2nd June 1855, Page: 3, Column: 1
The Wear Valley Railway
Court of Chancery. — Monday.
Meynell and Others v. Surtees and Others.
The bill was filed for the specific performance of an
agreement to grant a way-leave for a railway on the
payment yearly of triple damages. In March, 1843,
John Charles Ord was entitled in fee simple to the equity
of redemption of certain pieces of land which were subject
to a mortgage to the Newcastle-upon-Tyne Joint
Stock Banking Company, with a power of sale. The
Derwent Iron Company being the owners of the Wear
and Derwent Railway, were desirous of connecting it
with the Bishop Auckland and Weardale Railway, so as
to obtain access to the ports of Stockton and Middleton
on the river Tees, and having obtained the co-operation
of the Stockton and Darlington Railway Company, they
employed Mr. Emerson Muschamp, as their agent, to
obtain the necessary way-leaves for the extension railway
from the landowners through whose estates it was
to be carried. Among others, application was made to
Mr. Ord and the mortgagees of his land, and they received
an offer in writing of a lease of a way-leave for
60 years, by the yearly payment of triple damages. Relying
on this offer, the Derwent Iron Company entered into
an agreement with the plaintiffs, who are the directors
of the Stockton and Darlington Company, by which
£10,000 was lent at interest by the Derwent Company
to the Stockton and Darlington Company, and the latter
agreed to make the line of railway, the plaintiffs to be
the absolute owners of the line, and the Derwent Company
to assign to them the way-leaves they had obtained
from the landowners. In the meantime Mr. Ord became
bankrupt, and the mortgagees being allowed to keep the
land to pay themselves, a correspondence took place between
their solicitor and Mr. Muschamp, and it appeared
to be finally arranged that the way-leave was granted,
and that the rent was to be £36 or £51 yearly, the
surveyors differing about the value to that extent. In 1845
the railway was completed, and in September, 1846, the
banking company for the first time made a demand of a
rent of £100 a-year, and shortly afterwards they sold the
land to Mr. Surtees, the brother-in-law of Ord. In 1847
Surtees disputed the right of way-leave, and commenced
an action of ejectment to obtain possession of the land on
which the railway had been made. A bill was filed for
an injunction, and no proceedings were taken in the
matter for the next five years, but in October, 1851,
the estate came into the possession of Mr. Ralph Walters,
and he moved in April, 1852, to dissolve the injunction.
The cause was heard before the Vice-Chancellor Parker,
and he ordered the plaintiffs to pay into court a sum
of £400 to abide the issue of the suit, and continued
the injunction till the hearing of the cause. At
this stage of the proceedings the plaintiffs obtained an
act of Parliament empowering them to sell their interest
in he extension line to the Wear Valley Railway Company,
but they allege they have been unable to fulfil their
contract in consequence of not possessing a formal grant
of way-leave over the land of Mr. Ord, now in the possession
of the defendants. Mr. Surtees, in his answer
denied that the £51 a year tendered by the plaintiffs was
an adequate sum for the way-leave, and stated that,
according to the terms of the agreement with Ord, the
railway was to have been made merely for agricultural
purposes, the conveyance of lime, manure, &c., while it
turned out to be a public highway for conveying passengers
and goods. The matter was heard by the Vice Chancellor Stuart
in November last, and his Honour
dismissed the plaintiffs' bill, declaring that on the true
construction of the agreement the defendants were not
bound to grant a lease on the terms of triple damages.
Mr. Malins was now heard in support of an appeal
from this decree. Mr. Smythe and Mr. de Gex are on
the same side. Mr. Walker and Mr. Goven appear for
the defendant Surtees ; Mr. Bacon and Mr. Stevens for
Mr. Walters ; Mr. Wigram, Mr. Smale, and Mr. Southgate
for other defendants.
The arguments were not concluded.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bacon, — | | | |
| Gex, de | | | |
| Goven, — | | | |
| Malins, — | | | |
| Muschamp, Emerson | | Agent | |
| Ord, John Charles | | Land Owner | |
| Parker, — | | Vice-Chancellor | |
| Smale, — | | | |
| Smythe, — | | | |
| Southgate, — | | | |
| Stevens, — | | | |
| Stuart, — | | Vice Chancellor | |
| Surtees, — | | Land Owner | |
| Walker, — | | | |
| Walters, Ralph | | Land Owner | |
| Wigram, — | | | |