|
27th January 1855, Page: 4, Column: 2 The Coal-Pit AccidentThe VerdictThe conscientious journalist has more to encounter in the discharge of his public duty than the good-natured, but sometimes careless, public are inclined to imagine. Duty to the commonwealth, and justice to all, should be the predominating principle of his conduct; but these rules, it honestly and faithfully adhered to, will often and necessarily lay him open to the opposition of parties deeply interested in the suppression of truth, and powerful from their position and standing in society. For ourselves, we fearlessly stand forward as the defenders of right and justice against all other influences whatsoever; and therefore we make no apology for inserting the following observations. The inquest on the bodies of the unfortunate youths who were drowned in the Brynyrowen coal-pit terminated on Monday evening last, when the Jury, after an hour's consultation, returned a verdict of "Accidental death," accompanied with remarks expressive of regret that the necessary precaution had not been taken by the managers to prevent the catastrophe. Now, we profess not to understand either the logic or the justice of this verdict. The accident itself could, or it could not, have been guarded against; was of a nature that made it independent of human forethought, or was subject to it; was, in fact, the effect of pure accident, or the result of simple neglect. If from accident, then the verdict, we opine, was of the most unwarrantable nature, being eminently unjust to those gentlemen concerned in the management of the mine. If from neglect, then the verdict was a cowardly blinking of justice, injurious alike to the public at large and to the friends and families of the deceased. We know, that, were a pointsman on a Railway to neglect his duty wilfully, or otherwise, and an accident thereby were to result to the passengers, so that lives were lost, a verdict of manslaughter, would, in all probability, be returned against the delinquent, and compensation would have to be paid by the shareholders to the survivors or families of the deceased, in proportion to the amount of injury calculated to have been sustained. Thus decrees the law of the land, and we are quite sure that it is in strict accordance with all enlightened notions of justice and equity. Well, how stands the evidence in relation to the sad event in question ? Seven persons (mere youths) were wretchedly drowned whilst labouring in a mine adjoining some old workings, the precise position and extent not being known yet no means were taken, it would appear, to obtain correct information on the subject, although (we quote the words of Mr. Dickinson, the Government Inspector), "Ready means undoubtedly existed for ascertaining that this water was standing in the old workings ABOVE the level of the main coal in the Brynyrowen pit." What! seven men drowned like rats in an inundated sewer, and that, too, when "ready means" were at hand, that only required to be put into operation to have prevented it, and their death must be ascribed, must it, to accident ? The sad event could not have been the result of either ignorance or inexperience, for Mr. Dickinson quietly, but truthfully, observed that — "I do not see how the managers of the works can plead ignorance of the proper method of conducting a mine in the vicinity of old workings, inasmuch as some of the firm are amongst the ablest vein-mining agents in Europe, and their under-looker has had great experience in some of the deepest and most heavily watered coal mines in the country." If these remarks be correct, and we ourselves know that they were neither contradicted nor challenged, then those poor boys met with an early death through unpardonable neglect; and therefore, the proper verdict would have been — "Found drowned in the Sawney Pit of the Brynyrowen Colliery ; it appearing from the evidence that proper precaution had not been taken to prevent the accident."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||