24th May 1852
Letters to the Editor
Colliery Explosions
To The Editor Of The Times.
Sir,
The very numerous colliery explosions which have taken place within the last three weeks make it a matter of public interest to inquire into the probable causes of those accidents, with a view to ascertain whether they cannot be prevented.
It must be clear that to produce an explosion there is required a combination of circumstances, the want of any of which prevents any such result from taking place. The first requisite is the firedamp, an explosive gas. Now, this explosive gas is light
carburetted hydrogen — that is, carbon and hydrogen in certain proportions. Now, in order that the carburetted hydrogen may explode, it requires the presence of a given supply of oxygen from the atmosphere.
The explosion is, in short, nothing more than an instantaneous combination of the hydrogen with a part of the oxygen, the atmosphere forming steam, and the carbon, with the residue of the oxygen, forming carbonic acid. From the former, together with
sudden heating of other elastic matters, arises the violence of the explosion ; from the latter, together with nitrogen of the air, the choke or afterdamp, which is even more destructive of life than the explosion itself. It is a well-ascertained fact
that if the proportions of the mixture of firedamp with atmospheric air be far from the proportions required to form this new chymical combination no explosion will take place : or, in more popular language, if there be either much more or much less
firedamp in the atmosphere than one eighth part, it will not explode. The remaining requisite is the fire or heat which induces the new chymical arrangement to take place.
Now, it is perfectly clear that if any one of these requisites be absent the explosion will not take place. If you have no firedamp, if you have no oxygen, or if you have no fire, you can have no explosion. You must have oxygen in order to breathe,
therefore the question lies between getting quit of the firedamp or the fire. Hitherto our endeavours have been chiefly directed to insulate the fire in the lamp from the firedamp ; the safety-lamp of Davy had this object, but it accomplishes this object
very imperfectly. In a still atmosphere it is true that a flame will not pass through a wire gauze such as is used to cover the lamp ; but the moment the lamp is in rapid motion through the air, or the air in rapid motion through the meshes of the lamp,
the flame passes through without difficulty, a fact which Davy was aware of, but as to which the public and the miners are kept in the dark. In short, 99 out of 100 suppose it to secure absolute safety. Any one may convince himself of the fact by a very
simple experiment, for he will find that he can light a tobacco-pipe just as easily through the gauze of a Davy lamp as at a naked light, the current of air drawing the flame through the gauze ; and if the flame will light tobacco it will light firedamp.
Now, this being the case, it is easy to see how an accident may occur without any carelessness on the part of the miner. He is at work, his lamp behind him ; the air is passing at the rate of 3 or 4 feet a second ; he does not see the flame beginning to
lengthen, because his back is to it ; the air becomes more and more fiery, till at last the whole of the gas inside the lamp is in a flame ; the rapidity of the current of air blows it through the gauze, and a frightful explosion ensues. Or, supposing he
is in a still atmosphere, perhaps the miner happening to turn sees the lamp indicating the presence of firedamp. He very naturally takes up his lamp and moves rapidly away — his very doing so causes the air as rapidly to pass through the lamp, and
the flame to communicate with the outside, and he and all in the pit are destroyed.
It is perfectly clear, them, that the Davy-lamp is very frequently the cause of accidents in a fiery pit. There are many other working conditions in a coalpit which would make it give rise to an explosion ; no doubt the miners may be careless, they may
take off the tops of their lamps, but they certainly don't "poke holes in the gauze to light their pipes," because they can light them equally well without ; in fact it is only an absurd myth, invented in order to throw the blame of these
explosions on the wrong head.
The fact is, that the Davy-lamp will not secure a fiery pit, however cautiously it may be used. The only really effectual means of preventing these accidents is getting rid of the firedamp itself, and this is only to be done by an efficient ventilation.
The real reason why explosions occur is an inefficient and unscientific ventilation. The Government inspectors are of no real use — they serve as scapegoats for the owners and viewers of the mines, who are relieved of responsibility by the
inspection, without any additional safety being secured to the miner. It is much to be wished that some more efficient means may shortly be taken. Perhaps the only efficient one at hand is a Parliamentary inquiry into the security or the contrary of the
Davy-lamp, and such an inquiry is certainly due to a great number of lives that have unfortunately been lost. If the Davy-lamp be found from the evidence brought before them to be efficient, let Parliament insist on its universal adoption ; if it be not,
it is their duty to insist on those means which are efficient.
I remain, Sir, your obedient servant,
Edward Cayley.
5, Serjeants'-inn, Fleet-street, Saturday, May 22.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cayley, Edward | | | |