10th March 1855, Page: 2, Column: 4
Durham Spring Assizes
Manslaughter At West Hartlepool
Mark Scurr (25) was charged, under a coroner's inquest,
with the manslaughter of Robert Armston, in the
parish of Stranton, on the 26th September. Mr. Seymour
was for the prosecution; Mr. Tindal Atkinson
defended the prisoner.
The facts of the case may be thus shortly stated : The
deceased was a coal-trimmer at West Hartlepool, and
he prisoner a butcher in that town. For six weeks
before the 26th September the deceased met with an
accident by which he injured his collar bone; he became,
however, restored to his original health, and on the
Saturday before the Monday when he met with his
death, he was engaged from five to ten in the morning,
in company with a man named Rutter, in the ordinary
work of a coal-trimmer. At ten he left his work, and
went with a person named Dale to a public home kept
by Octavius Bell, and there had some ale. He remained
there a little time, left in half an hour, and about two
went to the Angel Inn, kept by a person named Davison.
When he went there the prisoner was sitting in the bar
parlour ; some conversation took place between deceased
and prisoner, which speedily turned into an angry
altercation ; when Armson went out, leaving the
prisoner behind him. After a little while he returned and
appeared to be seeking the prisoner ; he came into the
room where the prisoner and other persons were, and
the altercation was renewed, when the prisoner, who
was sitting opposite deceased, said, "Do you mean to
insult me," and taking up a tumbler glass by the mouth,
threw it at him. The deceased instantly fell ; he was
found to have been severely injured by a wound on the
head, was removed home, and after being insensible for
some time, he died on the Monday. When this occurred,
the parties were drunk, and after it the prisoner
expressed sorrow.
On the policeman being called, he said the prisoner
admitted having thrown the glass, adding that he had
done so in a moment of passion.
Mr. Atkinson submitted that the prisoner being very
drunk, did not know what he was doing. His intention
was, to throw the contents of the glass, and not the glass
itself. The learned counsel called Mr. Settle, the coroner,
and Mr. Kirk, who gave the prisoner an excellent character.
His Lordship said this was by no means an
aggravated case of manslaughter, having arisen partly from
accident. The case, however, was proved if the prisoner
committed an illegal act by throwing the glass, and his
drunkenness was no excuse, for if a man became voluntarily
intoxicated, be must be held answerable for all
the consequences which arose from being in that
state. The jury would say whether the prisoner intended
to throw the glass, or the contents, as was suggested.
He was bound to remind them, however, that
when taken into custody, the prisoner said he had thrown
the glass, not its contents, in a moment of intoxication.
The jury returned a verdict of Not guilty.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Armston, Robert | | Coal Trimmer | |
| Atkinson, Tindal | | Solicitor | |
| Bell, Octavius | | Innkeeper | |
| Davison, — | | Innkeeper | |
| Kirk, — | | | |
| Scurr, Mark | 25 | | |
| Settle, — | | Coroner | |
| Seymour, — | | Solicitor | |