Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd September 1851

Letters to the Editor

Colliery Accidents

To The Editor Of The Times.

Sir, — I have read with attention Mr. Cayley's excellent letter in The Times of last Tuesday, in which he speaks of Mr. Gurney's method of ventilation by steam jets. Having been myself for many years in the early part of my life employed in collieries, and having consequently an experimental knowledge of the many dangers to which the working miners are exposed, I have the more lively appreciation of the great benefits, in great security to life and improved health, to be deprived from the use of any means of securing an increased ventilation. Of late my attention has been more particularly directed to the consideration of the best means now known of effecting this object, in consequence of a deputation of miners from the north of England having called on me to give my opinion on furnace ventilation. They stated, that from the evidence given by Gurney, Cowie, and myself, before the Lords' Committee, there seemed to be an important principle of life and death involved in it. They alluded principally to the natural brattice as pointed out in the evidence of Mr. Gurney. They seemed to see clearly that if a natural brattice could be formed, then there could be no safety in furnace ventilation.

Everything tends to show that the furnace limit as laid down by Gurney is correct. M. Combe, the Government engineer of France, gives the following table calculated from a formula, which he arrives at after an elaborate investigation :—

Temperature de l'air
ascendant en
degrés centigrades
Nombres proportionels
à la masse d'air qui
sort dans l'unité de
temps ou à l'activé de
la circulation
Nombres proportionels
aux quantities des
combustibles bralúes
304343
4051102
5058174
6064266
10079632

In the first column we have the temperature of the air in the upcast shaft in degrees, centigrade. The second column contains the numbers proportional to the mass of air which flows out in a unit of time, or the activity of the circulation. In the third column are the numbers proportional to the quantities of fuel burnt.

The numbers in the second column increase slowly, and so much the more slowly as the temperature is elevated, while the numbers in the third column increase very rapidly, following a law much more rapid as the temperature is raised higher. Thus in passing from a temperature of 30° to 100° we do not double the mass of air that flows through in an unit of time, and working from the formula to temperatures above 100°, we find that every increase of temperature will only give an insignificant increase in the circulation. Although this formula is not strictly true, yet it is sufficiently so to show the certainty of the furnace limit.

The following is Mr. Gurney's evidence on this subject :—

"I have in my former evidence called attention to the fact that it frequently happens in furnace ventilation that the force of exhaustion and the amount of ventilation are in an inverse ratio to each other. This seeming contradiction we have called 'the furnace paradox.' There is another point, hitherto I believe unnoticed, connected with this system of far greater importance — namely, its capricious limit. It is well known that whenever attempts have been made to get a larger amount of ventilation in coal mines than is usually obtained, by increasing the heat, the size of the furnace, or otherwise, singular as the fact may be, they have never succeeded ; there seems to be a sort of magic quantity or uniform maximum, in spite of every modification, which runs through the whole ; the quantities of air drawn through the mines by the best arranged furnaces are so nearly alike that the coincidence is clearly not accidental, but evidently governed by some law of pneumatics not yet sufficiently examined ; these quantities seem to be in the exact proportion to the areas of their respective upcast shafts — about 1,060 cubic feet per minute to one foot sectional area of the shaft. Jarrow has an upcast shaft of 50 feet area, and passes 50,000 cubic feet of air per minute ; St. Hilda, 30 feet shaft, and passes 30,000 cubic feet of air per minute ; Felling, 48 feet shaft, 42,000 cubic feet per minute ; Seaton Delaval, 50 feet shaft, and before the steam jet was applied passed 50,000 cubic feet per minute ; Percy Main, 44 feet shaft, passes 35,000. I could mention others ; these are some of the collieries near Newcastle, and it will be observed their proportional numbers are nearly equal. There are mines which, from smaller galleries or longer and tortuous turnings, do not pass so much air. Dowdon, 201 feet shaft, passes only 130,000 ; Haswell, 109 feet shaft, passes 74,000 ; Seghill, 70 feet area, passes 42,000 only. There is but one case on record where the amount of ventilation exceeds 1,000 cubic feet per minute to the foot area of the shaft, and that case is the one, given in evidence by Mr. Wood, at Hetton. The shaft is 154 feet area, and the ventilation is stated to be 168,000 per minute. This may be considered as the extreme limit, for it was obtained by three furnaces, driven as hard as they could be driven. The proportion, it will be observed, is very little above the others notwithstanding — 14 on 154. In many of the above cases the furnaces have been increased in size, and the intensity of fire also ; but no more ventilation has followed. Viewers are anxious to increase their ventilation ; they try all feasible means with the furnace, but cannot do it. On looking carefully into the subject, and fairly regarding all the conditions found in mines, the explanation does not seem very difficult ; it opens views of the greatest importance to coal mine safety. The heat of the furnace, by the rarefaction of air in the upcast shaft, produces a partial vacuum at the base ; This partial vacuum, or exhaustion, is open to the atmosphere by two channels — one directly down the upcast shaft, the other by the galleries going to the downcast shaft ; and it is evident that air can come in to fill it by either passage ; but as it can come more readily along the galleries than down against the buoyant column of hot air, it comes that way in preference ; this, however, it does up to a certain point, and no more ; for when the resistance is increased by the speed (which it will be as the squares of its velocity) up to a force equal to the force of buoyancy in the upcast shaft, the maximum power is produced ; and any extra vacuum, or exhaustion from inward heat or otherwise, becomes supplied down the shaft.

The principle of the furnace limit first came out in the examination of Mr. Mather, a gentleman of the highest attainments both in literature and science ; this admirable man accompanied Mr. Gurney to Clackmannan, and I need only refer to Mr. Cayley's former letter in The Times to show what their united labours have accomplished in that burning waste.* What he (Mr. Mather) has said on the subject may be seen at page 338 of the "Minutes of Evidence," and which is the same in substance as already quoted as given by Mr. Gurney. Mr. Gurney, in the last day's evidence, stated that he had a letter from Mr. Donnison, of Seaton Delaval, which he wrote, having no connexion with this subject. He says, "I have burnt three or four times the quantity of coals and can get the temperature no higher." This gentleman had not then even heard that the furnaces might have a limit ; he stated a practical fact, and was no doubt astonished that such should be the case ; for why did he keep firing away if he did not expect to raise the temperature ?

As regards the natural brattice, I consider its discovery as one of the most valuable contributions to the science of mining ever made ; it shows that under the best furnace ventilation the poor men's lives hang frequently only on a "feather balance." We have given what Mr. Gurney's view of the natural brattice is, which is fully borne out by the Rev. Mr. Cowie, who was the Senior Wrangler of his year at Cambridge, and therefore took the highest honours ; this gentleman's opinion, to say the least, is certainly entitled to the most serious consideration. He is asked with respect to the action of a furnace indicating that there is a point beyond which the power of the furnace cannot be carried is correct on scientific principles. He answers, "I believe it is ; the action of the furnace is by creating a vacuum which will be supplied by the surrounding air in the easiest way possible ; if, therefore, the air can come down the shaft more easily than the air through the galleries it will come that way ; Now, the resistance to the air moving in the galleries will increase with the velocity, it will therefore increase up to a certain point, and after that the vacuum will be more easily supplied from the top of the shaft than from the galleries, and this will indicate the maximum power of the furnace."

My own evidence on this subject comes next. I am asked, "That with certain resistance in the passages of a mine, if the furnace is raised beyond a certain point, there follows a downcast current in the upcast shaft ?"

My answer was, "Yes ; all this is due to the force necessary to move a mass of matter from one velocity to another, and, consequently, the weight of the air in the workings cannot be so moved in an instant ; all the friction against the sides of the mine, and other resistances, have to be overcome before it can arrive at the increased velocity required.

The evidence of Mr. Woodhouse on this subject is quite to the point. His experience fully confirms the existence of the natural brattice. He observes that in some cases, where you warm the air in the upcast pit, by firing to a certain point, you reach the maximum current through the furnace. Then Lord Wharncliffe observes, "you may raise the heat of the furnace to such a point as rather to diminish its power of Ventilation ?" His answer is — "To a point where the power of ventilation ceases altogether, providing the current be taken through the furnace ; but if you divide the current, and take part of it through the upcast pit, without going through the furnace, although the air in the shaft be cooled, the effect is materially increased." He is asked if he has considered the explanation of that phenomenon. He answers — "No ; I have not ; at least, I am not sufficiently conversant with the subject chymically to understand it or explain it. I know that that is the practical effect."

What gives value to this fact is that Mr. Woodhouse, whatever might be his preconceived views concerning ventilation, whether he might be in favour of furnace ventilation, the steam jet, or any other, as he could not account for the phenomenon he could not know which way it would tell, whether for or against his own views. This, therefore, is, undoubtedly, an unprejudiced fact.

It is no wonder that such a question could not be answered on the spur of the moment ; it requires consideration. The following is an explanation which I have given both publicly and privately, and which some men eminent in science have considered satisfactory :—

The natural brattice is composed of a plate of air (if I may be allowed the term), of the mean temperature and density of the ascending and descending columns, and in a state of rest, or nearly so. An eddy on the side of a river is the same. The natural brattice may be said to be like the quiescent particles of water lying between the main current and the eddy. Now, if a current of cold air be passed along the drift into the upcast shaft, this cold air forces the heated air against the opposite side of the shaft, and thereby breaks the natural brattice, and the ventilation goes on as before. Such being the well-attested inefficiency and danger of the furnace ventilation, can nothing be done for this bold, noble, and hardy race of men — men that no dangers daunt, no difficulties deter ? Often I have seen these brave fellows, when accidents of the kind have occurred, rushing who to be first to enter the mine, which may be said to be surcharged with death, and with a determination to save their fellow workmen or to perish in the attempt, and too often the insidious poison has done its deadly work. Mr. Mather, when speaking on this subject, with his usual force and elegance observes, "The men who were exerting themselves for the recovery of their unfortunate friends acted with a solemn, high-wrought, steady courage, without bustle, scarcely with a remark, and what remarks were made were such as were necessary, brief and decided, and generally in a subdued tone, such as human nature assumes in its most vigorous, perfect, and ennobling moments."

I repeat, can nothing be done for men of such bravery and intrepidity ? Are prejudices, sanctified only by time, to hold their despotic sway, when modern science unfolds so many means, if not wholly putting an end to these sad catastrophes, certainly of lessening their number and their destructive effects. That great prejudices exist in favour of the furnace may be gathered from many parts of the evidence ; but the most sensible advocate for the furnace, in my opinion, is Mr. George Elliot, the eminent viewer of Monkwearmouth colliery. He observes, "I think the plan that I should adopt would be to make an ordinary furnace (such a furnace as we use daily), and I would plant a boiler on the top of it, so that I should have the full benefit of the furnace as a furnace, which we are all very fond of certainly, and which it is very difficult to supersede there is no doubt. I should put the boiler upon it, and whatever value there is in Mr. Gurney's plan I should combine them both, and that with the same fuel that should be at the bottom of the pit."

This is certainly a step in the right direction ; but, speaking of the furnace, he says, "We are all very fond of it," which shows that a prejudice, or at any rate a leaning in its favour, does exist. Now, I believe that few unprejudiced men can read the evidence before the Lords' committee without seeing that the furnace alone, without any accompaniment, is a capricious ventilation ; it is affected by the wind, especially by a strong wind ; and, according to Mr. Martin Jude and others, in south-west winds blowers give out very much. Nothing can be more simple in principle than the furnace, but it is liable to many objections besides those enumerated. Dr. Lyon Playfair considers that the furnace is not the best mode of ventilating a coal mine, and makes the following sensible observations :— "When the state of the barometer is low there is a considerably greater quantity of gas escaping into the mine than when the pressure is high ; there is no means in the furnace ventilation of adjusting the supply of air, for example, of causing a much greater circulation of air when required by particular circumstances ; whereas, by a mechanical ventilation, a greater supply of air is commanded in the conditions where it is required.

Mr. Forster, one of the most eminent north country viewers, said that with 53,000 cubic feet per minute the gas showed itself in the returns at the edge of the goaves, which, he observes, was not at all comfortable, but after using the steam-jet, and increasing the quantity from 53,000 to 79,000, and afterwards to 85,000 cubic feet,** this gas, which made its appearance at the edge of goaves, disappeared, and they have never seen any gas in that colliery since.

Surely such a powerful agent in ventilation as this ought not to be overlooked. It is the simplest of all mechanical means for effecting an increased draught, and, entirely under command, it can produce with the greatest ease all the effects that Dr. Playfair observes the furnace cannot. For instance, at a colliery where Mr. Gurney superintended the erection of the jets it was found that little more than half the number of jets was sufficient for the colliery ventilation of the mine. Now, under these circumstances, shoud the barometer fall, it is only necessary to open the other jets and the mine is immediately cleared.

Speaking of the barometer, I do not consider that the common barometer is at all a fit instrument. In such an important matter it is not sensible enough. We all know that we sometimes have rain before the barometer gives any indication of it. The gas may, therefore, make its appearance and the mines be doomed to destruction before the barometer shows that there is the least danger.

Mr. Gurney, whose unwearied attention to the interests of humanity has brought his great talents and inventive genius to bear upon this very important subject, has invented an instrument that he calls the differential barometer, which shows the slightest atmospheric change, and is, therefore, peculiarly adapted to such a purpose. The sympiesometer has much greater delicacy than the barometer, preceding it commonly from four to five hours in its indications.

I remain, Sir, your obedient servant,

King's College, London, Sept. 1.

James Hann.

* I believe Mr. Cayley was present some part of the time, and made some useful suggestions.

** Mr. Mather at the same colliery (Seaton Delaval) obtained 95,984 cubic feet per minute.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Cayley, —      
Combe, M.      
Cowie, —      
Donnison, —      
Elliot, George      
Forster, —      
Gurney, Goldsworthy      Whos Who Page
Hann, James      
Jude, Martin      Whos Who Page
Mather, James      Whos Who Page
Playfair, Lyon, Dr.      
Wharncliffe, Lord      
Wood, —      
Woodhouse, —      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print