Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd December 1853, Page: 5, Column: 2

Weekly Retrospect

Working Men & Their Employers

The strike still partially continues in Lancashire, but after a very careful examination of all the reports that have reached us, varying greatly in their complexion and colour according to the source from which they proceed, we are happy to say that we discover some signs of its speedy termination. The unemployed operatives of Preston, 10,000 or 12,000 in number, receive their miserable dole every Sunday from the Weavers' Committee, and hold their accustomed weekly meeting on the succeeding day at the Orchard, listening to idle and declamatory speeches, and closing their proceedings with empty cheers for the ten per cent.; but at Wigan, Burnley and Padiham we observe that there is a disposition to come to terms and resume labour — in fact, there is the appearance if not the reality of an unconditional surrender. Offers of work, we are told, have this week been accepted with avidity, there was a positive "rush" to obtain employment, and in some cases where the establishments could not be immediately opened, in consequence of the stoppage having been taken advantage of for the making of repairs and alterations, the men who found themselves temporarily ejected, expressed the utmost disappointment. Such is the result of the hard-fought contest upon which the operatives were tempted, unwisely, to enter. It is the same as that which has followed many preceding struggles, and painfully illustrates and confirms the proposition which may now be accepted as an axiom, that you cannot, by combination or intimidation, raise the rate of wages in any given pursuit or calling in which vast numbers of men are employed, above the market value of their labour.

But having thus repeated our opinion as to the futility and folly of strikes — an opinion based on the closest reasoning and sustained by the unerring testimony of events in the past and the present — we should very inadequately and unfairly discharge our duty were we to follow the example of our contemporaries generally and impute blame solely to the more numerous but weaker party in this unfortunate controversy. The Lancashire manufacturers have much to answer for in this matter, and certainly deserve a heavier penalty than they are likely to endure. It has been too long a habit with them to regard their men as mere machines — part and parcel of their "plant" and stock-in-trade, from which they derive pecuniary gain ; and for many years past it has been found necessary to protect, by penal enactments, women and children from becoming the victims to their inordinate thirst for gold. For our part we cannot but believe that had the mill-owners met their workmen in a friendly spirit, when additional remuneration was demanded, and shown them that the position of the trade and the profits realized were not such as to warrant such a concession — had the whole matter been talked over in the counting house in the same manner as bargains are made between manufacturers and their customers in the market or cloth hall — the strike which has enkindled so much bitterness and angry feeling between those who ought to be friends, and which has been so prolific of mischief and misery, would have been altogether avoided. Instead of the operatives being beaten they would have been won — instead of an unconditional surrender there would have been an amicable settlement; there would have been no victory in which to glory, but then the exasperation of the conflict would have been spared, the machinery of the mills would have kept running, there would have been no derangement in the current of industry, the markets would have been regularly supplied, the home or foreign customers would not have been disappointed, and the peace and prosperity of the largest manufacturing district of the world would have remained unbroken and unendangered. We are sorry, not merely for the sake of the cotton-spinners and weavers, but for the credit of the masters themselves, that they did not at the outset resort to the pacific and fraternal policy of negotiation. Some of them are great sticklers for international peacemaking ; we only wish that instead of turning a deaf ear to the wishes and requests of those who create their wealth, breathing out threats of defiance, returning a Roland for an Oliver (as one of their advocates boastfully proclaims they have done), and entrenching themselves behind the strong and invincible fortification of a Masters' Association — a kind of masked battery, which answers exceedingly well for offensive as well as defensive operations — they had practiced a little of the forbearance, magnanimity, and kindness which they so loudly and vauntingly preach. Even now this discrepancy between their doctrines and conduct is observable, and may be rectified ; for in the immediate prospect if not the very moment of triumph, they are exhibiting a vindictive spirit and entering upon a course of retaliatory action most unseemly and injurious. As a sort of set-off to the 10 per cent, agitation the "associated masters" have proclaimed a short-time movement, opening their mills only four days a week at the previous and in some instances a still lower rate of wages. Of course it is alleged that this step has been taken solely on account of the markets, but those who will be the sufferers consider that it has originated in a desire to punish and annoy, and especially to cripple the subscriptions for the men still out at Preston ; be the motive what it may it is unfortunate that it should have been adopted at the present moment, and it is singular if the producing power should require to be reduced after a long season of partial stoppage and rest. Another course pursued by the masters, is that of refusing work to those who took an active lead in the strike, and we need hardly say how objectionable and obnoxious that is to the general body of operatives, who thus see their leaders become marked men, their fate being held forth as a menace and warning to others who in the time to come may dare to oppose the interests of the capitalist and to vindicate the rights of labour.

And here we must again refer to a somewhat similar system which we are informed is now in operation in the coal trade. According to a report of the proceedings of the Cowpen miners which appears in another column, it would seem that the colliery proprietors, or some of them, have devised a scheme for reducing those who are in their service to the most complete and abject submission. The plan is, to refuse employment to any man who cannot produce "clearance lines" from his last master, and it is easy to see how potently, yet how silently, their crafty and cowardly policy will bear upon the miner. Let us suppose that the workmen of any particular colliery feel themselves aggrieved by its regulations or consider they are inadequately remunerated ; they first appeal to the viewer, but receiving no redress, they turn out. What are these poor fellows to do? The master may give them clearance lines or not, according to his will and pleasure — in all probability he will do nothing to help them to another situation ; and yet without his written or printed permission, they are debarred from obtaining work elsewhere, and must emigrate or starve! We call this wanton interference with the freedom of labour, tyranny — not the less cruel because of its contemptible character, nor the less easy to bear because practised by men who have for the most part sprung from the ranks and owe their position rather to circumstances than merit. We are not lawyers, and therefore know not whether such a procedure is illegal; certainly it is a violation of the spirit of the law, and whilst working men are punished (and justly so) for presuming to dictate to others when they shall work and the recompense which they shall receive, it is manifestly unfair that those who are discharged from one situation should have a ban placed upon their admission to another.

We see it stated that the Government Inspector of Mines for the North has been meddling in some of these unfortunate labour disputes ; we can hardly believe that any official would be guilty of such a manifest breach of propriety; but if the facts are as stated, his conduct calls for remark and rebuke. It behoves Mr. Matthias Dunn at once to set himself right with the mining community in this respect; we believe he owes his appointment in a great measure to their support and recommendation ; and if he should be found truckling to the masters, he may rest assured that it will tend very much to weaken his influence and destroy any confidence which from the nature of his office, as their protector, they are naturally disposed to place in him.

In every matter affecting the interests of employers and employed the most scrupulous care and caution are necessary; and since it is generally agreed that strikes are serious evils to all classes, we regard it as of the very last importance that nothing should be done to provoke these unhappy conflicts — above all that nothing like a retaliatory and revengeful spirit should be displayed towards those who, although sometimes misled and mistaken, are yet honest in purpose and sound in heart, whose labour creates wealth and who are the stay and strength of the nation.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Dunn, Matthias    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print