Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th March 1855, Page: 2, Column: 5

Durham Spring Assizes

Working Of Collieries

Important To The Coal Trade

Monday, March 5

His Lordship took his seat on the Bench at ten o'clock and proceeded with the following case :—

Working Of Collieries — Important To The Coal Trade

Smart v. Morton. — (Special Jury.)

Mr. Watson, Q.C., and Mr. Manisty were for the plaintiffs ; and Mr. Knowles, Q.C., and Mr. Unthank for the defendant.

Mr. Watson said the plaintiffs in the case were Mr. Smart and Mr. H. J. Spearman, and the action was brought against the defendant, Mr. Morton, for working coal underneath the land of the plaintiffs, which caused it to subside, by which means the surface had been considerably damaged. Mr. Smart and Mr. Spearman did not sue in their own right, but as the trustees of Mr. Standish, of Cocken Hall, who was really and truly the plaintiff in the action. The question they (the jury) would have to decide was nothing more nor less than the damage which the plaintiff had sustained by the manner in which the defendant had worked the mines. They were, perhaps, well aware that in modem times it had been the practice to work out the coals without leaving any pillars standing to support the superincumbent mass — that practice was, he believed introduced by Mr. Buddle in 1810, but up to that time all the coal mines had been worked with pillars left standing for support. When this new plan was, however, introduced many of the old mines were taken merely for the purpose of working the pillars which had been left standing during the former working. The mines in question were conveyed by Sir Ralph Cole, of Brancepeth Castle, to Ralph Carr, Esq., on the 29th of December, 1672, in consideration of the sum of £3375. Up to a recent period the mines had been worked in the ancient manner, but Mr. Morton for the last few years has been working out the pillars of the coal mine, the land had subsided, and a very serious injury has been done to the ground, and it was for this permanent damage to the land, that the plaintiffs now sought to recover. The mode of estimating the amount of damage would be to calculate what the selling price of the land was before the damage occurred, and what it is now. There had also been injury done to the houses on the land, and that would also be a question for them as to what amount of damage they would give. There were two issues raised in the caw. the defendants said that by the deed in question acts — they did were merely an exercise of the powers contained in that deed. But that could not be so, for the power given in the deed was power for working the mines of coal, but they had no right so to work the coal as to let down the surface of the land. The reservations in the deed were only for power to enter upon the land, to make shafts and obtain way leaves for the purpose of carrying the coal away. There was no power and no authority given under these deeds so to work the coal as to let down the surface of the land. It was not the practice so to work when the coal was let, and upon that point there have been several cases decided. Therefore upon the first issue he should contend that it would be for his lordship to tell them that it was not necessary for exercising the power contained in the reservations in the deed of 1671 that the surface should be let down. There were two distinct freeholds. The person who had the land had a distinct freehold, and the person who had the coal had also a distinct freehold, and neither party could do acts detrimental to the interests of the other. There was another issue raised upon the record that the defendant did not do the acts wilfully — that he did them according to practice of the mining of the day. That was, however, no answer to the case, because the practice of modern times did not apply to the present case. With respect to what really was the modern custom he would call some very eminent viewers before them, and they would tell them that although it was the modern practice to let down the surface of the land, that they always took particular care not to work under the houses. The only questions raised substantively upon the record were — first, whether the breaches complained of were necessary for the working of the mines ; and the other as to whether the present practice would sanction the defendant in working under the houses to let them down.

His Lordship — The only question upon your opening seems to be a question of working the mines improperly.

Mr. Knowles — According to the practice of working since 1810.

Mr. Watson — Except under the buildings, It has never been the practice to work under buildings. As I have already stated, I have several eminent coal viewers here to speak to that point.

After a few further remarks between counsel, his lordship said — What shall I take as the facts, suppose you take a special verdict?

Mr. Knowles — We should like the deed in first.

His Lordship — The deed in set out in the record — there is no plea denying it.

Mr. Unthank — We understand that the practice of removing the pillars has been in operation for 47 years.

Mr. Watson — I think I have had Mr. N. Wood (Mr. Wood was standing behind Mr. Unthank) in the box before upon that point, and he does not carry it so far back. I think I had him in the case of Humphreys and Brogden.

His Lordship — I might state that formerly it was the practice to leave pillars standing — that that practice ceased in 1810 — the practice was now to work out all the coal as that was found most profitable — that the question of working under buildings is disputed — the defendants have worked out all their coals under the lands and buildings according to the most approved mode of working, unless it was their duty to leave the houses supported.

Mr. Unthank — We say in addition that in any way of working, surface damage is likely to occur. First by the creeping of the pillars, and secondly by the pillars crumbling away.

Mr. Watson — I don't admit that.

Mr. Knowles — To some extent it is always the case.

Mr. Unthank — That is stated by gentlemen behind me.

His Lordship — The question, then, might be on the statute of limitations.

Mr. Unthank — It may be important in the reservation of the case.

Mr. Knowles — I believe it is well known that Lambton Castle is built upon ground that has been so worked, and we all know its condition now.

His Lordship — I cannot enter upon a discussion in that way. It sometimes happens that land is supported by water, and that when it is tapped the land settles.

Mr. Watson — If you have got any gentleman here who recollects the land in 1761 we shall be glad to hear him (laughter).

Mr. Unthank — In working the mines it was necessary to do acts that would cause damage — you cannot do without.

His Lordship — if it were necessary to do these acts the necessity would be limited. They must do these acts to make any profit.

Mr. Watson — We will give evidence to say what damage has been done to the building.

Mr. Manisty then called Mr. Thomas Emerson Foster, of Newcastle, who said I have been for many years a colliery viewer, and am well acquainted with the way of working coal mines in this country at the present time. My knowledge goes back 38 years. The present practice of working coal without leavings pillars has been carried on during the whole of that time. Mr. Manisty — Where there are buildings upon the surface is there any practice as to leaving or taking away the supports from underneath such portions of the land ? It depends upon the depth the coal is from the surface. What is the depth of the seam of the present coal mines ? The depth underneath the houses is about 96 yards from the surface. What is the proper mode of proceeding in such a case ? According to the proper mode of working the mines, if you wish to preserve the houses there must be some support left. Mr. Knowles — That is just the question. Mr. Manisty — In a case where the land and buildings belong to one party and the coal to another, in the absence of any agreement between the parties, what ought to be done ? — The coal ought to be left, or so much of the coal as will prevent any shrinking taking place. Mr. Knowles. Yes, Mr. Forster, but my friend has not asked you the question my lord wished to know. You are check viewer at Elemore, are you not ? — Yes I am. Do you work under the buildings there ? — The Hetton Coal Company do, paying the lessor all the damage they do. — You have worked under Mr. Pemberton's farm-houses, have you not ? — Oh yes, but that is at a much greater depth than this. Have you not also worked under houses on the Marquis of Londonderry's property at Kelloe? — I should fancy we have — What is the depth of Kelloe ? — About 120 or 130 yards — At Belmont have you not worked under the buildings ? — Not under Belmont Hall. — Is there not a farm-house, and have you not worked under that ? I cannot speak to that without the plans. I cannot say whether we have or have not. — I think I may assume, as far as you have shown, that the custom is to work under farm buildings ? — Oh yes, paying the damage you occasion, but in the instances which have been mentioned the land and coal belonged to the same party. — I suppose you know that the Bishop and Dean and Chapter of Durham are perhaps the largest coal owners in the kingdom ? — They are pretty large owners. And they let the coal, do they not ? — Oh yes, -Throughout their property is it not the custom to work under the buildings? — It is.

His Lordship — In those instances where the Dean and Chapter have the coal, have they the surface also? — Witness — No, it is leased.

His Lordship — But the freehold is in them ? — Witness — Yes. I know one instance where the Dean and Chapter tenant had to buy the whole property for setting it down.

His Lordship — Part of the Bishop's property is copyhold, is it now ? — Yes. — There is the same custom I suppose there? — Not in all mines ; in some they have power to sink in the copyhold ; in others not. — Does it not come to this, so far as your knowledge of the practice goes, that they have always worked under the buildings unless there was an express stipulation in the lease that they should not ? — Yes.

Mr. Watson — The cases you have given are modern cases ? — Witness — All within the last 30 years.

Mr. Watson (to Mr. Knowles) — Are you going to contradict this ? — Mr. Knowles — I don't want any contradiction.

His Lordship (to witness) — When you get to deep pits do you work under the buildings ? — Oh yes.

His Lordship — Why ? — Because it does not affect the surface so much.

His Lordship — You work under the buildings because you think them secure.

His Lordship — When you work under land, and work out all the coal without leaving any support, on what principle do you do that ? — We dig the whole away, and we allow the roof to fall in. Why don't you work under the houses ? — Because they would in all probability come down. But why should you not let the houses down as well as the land? — The houses would cost a great deal more. Then in one case you would not run the risk of having to pay the amount of damage as you would in the other ? — Decidedly not. And in order to avoid that large amount of damage you leave props to the houses ? — Just so. I suppose you find the profit of working the columns sufficient to pay for the surface damage of the land, and leave a profit ? — Yes.

His Lordship — Does not that explain the whole thing ?

Mr. Watson — Yes ; but I have got other witnesses.

His Lordship — I thought when the gentleman mentioned how careful they were not to let down Belmont Hall, that the question was merely with reference to the amount of damage. The custom is to clear away all the coal under the land, but they found they might be losers if they took it all from under the houses.

It was ultimately agreed that a verdict should be entered for the plaintiff, subject to a motion, and that the question of damage should be left to Mr. Dobson, architect, Newcastle.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brogden, —      
Buddle, John      Whos Who Page
Carr, Ralph      
Cole, Ralph, Sir      
Dobson, —      
Forster, Thomas Emerson      Whos Who Page
Humphreys, —      
Knowles, —    Q.C.  
Londonderry, Marquis of      
Manisty, —    Solicitor  
Morton, —      
Pemberton, —      
Smart, —      
Spearman, H. J.      
Standish, —      
Unthank, —    Solicitor  
Watson, —    Q.C.  
Wood, Nicholas      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print