it out. This was probably caused by the leather of the bucket lapping over, having been worn out. The buckets are usually changed every week or fortnight, but since the late accident and the incessant action of the pump, they required to be changed every three hours. On these occasions, in order to draw up the bucket, a chain is fastened to the pump rods, and it is worked on a capstan on the top of the pit. Eight men were working it on that evening, and as they were not enough, he called three or four other men who were by to assist. It was a thick strong chain and has been in use for the last 18 or 19 years, and it was not perceptibly corroded. Suddenly this chain broke in two, about 10 yards from the top he should think, and the remainder fell down the shaft. He saw his brother fall, but did not think that the chain hit him. He was inclined to believe that his brother, who had hold of the rod, fell with it heavily on a lower shaft 7 yards below, and was thus killed. That was his opinion. It was his duty, as engineer, to look to the chain and the other gearing. In answer to the coroner he stated, that he himself saw no defect in the chain. This witness then detailed at some length the process attending the changing of the buckets, at which time only the chain is ever used, and added that no accident ever occurred with it before, although the buckets have occasionally stuck fast in the pumps. He himself did not know of any method by which the buckets could be prevented from corroding and wearing out. When he went down into the pit, his brother was lying on the second shaft quite dead, with the chain close by but not touching him He had worked for Mr. Clayton some 4 or 5 years.

Mr. Frederick Hutchinson, clerk to the company, produced the broken link which caused the accident, and also the half of another link in two to show the quality of the iron. The deceased, he said, was the engineer and pitman of the engine pit, and it was his duty to see to everything connected with it. He was a very active and energetic man, and since the accident had occurred, he had been most anxious that the gearing and everything belonging to the engine should be in good order, as amongst other motives some of his own relatives were among the sufferers. So anxious was he, that Mr. Clayton had to drive him away several times that he might have a little rest, but he would return again in a very short time, This anxiety and excitement had almost rendered him reckless, for he was usually very cool and collected, although if necessity required it, he could be as active as a cat. He was a very bold, good workman, and shrank from performing no duty. The men were naturally anxious to change the buckets as quickly as possible, and so expert was he that he had been known to change them in 15 minutes, although it took half an hour to do it ordinarily. He had three or four men always under him. Mr. Hutchinson then produced the link which appeared much lengthened, as if it had been drawn so by some great weight. It had not been snapped off or broken, but seemed as if it had opened at the welding at the transverse end. He explained that the weight it would have to sustain was about one ton.

The Coroner remarked it was important that much attention should be paid to the buckets, otherwise they would break all the chains in the world. He wished to know if some plan could not be invented to prevent them curling up after the leather was worn out ?

Mr. Hutchinson said, he believed an invention had just been patented which would meet the difficulty to some extent, by means of iron rings; but those in general use were the same as those used by them. They would last, under ordinary circumstances about a fortnight, and as more time could then be taken in changing them there was little or no danger. It was the urgency of the case and the desire to change them so quick that caused the danger. He then made some remarks in relation to the water which he said was of a most remarkable taste. It tasted like Spa water, and was evidently full of dissolved minerals which it held in solution.

The Coroner then called attention to the Government rules for the regulation of mines, and wished to know whether a copy of the same was supplied to all the workmen ?

Mr. Hutchinson: Yes, a copy is given to each man.

The Coroner: In Welsh as well as English ?

Mr. Hutchinson: No, not in Welsh.

On the Coroner observing that he thought it very desirable that the rules should be printed in Welsh, Mr. Hutchinson promised that Welsh copies should be printed and distributed at once.

The Coroner then went on to say in the 20th Rule mention was made of the "head banksman" whose duty it was to examine daily the ropes, chains, and gearing of the pit under his charge. He wished to know who was the head banksman of the engine pit ?

Mr. Kyrke and Mr. Hutchinson explained that there was no head banksman at the engine pit, so that in this instance the rule could only apply to the working pit. The head banksman in this locality was the person who was head of those who took away the coal from the pytches, and was not an engineer at all.

The Coroner: The rule could never mean this individual who might only be a common labourer, whereas it required a person of some scientific acquirements to properly examine pit gearing.

Mr. Kyrke said, there could be no doubt but what the rules were very indefinitely worded and evidently wanted a revision.

Samuel Warburton was then examined. He I said, I have worked at the engine pit under deceased for about 4 years, aud on Wednesday evening I was down the engine pit with him, as I always went to assist him in changing the buckets. We were standing side by side on the stage at the first lift, and had both of us hold of the rod with our left hands. The rod was fast in the barrel, and we shook it in order to loosen it. The deceased held in his right hand a wire by which the signal for raising or lowering is given, to the engineer above. He said to me, "stop a bit, I'll lower it," and he then gave four knocks by means of the wire. That was the signal for lowering, and the men at the capstan above lowered the chain until the deceased, seeing that it began to double, as the rod still continued fast, stopped them, fearful of the chain being jerked when it was again raised. He then knocked five times which was the signal for raising, I did not hear or feel the chain jerk, but when it was pulled tight I heard it break. I jumped instantly to the other side of the stage to save my life, and did not see the deceased alive again. In about five minutes I heard him groan once. The chain was broken from pulling and not by a jerk. He also believed that the deceased was not struck by the chain but fell with the rod, but could not say for a certainty. The chain is a good chain, but he would much rather trust to a rope than a chain, because any defect in it could be more easily discovered.

Mr. Kyrke stated, that his father who was formerly owner of the mine, ordered the chain 18 or 19 years ago. It was made without regard to expense, and the very best iron was put into it. It had been tried at Liverpool and has proved to bear ten tons weight. He had seen the man who made it but a few days ago, and he informed him (witness) that it was made of the very best iron. It had never broken before; but it had probably done more work during the last fortnight than it had in any one or even two years before, as it was only used to raise the rods when the buckets required changing.

The Coroner said, it was unnecessary for him to make any remarks to the jury as they could all remember the whole of the evidence. There could be no doubt that the man's death was caused by the breaking of the chain, and it was for them to say whether it broke in consequence of some defect or in consequence of some fault in the management of the machinery.

After a short consultation, the jury returned a verdict that "The deceased accidentally met with his death in consequence of the breaking of a defective chain and the jury recommended, that for the future, a rope be used to raise the pump rods instead of a chain."


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Clay, Ephraim    Juror  
Clay, John    Inn Keeper  
Clay, John    Juror  
Clayton, —    Mine Owner  
Griffiths, Robert    Juror  
Griffiths, W.    Juror  
Hughes, David    Juror  
Hughes, Jonathan    Juror  
Hutchinson, Frederick    Company Clerk  
Jones, Henry    Juror  
Jones, Richard    Juror  
Kendrick, Robert    Collier  Deceased, Individual Page
Kenrick, John    Collier  
Kyrke, —    Mine Owner  
Lloyd, Thomas    Jury Foreman  
Nolan, Patrick    Juror  
Rowe, Edward    Juror  
Thelwall, B. H.    Coroner  
Warburton, Samuel    Collier  
Williams, William    Juror  



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
30 Sep 1856  Inundation Of The Brynmally Mines (Annual Register for 1856)
04 Oct 1856  The Catastrophe At Brynmalley And The Case Of Manslaughter (Wrexham and Denbighshire Weekly Advertiser)
04 Oct 1856  Dreadful Occurrence At The Brynmally Colliery, Thirteen Lives Supposed To Be Lost (Wrexham and Denbighshire Weekly Advertiser)
10 Oct 1856  Fearful Coal Mine Inundation, Wrexham, Thursday (The Welshman)
11 Oct 1856  The Catastrophe At The Brynmally Colliery (Wrexham and Denbighshire Weekly Advertiser)
18 Oct 1856  The Fatal Accident At Brynmally (Wrexham and Denbighshire Weekly Advertiser)

Links to related pages

 

Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page
Memorial Page  Memorial images gallery

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print