|
30th August 1851, Page: 3, Column: 2 The Explosion At Washington CollieryThe Adjourned InquestThe inquest on the bodies of the sufferers by this dreadful calamity was resumed on Wednesday morning, at nine o'clock, in the National School Room, before Mr. Favell, one of the coroners for the county of Durham. Mr. Matthias Dunn, one of the Government Inspectors of Mines, was present, and took a part in the examination of the witnesses and the general proceedings. There was a numerous attendance of coal-miners and other persons connected with the neighbourhood, as well as several of the principal viewers in the counties of Northumberland and Durham. Mr. Phillipson, of Newcastle, was present to watch the evidence on behalf of the owners of the colliery, Messrs W. Bell and Co., and the Hon. and Rev. Mr. Denman, the rector of the parish of Washington, was in the room part of the morning. William Hartley was the first witness called, and deposed : I am a hewer employed at the Washington Colliery. On the night of the accident I was in the back-shift and went in at about ten o'clock; after burning eight candles, which were far more than I ought to have burnt in the time, in consequence of the air being mixed with gas, I came out. This was between four and five o'clock. There was danger, but not more so than usual. I constantly had a fear upon me, and for some weeks past have considered the pit unsafe. The candle burnt heavy. I was working in the furthest board of the first rise. I had never told any of the deputies or overmen that I did not think the pit safe. There is gas hanging among the stones, and if we put our candles upon the stones, they "click" — that is, the gas burns, until we put out the candle. Had seen this done when with the deputies, Todd and Barras, were there. Whilst there, I told the back overman the air was "mixed," but he (Charlton) said "there was good air coming up" — he knew very well it was mixed. At that time my candle had "a top" upon it. There was as much brattice as I wanted. My father worked in the same pit, and he considered her dangerous. About a month ago I found "fire" upon a tub of Anthony Henderson, and I then thought the pit was not safe for a man to be in. Henderson is an old pitman. By Mr. Dunn: Did not leave my work on account of any fear as to the general state of the pit I had no more fear than usual. I did not mention my fears to the deputies or overmen, because they all knew the state of the pit as well as I did. Did not observe any difference either in the quantity or quality of the air on the day of the accident. Benjamin Hartley: I am a hewer employed in the pit, and went down on the day of the accident in the fore-shift about two in the morning and came up at half-past eleven. I was going to hole a wall in the second dip board, and was working in the headways board by the south dip side. I have worked in that part of the pit six weeks, and two days, in that board ; the pit, during that time, has not been in a good state. If I took a lighted candle into the high nook she "clicked" — she made so much gas. This was the case in all the parts I had been in. I think the gas came from the stones in the low part of the scam. The "low" of the candle used to burn like an oil lamp. I thought the pit dangerous, and have been frightened a good while now, she was in such a bad state. I was only in one place where there was good air, and that was the first rise. There was no brattice in the part where I was working the past two days; in my opinion there ought to have been a brattice. I never asked for a brattice. Geo. Charlton was the overman having charge when I was there. He was in the pit on Monday. I did not ask for a brattice, because I thought the overman would know there wanted one as well as myself. I spoke once to Charlton about the pit making gas, and he tried the high nook with his lamp, and said there had been a slip off. He told me she was making gas there, and that I was to go a little further down. He did not tell me I was to get a lamp. The last day I was at work (Friday week) there was a "low" three inches long to the candle on the clay. I did not tell any of the deputies about this. On one occasion, about six weeks ago, working at the west board my candle "clicked." I told Thomas Barras the gas was bad; he said it was good. He was then at the second rise; I do not know whether he went to look at it. [Witness afterwards explained that "the second rise" and "west board" are so near each other, that it was not necessary for Barras to go out of his way to look at it.] On the morning of the misfortune, Peter Morgan came into my house, and after hearing what had happened, he said "That was just what I expected — she was in such a dangerous state." Morgan has removed to Pittington. I told the policeman on Monday he ought to be summoned, and on Tuesday he removed. By the Inspector: Could not tell when the candle "clicked" whether the gas came from the coal or from the thill or floor of the pit. I think it arose from the general air. The "low" was then five inches long. I put it out with my cap. The flame was three inches square. By Mr. Forster, a viewer: I have worked in the Hutton seam at Broomside. It is common for candles to "click" in that seam, but they never "clicked" at Broomside. William Lamb; I am a deputy at Washington Colliery, and have been in that situation three weeks. I was in the pit on Monday week, and went down at half-past one in the morning ; I left at half-past ten. I was at the polka flat the whole of the time. The air was in a good state at that part of the pit. There had been a fall straight down from the flat eastwards, but I did not see any gas arising from it. I had not been there for a week before the pit fired. The last time I saw Robert Todd was the Friday before she fired ; Todd said something to me about the stones, but nothing about any gas. On the Monday morning that part was quite clear of gas. No complaints were made to me. By the INSPECTOR: None of the boards near where the Todds worked were bratticed. They needed none, for there was a hole about 10 yards from the face where young Todd was, which went into another board. There was nothing to force up the air. The air gets far further down without any brattice to carry it down. This was a dip board, and in such a board the air will travel 30 or 40 yards further than the others. I consider that board was safe the way it was worked. Never heard Robert Todd say he wanted a brattice. By Mr. Forster : There was sufficient air passing through Todd's place to keep it clean. By the CORONER: This air came through the "stenton," about 15 or 20 yards from the place. The air through the holing was so strong on the Friday before the accident that it put out my candle. It would have been safer to work this dip board with lamps. By the INSPECTOR: My duty is to see that all the places are clean, to take up the bottom or stones, and lay down the plates. By Mr. Phillipson: Never saw indications of danger in the pit. Had heard men complain of the way in which their candles burnt in the cross-cut of the flat where the pit fired. Those complaints were made to me about three weeks ago. Did not go to examine that part, nor tell any of the deputies or overmen about it. There are about 30 lengths of plates in young Todd's board. By Mr. Forster: There was a good current of air coming over fall into Todd's board on the Monday, about seven o'clock, when I was there. Robert Todd, who was examined at the opening of the inquest on Wednesday, was next called. In answer to the Inspector, he said : The air came up to my board by the back cross-cut. There was nothing to force the air into the board ; most of the air therefore, went along the headways. The Coroner then enquired of Mr. Cruddace, the viewer, if he was prepared to give any information as to the place where the fire occurred — Mr. Cruddace said, the pit had been examined by several viewers, and mentioned Mr. Nicholas Wood as one who was prepared to give evidence on this point. Mr. Wood was then sworn. He deposed: I reside at Hetton, and am a colliery viewer. I examined the pit on Monday last, in company with Mr. Thomas E. Forster, Mr. Wm. Anderson, and some of the men belonging the colliery. My opinion is, the pit fired in the second east board beyond the doors, in the first cross-cut way. We looked very particularly as to the direction of the fire, and we were perfectly satisfied it had come out of this board. This was indicated by the cinders of the props, the dust and scoria. It is a very dusty seam, and some of the men were probably choked with the dust. The stoppings were all restored when witness went down. In the place where the fire is supposed to have taken place William McNare's body was found, and a lamp was also found there with the top off. Witness himself picked up the bottom part of the lamp ; and he was told by Charlton that that lamp had never been removed. The top of the lamp had been picked up on the other side of the board. This led witness to suppose that the fire was caused by the top of the lamp having been taken off. Witness thinks something must have happened to check the ventilation of the mine at the time she fired, so as to reduce the amount of atmospheric air introduced, and render that part of the pit unsafe. If there was 1000 cubic feet of air going through the pit, he thought it must be safe. That led him to think there must have been some interruption in the ventilation to have caused the explosion. The occurrence of a fall of stone in the mine would tend to choke the passage. This would take place if the fall occurred in the return air course. Witness has discovered traces of fire in the polka flat, but could not trace it as being part of the same fire as that which caused the explosion. In all explosions of which he has had any knowledge, he has found traces of several distinct firings. All the Hutton seams produce gas, which requires to be taken off. The candles burning with "a large top," showed that there must have been a large quantity of carbonic acid gas, as well as inflammable gas, mixed with the air. Thinks the system of ventilation used in this mine, of carrying the air along the face of the workings, a good system. If the air was charged with inflammable gas. It would explode with a much shorter top than if the air was mixed with a portion of carbonic acid gas. The carbonic acid reduces the inflammability. Mr. Thomas Emerson Forster, viewer, resides at Newcastle. Went down Washington pit on Monday last. Had heard Mr. Wood's description of the place where the firing occurred, and perfectly agrees with Mr. Wood's statement. Had no doubt there had been something to interrupt the air course. Had heard that there were falls in the pit, and if so, they had probably been the cause of the obstruction. If there were no falls, he could only attribute the explosion to a sudden discharge of gas. The discovery of a lamp in one of the boards led him to believe there had been something wrong in that board. Very little damage was done to the pit. There must have been a very small quantity of gas in the pit generally when she exploded. Does not consider it necessary to brattice the dip boards. Mr. Wood here remarked that in the Monkwearmouth pit, he had observed the air go along the board with a strong force when there was no brattice. This current arose from the difference of temperature between the lower and the upper air. Mr. W. Anderson, viewer, of South Shields, was down the pit on the 17th of April last, as well as on Monday. He confirmed the previous witnesses as to the general ventilation of the mine. Mr. Charles W. Anderson, viewer, son of last witness, said that on Monday, he traced the firing from the cross-cut to the Polka flat. Mr. George Southern, viewer, of Kibblesworth, who went down the pit on Monday, agreed generally with the previous witnesses as to the cause of the explosion. Mr. William Barkas, jun. and Mr. Laws, viewers, said they also agreed with Mr. Wood. Mr. Samuel Wood gave similar testimony. Robinson Todd: I am a hewer at Washington pit and have been so employed two years. I worked in the same board as Macnare, who was one of the men killed by the explosion. I think on the day when the pit fired, it was a little worse than usual. I was frightened, in consequence of the absence of the men who worked near me ; I was afraid, because I was such a long way from other men. The candle showed more danger that day than it had previously done. I did not take much notice of the air, but it seemed about as usual. There are about six lengths of brattice of two yards each in the board where I worked. From the top of my board to the bottom would be 42 to 43 yards. There was not over much air ; I should have liked it better if there had been more. The candle always showed danger. If the brattice had been put down to the face there would have been more air. I saw the deputy that day and asked him to try his candle at my place, as we did not like it very well; he did so, and said she was considerably better than the day before. Had never made any compliant to Charlton or any other person of want of air. On Monday I went down the pit, in company with the viewers, at the request of Charlton ; I did not got so far as my own board, and cannot tell where the pit fired. Next day I accompanied Mr. Dunn, the Government inspector, into the pit; we then reached up to the face of my board, and from the examination I made I am satisfied she fired at the spot mentioned by Mr. Wood. I go past this board every day, but did not take particular notice on the Monday before the explosion took place. The Coroner inquired if any persons had examined the pit on behalf of the men ? — Mr. Cruddace said Mr. Joseph Jude, Mr. Thomas Todd, and Mr. Robert Smith had done so on Saturday. — The Coroner observed that he would like to call these witnesses. Joseph Jude deposed: I am a hewer and worked in the second headways board in the cross-cut for three weeks before the fire. On the Monday of the accident I went down about two o'clock and came out at six in the morning. Whilst there I did not observe anything different on the candle from what I had noticed on other days. When I first went to work at this flat I was rather alarmed at the "top" on the candle and sent for the deputy ; Thomas Barras came with a lamp. I told him I was not afraid of any explosion there so long as there was a good atmospheric air, but if any fire took place elsewhere, it might lead to serious consequences. He said he had brought me a lamp, for danger might arise from the sump. The air was then sufficient to sweep away any impure gas. There was sufficient brattice in the west boards, but part of the east boards were not bratticed up. I did not think it necessary that this should be done. On the Monday I did not apprehend danger, and therefore did not speak to any of the deputies on the subject. The gas generally came from the bottom or thill, rather than from the whole coal. On Tuesday (after the misfortune had occurred) I went down the pit, and got to the Polka flat end. The stoppings were all driven out and we put in temporary brattices. The crossing had been blown down, but it was nearly repaired. I could observe nothing then indicating the cause of the fire. On Saturday I went in company with other men, at the request of Mr. Cruddace, to examine the pit. We got to McNare's board, where I thought the fire had taken place. I found the bottom of a lamp near to the face of the board at the north side, and understood the man there was allowed to work with his lamp top off. I think she had not fired there, for unless there was a great escape of gas, there could not have been an explosion. The conclusion I have come to in, that the pony driver had taken a siding, in order to get at McNare's coal, and in doing so had incautiously set the gas from the thill on fire with his candle : it had burnt there a minute or two, and the air being arrested by some cause in the west workings, the fire had grown larger, being encouraged and strengthened by the gas with which the air was loaded, and had gone up to the polka flat. The pit might have been fired by the boy having taken a candle up to the face. We did not observe that the pit was making an extraordinary quantity of gas on Saturday, but the air had not got into its regular course then. The men always work with candles at that part of the mine. I looked at the thill; there had not been any eruption in it. By the INSPECTOR: There must have been some interruption in the general air course to occasion the accident. On Saturday there was about the same quantity of air at my board as when I was working there. There are two doors in this district; if one of those was neglected and set open, the air in the east workings would be considerably lessened. I have seen the fall on the west return, which might stop the air; this I had not seen before yesterday, and therefore cannot tell whether the fall was in consequence of the explosion or not. It might have been there on Saturday, but there was a difficulty in getting to the place. [Witness suggested that, in the future, It would be better if the air was split, and each flat had its own air; in reply to which Mr. Cruddace said he intended to try this as an experiment, but was not satisfied that it would answer. Witness added, that although the men frequently complained of the air being loaded, they never had the courage to go to Mr. Cruddace and tell him of the circumstance. He did not know what they were afraid of, for he had always experienced the greatest civility from that gentleman. When he went to work there, having heard unfavourable reports as to the state of the pit, he spoke to Mr. Cruddace on the subject, and he told him that he did not allow gas to accumulate anywhere; if there was gas in the pit, it was entirely the fault of his agents. An adjournment of an hour here took place, and on resuming Thomas Todd was examined. He deposed ; I am a hewer, and was in the pit on the Monday before it fired. I went down about half-past eight in the morning and left about five in the evening. I was working at the southernmost board of the Polka flat. The pit was then in a good state. There were no brattices in that part of the pit; none were required. I was next down on Saturday afternoon last, and was then at the first east board of the cross-cut flat. I saw the place where the pit had fired, but cannot tell the cause of the fire. Immediately after the pit fired (about twelve o'clock on the Monday night) I went down, accompanied by John Armstrong and James Bell. I found John Bird in the rolley-way; he was not much worse. After this I found Armstrong, a boy, near the first cross-cut; he had been slightly burnt. The after-damp was there very strong. Armstrong was sober, but cannot say positively whether Bell was sober or not. He went "in-bye" as well as I did. Robert Smith: I am a hewer and worked in the north side of the pit before she fired. This is quite a different part from the Polka Flat. On Saturday I went into the pit with Mr. Cruddace, but did not examine the flat. I was along with Jude and the master, but did not interfere. I heard Jude say to the master, if something was not done, he would be be obliged to leave. John Hall: I am a shifter, and worked in the Polka Flat before the pit fired — at the fall, opposite the "stenton." I came out about noon on the Monday ; the pit then was clean at the fall. There was plenty of air in this part of the pit. On Friday night I was in the straight-in board of the south rolley-way, with George Cherry and George Lamb, about six o'clock. The candles blazed — "were tailing up." This was owing to the gas in the air. The gas, I should say, came both from the whole coal and the bottom. I do not think we have sufficient brattice in our board. The air was quite slack in the face. The brattice would be twelve or fourteen yards from the face. I considered it very dangerous, on account of the slackness of the air. Before this time Edward Ramsay mentioned the danger to Mr. Cruddace. I have no reason for not speaking about it myself to Mr. Cruddace ; I trusted my life was in better hands than my own. I was not afraid to name it to the owners or deputies. Edward Ramsay: I am a hewer, and was last down the pit on the Friday night before she fired. I was in the crosscut flat, at the first headway in the west-side board. The pit was then in a very bad state ; the air was very much loaded with gas ; and the candles shewed danger — the light was bluish and the top three or four inches long. Some gas came out of the bottom or thill. The candle sometimes flashed there. I considered the pit unsafe, and mentioned it to the deputy Thos. Hall, who was lost by the explosion. I afterwards told Todd, another deputy, who was in the next board trying the top nook with a lamp, and she fired at it. I said "Tommy, if it goes off with that, it will be a bad job." I told him, on account of the air being so loaded, and there being such a top on the candle, the poi was not safe. Todd made no reply. Six weeks ago. I observed on the candle indications of danger, and put out the light. I came to station in the dark, and told Peter Horn, another deputy the pit would fire; all he said was, it would not. I afterwards complained to William Hall; he tried the place with his lamp, and said he believed she was not very clever but she would not fire. I asked him for a lamp, but he would not give me one. Hall, I believe, was a careful, industrious man. I think the pit was worse on the west side on Friday night, than she was on the east side six weeks ago. There has been little change within that period, except one night about three weeks ago, when the air was rather cooler. The air, generally speaking, has been very heavy. By the INSPECTOR: I was afraid of something serious happening; I had a dread upon me every night. Mr. Wood, on being recalled, said if the candle was burning in carbonic acid gas, it would shew a light colour tinged with blue ; if in inflammable gas, a blue colour. George Wilkinson: I am under viewer at Monkwearmouth Colliery. On the Tuesday after the Washington pit fired I went down between twelve and one o'clock. There was five or seven cubic feet of air per second, going through an area of 40 feet, down the old engine bank, equal to from 15,000 to 17,000 per minute. I put in stoppings and drove this air into the workings where the accident occurred. [Witness then spoke to finding some of the bodies.] When at the face, where McNare had been working. Brown, who was before me, picked up the top of a lamp, and I put down the number (48) in my book, also taking possession of it. The lamp was three or four feet from the face, between a tub and the face. McNare was found about 25 yards from the face. He was burnt very much on one arm, and was lying on the north side of the board. McNare was formerly employed at Monkwearmouth Colliery; he was a steady man, but was discharged there for having taken off the top of his lamp. It was plain to us that the fire had originated at this spot and had gone north and west. We could not find the bottom of the lamp. In my opinion the fire had been occasioned from this lamp used by McNare. There was a great deal of gas at the face of McNare's board when I was down ; at the other boards there was less gas. By the INSPECTOR: I think the general air course had not been in a good state before the accident. I said to Charlton I was afraid there had been some gas lodged at the face of the workings, and he replied that he looked at all that part of the pit. The gas at McNare's board would not have been sufficient to fire the pit. I have no doubt the weakening of the general air would make the gas at McNare's board worse. John Dawson spoke to having found the bottom of the lamp. He and a man named Stokoe went to look for it on Friday, after the top had been found by Wilkinson. They discovered it 5 yards from the face of the board where McNare had been working — about two yards N.W. from where the top was found. It was slightly covered with a fall. Witness thought the pit had fired on the wall at this place. The wall was much scarred by the fire. When men take the tops of their lamps they frequently place them on a cracket or stool. There was a cracket in McNare's board on which he sat. By the INSPECTOR: Was near McNare's board on the Monday of the accident; there was no accumulation of gas there then. There might be sufficient gas, if there was a fall at McNare's board, to cause the explosion. On the Friday before the accident there was no fall there; I travelled through the waste alone. George Wilkinson recalled, stated, having heard where the bottom of the lamp was found, he unhesitatingly gave his opinion that the pit had fired near that place, at the lamp in McNare's hand. I think McNare had dropped the lamp when it fired, and had then fallen himself. George Charlton, the overman who gave evidence on Wednesday last, was recalled and corroborated the evidence of the last witness as to the locality of the fire. He thought, however, that gas from McNare's board would not have been sufficient; there must have been some check to the general ventilation. Common candles, bought by the men themselves, were used at the pit. By the INSPECTOR: No complaints were ever made to me by the men as to the state of the pit. By Mr. Forster: Never saw any gas behind the board ends or bracket stoppings. Ralph Stoker, shifter, spoke to having been with Dawson when the bottom of the lamp was found. He thought the fire had originated at the lamp, and the thill had been lifted by gas coming off it. Mr. Cruddace handed in a copy of the code of regulations issued for the guidance of the officers and men employed. It contained a strict prohibition against persons working at dangerous places, and also directed notice to be given of any danger to the overmen. At the request of Mr. Phillipson, John Hunter was called. He deposed: I am an engine-wright at the colliery. There is sufficient material at bank for brattice, and whenever an overman applies for it he can have it. In answer to the Coroner, the jury said they would like to have the opinion of the Government Inspector as to the cause of the fire. Mr. Dunn was then sworn, and deposed : I have examined the pit since the fire. I had not done so before. Yesterday I examined the pit, and I am quite of opinion that the fire originated in McNare's board; I think there has also been a deficiency of air in that eastern quarter. This might arise from three causes: first, a temporary stoppage where the falls had taken place, provided they had done so before the fire; second, a temporary disregard of one or both of the leading doorways in that district, one the rolley-way door leading south, and another the door leading east to the place where McNare was employed ; or thirdly, the slackening of the furnace. There are two furnaces, one 9ft. and the other 4½ft in width; the upcast is 7ft. 6in. in diameter. These furnaces require a great deal of heavy fuel, and it is possible in the night-shift the men employed there might, from neglect, being removed from surveillance and observation, allow the fire to be slackened. If seven to eight thousand cubic feet of air per minute were passed and sustained through the pit, I agree with the witnesses that it was quite sufficient to keep it safe; it could not be called a fiery pit. The dip boards, considering the length of the pillar and the distance of the fire-holing, would have been safer and healthier if they had been partially bratticed. The exploring drifts are of the uniform width of 4½ yards ; they would have been better if they had not been so wide. In my opinion there had been a considerable fire to destroy so many people from after-damp, and the fire, having originated at McNare's board, was strengthened from some of the causes I have indicated. I had never been called upon to visit this colliery. Mr. Dunn added, that although the act under which he was appointed came into operation in November last, and his district included the four northern counties of Northumberland, Durham, Cumberland, and Westmoreland, it was rather remarkable that he had only been called upon in one instance to make an examination or give advice. It would appear from the evidence which had been given that the men at this colliery apprehended danger to their lives, and yet they had not communicated their fears either to Sir George Grey or himself. Without he received information on this point, he might visit half the collieries in the country without hitting upon those which required inspection. He had never been called upon to visit this pit, and certainly it had not the name of being a fiery pit. The Coroner : Suppose the men complained to you of the state of any pit, you would feel yourself bound to visit and examine it? — Mr. Dunn : Yes, and to confer with the managers ; but the inspectors are expressly cautioned not to take upon themselves any responsibility. It was now seven o'clock, and the Coroner proposed to postpone the summing up until the following evening, in order to give him time to peruse and digest his notes. A conversation ensued, and ultimately he adjourned the court for two hours, to afford him an opportunity of doing so. About midnight, the jury returned the following verdict: — "We are of opinion that William Hall, and 32 others named in the depositions, came to their deaths by the firing of Washington Pit, in McNare's board, on the 18th of Aug. instant; and we are of opinion that the air having been highly charged with gas previous, and probably receiving a sudden check, had caused the fire to increase outside his board ; that lamps ought to have been used instead of candles, and there should have been more brattices, as recommended by Mr. Dunn." The number of persons killed amounts in all to thirty-five. The inquest on the bodies of the two furnace-men who went down the pit after the explosion, and were killed by the after damp, will be held on Monday next.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||