|
9th October 1856 Arbitration CasePerry V AttwoodAt the last Cumberland assizes, an action was brought by Mr. Wilson Perry, solicitor, of this town, to recover certain royalty rents under a deed of lease, from Messrs J. H. and H. Attwood, of Hazel Holme, near Whitehaven. After opening the case, it was agreed to refer the matter in dispute to arbitration, John Monk, Esq., barrister-at-law, being the party selected to inquire into, and determine upon, the questions at issue, for which purpose, on Friday, Mr. Monk opened a Court in the Globe Hotel Assembly Room, Mr. Temple, QC., instructed by Mr. Postlethwaite, solicitor, Cross Street, appeared for the plaintiff; and Mr. Manesty, instructed by Messrs Brockbank and Helder, for the defence. The preliminaries having been arranged, Mr. Temple briefly stated the case. In the month of March, 1846, the plaintiff and the late Mr. Robert Jefferson granted a lease of certain mines at Woodend, near Whitehaven, for 21 years, at a fixed rent of £400 a year, in addition to which there was to be a rent of 2s 9d per ton for every ton of iron ore which the defendants raised during the term of their lease. The lease set forth the number and nature of the books to be kept by Messrs Attwood for showing the quantity of ore raised, and that such books should be open to the inspection of the lessees, or their properly-authorised agents. By the terms of the agreement, it was understood that the royalty ton should consist of 10 kibbles of a certain size, which would contain about 35cwt. The defendants continued to work the mines, and to render accounts periodically, until the month of July, 1855, when, from a conversation which Mr. Postlethwaite, who was then acting as the agent of the plaintiff, had with Mr. Attwood, it transpired that the kibbles used by the defendants were so large, that 10 of them, instead of containing only 35cwt, would in reality contain 48cwt; and the plaintiff alleged that payment of the royalty rent had been evaded on the difference between 35cwt and 48cwt, on every ton of iron ore which had been raised. Mr. Temple observed that it might be contended on the part of the defendants that they had used bogies instead of kibbles, and that 5 bogies contained 35cwt, or a royalty ton, and that they were returned as such. In that case, though the plaintiff had in reality been no loser, yet he contended that, according to the terms of the lease, the defendants were not entitled to use the bogie, but only the kibbles of such capacity that 10 would contain a royalty ton of 35cwt. If bogies were used instead of kibbles, he should be able to show that it was without the knowledge or consent of the plaintiff, and, so far at least, was an evasion of the terms of the lease. But the defendants did not stop here. He contended that the defendants were only entitled to heap the kibbles to such an extent as would make up for the cavities below; but instead of being content with this, he thought he should be able to show that they had resorted to various contrivances to heap more ore upon the kibbles or bogies than they were entitled to do. For this purpose they had a carriage constructed, technically called a "tram," in such a manner as to carry a kibble in a perfectly horizontal position up an incline, and thus prevent the heaped-up ore from falling off. They had also bevelled the edges of the kibbles and bogies, and they or their servants had been in the habit of making a wall round the rim of the kibbles and bogies, in order to enable them to heap on more ore. Those were some of the circumstances into which they would have to inquire; and if he should prove that such evasions had been practised, he thought there would be no difficulty in determining the amount to which the plaintiffs were entitled. Mr. Temple then proceeded to take evidence. Up to Wednesday night, 40 witnesses had been examined for the plaintiff, and about 15 more remained to be examined. On Monday, the arbitrator inspected the mines, but it is impossible to say when the case will close, as there are upwards of 50 witnesses to be examined for the defence.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||