|
15th November 1851, Page: 6, Column: 5 The Colliery Explosion At West MoorIn last week's Guardian we recorded the particulars of an explosion in West Moor Colliery, by which seven men and two boys were killed. Yesterday week Mr. Stephen Reed commenced the inquiry into the cause of their death, and after taking the evidence of two witnesses (already published in our journal) adjourned it until the following Monday. Adjourned Inquest On Monday afternoon, the inquiry was resumed at the School-room at Killingworth, which was crowded with miners, who seemed to take great interest in the proceedings. — Mr. Philipson, solicitor, again attended on behalf of the owners, and Mr. Brewis was retained by the Miners' Association. Mr. Brewis said that the men connected with the colliery, had come to a resolution, which he wished to lay before the Coroner, but he had not yet got it in writing. — The Coroner observed that all statements must be in writing, in order that they might be put on record. — Whilst the resolution was being committed to paper, Thomas Barron, the overman who was examined on Friday last, was recalled, and said :— I do not think that neglecting a door in any other part of the colliery, would affect the air in the quarter where the explosion took place. I left that part at three o'clock in the morning to visit other parts of workings, and at that time I considered the place perfectly safe for the men to work with Davys'. I met the deputy, Matthew Caughlin, who was to succeed me, at four o'clock, proceeding to the quarter where the explosion occurred. I told him the workings there were perfectly free. I knew William Hay, who lost his life there, and believe that he was addicted to smoking. — By Mr. Brewis. — I met Caughlin at the cabin near the shaft; he was going to the place I had left. I know Thomas Storey; he did not tell me, to my recollection, that the mine was in a dangerous state. No conversation took place between me and him on that day. I visited Storey's place on the 26th October, the day the lamps were first introduced. I saw Storey and Proctor in the south-east drift, and observed that the top coal had come away from the roof, and that gas was making. I held a lamp to the gas, and it fired. At that time the men had candles burning, and I told them not to put their candles there, or they would get burnt. The men did not ask me for lamps, but when they went out, the men who succeeded them took lamps. Storey was burnt about half an hour after I had this conversation with him. I did not communicate this conversation to Mr. Johnson, the viewer. Since the 28th ult. no candles have been used. I introduced the safety lamp before I saw Mr. Johnson, and when I told him he approved of it. The Coroner then said he was ready to hear any witnesses that Mr. Brewis might wish to bring forward. Thomas Storey was then called by Mr. Brewis, and said :— I was first employed in the colliery when a boy six years of age, as a trapper. After working here for 14 years I left at a strike, having been turned away on account of being connected with a Union. For the last three months I have worked here again. On the 23rd, when Wm. Simpson was burnt, I was in the pit, but not in the same shift. We were working with candles, but I did not then consider it safe to be working with naked lights. Candles were used till the 25th, on which day, Barron, the overman, came into the roller-way board, and showed me the gas with the lamp, and it fired. My place fired that morning on my and my "marrow," and we were both slightly burnt. Lamps were introduced after that. I have not wrought any since, having been disabled by the injuries I received. Brattice was carried up to two or three feet of the face of the coal. There was air, but not sufficient to keep the place clean. I did not make any complaint regarding the place I wrought in, to the underviewer, but I mentioned it to Barron, the overman, the morning she fired on me. Mr. Hunter has been asked for lamps by a man now in eternity, and Mr. Hunter in reply asked him if he was a countryman. Mr. Barron was asked for lamps before she fired, and if lamps had been used then I should not have been burnt. By Mr. Philipson :— During the last three months I have wrought the whole coal in my board, safely, sometimes with candles, and sometimes with lamps. Barron first called my attention to the gas on the 28th; I told him it was not safe to work with candles. I have used both the Davy and Stephenson's lamps. When Stephenson's lamp goes into gas, it extinguishes it, but the Davy will still burn. Stephenson's is a larger lamp, and may perhaps admit a larger quantity of gas. The lamp going out shows that the atmosphere is highly explosive. When the Davy fills with gas, it does not go out, but indicates that there is danger. The usual quantity of air was in the workings on the 27th. I have known Stephenson's lamp to be extinguished in the pit whilst the Davy has burnt. By Mr. Brewis :— I cannot tell when the owners first introduced the Davy lamp into the West Moor pit. Neither Mr. Hunter nor Mr. Johnson ever made any enquiry of me as to the firing of the pit. — By Mr. Philipson ... I have worked in Haswell colliery ; Davy lamps are generally used there. I do not remember any of the men ever objecting to them there, I considered the Killingworth pit to be safe with Stephenson's lamp, but would not have hesitated to have gone to work with the Davy lamp. By Mr. Brewis :— I consider Haswell colliery safer than West Moor; the former is much better ventilated. During the examination of the last witness, Mr. Brewis handed to the coroner the resolution, to which he had before referred. It was as follows :— It is the request of the workmen that questions be put direct to the witnesses by Mr. Brewis, instead of in writing, through the Coroner." — The Coroner said he could not depart from his rule. He would carry this enquiry to any length in order to satisfy all parties, but he must strictly adhere to the rule he had laid down. Robert Orton said :— I have worked in this colliery all my life, and consider it safe with lamps. I have worked with candles, but the pit has never fired upon me. I have worked with the Davy a few months. When Mr. Hunter came to the colliery I got a Davy, but before he came I always worked with Stephenson's lamp. I prefer the latter. Whilst working with the Davy, the pit never fired. There is a rule that when the gas is likely to fire, we are to come out. On the 31st October, I went to work at four o'clock in the morning, in the far north board where Hay was, and left about twelve o'clock. I then thought it safe where I was working. We left a few minutes earlier than usual, on account of the breakup in the bank. Hay and his partners were going towards the board, when I came out. None of them were smoking when I passed them. The air was as normal that morning in the workings. An hour after I had left the pit, I heard that an explosion had taken place. I cannot tell the cause of the explosion. I smoke myself, but cannot tell whether a pipe can be lighted at the Davy. The cap of Stephenson's lamp can be removed. The deputies examine the workings before the men go to their boards, and if they say the pit is not safe, we are prevented from going in. The Davy lamp has been introduced since Mr. Johnson and Mr. Hunter came. The men have no means of knowing what quantity of air there is in workings, but if there is a greater quantity of gas than usual it can be detected by the smell. In such a case the men would go out, and report to the deputy. I never had occasion to report to the deputy, except about ten weeks ago, when I was fined 10s for remaining in the place where the gas was. Thomas Rutherford, a pitman, was next examined, but his evidence was very similar to that of the last witness. He left the pit shortly before the explosion, and had no apprehension of danger. His opinion as to the cause of the explosion was, that a sudden discharge of gas took place, which could not be provided against. Cuthbert Dunn, another pitman, said he had never seen any of the printed instructions of the colliery. If he had seen any danger he would not have complained, as he believed the deputies would not have attended to him. James Hedley, a hewer, said — I have been at West Moor colliery six years. For a month past I have considered the pit to be in a very bad state from the accumulation of gas. I work in a part called the Willington bank, which is three quarters of a mile from where the explosion took place. I worked with Stephenson's lamp. The deputy came into my place the other day ; it had been foul for two or three days, and he employed two men to shake the brattice so as to drive the gas out, and when he came down the board his lamp was red hot, and he had to sit down while it cooled. I have never complained either to the viewers or deputies that the pit was unsafe. There was nothing to prevent me complaining, but I did not do it. There is a man who has charge of the lamps, and has to see that they are properly cleaned before being given to the men. I now produce two lamps, one of which came from Hepple, and the other from Sutherland, both of which are imperfect. I never complained to the deputy of the lamps being imperfect. These lamps have been brought to me since the explosion. I have known the deputies try the lamps, and when the locks slipped, the men had to take them back to the cabin to be re-locked. The men are not allowed to go into the cabin where the lamps are kept. I have the printed rules of the colliery, which particularly order that when danger is apprehended, the men are to come away. Thomas Cuthbertson, who has been upwards of 20 years at West Moor Colliery, was next examined at considerable length, but his evidence was of the same nature as some of the preceding witnesses. He thought there was not sufficient air in the workings. He never complained, because a man who did so, was "picked at" or discharged; but he never remembered a man being turned away at this colliery for complaining. Mr. Liddell, head viewer at Gosforth, was then called by the Coroner, and said :— I examined Killingworth colliery minutely since the last explosion, and found the workings at the flat little disturbed by the explosion. When I arrived at the flat it was quite evident that a quantity of flame had passed from the return east drift, struck against the south wall side, and diverged each way, both out-by and in-by. The props and planks were burnt only on one side in both directions. A few yards further there were traces of fire on both sides of the props and planks. I then arrived at the innermost stenton, where it was quite evident that a mass of gas, in a state of flame, had passed down and again extended each way, one going to the face and the other towards the flat. From the innermost stenton to the face of the fore-east drift, the props and planks were charred on their west sides only, clearly showing that the fire had passed from the innermost stenton into the face of the east drift. I then walked back to the flat stenton, and up it into the northernmost or return east drift, where the destructive force of the explosion had been much greater. I examined that drift all the way from the stenton to the face, and I am satisfied that the fire originated at or near the face of the northernmost east drift. I think, from the appearances that an extra quantity of gas had been given off at that time. If lamps alone had been used, I do not think the explosion would have taken place. I do not think it could have been caused by drawing the flame through the gauze to light a pipe. The cause of the explosion is to me a mystery. After the explosion, when there was considerable derangement, every part of the pit that I examined was perfectly clean. Mr. W. Armstrong, viewer of Wingate Grange, said he fully coincided in all that Mr. Liddell had said. Is was now past eight o'clock, and the Coroner adjourned until the following morning. Tuesday This morning, at ten o'clock, the inquiry was resumed by Mr. Reed, at the same place, when the room was again filled with miners. Matthew Caughlin, a deputy overman at West Moor Colliery, was first called, and said :— On the 31st October I went down the pit at twenty minutes to four in the morning, and succeeded Mr. Barron, whom I found waiting at the cabin. He reported to me that all was right. My duty was to inspect that portion of the pit where the explosion took place; and I found, on examination, that everything was correct. I had a Davy lamp, which did not indicate more than usual the presence of gas. Gas is always coming away, more or less, from these workings, but I consider there is sufficient air to render them safe. I was in the workings till half-past eleven o'clock, and then came to the break-up in the bank. Until the rolleys and tubs were put right, the men had to leave off work, as they could not get their coals away. The rope was repaired by one o'clock, two men having assisted me, and we then went to replace the rolleys. During this time I think there would not be any interruption of the air. Whilst I was mending the rope on the incline. Hay and the other men, who worked in the same district with him, passed me on the way to their board. I told them to stop and assist in getting the rolleys on, but they all went away towards the flat without doing so, and I saw no more of them. When William Hay came to me, I perceived that he was smoking with a pipe ; I told him that he had to go to the stenton in the straight-in drift, and he said he would not go. I told him that he would have to go, and he asked me what he had to go there for, when I replied that as he belonged to the back drift, according to rule the stenton Was his. After he left me he came back, and said he would not go to the stenton where I required him. He went away again, and I saw him no more. The men are forbidden to smoke when they have lamps, but I did not remonstrate with Hay when he came to me in the rolley-way, because he had a candle ; candles are used in the rolley-way. I left the pit before the explosion took place. On hearing of the explosion I went down again; and assisted to bring out the sufferers. When I left the workings before the explosion, I was succeeded by another deputy named Musgrove Clark. It is possible that the brattice in the back drift might be injured by the fall of the top coal, which is about two feet thick. In the fore drift the coal had occasionally so fallen, and there would be an additional quantity of gas thrown into the workings in consequence. In case such a fall did take place, it must have been after I left. In the far north board timber was needed to keep up the top, and two pair of gears are placed there for that purpose; the brattice props also had the effect of keeping up the roof, but these were all blown down by the force of the explosion. William Gilchrist said, — I am lamp keeper at this colliery. It is my duty every morning to see that the lamps are clean and in a perfect state of repair, before they are given to the men. I am careful to see that the lamps are locked. The men know their own lamps, and have the same every day. On leaving work they take their lamps home with them, fill them with oil, and bring them to me in the cabin in the morning before they go to work. If an imperfect lamp is brought to me, I do not allow the man to take it with him; if I have another lamp by me, I give it to him, but if I have not the man has either to borrow one, or lie idle till his own is repaired. After I leave the lamp cabin, a boy named John Thompson is left in charge, and has to lock the lamps, and light such as go out. All the lamps were in a perfect state of repair that morning, as far as I could see. It is my duty to condemn such lamps as are not perfect, and during the three months I have been lamp-keeper I have condemned five or six, and changed the bottoms of some others. The two lamps produced yesterday by a witness belong to Sutherland and Hepple. I remember delivering Hepples, which was properly locked when given to him. I don't recollect delivering a lamp to Sutherland that morning. After the lamps are delivered to me at the cabin, they are again examined by the deputies at the flat, but the deputies are not entrusted with keys. By Mr. Brewis :— I have heard that the men receive sixpence a score more when they work with safety lamps, than when they work with candles. When I leave the cabin two of the deputies attend it in turn, and they examine and lock the lamps. By the Coroner :— There are printed rules to regulate the men, hung up in the cabin ; but the men are not allowed to go into the cabin. The rules are placed on a board, about 30 yards from the cabin, in a conspicuous place, so as to catch the eye of the men. John Thompson, a boy eleven years of age, said :— I am employed in Killingworth Colliery, and have charge of the lamp cabin, after Gilchrist leaves, which is about half-past eight o'clock in the morning. My duty is to lock the men's lamps, and light those which go out. I am very careful in locking all the lamps, after which they are examined by the deputies. John Hall deposed :— I have twice been employed to distribute the rules for regulating the workmen at this colliery. [A copy of the rules was here produced.] I was ordered to leave a copy of these rules at every house. I left a copy at the house of Cuthbert Dunn, who was examined yesterday. The last time I delivered the bills, which was a short time ago, I called again at Dunn's house, and his wife said there was no occasion to leave one, as he had a copy already. Thomas Barron being recalled, said :— On the 31st October I went into the workings where the explosion took place. I was present when the whole of the men were found. Wm. Hay was found in the second north board, lying on his knees and face. The face of the coal would be two yards north of him. He had no clothes on ; they had been on him, but were burnt off by the fire. His Davy lamp was lying close in behind him, and is the one now produced. The lamp is locked and perfect, except that the gauze is dented in by the explosion. I did not find any candle. Joseph Wright, who was called by Mr. Brewis, said that he left West Moor colliery yesterday week, because he was afraid any longer to work there, and for no other reason. He had sought work elsewhere before the pit fired the last time. Mr. Hunter, the underviewer at West Moor, wrote to Mr. Menham of Gosforth, in order to prevent his getting work there. He did not tell any of the deputies that he was going to leave the colliery. Mr. Matthias Dunn, Government Inspector of Mines, then rend the following report regarding the explosion :— "That part of the colliery wherein the recent explosion happened is in a tract of whole coal contiguous to the main upcast dyke, being distant from the shaft about 1200 yards, and in depth from the surface about 200 fathoms; the coal is eight feet high, but little more than six feet is worked away. The extent of the present workings does not exceed 100 yards, the east drifts being each nine feet wide, and twenty yards apart, the holings for ventilation made at every forty yards, the coal rising to the northward about one in three or four. The general ventilation of the colliery is said to have consisted of about 30,000 cubic feet per minute, of which about 6,500 was allotted to these workings. The coal is admitted to have produced a constant discharge of gas, so that every place required bratticing. Upon the 23rd October last, whilst the places were all at work with candles, W. Simpson was burnt, and afterwards died, and upon the 28th two other partial fires took place in the straight-in drift, which induced the overman to put all the places on with lamps, which seems to have settled all apprehension of danger. But upon the 31st October the explosion in question took place, and the present inquest is for the purpose of ascertaining — first, what produced the accumulation of gas, and second, by what means it exploded. First, — it is in evidence that up to within an hour of the explosion, the air seemed to be in its ordinary state, and the working places satisfactory, all the men using lamps. Opinions have been given that a violent discharge of gas had suddenly taken place either from the top coal, or at "danty backs," some of which had been passed through, or that a sudden damage had taken place in the brattice of the back drift by the falling of the top coal. An accident had occurred to the tubs in the engine bank simultaneously, but it does not appear that any stoppage of the air was the result, for the area of the place was upwards of sixty foot. My opinion coincides with others, that the back east drift had been the scene of the greatest fire, but with them I am unable to say to which of the causes accumulation of gas is attributable ; but as the places were going day and night, and the quantity of brattice drift daily increasing, a slight damage, of the brattice would, in a very short time, produce an accumulation of gas, especially if from slackening of the furnaces, or other cause, the ordinary current of air was diminished; for the preceding facts show, that although it might be adequate to maintain the places In safety, when arrangements were perfect, yet there does not seem to have been a very great margin between safety and danger. Second, — It is impossible to discover by what means the gas ignited ; both Stephenson's lamp and the Davy were employed, and although it is well known that the Davy will explode under violent current of air, yet it is probable that in this case the air current would be sluggish, at the same time, whilst the lamps were furnished with shields; therefore, whether it has occurred from any failure in the lamps, from any attempt to light a pipe through the gauze, or by any imprudent introduction of a naked candle, in my opinion it is impossible to determine, as all the persons in these workings are killed." Mr. Brewis enquired of Mr. Dunn his opinion as to the propriety of increasing the column of air in the colliery, and Mr. Dunn replied by reading the following suggestions, which he had committed to paper :— "After having examined the pit, and learnt the arrangements regarding the ventilation, I took the liberty of making some suggestions to Mr. Wood and the viewers, which I am since fortified in repeating, as having a tendency to render these workings much safer in future, for I consider that will best be accomplished by obtaining an increase of the air current. Before the air current reaches these workings, it suffers a diminution of about 4000 cubic feet per minute, which passes through the college of the district, where very few men are at work, and where safety lamps are used. I therefore suggest to retain this air in addition to the 6500 feet now employed, which will give an increase of 30 or 40 per cent. in these new workings, and to return this aggregate air through the college workings, instead of as at present, allowing it to escape to the upcast shaft. This arrangement would, I submit, benefit both districts, and would in fact amount to dividing the whole current into three splits instead of four. According to the present system sixty yards of bratticed air must be conveyed, before one drift can be holed into the other; I therefore suggest that the holings should not exceed 25 yards apart instead of 40, which will diminish the bratticing 15 yards at each holing, which will undoubtedly preserve the faces of these winning places in greater safety, for where the coal is high and rising so rapidly, it is difficult to keep the brattices at all perfect, therefore the more they can be shortened the better." — Mr. Dunn further stated in reply to Brewis, that, in his opinion, a larger volume of air would render the pit more safe. It was his business to examine the various pits in the district, but as there were about 2000 in his district it was impossible for him to examine them all. The Coroner briefly summed up the evidence, and the jury, after a few minutes' deliberation, returned a verdict of accidental death.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||