|
2nd April 1853, Page: 8, Column: 4 The Accident At WillingtonAdjourned InquestThe adjourned inquest on William Stephenson, the engineman who was killed at Willington, was resumed on Thursday, before Stephen Reed, Esq., coroner. Mr. Fletcher, being re-called, stated that the wheels of the engine 104 were all flanged, which was a sufficient precaution to prevent the engine getting off the line. The drivers may have been a day and a night at work occasionally without rest; but in that case they are off work on the following day. He had had no complaints of the men being overworked. The enginemen have from five to seven shillings per day, according to servitude and merit. At the request of Mr. Reay, foreman of the jury, witness produced a copy of the printed directions which were given to the drivers. Mr. Robert Spence bank manager, of North Shields, said : I was a passenger by the four o'clock train from Newcastle, on the 2nd of March. To the best of my recollection we reached the Wallsend station about the usual time. On leaving that station we came on the line where there is a colliery crossing. Our train was stopped ; I looked out of the window and saw the guard of our train run past. I got out and ran forward, and at a short distance in advance I saw the first carriage of a train partially over the rail. I perceived some men carrying the dead body of the engineman; and beyond them I saw some other men assisting the stoker. I went to examine that part of the line where they appeared to have got off. I first observed the line ploughed up, and then noticed some broken rails, and a quantity of timber lying on the side of the line, where the engine and tender seem to have passed. I also noticed about the same place, one piece of the longitudinal timber lying close to the south rail. I walked a little further east, and for some distance in that immediate neighbourhood, between the line of rails on the south side I saw a quantity of rubbish piled up between the rails ; so far I could judge it appeared to be about six or eight inches in the middle above the top of the rail. Where it had fallen to the rails it appeared to be nearly on a level with the rail, close to the rail itself. I also saw a stone at that place, about the size of my fist, close to the north rail on the south line. The stone was not broken ; I did not see any fragments lying about. Still a little further eastward, I noticed a quantity of materials were lying about, among which were rails and chairs. Some loose rails were lying between the line of rails. I returned to the place where the engine was lying and I saw Mr. Story, solicitor, with his note book apparently taking notes, assisted by Mr. Weatherhead of Berwick. At the same time I saw Mr. Cook, of Newcastle, measure the distance between the rails at two different points, only three or four yards apart. The difference of gauge was three quarters of an inch. It was measured with a piece of string. I did not notice whether the rails were bent at that place. After this I proceeded homewards along the bridge where, on looking at the rail, I noticed several pins wanting; and I also noticed what appeared to me to be decay about the sleepers in some places. These appearances were on the surface. I saw holes in the rails without pins, but there were pins at each end of the rails at the joinings. The rails on the south side were much worn. I did not observe any pins out of the chairs. On the Saturday, when the trucks were thrown off the line, I went along the bridge in the train at four o'clock in the afternoon; and I noticed towards the centre of the bridge on the south line, lying amongst the ice and snow which were then very deep, loose spare rails between the lines. They appeared to me to be so placed that the vibration might cause them to be moved into a dangerous position, The trucks were thrown off the north line. Before the accident I noticed cross-sleepers having been put under the rails and covered up with ballast, but the ends might be seen standing out. I did not notice particularly that there were cross-sleepers wanting on the bridge. By Mr. Haggie — Previous to the accident I had not written to the Directors complaining of the state of the line, but I had written to the Board of Trade. Mr. Henry Story, solicitor, said — I was in the train which left Newcastle at four o'clock on the 2nd of March, going to Shields. About twenty-five minutes past four the train came to a stop at the Killingworth Railway crossing. I got out of the train, and the first thing I saw was a man and a woman coming westward along the line from the train, the first carriage of which was off the line; the woman's face was bleeding. I then came to the train of passenger carriages which was standing on the south line. The first second-class carriage, had its fore wheels off the rails. Mr. Weatherhead and I commenced our examinations of the line and we observed a large square chair. Two feet east of that there was a wooden chair driven within the north rail of the south line which had evidently been subjected to great pressure from above; the cast end of the wedge was forced downwards, and the other end lifted. The upper edge of the wedge had been worn down by friction. The rails on this part of the line are laid on cross sleepers; and I noticed that the chairs both on the north and south rails of the south line were in the majority of instances fastened with one pin. I cannot, in fact, say that I saw one chair with two pins, with the exception of the large chair which was secured by two. At a short distance to the westward of the large chair, the line is again laid on longitudinal sleepers, and from the commencement of the longitudinal sleepers to the west of the cabin, the space between the rails was heaped up with ballast. At the middle it might be eight or nine inches higher than the top of the rails, sloping down till it came within half an inch of the top of the rails. The mark of the flanges of the carriages and engines could be distinctly traced on the ballast, which had been pressed down. Stones of various sizes were scattered about on the top of this ballast ; and a short distance to the east, from when the first trace occurred of the wheel getting off, I observed a stone lying near the north rail of the south line, which had been crushed. There were other stones lying about, some of which had apparently been pushed aside by the flange of the wheel from where they had been lying. I then proceeded further westward to the place where a rail had been broken, and for a space of 60 feet to the west of the cabin : for 40 feet east again the rails had to be taken up. I objected to the man, whom name was Charles Burn, taking the rails up till Mr. Harrison came. When Mr. Harrison saw the line it was in a different state from what it was in immediately after the accident. There was a quantity of old sleepers lying on the south side of the east embankment, on the west end of the bridge, which were all scattered about and broken, evidently by very great force. I then walked further westward on the line, and observed at a place to which my attention was directed by Mr. Weatherhead, that one of the longitudinal sleepers, on being pressed by the foot, sank, and the water oozed up on each side. The Coroner then addressed the jury, and observed that supposing they found there had been a certain amount of negligence, yet unless they could fix upon some individual what amounted to a criminal act, resulting in loss of life, they could not find a verdict implicating any of the company's servants. The Coroner proceeded to recapitulate the evidence, and remarked that there was one important fact which this enquiry had established, namely that the viaducts on the line had been found to be in a sound and perfect state of repair and condition, a fact which would remove the apprehension in the public mind as to their safety. It was satisfactory to know that these bridges were examined twice every year by the company's engineer, and the report made on their recent examination, both by Mr. Harrison and Capt. Wynne, was a guarantee for their perfect stability. On the conclusion of the coroner's address, the jury adjourned for five minutes to take refreshments: they were then shut up in their room, where they remained in consultation for about two hours, after which the public were readmitted. Mr. Reay, the foreman, then read from a paper as follows: That William Stephenson came to his death by the engine No. 104 running off the line of rails, and falling over the embankment at the west end of Willington Viaduct, on the Newcastle and Tynemouth Railway, on the 2nd of March, 1853. They also find, from the evidence brought before them, that the line was not in a good and safe state, and that gross negligence in the management has been manifested in allowing ballast from the north line of Willington Bridge, while under repair, to be laid upon the south line, so as to render it dangerous. They are of opinion that a strange engineman ought not to have been sent down the line without some caution given as to the repairs going on at Willington Bridge. They are also of opinion that some legislative measure should be passed, making it compulsory on railway companies not to remove a single vestige of destruction of the line, carriages, &c., but that everything remain intact until inspected by competent persons. The Coroner said he would take care that these remarks were embodied in his return, and he hoped they would have a good tendency with regard to railways generally, in causing proper measures to be adopted to remedy the causes of these accidents.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||